Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want DS to go to the best university?

419 replies

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 14:36

DS now has five offers from universities: three Russell Group, one a well-regarded uni but not RG and one a newer university (former poly years ago) offering him BBC (he is predicted AAB). The courses are pretty similar at all five unis (can't go into more detail because he would be furious if he found out I was posting on MN!).

He is adamant that he wants to go to the former poly because he likes it the most. He also reasons that he will have a more enjoyable and less pressurised time there and that he is more likely to get a good class of degree (2.1 or 1st) from the ex-poly - rather than a 2.2 from a Russell Group uni that he just scrapes into. So he is going to firm the ex-poly (he won't have/need an insurance as it is his lowest offer).

AIBU to want him to firm one of the more prestigious Russell Group unis and insure the former poly? DH says I am as it is DS' decision and he's the one who will be going to uni.

OP posts:
Clymene · 24/03/2023 18:48

Why are people banging on about their experience of recruitment 15 years ago? It's not like that anymore.

In much the same way as universities now make contextual offers, most businesses have realised they are overlooking an awful lot of exceptional talent by restricting their recruitment pool to a very small number of universities with a majority of privately educated students.

And the workplace is much better for it.

Hongkongsuey · 24/03/2023 18:34

A lot of these posts argue their cases very well-but all the arguments in the world won’t cut it if the person doesn’t want to be where they are. It’s all very well arguing that to earn big bucks, it’s easier to get that if you’re from a top university-but that person has to want that very much in order to get the most out of it. My dd is very ambitious in her career and is always looking what she can do to get ahead. She wants life with a few bells and whistles so knows she has to earn a reasonable amount. But many people don’t want to earn 6 figures and can have a great life without that. There is a middle path between earning 25k and 250k-and many graduate jobs won’t get above say 70k. That’s a good salary if you look at earnings in the UK-yet some on MN only seem to value careers which only a few people attain.

PhotoDad · 24/03/2023 18:20

MorningMoaner · 24/03/2023 10:30

This is my DD's life! Except she has several dogs.😁
She runs her own (creative) business. She isn't rich and she probably never will be. But she doesn't need to be. She has a good relationship, self determination and is doing what she loves. So she is happy. She would sooner chop her own limbs off than work for a 6 figure salary in the City. I do find it odd how many people equate that kind of thing with success. I can't think of anything worse. And I could probably have done it had I wanted.

Always happy to hear about other people who have followed the path that DD is set upon! I completely accept that some people are happy with City careers, and care about salaries. But I wouldn't be happy in that sort of job. (I did summer work with a law firm in sixth-form and indeed through uni and it put me right off.)

I do get the feeling that my highly-selective Oxbridge degrees, plus my RG Ph.D., in very academic subjects "only" leading to a teaching career is sometimes seen as a "waste" by those City types. But it seems to me that as a society we should want teachers to be passionate, intelligent, and informed (insofar as I am those things!)

Ozgirl75 · 24/03/2023 17:36

I don’t doubt that - but companies have to use something don’t they? If you’re taking on doctors, a job where you obviously have to be very clever, retain a shit ton of info and be prepared to work really hard in a pressured environment, then surely you’d look at young adults who had demonstrated, through their exam results, that this was something they could do? And if there are (say) 50 places, 400 applicants, why wouldn’t you choose the ones with the best A Levels, the highest degree from the most academically rigorous institution? I’m sure some people DO get overlooked, but how are recruiters supposed to know that when they have hundreds of applications for these competitive places.

If you were choosing a tennis player for a scholarship, you’d choose the one who had won the most matches against the hardest players. You might look at one who’s won everything but when you see that they’ve played against people much less able than them, you’d rule them out. I don’t see why it would be different for academic study.

The people who blossom later aren’t doomed though, they can work their way up, or change jobs, progress etc. It’s not like it’s all over if you don’t go to the best university. It might be a bit harder to end up at (say) a top company to work for if your exam results aren’t great, but once you’re in any job, there’s normally the ability to prove yourself, if you’re good.

Equally, it sounds like there are loads of companies these days that don’t mind where you’ve gone to university, so he could work in one of these places anyway.

thing47 · 24/03/2023 17:13

Except that the most academic children at 17/18 aren't de facto the most academic adults after 3 (or 4) years at university. That does not take into account the different teaching and learning styles at school v university, how some people thrive when they can narrow their studies down to a specific area while others might be better 'all-rounders' but aren't as well suited to really focusing in on one thing. There are so many different factors to consider and all the pedagogic research indicates that educational achievement is not linear, so just assuming the DCs with the best A level grades are going to be the best graduates has very little support from the data. They may be, they may not be.

Ozgirl75 · 24/03/2023 16:55

Parker231 · 24/03/2023 16:06

How did you quantify a “good “ Uni?

We defined “good” as “top” - in other words, academically rigorous (Oxbridge, Kings, UCL, Bristol, Manchester, Nottingham, Exeter, Leeds, Durham, Warwick etc).

Ozgirl75 · 24/03/2023 16:52

Given that you haven’t said what subject he’s doing, or which universities he’s looking at, it’s kind of irrelevant anyway. I’m just explaining my experience. Doesn’t make it right, but some careers are specifically academic and will chose candidates from the best universities, the ones that take the most academic children. If he’s going into Formula One racing, then I imagine there is a “best” place for him to have gone for that. I don’t know anything about that, so yes, maybe Oxford Brooke’s is better than Bristol for that subject.
It sounds like he isn’t choosing a particularly academic path anyway as otherwise he would want to go to the university that was the most academically challenging, not the one where he’ll get the easiest ride.

sorcerersapprentice · 24/03/2023 16:42

I regularly interview graduates for our Graduate programme for a FTSE 100. They have to have a 2.1 or for it to be the predicted grade, then do verbal and numerical assessments and a phone interview with HR before they get to me. If they've done all they, they've proven their academic credentials. I don't pay much attention to the Uni tbh; I'm much more interested in how they can demonstrate the particular competencies we require.

Encourage him in his second year to look for summer placements or Year in Industry opportunities, then to apply direct to the grad schemes

Uni should be a great time of his life - let him choose!

cardibach · 24/03/2023 16:35

I firm accepted my lowest offer too. It was below predicted. I loved the place on sight, took pressure off my A levels a bit and had a whale of a time living where I did. Hasn’t held up my career at all, but I didn’t want high flying stuff where snobbish views about the self selected Russell Group would be an issue.

thing47 · 24/03/2023 16:34

Sorry @TizerorFizz , that wasn't aimed at you! Cross posts x

thing47 · 24/03/2023 16:33

Oh good, another lawyer has come along to detail their firm's archaic and snobby hiring practices. Look, if that approach works for them, bravo, have at it. Most professions and industries have moved on from the dark ages and take a more enlightened view. Also, most students don't want to become lawyers. A level grades are totally irrelevant to most employers hiring graduates. And totally irrelevant to most universities looking at Masters applications.

And FWIW if you were recruiting for a Formula 1 team, you would take an engineering candidate from Oxford Brookes over one from Bristol every time.

TizerorFizz · 24/03/2023 16:25

@Parker231Law keeps details of where recruits come from. The universities are RG plus for the vast majority of recruits. At the Bar it’s even more narrow! The milk round quoted is about right with maybe Exeter and Nottingham thrown in. As it’s competitive, there are filters. Some will be on line tests and others will be scrutiny of application.

@jfl You don’t know what a MFL degree involves do you? That’s a bit sad really. I suggest you get better informed.

I keep hearing that love of job means more. Money isn’t important. Sadly it is if bank of mum and dad is bankrupt. Or you want to live in London. Or you live/work in an expensive area and want to save for a property. Even if you rent a property, you need a decent salary! Working at a low paid job with limited prospects might make you feel warm and cuddly but it doesn’t pay tgd bills. Certainly not childcare! Some DCs will eventually have to wake up and smell the coffee.

Also helping others snd earning well are not mutuality exclusive! DD helps plenty of people as a family barrister and makes money, plus, shock horror, did a MFL degree too!

Parker231 · 24/03/2023 16:06

Ozgirl75 · 24/03/2023 16:03

I can only offer my perspective. I worked at a mid level London law firm (around the top 60-70 mark) and when we went to recruitment fairs, we only went to Oxbridge, Bristol, UCL, Kings, Manchester and maybe a couple of others. Basically from those and from the general applications we would get, we would receive around 500 applications for the 23 training contract places.
We discarded anyone with a 2:2 and then anyone not from a good university. This wasn’t because the work was particularly hard, but just that when you have SO many people applying, we needed some way of sorting them. We didn’t have time to look at every application from Brighton or UWE, I’m sure there were some great people we missed, but if you have the chance of taking someone with 3 As and a 2:1 from Bristol over someone with BCC from Oxford Brookes, you’ll always take the “better” candidate, that’s just how it goes.
Having said that, law is quite particular and very competitive and it sounds like things might have changed since I was doing that 15 years ago!

How did you quantify a “good “ Uni?

Ozgirl75 · 24/03/2023 16:03

I can only offer my perspective. I worked at a mid level London law firm (around the top 60-70 mark) and when we went to recruitment fairs, we only went to Oxbridge, Bristol, UCL, Kings, Manchester and maybe a couple of others. Basically from those and from the general applications we would get, we would receive around 500 applications for the 23 training contract places.
We discarded anyone with a 2:2 and then anyone not from a good university. This wasn’t because the work was particularly hard, but just that when you have SO many people applying, we needed some way of sorting them. We didn’t have time to look at every application from Brighton or UWE, I’m sure there were some great people we missed, but if you have the chance of taking someone with 3 As and a 2:1 from Bristol over someone with BCC from Oxford Brookes, you’ll always take the “better” candidate, that’s just how it goes.
Having said that, law is quite particular and very competitive and it sounds like things might have changed since I was doing that 15 years ago!

adriftinadenofvipers · 24/03/2023 13:53

jfl · 24/03/2023 04:26

MFL is mostly a joke degree for not very bright students. So many Europeans grow up speaking 2-3 (or even more) languages by the time they even start high school. The idea that you should be "wasting" your degree trying to learn French or Spanish is completely and totally absurd. If you want to know hose languages then you should learn them when you are young.

A 21 year old MFL graduate literally has the same skills that a 12 year old Swiss kid has (who knows English, Dutch and French by default). Its absurd to say that you should waste your degree on this rather than learning an actual skill or academic discipline.

You are the absurd one here. How insulting.

The fact that the teaching of MFL is so neglected in the UK is no reason to give up on them altogether. By the time a languages teacher completes a PGCE, they will have Lea their language for approximately half their lives.

But hey, let’s bin languages altogether?! Hasn’t shouting louder in English has always been a foolproof way of making oneself understood when abroad?

Then you wonder why the English are unpopular in Europe!!

Shanksponyorbust · 24/03/2023 13:36

They’ve been called universities for over 30 years. Anyone with the ex-poly mentality needs to give their head a wobble. Let him choose where he would like to go. Far better to have a happy student on a course they want to do.

TizerorFizz · 24/03/2023 13:34

@HedgehogB Ha. Yes. I’m surrounded by them! As I’ve said, it’s down to ambition and what makes you tick. If the DS in question is happy to stay local that’s down to him.

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 24/03/2023 13:01

If my example is anything, let the child do what he wants.
My dad didn’t let me… guess what I struggled for years, and ended up with what I originally wanted anyways.

HedgehogB · 24/03/2023 12:31

TizerorFizz · 24/03/2023 12:07

@HedgehogB
Ftse 100 was not what I was talking about! Obviously they pay their employees on varying pay scales though. My DD earns £200k gross at 30. So do lots of her friends. These jobs are obviously in London. Of course there are high earning young people! Just because you live in a bubble, it doesn’t mean others don’t have ambition. They are not unhappy either. DD loves her job. However few get it.

No I do get it and you are right, but it’s not all about law and finance. OP needs the whole perspective. I’m personally more about the person and the values not the £££££ - you can’t build a life purely on money and many of my ex uni friends (Exeter , law etc) got very burned out on high salaries earned in London and some regret putting off kids now, have divorced / flashy Sloane husband from Radley turned out to be a love rat, etc. I am aware these are all gross generalisations though as well !!! Many made their cash - all credit to them- and now live out in the Cotswolds/ Devon. I skipped that step and stayed regional, most definitely poorer financially but I think my life on balance has been happier than some? But yes, only sone? Can see all sides of this argument tbf. I still Got a nice home , garden and pension. Some of them (not all) seriously questioning what it was all for though . I work for a ftse STEM so it’s not as RG focused. So yea it’s different

Onthenosecco · 24/03/2023 12:29

TizerorFizz · 24/03/2023 12:07

@HedgehogB
Ftse 100 was not what I was talking about! Obviously they pay their employees on varying pay scales though. My DD earns £200k gross at 30. So do lots of her friends. These jobs are obviously in London. Of course there are high earning young people! Just because you live in a bubble, it doesn’t mean others don’t have ambition. They are not unhappy either. DD loves her job. However few get it.

Yes, nobody outside London is a high earner.

DrPrunesquallor · 24/03/2023 12:22

adriftinadenofvipers · 24/03/2023 12:10

What a crock!!!!

🤣🤣🤣 not in my world.

DrPrunesquallor · 24/03/2023 12:20

OMGitsnotgood · 23/03/2023 19:36

I don't believe this. An employer will want to know where someone has gone to Uni!

This is simply not true for the majority of employers. Might be true for a few specific companies/professions. Although the major corporate I worked for did know which uni someone went to (they might be blind now I don't know) it made no difference whatsoever where someone got their degree from. A degree simply shows that someone has a particular academic ability (we only wanted 2:1 or a first). Selection is more about all the other skills/competencies/characteristics that make a candidate a good match for the company and the role.

That isn’t quite true in all professions.
Whilst we don’t chose based on whether a uni is RG we do like to know what uni it is.
As architects different unis have different specialisms.
Some are more tech based, some more design based.
If a person is fairly recently qualified and we want someone to do more detailing then we won’t necessarily be looking at the high flying design based schools. We’ll look at them when we want someone a bit more design savvy.
Of course the portfolio is the final clincher.

But again, it makes absolutely no difference to us if they went to Oxbridge, RG or other
Also, as PPs are stating here about grades. A lot of excellent designers are not good at written exams and their design grades and final grades will be pulled down if they don’t do well in the written exams. We re not interested in whether they know the makeup of concrete or contractural law when we want a designer so if they went to a good design school we interview them based on their portfolio.

adriftinadenofvipers · 24/03/2023 12:10

jfl · 24/03/2023 04:22

Many of the replies in this thread are crazy

Yes its important for your child to be happy, but life doesnt end at 21. Yes, "university experience" is great and fun and important, but not being poor when you are 30 is even more important. You only have to spend some time reading mumsnet threads (let alone looking around in daily life) to see the lives full of misery that many people lead. Sure, its "fun" to do an arts degree or attend a 3rd tier university in a "nice" city, but what are you doing to do when you are 30 years old and only earning £30-40k and having to check your bank balance at the end of the month when you go shopping?

The reality is that smart people with good degrees find it easy to earn a lot of money in the modern era. A halfway intelligent person in London with a decent degree should easily be on £80k+ by their early 30s. On the other hand, you could do a "fun" course in media at Huddersfield and tell yourself that earning £40k is "good enough", while you worry about rationing your heating in winter and try to decide if shopping in Lidl will let you afford to run a car. This is surely not the sort of life you want for your child.

The above replies claiming that post-1992 universities are "really better than people think" are especially disingenuous. These universities are mostly all crap and will always be crap. Sure its elitism, but the reality is that they mainly cater to students that aren't very bright. Sure, most of the students there do "get jobs" but they are rarely well-paying jobs, and most will just fall into the usual £30-50k mediocrity. I do sometimes wonder how many of the posers who say this are really academics at post-1992s who werent able to secure academic jobs at Russell Groups and are dealing with insecurity issues.

Without wanting to overly emphasise the racial issue, I do think that this issue of low standards is mostly a white issue. Its bizarre how many middle class white families seem happy to sit back and let their kids make awful decisions that will lead to life-long poverty just because "it makes them happy" in the short term. Its almost impossible to imagine this issue even coming up in an Asian family, since "go to the best university you can" is so self-evidently obvious that its axiomatic.

What a crock!!!!

TizerorFizz · 24/03/2023 12:07

@HedgehogB
Ftse 100 was not what I was talking about! Obviously they pay their employees on varying pay scales though. My DD earns £200k gross at 30. So do lots of her friends. These jobs are obviously in London. Of course there are high earning young people! Just because you live in a bubble, it doesn’t mean others don’t have ambition. They are not unhappy either. DD loves her job. However few get it.

HedgehogB · 24/03/2023 11:48

Stugs · 24/03/2023 09:26

I love an organised uni! Swansea seemed much more organised than Exeter for example.

I went to Exeter and saw my tutor once