Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think less women breastfed

134 replies

bbyno2 · 23/03/2023 11:27

Stats are out that at 8 weeks of age almost 50% (49.3%) of babies are being breastfed. The way threads go and people talk around breastfeeding on mumsnet and my peer groups aibu to think it would be a lot less.I thought like 30% max as those who breastfeed seem to act like they are a minority (I guess they are by 0.7%?)

Data: www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/resource/breastfeeding#breastfeeding-of-infants

OP posts:
Babyboomtastic · 23/03/2023 14:03

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 13:45

I think I view 50/50 parenting very differently than a lot of people on here. I also don't see breastfeeding as a barrier to equal parenting.

To me, 50/50 doesn't mean doing half of every job. I look over the whole course of the kids' lives. At some points it will be more me (my DH couldn't do half the pregnancy) and at other times it will be more him (I have to travel quite a bit at the moment for family reasons) it averages out over time.

My DH never gave our daughter any milk, but he did a ton of other stuff for her. For our son he could only give a potential 4 bottles a week out of 14 given. That didn't mean he couldn't do anything else for them. Or that he'd met his dad quota with those 4 bottles.

He's as much a parent as me. How we fed our children as infants has no impact that. It's such a small amount of our children's lives.

But then I grew up with a similar set up. My dad was just as much a parent to me as my mum. He did everything for us apart from breastfeed us. He was the one who did more of the emergency child care etc as he had a job that was more flexible.

I've seen many many people say that, and many of them truly believe it, but often their families do not look equal to me. It's still the women that usually do more of the nights, the cooking, the child rearing, but still sees it is equal, because he does more than in some families.

With my accidentally bf baby, we desperately tried to keep a balance of equal (but different) parenting, but the difference in how our daughter sees us is light and day compared to the equality we have with our ff child. He was (is) fully involved in every other aspect. With a mixture of SPL, Covid and other things, he's been round in her life full time for at least half of it. He is very much the 'other parent'. I'm the one she cries for, goes to when injured, sleeps with at night.

It's wonderful when it works out totally equal despite breastfeeding, but it's a lot harder I think. We tried and failed

Whattowearintheoffice · 23/03/2023 13:57

Babyboomtastic · 23/03/2023 12:41

I don't think the exclusive BF rate is a good metric at all.

My daughter was pretty much exclusively breastfed, and I fed her for 2.5y. She had some formula in the first few weeks. 99.9% of her nutritional intake was breast milk.

I know others who bf for 3+ years who gave a single tip up in the first week, it for a time supplemented. They were effectively exclusively breastfed babies but again excluded from the figures. Or those that began weaning before 6m, even by a day.

Extended bf is quite common in my area, but I only know of 1 woman who would have ticked the 'exclusive to 6m' box. I know about a dozen who were in the 99.9% category though.

This is an interesting point. My first got probably 50ml total formula in the early days, given by a midwife, as she struggled to latch. Then she was breastfed exclusively to six months. It’s funny to think that 50ml means we go in the partial cohort. I continued to breastfed for more than two years (but she had a bit of formula between 7-12 months too).

My second has never had any formula.

tfresh · 23/03/2023 13:47

It's extremely class/income based. If you're hanging around more people on benefits, or unemployed you're going to see a lot less breastfeeding.

queenatom · 23/03/2023 13:46

I'm surprised its that low! Obviously these things vary massively from place to place but most people I know breastfed till 6 months. In our NCT group we all tried breastfeeding, 6 of 8 were still breastfeeding at 6 months and 5 of us made it to a year.

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 13:45

I think I view 50/50 parenting very differently than a lot of people on here. I also don't see breastfeeding as a barrier to equal parenting.

To me, 50/50 doesn't mean doing half of every job. I look over the whole course of the kids' lives. At some points it will be more me (my DH couldn't do half the pregnancy) and at other times it will be more him (I have to travel quite a bit at the moment for family reasons) it averages out over time.

My DH never gave our daughter any milk, but he did a ton of other stuff for her. For our son he could only give a potential 4 bottles a week out of 14 given. That didn't mean he couldn't do anything else for them. Or that he'd met his dad quota with those 4 bottles.

He's as much a parent as me. How we fed our children as infants has no impact that. It's such a small amount of our children's lives.

But then I grew up with a similar set up. My dad was just as much a parent to me as my mum. He did everything for us apart from breastfeed us. He was the one who did more of the emergency child care etc as he had a job that was more flexible.

Babyboomtastic · 23/03/2023 13:45

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 13:35

No, I mean the actual product of breastmilk is free. It is made by the mother for the baby. You don't 'need' anything more than boobs to do it.

I know a single mum of 4 whose on a very low income. She'll be the first to tell you that a big reason why she breastfed her youngest 2 was cost and lack thereof. She doesn't have any breastfeeding bras or tops or pumps or kit. She just fed them.

If you've got money for formula, you've also got money to spend on breastfeeding if you want to do that.

If you've not got money for either, the free product could be a viable choice.

You miss the point. Many mums on low incomes don't have the luxury of being at home to breastfeed and have to return to return quickly.

A tub of formula costs about the same as an hour pay in minimum wage. Extortionate but a lot cheaper than not being able to work at all.

cazinge · 23/03/2023 13:42

@DappledThings don't assume bottle = formula. My DS was exclusively fed breast milk for over 12 months (up to 14 months he was mixed BM & cows) but it was only ever from a bottle as he couldn't latch due to undiagnosed tongue tie.

Try being an mother who exclusively expresses...then you really are in the minority & you don't belong in either tribe 😂

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 13:35

Babyboomtastic · 23/03/2023 12:51

Yet, breastfeeding is 'free' (please let's not get into the 'its only free if ... or 'I spent £x on it') so it would make sense to help women on lower incomes to breastfeed as it will reduce impact on their budget.

And yet you've raised the subject of cost. So what your mean is, please don't say anything to contradict my opinion on this 🙄

Your assumption is based on mother's in poorer families having a decent length maternity leave for a start. What about the mum who has to return to an evening cleaning/pub/retail job at 3m to keep afloat? Those who for financial reasons can only have 6w off but has family who can care for the child? Or those families where the dad doesn't work but the mum does, so she takes the minimum? For some women, and especially those on lower incomes, they don't have the luxury of long maternity leaves, and breastfeeding (without considerable pumping) isn't viable.

No, I mean the actual product of breastmilk is free. It is made by the mother for the baby. You don't 'need' anything more than boobs to do it.

I know a single mum of 4 whose on a very low income. She'll be the first to tell you that a big reason why she breastfed her youngest 2 was cost and lack thereof. She doesn't have any breastfeeding bras or tops or pumps or kit. She just fed them.

If you've got money for formula, you've also got money to spend on breastfeeding if you want to do that.

If you've not got money for either, the free product could be a viable choice.

Parker231 · 23/03/2023 13:35

Whattowearintheoffice · 23/03/2023 11:38

The data is for either full or partial breastfeeding at 6-8 weeks. “Between 2009/10 and 2018/19, the percentage of infants totally or partially breastfed at six to eight weeks fluctuated at around 45%, before increasing to 49% in 2021/22.”

Considering the advice is exclusive breastfeeding until six months, that seems like a very low number to me.

Every woman I know in the UK who had a baby tried breastfeeding. We know that bottle feeding is very much in the minority for first feeds in the UK. But there is such a fall off in breastfeeding by 6-8 weeks. What happens to cause that? There are many reasons but formula feeding starts as a minority and becomes the majority when babies are still newborns.

Didn’t go to any baby groups so no comparison but I used formula from day one. It’s only on Mn are people interested in how others feed their babies

happysingleversary · 23/03/2023 13:31

RedRobyn2021 · 23/03/2023 13:29

I literally have never met someone IRL who is still breastfeeding as long as me, my DD was 2 in February

Most mums I meet maybe start off bf but eventually formula feed and I basically feel like a weirdo!

I think there are a lot of factors which effect the numbers but namely it's the lack of support for those who want to.

I fed til 5. Friend til 6.
It's not very common where I live. It was my friends who opened my eyes.

RedRobyn2021 · 23/03/2023 13:29

I literally have never met someone IRL who is still breastfeeding as long as me, my DD was 2 in February

Most mums I meet maybe start off bf but eventually formula feed and I basically feel like a weirdo!

I think there are a lot of factors which effect the numbers but namely it's the lack of support for those who want to.

Babyboomtastic · 23/03/2023 13:19

Logicoutofthewindow · 23/03/2023 12:56

May I ask what put you off in the first place since you never attempted it? Just wondering if like the women I work with it was pressure from b/f, worry of drooping, other worries etc.

Can I answer this too please?
I chose to ff my first, and decided to mix feed my second (but she refused bottles from birth so it was just boob for 2.5yrs).

With my first:

Pressure from bf: no husband for supportive either way
Worrying about dropping: couldn't care less.

For background, I'm a married professional woman.

I just didn't want to. I didn't want to have the sole responsibility for feeding my baby. I wanted to be able to share the nights (I did) and the leave (we did SPL). I wanted us both to be parents on equal footing, with no default parent. I saw how easily the role of default parent emerged, and how that seemed more obvious in friends who breastfed. I'd given my body up for 9m, it went through a battering in pregnancy, and then surgery, and I wanted it back again. I'd done the but that HAD to be just me, now it was time to share.

I then looked up various studies on the benefits of breastfeeding, especially sibling studies and that that tried to eliminate the socio-economic factors, and my view was that the benefits of breastfeeding, in a country like the UK, were overstated. A small increase in tummy bugs and ear infections and that was about it.

I was content with my decision.

I didn't change my mind for my second, I was content with the idea of formula, but I liked the idea of being able to breastfeed in a sling, and I figured if we did mix, I'd do boobs, my husband would do bottles and we'd have a lot of flexibility and still be able to share. Baby had first fees from boob, second from bottle and then roughly alternated, until a couple of days in, she started showing a preference for boobs, and by day 5 refused totally.

Dirtydiesel · 23/03/2023 13:16

I fed some expressed milk until 6 weeks. Ds never latched on and by then the bulk was formula and I was sick of never leaving the house ( because of all the expressing) so I abandoned it. All the other women in my family breast fed until at least a year.

TheOtherHotstepper · 23/03/2023 13:07

My DC were both EBF until six months. Neither ever had a bottle (of anything). We carried on until they both completely weaned themselves at a little over 12 months, by which time I was back at work.

My SD is still BF on demand day and night. DGS is a month off his third birthday, so I guess she is very much an outlier. However, he does not count as EBF, however much she might want him to, because he spent three weeks in hospital as a newborn and was fed formula by naso-gastric tube.

NotJohnWick · 23/03/2023 13:05

Shirty48 · 23/03/2023 12:57

100% of women should do what’s best for them. That’s the only statistic that matters. Your breasts your choice.

If you look at the disparity in bf rates compared with other countries, and the number of threads with women who either want to continue bf'ing, or want to stop, but don't know how and haven't got any support, it's pretty obvious that this isn't the case. It's important to understand why people make the choices they do to tailor support.

happysingleversary · 23/03/2023 13:05

Of course. That's marketing for you.

No one is taught the real reasons to breastfeed in school.

When I found out they provide the immune system and gut I was shocked. I was 35!

We should be taught but we won't because long-term health problems and formula provide massive revenue.

DeflatedAgain · 23/03/2023 13:05

I breastfeed but only know one other mum who does also. The rest formula feed and didn't even try too 🤷🏻‍♀️

Chilloutsnow · 23/03/2023 13:03

@Logicoutofthewindow

None of those things. I just simply never wanted to breastfeed. I think if I truly reflected on that, for me, I found starting off with formula just less of a faff.

For me it was quite simple, I made up 24 hours worth of feeds and I stored them in the fridge. It was then just a quick 15 seconds in the microwave, a shake and bottle in. I also never wanted to be the sole person responsible for feeding my baby and I didn’t want to express. I quite liked it when my milk dried up, the pounds fell off me and I began to feel like “me” again.

My first baby would take big feeds via the bottle and consequently would sleep through for long periods. This then influenced my choice for babies 2 and 3. All my babies went a good 4-6 hours between feeds and were very quickly sleeping through the night.

Now this may have just been luck? Or it could have been I was able to get more formula down them, hence filling their bellies up more.

So to conclude that’s why. I had successfully done it for baby number one and then after that I just stuck to what I knew. Do I think formula is comparable to breast milk? No I don’t. I think breast milk is the most superior nutritional option, but for me, on balance of all the things I mentioned it wasn’t worth it. I was very happy to just bottle feed.

LulooLemon · 23/03/2023 13:02

To breastfeed or not to breastfeed is often heavily influenced by people around the new mother - whether her sisters, cousins, friends, colleagues breastfeed.

In my experience with the NHS, it was neither encouraged nor discouraged. I had to be proactive in seeking help on the early weeks.

It was (for me) not exactly free of charge as I bought a large number of BF bras for day and night (they drenched easily), plus loads of washable breast pads, disposable breast pads, pump & sterilizer & freezer bags so that DH could try to bottle feed (that didn't work!).

Overall I was really happy with my choices.

Shirty48 · 23/03/2023 12:57

100% of women should do what’s best for them. That’s the only statistic that matters. Your breasts your choice.

DappledThings · 23/03/2023 12:57

There were very few breastfeeding friendly facilities where I lived. Some baby changing rooms didnt even have a chair to sit down. I have barely seen anyone breastfeeding in public. For the few time I did breastfed in public I got some strange stares which made me very uncomfortable.
Not my experience at all. But then I consider every cafe, park bench and anywhere else to be a breastfeeding friendly space because I chose to make them so. Never had a weird look or comment in 2 x 14 months.

Logicoutofthewindow · 23/03/2023 12:56

Chilloutsnow · 23/03/2023 12:51

I bottle fed my three. I never attempted to BF and their lips never even made it onto my nipple. For me, no amount of guidance, education or support would have swayed me into breastfeeding. Having said that, formula is bloody expensive now so I may have thought twice in this current economical climate.

May I ask what put you off in the first place since you never attempted it? Just wondering if like the women I work with it was pressure from b/f, worry of drooping, other worries etc.

MrsAvocet · 23/03/2023 12:54

As others have said all these things depend very much on the definition of breastfeeding used in the study. "Any breast milk at 8 weeks" will likely produce quite different figures to "exclusive breastfeeding at 8 weeks".
And national figures are an incredbly blunt tool anyway. When you look at previous studies that have split data by things like geography and socioeconomic status the differences in both initiation and continuation are absolutely vast. There will be some areas where more or less every new mother at least starts breastfeeding and most continue, and others where it is almost zero. Probably very few of us live lives where the national average is our personal experience.
In my personal life, almost all the mothers i knew when my children were young breastfed for at least 6 months, many for several years but I know that wasn't representative.

Logicoutofthewindow · 23/03/2023 12:54

Reugny · 23/03/2023 12:25

If you read the stats breast feeding depends on ethnicity, age and socioeconomic status.

This means if you ebf, partially breast fed or didn't at all then those around you will be highly likely to be doing the same due to where you live.

This. I work with women from poorer backgrounds and sadly a high number of them chose the bottle. It's sad when most of them have a free supply on tap. Lots of reasons but sometimes the 'bf/bloke' doesn't like it, worries about drooping, think bottle looks better.

Chilloutsnow · 23/03/2023 12:51

I bottle fed my three. I never attempted to BF and their lips never even made it onto my nipple. For me, no amount of guidance, education or support would have swayed me into breastfeeding. Having said that, formula is bloody expensive now so I may have thought twice in this current economical climate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread