Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU nursery worker stepped on my baby's hand

143 replies

2babies93 · 23/03/2023 12:16

DD is 12 months. She's been at nursery for a few months as I'm back at work. We've had a few problems there, mostly though, the manager's attitude sucks. We decided to look for, and have found, somewhere else, but they don't have space for 6 months. (This is because of other unrelated issues which are not relevant to this incident).

Last week I got a call from the nursery; "A carer was walking past DD and then she started crying. On review of CCTV we can't see what happened, but they may have stepped on her hand." Her hand was red and sore after, but not swollen. She was fine that evening when I picked her up.

They won't let me see the CCTV - is that normal?

I understand that kids have accidents. She's banged her head, fallen over, been bitten etc. and these incidents don't really bother me (much) because I know they will happen. Kids don't know how to play nicely and with staff ratios, they won't be able to prevent everything. I've never complained about an injury/incident before this - and I've not yet formally or otherise complained about this, but I think I might (help!).

I'm uncmofortable with the fact that the carer "may have" stepped on her. Surely you'd know? If it's just an accident, why not just admit it? Also, I feel like this type of accident isn't acceptable. This is not DD v another child, it's DD v an adult. An adult who's working in a nursery and should be careful where they are stepping, right?

I need some outside influence. My main concerns are:

  1. The use of "may have", it feels like a cover up?
  2. I can't see the CCTV. My older DD was at a different nursery (moved house) and we could see the CCTV of any incidents if requested.
  3. The fact that she was hurt by an adult. I don't feel like stepping on a child is acceptable, even if accidentally.

AIBU to insist on seeing the CCTV? WIBU to I take her out early because of this incident? I don't know what we'd do for childcare, but I feel so uncomfortable leaving her there. I'm really upset...

Thank you, please be nice even if I'm being unreasonable. I'm here for help/to get perspective.

OP posts:
Muu · 23/03/2023 17:45

Accidents do happen but if you overall get bad vibes from the place then look for something else.

tiaandduck · 23/03/2023 17:02

There may be policies to follow with the cctv, it may not be as cut and dry as refusing to show you

With the hand, I couldn't get worked up about it. It's so easy to step back and stumble if there is a young child behind you unknowingly.
What would bother me though, is the lack of explanation. If they came out and said oh Susan accidentally stepped on Emily's hand, we are so sorry about that, then that would be fine.
Your gut is telling you something, so just go with it.

bedtimestories · 23/03/2023 16:57

You can ask for the CCTV footage under the freedom of information act

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 23/03/2023 16:46

At the end of the day OP, you're arguing with the wrong people here.

No one here can override GDPR. It's written into law. We (and the nursery) cannot override law because we don't personally agree with it. That's like me giving you permission to break into your neighbours house and take all their stuff.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 23/03/2023 16:45

Footage can be saved and shared as well, remember. Memory and eyesight are harder to share.

DontMakeMeShushYou · 23/03/2023 16:12

2babies93 · 23/03/2023 15:16

Exactly, it's one rule here and another there.

Many comments also talking about looked after children etc. I could've seen them at the settling in session, or I may see them at drop off/pick up, or I may see them in the photos they send home (yes some have other children in). The nursery we are moving to also does pick up/drop off in the room, so we would see the other children then too. CCTV is arguably "safer" as it often won't even be clear enough to pick out a baby you hardly know.

It isn't because it is a safeguarding risk, although it may be. It's because of GDPR.

A CCTV recording is counted as processing of personal data. Therefore it falls under GDPR legislation. Data relating to children is given special protection. The nursery is complying with its data protection obligations. As it should.

Littlewhitecat · 23/03/2023 16:03

OP you have a choice. You continue to send your child here despite clearly being upset about the way the nursery had dealt with this incident or you send your child elsewhere. You either trust the nursery (which you don't appear to do) or you don't. If you don't trust them why on earth would you continue to send your child there? You can't claim child care is more important than child protection. What parent who genuinely thought their child safety was at risk works continue to use that setting? What would you do if you saw the CCTV footage? Demand the staff member was sacked? Do you honestly think given how wound up you are about this that seeing the footage is going to make you happy? They aren't going to show it to you so make your choice.

Anonhopingforbaby · 23/03/2023 16:02

@2babies93

If you don't think it'll be clear enough to see looked after babies, why would it be clear enough to see yours?

I'm sorry but you could be anyone, yes maybe a member of staff could vouch for you, but how does anyone know that's truthful? You're spinning an accident way out of proportion and need to relax.

ohyouknowwhatshername · 23/03/2023 15:38

Thehop · 23/03/2023 12:23

I think the fact that she was fine at pick up and they've gone out their way to investiga/identify what may have happened and tell you is admirable and shows honesty.

I agree. Accidents happen OP. The nursery have told you about it and your baby is OK, that's the main thing.

2babies93 · 23/03/2023 15:16

Babyboomtastic · 23/03/2023 14:56

I find it a bit baffling that you are allowed to see the other children in person for viewing a nursery, settling in, any other time you go in, and that's fine, but viewing the same children, in the same room, on cctv (supervised so you can't record/download it) is a safeguarding risk.

Exactly, it's one rule here and another there.

Many comments also talking about looked after children etc. I could've seen them at the settling in session, or I may see them at drop off/pick up, or I may see them in the photos they send home (yes some have other children in). The nursery we are moving to also does pick up/drop off in the room, so we would see the other children then too. CCTV is arguably "safer" as it often won't even be clear enough to pick out a baby you hardly know.

OP posts:
Applerumbl · 23/03/2023 15:13

So what are you hoping to achieve by seeing the CCTV. Are you expecting a nursery worker to have purposely stepped on your child's hand. Do you really believe this is what happened.
Or, much more likely a nursery worker accidently stood on your child's hand, small children move a lot, their hands move too, have you never accidently hurt someone? Because most people have.

Scalottia · 23/03/2023 15:10

Raineth · 23/03/2023 13:02

I would be absolutely livid and report them to Ofsted for negligence. Yes it was an accident, but they should not have been stepping that close to a baby, and they should have been extremely clear where the baby was at all times!

The CCTV I don’t think they’ll show you but I’d ask for a written assurance from the manager that it will not be deleted. Tell them you are considering a police complaint for criminal negligence and that the CCTV is relevant evidence.

Who stands on a baby ffs.

I wouldn’t leave my baby there another 6 months either.

Don’t get distracted by the CCTV issue, the point is that they negligently injured a baby they were looking after. Work out what action you want. I’d be pushing for an emergency Ofsted inspection.

Dramatic.

WimbourneWasps · 23/03/2023 15:09

Take her out and look after her yourself if you're that concerned

MumOf2workOptions · 23/03/2023 15:04

@2babies93
I'd phone up children's services at your local authority and speak to the senior on call social worker and explain what has happened and ask them to investigate it as a safeguarding concern - i'd be fuming 😤

Anonhopingforbaby · 23/03/2023 15:01

IndiganDop · 23/03/2023 14:16

This doesn't make sense to me.
How is the nursery apparently covering up anything? Your baby cried, they didn't know why, they looked at cctv and still couldn't be certain, but thought it was possible that someone stepped on her hand. I assume it's "may have" because the person stepping didn't feel anything underfoot and is therefore not sure that they can have stepped on her, "but on the other hand she started crying as I walked past so perhaps it's possible that I stepped on a finger without noticing...."

If they wanted to cover up, they just could have said nothing, handed over your baby who by then was calm and with no visible injury, and you'd have been none the wiser.

Not everything is clear cut in life. This really really would not have bothered me at all. I'd have thanked them for drawing it to my attention and watched her that evening for any signs of illness or any bumps or anything that might provide an alternative explanation for her getting upset, since nobody was 100 percent sure what happened.

With ratios of 1:8 in baby rooms, and crawling or tottering babies, accidents are going to happen. If this is the worst thing you have to deal with in relation to your daughter you are incredibly blessed.

Exactly. Another baby could've done something. A toddler could've done something, dropped something erc. It's not that big a deal

AbreathofFrenchair · 23/03/2023 15:00

Raineth · 23/03/2023 13:02

I would be absolutely livid and report them to Ofsted for negligence. Yes it was an accident, but they should not have been stepping that close to a baby, and they should have been extremely clear where the baby was at all times!

The CCTV I don’t think they’ll show you but I’d ask for a written assurance from the manager that it will not be deleted. Tell them you are considering a police complaint for criminal negligence and that the CCTV is relevant evidence.

Who stands on a baby ffs.

I wouldn’t leave my baby there another 6 months either.

Don’t get distracted by the CCTV issue, the point is that they negligently injured a baby they were looking after. Work out what action you want. I’d be pushing for an emergency Ofsted inspection.

Are you always this dramatic?

I can literally guarantee Ofsted would not inspect over this incident.

The baby wasn't stood on, their hand was caught by the members of staffs foot. Trust me, it's not that uncommon, especially babies that stealth crawl and end up right behind you.

It's not negligence, it's not criminal negligence and it's not whatever other dramatic situation you are trying to froth up.

I suggest you make a brew and calm yourself down, it's not healthy to have thos much fury inside you. Or maybe channel it into fiction writing?!

Babyboomtastic · 23/03/2023 14:56

I find it a bit baffling that you are allowed to see the other children in person for viewing a nursery, settling in, any other time you go in, and that's fine, but viewing the same children, in the same room, on cctv (supervised so you can't record/download it) is a safeguarding risk.

ElizabethBest · 23/03/2023 14:54

For clarity on the why it's not ok - you say you'd be fine with all the other parents seeing footage of your child. What about if your husband was extremely abusive and had been violent to your DC, forcing you to get a restraining order, and you are worried he's looking for you. Are you ok then with a bunch of strangers seeing your child? Strangers who could be that husband's coworker, or gym buddy or new neighbour, who might then share that information or footage.

What if there is a child who is in foster care due to neglectful, addictive or abusive parents who is then identifiable from that footage?

wombat1a · 23/03/2023 14:49

I know lots of people who have stepped on dog s**t, I am sure they try to avoid that just as much as they try to avoid a babies hand.

RE CCTV, most CCTV I've seen is pretty poor, you can make out who people are and you can see they are doing something but you generally can't make out details. You certainly wouldn't be able to see if someone stood on a babies hand or just missed it - it would only be from a reaction you would 'know' and even that can be misleading.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 23/03/2023 14:48

I don’t think you’re the kind of person for whom a nursery is ever going to work, OP. Between insisting that you being a mum overrides legal protections and thinking accidents are unacceptable, I think the only thing good enough for you will be your own care.

I feel for the nursery, honestly.

ElizabethBest · 23/03/2023 14:47

It may be that there's a looked after child in the same nursery class, in which case the nursery are absolutely not allowed to show footage or photos under any circumstances. If she wasn't showing distress at pick up, and they went out of their way to tell you and investigate then I think YABU.

Lwrenagain · 23/03/2023 14:44

Any parents of adopted or care givers of looked after children would be very upset if you saw images of their children.
Say you recognised a LO who'd been removed from the Local Authority and placed into care, but LO's birth parents were friends or colleagues and you were to say, without any knowledge of course, "didn't know our LO's were in the same room at little angels", you've accidentally put many people and children in danger.
Sadly, not out the realm of possibility.

I'm a clumsy fucker and I've gone tumbling over my kids more times than I'd care to share, but something about the lack of clarification seems off.

Trust your judgement, new and shiny isn't always for the best.
Nurseries are hit and miss, I've worked in them and I'd only send my children to council ran ones, which may not be helpful to you, but I'd consider a child minder before a nursery.
Also, look for older staff, not all ran with one experienced staff member and apprentice staff.

Gincan · 23/03/2023 14:43

I accidentally poked my daughter in the eye earlier. Maybe I should turn myself in to social services.

BasiliskStare · 23/03/2023 14:27

They have admitted the " may have. " - so they are not covering it up - they probably do not know the specific circumstances but you can't go again the law and demand CCTV - accidents do happen . So to my shame I failed to catch DS when he fell over once and he has a slight scar from stitches . It was an accident. Me not the nursery.

I think other posters are right - if your trust is broken with this nursery - then remove your child. But I suspect you are a hiding to nothing to expect CCTV which may show other children. Report as you will but if you do not trust the nursery then find another. This is a long time ago but at DS's nursery there was a book where any falling over , injury , however slight had to be written down. I trusted that nursery & thereby might be the difference.

2babies93 · 23/03/2023 14:23

JarByTheDoor · 23/03/2023 14:08

Exactly — that's what smells wrong to me about this situation. If someone stood on a baby's hand they will have noticed. Either it was something else altogether that happened, meaning the nursery either don't know what happened so can't prevent it happening again with worse consequences or do know what happened and are hiding it, or the staff member who stood on the baby, and must know damn well they stood on the baby, is hiding the fact that they know they did that. I would much rather have babies being looked after by people who are honest. CCTV or not, if a staff member stood on a baby I'd expect them to have told someone about that or recorded it. If they'll deny all knowledge of a minor accident that caused no serious harm, what else will they lie about?

That's my maim concern. If they just admitted it, I'd not think twice.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread