Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want DS to go to the best university?

419 replies

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 14:36

DS now has five offers from universities: three Russell Group, one a well-regarded uni but not RG and one a newer university (former poly years ago) offering him BBC (he is predicted AAB). The courses are pretty similar at all five unis (can't go into more detail because he would be furious if he found out I was posting on MN!).

He is adamant that he wants to go to the former poly because he likes it the most. He also reasons that he will have a more enjoyable and less pressurised time there and that he is more likely to get a good class of degree (2.1 or 1st) from the ex-poly - rather than a 2.2 from a Russell Group uni that he just scrapes into. So he is going to firm the ex-poly (he won't have/need an insurance as it is his lowest offer).

AIBU to want him to firm one of the more prestigious Russell Group unis and insure the former poly? DH says I am as it is DS' decision and he's the one who will be going to uni.

OP posts:
GasPanic · 23/03/2023 15:52

imjusthereforAIBU · 23/03/2023 15:38

Enjoying University and being enthused about your course will likely lead to him doing better, which has better employment prospects than a lower grade at a "better" university. With the exception of the top few, University rankings change all the time too. The Uni I went to is ranked substantially differently now to when I studied there.
As an interviewer for my employer (Engineering), we don't really care in our industry where your degree is from. We've had Cambridge graduates who have been wholly unsuitable for the role and ex-poly grads who have thrived. What matters more is evidence they worked hard, they learned skills and relevant knowledge and they are the right fit with the right attitude for the employer. However this is my industry and not all are the same. For example that might be completely wrong for medicine.

So I interview too (and actually read the CVs).

First thing I would ask is, you did really well in your A levels why did you pick University X to go to ?

And if they said something like it's nearer home and would be cheaper, or I was interested in this particular course or had better rep for helping people with disabilities or some other valid reasons I would be fine.

And if they said I picked it because I wanted to slacken off, party on and still get a great result then I would not be fine - I would not see that as evidence of someone who wanted to work hard or fulfill their potential.

LlynTegid · 23/03/2023 15:52

I think his view is wrong, though I doubt I could persuade him otherwise. Though having had a conversation about university with a couple of people the other day, I'd be looking for a job with prospects not three years of debt and potential stress.

I think you will have to accept his decision, you have expressed your view.

FoxCorner · 23/03/2023 15:52

When we looked round a sixth form college they referred to Top 15 Unis rather than Russel Group.
If I had a dc who wanted to do a vocational subject such as Optometry at an ex poly I'd be delighted that they knew what they wanted to do and would be employable. Ex polys seem to have a lot of vocational subjects.
Dd1 wanted to do a Science Subject rather than vocational though and picked a RG/Top 10 Uni

Hankunamatata · 23/03/2023 15:52

Some ex polys are regarded more highly than others except for specific subjects

novalia89 · 23/03/2023 15:51

BurbageBrook · 23/03/2023 15:47

He's probably right, he will stand out academically from other students at the ex poly and be more likely to get a First.

That is a massive bias. Maybe he won't stand out. He might be with the students who can't afford to move to a red brick because they have a family or caring responsibilities and have to live at home. Or they went to an extremely bad school and still scraped a BBB and the student that managed ABB attended an exclusive boarding school from the age of 7. The sort of attitude where you think that you will stand out academically and slight snobbish entitlement whilst attending a poly will ensure you get a poor grade.

Hankunamatata · 23/03/2023 15:51

I went to ex poly the teaching was far superior to red brick in same city. My bf did similar degree at same time - he admitted poly was much more engaged as staff were there to teach

Clusterfunk · 23/03/2023 15:51

I think your son has his head screwed on right. Also, this is now his life and he’s making his own adult decisions. You can advise, but ultimately it’s his choice.

I sit on recruitment and interview panels. Both in my department and occasionally at national scheme level in my profession. We absolutely don’t care where you got your degree. Your overall grade and your ability to write an excellent application will get you an interview. Then how you answer the questions gets you the job.

I’m not naive enough to think all professions are like this; some I’m sure are still an “old boys” network. But modern employment law is moving more towards removing things that can be used to discriminate against you on applications such as place of study, sex, names. All I get when I’m paper sifting is degree results and any previous employer details.

For what it’s worth, I also went to a RG university and nobody in my field gives a shiny shit 😂

RaRathenoisylittlelion · 23/03/2023 15:50

It's his life, let him choose and trust in him & show him that you value his opionion.

I have experience of Oxbridge and Russell Group. I wouldn't recommend Oxbridge for undergrad as a University experience due to the short, intense terms.

Russell Group was great, decent pace of work (very dependent on course, thinking about friends how many hrs you need to put in) and we were in a great city that I wanted to live in, with likeminded people who chose to be there too. I would imagine the same of the ex-poly, if it's a course he likes, in a setting he likes, he will meet people he likes. It will all be well and life is about being happy.

dreamingofsun · 23/03/2023 15:50

All 3 of my kids have been to RG. Several of the poly's had very limited amount of teaching time and relatively few and easy exams according to my kids, compared to RG unis. So i find it hard to believe that employers would be as happy with degrees from those ex polys since they would have learnt a lot less - maybe it depends on the type of degree - mine used the degree learning as part of their current jobs.

has he checked how much learning time there is and what the employability stats are? And how much the average salaries are post uni? Is he likely to want to do a masters and has he checked about numbers going on to do this?

I agree with others that this has to be his decision.

Sekena · 23/03/2023 15:50

I would STRONGLY advise you based on my own previous experience to stand back and allow him to make his own decision

novalia89 · 23/03/2023 15:49

GasPanic · 23/03/2023 15:34

Depends really on who's paying for it.

If he is paying for it how he spends his god knows how many £ going to uni and either gets a result or wastes it is in his court.

But to me the idea that someone wants to go to a less reputable or easier place because they will get an easier ride seems to me to be a bit of an attitude problem and is some display of immaturity. You're not going to uni to get an easy ride. You're going there to get a valued qualification. Sure there is fun to be had in the downtime. But it's about the hard work first and the fun second. It has to be - it costs too much £ to throw away.

The easiest ride is not to bother going at all. Then you at least aren't £££££ down and have the chance of applying again in a few years when you've got your head straightened out on why you are applying and wanting to achieve the best result you are capable of. It would be a pain if he gets one year into the course and then decides it's too much like hard work and ends up with a load of debt and no result.

'But to me the idea that someone wants to go to a less reputable or easier place because they will get an easier ride seems to me to be a bit of an attitude problem and is some display of immaturity. You're not going to uni to get an easy ride.'

Absolutely this. He is not going to university for an easy ride. He is going to get a degree. People seem to forget this and go just to experience being a student and wonder why they are stressed trying to learn a subject that they have no desire to do.

AutumnLeaves23 · 23/03/2023 15:47

YANBU
I think we as parents are there as more experienced people for our kids, to give advice. They don’t have to take it!

But yes if my child was saying they were picking a course as an easier, more relaxed option - I’d be urging them to rethink it. As sometimes the more ‘challeninging’ courses are way more interesting, with better teachers.

So maybe the way to do it, is to look more deeply at each college with him, lay out the pros and cons,
What is the teaching like?
What are the students saying?
What is the area and life like?
What jobs and opportunities could it lead to?

The only thing I would say is you do seem to have your own bias, even mentioning the ‘Russel Group’ means that you might be looking merely at ‘prestige’ when plenty of courses are much better in places not in the Russel Group - which is a very broad brush blunt way of looking at colleges. So give him ‘real’ advice, not one that might tend towards ‘snobbery’.

BurbageBrook · 23/03/2023 15:47

He's probably right, he will stand out academically from other students at the ex poly and be more likely to get a First.

MasterBeth · 23/03/2023 15:47

Happyhappyday · 23/03/2023 15:41

There is totally an advantage to going to a more prestigious uni!! Especially depending on the course. You get access to career fairs, the quality of employers that go there will be higher. You’ll go to an interview and the interviewer will also have gone to Oxford, you build that little connection etc etc. You get access to alumni networks/mentoring etc. Uni should be about securing a good job afterwards, the ex poly might be the right place for his course, or it might not.

Uni should be about securing a good job afterwards

It's one factor, not at all the only factor.

BarbaraofSeville · 23/03/2023 15:47

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 14:47

"There are rankings according to subject - it's possible that he is making the smart choice by picking the ex poly."

The ex poly is firmly in the bottom half of the subject ranking tables though so not in this case. It does score highly for graduate employability and student satisfaction though.

What are they ranking for seeing as that suggests that it doesn't give much weight for 'graduate employability and student satisfaction'?

Both those sound like rather important factors, which suggests that the ranking process isn't particularly objective/reliable.

RachelSq · 23/03/2023 15:45

I went to a top tier uni (requirement AAA, but would now include A* now that these are a thing). I flunked it and got a 2:2, as did a good chunk of my year in my subject (about a third of us).

My sibling did the same subject at an ex-Poly and got a 1st (and had BBC as A Levels).

Honestly the calibre of his course was terrible compared to mine (I could have passed his final year after my first year easily) but he still managed to get the unrelated graduate jobs whereas I was the one struggling to get one because of the 2:1 requirement.

In the end I’ve jumped him again career wise, but I still begrudge that he had a more fun time at uni and got a better grade meaning his start in professional life was easier.

So I’d say go for the ex-Poly unless you actually think you’re academic research material where the better course actually matters.

Jarstastic · 23/03/2023 15:44

I’m curious why he wants to go to the poly. If he really feels he will maximise his potential there that’s one thing. If he thinks it’s an easy ride it’s another. And how will he feel as a potentially AAA student being with people who in some cases would be less than BBC.

i know of and have read of cases where people chose universities and courses because of unconditional offers then eased off at A levels, ended up with a not so good result in an degree they may not have done if not for the unconditional offer and had several years of extra study and debt.
I know this is not the same in this situation but I think there are some parallels.

I appreciate you are guiding (not saying my way or the highway). That’s what parents are supposed to do.

MasterBeth · 23/03/2023 15:44

The best university for your son is not necessarily the most prestigious university.

TheLoupGarou · 23/03/2023 15:43

I don't think the perception that students get an 'easier ride' at less prestigious universities, or that it is somehow easier to get a good degree is correct, so if that's what he is basing his decision on he might be disappointed....

However, his life his choice.

Passerillage · 23/03/2023 15:42

I've worked in graduate studies admissions and for competitive graduate programs it DOES make a difference. All other things being equal, an applicant from a high ranking uni (for that subject) is going to get picked before an applicant before an applicant from a low ranking uni.

Nobody will be looking at his a-level results, so unless in his cover letter for grad programs he makes a compelling case for having actively chosen the low-ranking uni in order to work specifically with Professor Genevieve Blinkenhausen-Fustenberger on her groundbreaking work on protofeminist ant societies in Samoa, it will just look like he couldn't get into anywhere better.

But if he really wants to go to wherever he has chosen, you can't reall stop him. His life, his student loans.

Happyhappyday · 23/03/2023 15:41

There is totally an advantage to going to a more prestigious uni!! Especially depending on the course. You get access to career fairs, the quality of employers that go there will be higher. You’ll go to an interview and the interviewer will also have gone to Oxford, you build that little connection etc etc. You get access to alumni networks/mentoring etc. Uni should be about securing a good job afterwards, the ex poly might be the right place for his course, or it might not.

novalia89 · 23/03/2023 15:39

It's his life decision. He will always resent you for choosing something that will affect his next three years or potential life. His reasonings are a bit off though 'more enjoyable and less pressurised time there and that he is more likely to get a good class of degree (2.1 or 1st) from the ex-poly - rather than a 2.2 from a Russell Group'. If he thinks that this is true then he is destined to do badly. There is nothing worse than being complacent and then failing.
Polies can be just or even more vigorous than Russells. My degree is accredited by the RIBA, who moderate and accredit all of the unis and therefore the standard is equal.
I have attended a poly and a russell group and the standard was no different. I found that lots of students lived at home in the poly, and they chose it for that reason, and had more of a 'go in, get the work done and go home' attitude rather than the red brick 'student life experience'. It was split maybe 50:50 local students in the poly.
It is totally dependant on the course too. There are some courses where everyone seems to get 80% and others where it isn't as common. Of course if you get a job in the industry related to the course they know what the average is for that field so the grade doesn't matter as much, it's just what is average for the field.

imjusthereforAIBU · 23/03/2023 15:38

Enjoying University and being enthused about your course will likely lead to him doing better, which has better employment prospects than a lower grade at a "better" university. With the exception of the top few, University rankings change all the time too. The Uni I went to is ranked substantially differently now to when I studied there.
As an interviewer for my employer (Engineering), we don't really care in our industry where your degree is from. We've had Cambridge graduates who have been wholly unsuitable for the role and ex-poly grads who have thrived. What matters more is evidence they worked hard, they learned skills and relevant knowledge and they are the right fit with the right attitude for the employer. However this is my industry and not all are the same. For example that might be completely wrong for medicine.

GasPanic · 23/03/2023 15:34

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 15:22

I'm offering advice FGS. I am not going to stand in his way - I know it is his decison

Depends really on who's paying for it.

If he is paying for it how he spends his god knows how many £ going to uni and either gets a result or wastes it is in his court.

But to me the idea that someone wants to go to a less reputable or easier place because they will get an easier ride seems to me to be a bit of an attitude problem and is some display of immaturity. You're not going to uni to get an easy ride. You're going there to get a valued qualification. Sure there is fun to be had in the downtime. But it's about the hard work first and the fun second. It has to be - it costs too much £ to throw away.

The easiest ride is not to bother going at all. Then you at least aren't £££££ down and have the chance of applying again in a few years when you've got your head straightened out on why you are applying and wanting to achieve the best result you are capable of. It would be a pain if he gets one year into the course and then decides it's too much like hard work and ends up with a load of debt and no result.

NIparty · 23/03/2023 15:33

I did the uni and course my parents coerced me into, hated it, and only now at 36 am I beginning to study in the course of my choice after suffering through a course and subsequent career/jobs I hated after that. Its a source of great contention between us, and I'll never forgive them for it. Now they say oh but it was your choice - but the pressure they put me under, the emotional black mail etc - no, 17 year old me did not have a choice.

You can offer your advice and opinion (non pushy), but its up to him how much of that he takes on board. And ultimately snd rightly, it'd his decision.