Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think less women breastfed

134 replies

bbyno2 · 23/03/2023 11:27

Stats are out that at 8 weeks of age almost 50% (49.3%) of babies are being breastfed. The way threads go and people talk around breastfeeding on mumsnet and my peer groups aibu to think it would be a lot less.I thought like 30% max as those who breastfeed seem to act like they are a minority (I guess they are by 0.7%?)

Data: www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/resource/breastfeeding#breastfeeding-of-infants

OP posts:
Babyboomtastic · 23/03/2023 12:51

Yet, breastfeeding is 'free' (please let's not get into the 'its only free if ... or 'I spent £x on it') so it would make sense to help women on lower incomes to breastfeed as it will reduce impact on their budget.

And yet you've raised the subject of cost. So what your mean is, please don't say anything to contradict my opinion on this 🙄

Your assumption is based on mother's in poorer families having a decent length maternity leave for a start. What about the mum who has to return to an evening cleaning/pub/retail job at 3m to keep afloat? Those who for financial reasons can only have 6w off but has family who can care for the child? Or those families where the dad doesn't work but the mum does, so she takes the minimum? For some women, and especially those on lower incomes, they don't have the luxury of long maternity leaves, and breastfeeding (without considerable pumping) isn't viable.

ShirleyPhallus · 23/03/2023 12:45

NotJohnWick · 23/03/2023 12:42

I imagine there's lots of reasons. Single mums are less likely to be well off, and won't have the support needed to get them through the very labour and time intensive early weeks of breastfeeding. Two parent families with low income, again, won't be able to take maternity/paternity leave for as long, and won't be able to buy in outside help - childcare for older children, easy to cook food, cleaners, lactation consultants. In general, there's an inverse relationship between income and number of children- better off families on average have fewer children, more spaced out, so more time to devote to establishing breastfeeding. Well off women in general have their first children at a later age, when they are more likely to be confident with feeding in public. There's probably peer pressure amongst wealthy mums groups to be 'perfect', which in those circles means breastfed, organic, BLW, Montessori type approaches.

In short - breastfeeding is initially time consuming and money buys time.

This is a really interesting take given I simply thought formula = money / BF = free but they’re all good points

NotJohnWick · 23/03/2023 12:45

Babyboomtastic · 23/03/2023 12:41

I don't think the exclusive BF rate is a good metric at all.

My daughter was pretty much exclusively breastfed, and I fed her for 2.5y. She had some formula in the first few weeks. 99.9% of her nutritional intake was breast milk.

I know others who bf for 3+ years who gave a single tip up in the first week, it for a time supplemented. They were effectively exclusively breastfed babies but again excluded from the figures. Or those that began weaning before 6m, even by a day.

Extended bf is quite common in my area, but I only know of 1 woman who would have ticked the 'exclusive to 6m' box. I know about a dozen who were in the 99.9% category though.

Agreed. Mine were bf until 2y5m and 2y10m, but DC1 had a bottle of formula when I was taken to a&e by ambulance (suspected anaphylaxis) when she was about 3 months, and DC2 started pulling food off our plates about 2 weeks before turning 6 months, so neither of them were exclusively breastfed. Even though in practice they clearly were.

mishmased · 23/03/2023 12:44

PinkDaffodil2 · 23/03/2023 12:35

It differs so much by demographic your experience is unlikely to reflect the national norms.

Only about 1 in 3 in the UK are still breastfeeding at all at 6 months. I’ve never looked up the statistics for 2 years but I breasted until 2.5 years, the other 3 female GPs at my practice all fed at least some of their children for that long, plus our pharmacist is feeding her 2 year old! The Mums I did GP training with are similar.
Several of them had never given their child a bottle - myself included. Exclusive breastfeeding and It feels really normal to me but I’m pretty sure it’s actually very rare in the UK and GPs (or just my bunch!) are outliers.

This is lovely to read as I've had to challenge a GP and a physio that said there was no benefits to breastfeeding past 6 months. This was partly in reference to someone asking me about breastfeeding feeding my then 2 year old. Another doctor friend had a similar attitude but I can't be bothered.

NotJohnWick · 23/03/2023 12:42

ShirleyPhallus · 23/03/2023 12:32

I thought this was a trend too, and wonder why. Is there just more support for BF in more affluent areas?

I imagine there's lots of reasons. Single mums are less likely to be well off, and won't have the support needed to get them through the very labour and time intensive early weeks of breastfeeding. Two parent families with low income, again, won't be able to take maternity/paternity leave for as long, and won't be able to buy in outside help - childcare for older children, easy to cook food, cleaners, lactation consultants. In general, there's an inverse relationship between income and number of children- better off families on average have fewer children, more spaced out, so more time to devote to establishing breastfeeding. Well off women in general have their first children at a later age, when they are more likely to be confident with feeding in public. There's probably peer pressure amongst wealthy mums groups to be 'perfect', which in those circles means breastfed, organic, BLW, Montessori type approaches.

In short - breastfeeding is initially time consuming and money buys time.

Babyboomtastic · 23/03/2023 12:41

ILookAtTheFloor · 23/03/2023 12:34

The key metric for me is exclusive BF- I imagine that figure is very low. At 8 weeks I imagine most have a least a bit of breast milk, so that figure does seem super low.

The number exclusive BF and no formula at all at 6 months is tiny in my experience.

I don't think the exclusive BF rate is a good metric at all.

My daughter was pretty much exclusively breastfed, and I fed her for 2.5y. She had some formula in the first few weeks. 99.9% of her nutritional intake was breast milk.

I know others who bf for 3+ years who gave a single tip up in the first week, it for a time supplemented. They were effectively exclusively breastfed babies but again excluded from the figures. Or those that began weaning before 6m, even by a day.

Extended bf is quite common in my area, but I only know of 1 woman who would have ticked the 'exclusive to 6m' box. I know about a dozen who were in the 99.9% category though.

emituofo · 23/03/2023 12:40

Depends on the country. I had my my DS in New Zealand and DD in the UK, I breastfed them both up to 14 months, but very different experiences.

In NZ the breastfeeding culture is so strong that formula is almost not an option. I remember asking my MW if I needed to prepare formular when giving birth just in case and she told me no, you WILL breastfeed. After giving birth, there were nurses who came to wake me up a few times at night to encourage ( almost force me to breastfeed). Everywhere I went, ie shopping malls, museums etc there were breastfeeding facilities with multiple curtained spaces so you could easily feed in privacy. Breastfeeding in public is very common, no one looks at you. On the other hand, I have friends who couldnt breastfees and almost got bullied and discriminated by other health workers and mums.

In the Uk, no one encouraged me to breastfeed. There is definitely no pressure at all. There were very few breastfeeding friendly facilities where I lived. Some baby changing rooms didnt even have a chair to sit down. I have barely seen anyone breastfeeding in public. For the few time I did breastfed in public I got some strange stares which made me very uncomfortable.

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 12:36

It's an interesting one.

In some countries it's a mark of wealth and status to formula feed. It's showing that you have the clean water to make it and the money to buy it.

Breastfeeding support is so dependant on charities and grants that you need the demand to make the applications to get the grants.

Sadly if an area has low rates, there isn't the drive from those with the money to improve support there as 'there isn't the demand'.

Yet, breastfeeding is 'free' (please let's not get into the 'its only free if ... or 'I spent £x on it') so it would make sense to help women on lower incomes to breastfeed as it will reduce impact on their budget.

PinkDaffodil2 · 23/03/2023 12:35

It differs so much by demographic your experience is unlikely to reflect the national norms.

Only about 1 in 3 in the UK are still breastfeeding at all at 6 months. I’ve never looked up the statistics for 2 years but I breasted until 2.5 years, the other 3 female GPs at my practice all fed at least some of their children for that long, plus our pharmacist is feeding her 2 year old! The Mums I did GP training with are similar.
Several of them had never given their child a bottle - myself included. Exclusive breastfeeding and It feels really normal to me but I’m pretty sure it’s actually very rare in the UK and GPs (or just my bunch!) are outliers.

Curiosity101 · 23/03/2023 12:34

In those stats it doesn't meant 50% are exclusively breastfed, I suspect that number is much much lower.

What I see is at 8 weeks 50% are exclusively formula fed. And the other 50% get some amount of breastmilk through some mechanism. When they say breastfed, they don't require that it is done directly or completely.

So the 50% population of breastfed 6-8 weeks olds is made up of:
Exclusive breastfeeding
Combi fed (breastfed direct and formula bottles)
Combi fed (breast milk via a bottle and formula bottles)
Combi fed (breastfed direct, breast milk via a bottle and formula bottles)
and probably some other combinations I've not thought of.

ILookAtTheFloor · 23/03/2023 12:34

The key metric for me is exclusive BF- I imagine that figure is very low. At 8 weeks I imagine most have a least a bit of breast milk, so that figure does seem super low.

The number exclusive BF and no formula at all at 6 months is tiny in my experience.

ShirleyPhallus · 23/03/2023 12:32

NotJohnWick · 23/03/2023 12:29

I moved from a fairly low income area, where I was the only one in a busy baby group breastfeeding (the only one out of 20+) to a fairly affluent area, where nearly all the babies were breastfed. The difference was very surprising.

I thought this was a trend too, and wonder why. Is there just more support for BF in more affluent areas?

mishmased · 23/03/2023 12:29

I realised I'm in the minority when a colleague was shocked that I'm still breastfeeding my 22 month old.

NotJohnWick · 23/03/2023 12:29

Reugny · 23/03/2023 12:25

If you read the stats breast feeding depends on ethnicity, age and socioeconomic status.

This means if you ebf, partially breast fed or didn't at all then those around you will be highly likely to be doing the same due to where you live.

I moved from a fairly low income area, where I was the only one in a busy baby group breastfeeding (the only one out of 20+) to a fairly affluent area, where nearly all the babies were breastfed. The difference was very surprising.

GrannyWeatherwaxsBroomstick · 23/03/2023 12:27

All of my NCT group breast fed at first. One gave up at 3 months (because she had twins and it was just too much for her). Others tailed off up to a year. A couple of us carried on until 2 years. DS was 2 years 9 months when he stopped.
I noticed that there were generational differences in people I knew. My parents & their friends were very much in favour of formula, but my grandparents and their friends were very much in favour of breastfeeding.

7Worfs · 23/03/2023 12:27

Only 0.5% of UK babies breastfed at 12 month old? If that’s accurate it’s tragic. I doubt it though - is this data fed through health visitors and include pretty much everyone?

Chickenly · 23/03/2023 12:25

So, at eight weeks, just under 50% of babies are breastfed or combi-fed and yet you’re shocked that breastfeeding is perceived to be the minority? It is the minority. Even at only eight weeks in (keeping in mind that WHO recommend breastfeeding for two years) over half of babies aren’t breastfed at all. I only know of one person who breastfed until 2 years (not that I’ve conducted a survey on it). The data you’ve provided supports the perception you’re trying to disprove. Am I too cynical or was there an ulterior motive in posting?

Reugny · 23/03/2023 12:25

If you read the stats breast feeding depends on ethnicity, age and socioeconomic status.

This means if you ebf, partially breast fed or didn't at all then those around you will be highly likely to be doing the same due to where you live.

pointythings · 23/03/2023 12:23

It varies wildly - in the (very small) baby group I was part of, way back in 2001, at 6 weeks 5 out of 6 of us were bf. By a year it was 2, me and one other lady. When we all had our second babies (at roughly the same time, weirdly enough) 4 out of 6 of us were bottle feeding, I was breastfeeding and our 6th only had one child. I fed both of mine to past a year, and that was very unusual round here to the point where the hv was surprised when I couldn't answer the question about how many oz of milk my DD2 was taking.

DappledThings · 23/03/2023 12:20

It was really rare to see a bottle fed baby in the bit of South London I was in. NCT group was 8 of us, everyone tried bf. One it didn't work out for but the other 7 of us were still all ebf at 8 weeks, 5 carried on past a year. Wasn't unusual.

MattieandmummyandIs · 23/03/2023 12:17

I'm one of the rare breastfed until 2 ladies.

Of my 9 strong NCT group all breast fed until 6 months and by 1 year that had dropped to 7 still breastfeeding. 3 continued to feed until 18months and then there were the last 2 at 2 years old. I suspect though that we were an unusual group, of my second baby friends the vast majority are formula feeding.

LynnLardAssian · 23/03/2023 12:08

I am the only one of my friends who gave up breastfeeding early (6 weeks is the longest I fed for). Every other woman I’m friends with or in my family BF’d until at least 6 months, many up to 12 months and a couple beyond that.

I definitely felt like the odd one out!

Wowzel · 23/03/2023 12:03

All my friends breast fed except me, who tried and couldn't

WhatNoRaisins · 23/03/2023 12:01

Infant feeding seems almost tribal to me. You can feel like you're in a minority even when you aren't statistically depending on what most people immediately around you are doing.

GobbieMaggie · 23/03/2023 11:52

My first was bf for 12 weeks and then I went back to work. The other two were formula fed from the outset. They all grew up happy and healthy.