Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want DS to go to the best university?

419 replies

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 14:36

DS now has five offers from universities: three Russell Group, one a well-regarded uni but not RG and one a newer university (former poly years ago) offering him BBC (he is predicted AAB). The courses are pretty similar at all five unis (can't go into more detail because he would be furious if he found out I was posting on MN!).

He is adamant that he wants to go to the former poly because he likes it the most. He also reasons that he will have a more enjoyable and less pressurised time there and that he is more likely to get a good class of degree (2.1 or 1st) from the ex-poly - rather than a 2.2 from a Russell Group uni that he just scrapes into. So he is going to firm the ex-poly (he won't have/need an insurance as it is his lowest offer).

AIBU to want him to firm one of the more prestigious Russell Group unis and insure the former poly? DH says I am as it is DS' decision and he's the one who will be going to uni.

OP posts:
DrPrunesquallor · 23/03/2023 17:36

MorningMoaner · 23/03/2023 17:30

Not to mention the fact that AAB is only one grade different in each subject than BBC so there is not necessarily a huge difference between performance. An AAB student might only have gained a few more marks than a BBC student if they were just either side of the grade boundaries in each subject. A bit of an off day or a spot of luck with a question could easily make that difference. We're hardly talking the difference between Einstein and Joe Public.
Back in the dark ages when I went to University the standard offer for my course was BBB. I got AAAA and also passed 2 special papers. Was there any discernible difference between me and others like me and those who "only" had Bs by the time we graduated? No. And nobody cared about A levels - I don't think I ever knew what results most of my friends had. It certainly did me no harm to have to spend three years with them!

Well said Morningmoaner.👏👏
Fancy dc having to spend time with people who got lower grades than them.🤪

Cavies · 23/03/2023 17:36

GnomeDePlume · 23/03/2023 17:14

Is that so niche that in fact very few universities of any type will have the appropriate facilities?

That is the opposite of niche. Any molecular/cell biology/genetics degree would have facilities for this.

Do you have an example of a Uni offering it without the required labs?

ReneBumsWombats · 23/03/2023 17:35

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 15:21

"Is it some sort of cry for help? Is he taking his foot off the pedal in the run-up to exams, giving himself permission to get BBC grades rather than the predicted AAB."

I can see why you might think that @senua. But no, he got AAA in his mocks last month so he should make AAB which is his highest offer.

Predicted AAA and he "just scrapes" into a RG uni?

piedbeauty · 23/03/2023 17:35

Interesting! I didn't realise about blind applications and that many prospective employers don't ask what uni you went to any more.

TitoMojito · 23/03/2023 17:34

YABU. He’s going to spend multiple years at uni, wouldn't you rather he go to one he thinks he'll enjoy?

ThomasinaLivesHere · 23/03/2023 17:34

I get where you’re coming from however as someone who went to a top university I’d say it’s overrated. Lots of grad opportunities just want to know what classification you got. The civil service even require you not to list the university. I guess you can’t share what he wants to be as that’d hint at the course. Ultimately he gets to decide.

Crystalsandpebbles · 23/03/2023 17:33

I have experience of being summarily rejected from a course ( at the point of enquiry, not interview) because I had a 2.2. The fact that it was from a RG uni 20+ years previously ( before grade inflation) cut no ice. Maybe OP's son has a point. I did do the course elsewhere in the end.

MorningMoaner · 23/03/2023 17:30

thing47 · 23/03/2023 16:50

There again, he - an AAB student - is going to have to spend three years with people who have scraped to get into a BBC sort of place.

The fact that he did better at A level doesn't in and of itself mean he is going to do better in his degree, of course – university education and learning is quite different in style from A levels and some students will prefer it and thrive, while others may not.

People over-estimate the importance of A level grades for graduates – once you have a degree a lot of potential employers won't be all that interested. FWIW the majority of Masters courses do not ask for A level grades on the application form, which tells you something about how relevant universities themselves think A levels are for graduates…

Not to mention the fact that AAB is only one grade different in each subject than BBC so there is not necessarily a huge difference between performance. An AAB student might only have gained a few more marks than a BBC student if they were just either side of the grade boundaries in each subject. A bit of an off day or a spot of luck with a question could easily make that difference. We're hardly talking the difference between Einstein and Joe Public.
Back in the dark ages when I went to University the standard offer for my course was BBB. I got AAAA and also passed 2 special papers. Was there any discernible difference between me and others like me and those who "only" had Bs by the time we graduated? No. And nobody cared about A levels - I don't think I ever knew what results most of my friends had. It certainly did me no harm to have to spend three years with them!

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 23/03/2023 17:30

Choconut · 23/03/2023 14:46

Surely what we all aspire to be is happy? If this uni makes him feel happy then why would you try to make him go somewhere else he doesn't feel happy about?

This new trend of placing “happiness” over e rushing is interesting and by “happiness” I see it as just taking the easy way out and using the guide of happiness and mental health to justify it.

Teminds me if a conversation with my nephew who didn’t want to go to university as he didn’t think he would be happy yet he had no other plan of what to do. Claimed money isn’t I present and he is happy to live in a shared room for the rest of his life etc. and yet he also wants the latest phones, cars; travel etc.

Many of these decisions are being made naively and based on short term thinking and taking the easy way out. Na t if our kids now lack drive and ambition but quickly justify it with mental health and search for happiness.

Peppadog · 23/03/2023 17:28

Ah this is tough. I remember back to my final year at college when my parents were talking to me about unis and all I cared about was the night life in the town and where my boyfriend was going.
Fortunately he chose a RG uni so I went there, by pure chance. I had no concept of prestigious uni's VS non prestigious whereas now I'd feel differently. I feel for you OP.

dreamingofsun · 23/03/2023 17:28

Novalia - Of course my kids know that their friend/housemate, girlfriend has less teaching time and fewer exams - the person tells them. You dont have to study at a place to be aware of this. My husband didnt need to work at my company to know my work hours.....

begoneday · 23/03/2023 17:27

He sounds very mature, How happy he will be and how pressured he will feel cannot be underestimated. Uni students have staggering amounts of mental health issues these days.

Yankeedoodlemandy · 23/03/2023 17:27

People are questioning me saying recruitment agencies don’t always have access to where a degree came from. I don’t have personal experience but there is lots of talk on blind recruiting on the
’what I wish I knew about university ‘ Facebook page . People commenting on there saying they recruit without knowing in big companies .

Mojoj · 23/03/2023 17:26

He's going to uni, not you.

Sallyh87 · 23/03/2023 17:25

In my experience once you get past the first few years of experience in a job no one cares where you went to uni or if you even did. It very annoying for me because I have a masters from a fairly good uni! I base this on working in HR / recruitment in Banking and Finance and also the public sector for the last 15 years.

pollykitty · 23/03/2023 17:24

My own personal feelings are when you’re 18, you are an adult and responsible for your own decisions. Of course you can throw your opinion in about his choice but it’s his life and he sounds like he has made up his mind. Be happy for him.

KStockHERO · 23/03/2023 17:23

GnomeDePlume · 23/03/2023 17:14

Is that so niche that in fact very few universities of any type will have the appropriate facilities?

No. Lots of RG universities attract funding enough to have these facilities. Non-RGs don't consistently attract those funding levels.

My point is that non-RGs still 'sell' students the idea that they're being trained in the area. But they're not being trained to the level that employers in the field will consider them for decent roles. Because the universities don't have the equipment or infrastructure to do so. The students are being sold a pup.

As PPs have said its field-dependent.

OvaHere · 23/03/2023 17:22

It's not unreasonable to think it or even to offer your point of view. At the end of the day though it's his choice so just don't cross a line from advice to pressure.

DrPrunesquallor · 23/03/2023 17:21

Justalittlebitduckling · 23/03/2023 17:15

Are you finding his studies? This does affect the dynamic for sure. But there was a thread on here a couple of months ago really regretting pushing her son into Oxford where he was really miserable when he wanted to go to York, and he was going to drop out and their relationship was really strained.

I believe he did drop out. It was very sad to read of his struggles.

Ishefuckingkiddingme · 23/03/2023 17:20

Clymene · 23/03/2023 17:08

Oh that's good to know @Ishefuckingkiddingme. On that (very long) thread, the only people from professional services firms who said it mattered were from magic circle firms.

Not in my experience of MC firms. It tends to be a perception people have from the outside (which MC firms are spending a fortune trying to counter). I went to a non-RG university and I got training contract offers from both Allen & Overy and Freshfields. And, after qualification, where you went to university matters even less. The numbers of non-RG trainees at MC firms is low but, truthfully, that’s because non-RG candidates choose not to apply or choose to go to other firms because of the reputation that they’re not non-RG friendly firms…the loss of talent from that is why there’s such a push to change that perception.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 23/03/2023 17:20

Has he been to the opendays?
A lot has changed at universities in the last decade. Its your son's choice at the end of the day.

The UCAS hub helps compare various courses. Things you could look at is how many teaching hours are allocated to the course. How do they assess his work (proportion coursework v exams)
YOu can also ring admission tutors and find out how many students do a course and what proportion get firsts and 2.1s. they often don't put this in the brochure but will tell you and they don't mind speaking to your personally. They don't take names either so it won't affect his application.
Which uni has the biggest department for the subject?
eg engineering. Some unis specialise in it, which means he would have the choice of lots of different modules and tutors and aligned subjects - that is what I would base it on.
If he's doing film studies for e.g.. is the uni more practical with a lot of studio facilities or is it more of an essay writing course, looking at the history of film. Some former polys specialise in particular subjects... If his course is at a place that specialises in his subject - it might be better for him than a more established uni that tries to cover a wider range of subjects.
What does he want to do afterwards? Would he benefit from an MA - he could go to another university to do that.
Another consideration is how much extra curricular there is - if he likes skiing, does it have an active snow club that arranges trips. Is it near a lively town with lots going on.
If he has really looked into this and is not just being influenced by friends, then maybe you should embrace his choice and not make him feel like he picked a second best course when its what he wants to do.

Kennykenkencat · 23/03/2023 17:20

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 14:44

"lots of employers now haven’t got access to where you did your degree only what you did and what grade"

Amazed by this if true. So there's literally no advantage in going to a prestigious uni like Oxford or St Andrews when it comes to getting a job? That does make me feel better about the ex-poly!

To be honest if he wants to go to university and run up thousands in debt then he might as well enjoy it.

No point you choosing for him because anything that goes wrong or doesn’t work out it will be your fault.

LilylilyDaisy · 23/03/2023 17:18

He sounds very bright, so I'd have faith in letting him make his own informed choices. If he's considered all the options carefully and has made his choice accordingly, then that's his decision.

I was made to take the naice educational option as my parents felt it had more kudos. I wasn't very happy, struggled a bit and ended up doing not as well as I know I could have done at the less prestigious, but more supportive and forward-thinking place.

poetryandwine · 23/03/2023 17:18

I am a former Russell Group admissions tutor. I think your DS must make his own decision.

Light touch discussion is fine. Here are some things you and he may not have thought of.

Given that the course at the post 1992 uni ranks highly for both student satisfaction and employability, what components are pulling the ranking down to the bottom half? Is research the main one? Unless your DS is doing a traditional academic subject and a PhD is a possibility, a low research ranking should not affect his student experience. As PPs have implied, this may leave the staff more time to focus on teaching and they may be more interested in doing so.

Of interest to you both, even though employers are moving towards blind applications, evidence is emerging that a good education pays off. Specifically, in some branches of the Civil Service that have been doing blind applications for a little while, the percentage of Oxbridge entrants has risen. It is thought that this is because their training prepares them so well for the testing and interviews. (After reading about this on MN I verified it in the respectable press, but I don’t have time to chase down a reference now). How far this extends to other unis I don’t know.

Post 1992 unis broadly speaking offer more academic support to students than the RG, but this may have unintended consequences for your DS. How will he be assessed? In a number of degree programmes I know of assessments are more frequent than in the RG (again, broadly speaking).

Research on teaching and learning supports this. The best and brightest at Oxbridge essentially get it, in the form of very frequent feedback on informal assignments that are all but mandatory. Many, many RG students get away with learning less than they might because without any external need to keep up with their work, they don’t.

’Recommended reading’ in the RG may well become the subject of an assignment in a post 1992 uni. This becomes a theme.

If your DS is under the impression that he will be working less at the post 1992 uni, he needs to investigate the teaching, learning and assessment methods for his degree programme. It may not follow the dichotomy I have suggested. But many degree programmes do. The good news is that if he chooses the post 1992 and does the required work, he is likely to be very successful.

Justalittlebitduckling · 23/03/2023 17:15

Are you finding his studies? This does affect the dynamic for sure. But there was a thread on here a couple of months ago really regretting pushing her son into Oxford where he was really miserable when he wanted to go to York, and he was going to drop out and their relationship was really strained.