Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think less women breastfed

134 replies

bbyno2 · 23/03/2023 11:27

Stats are out that at 8 weeks of age almost 50% (49.3%) of babies are being breastfed. The way threads go and people talk around breastfeeding on mumsnet and my peer groups aibu to think it would be a lot less.I thought like 30% max as those who breastfeed seem to act like they are a minority (I guess they are by 0.7%?)

Data: www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/resource/breastfeeding#breastfeeding-of-infants

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Allthingsfloralandpatterned88 · 24/03/2023 20:38

Albiboba · 24/03/2023 10:12

Maybe read the full comment instead of foaming at the mouth over one words without actually understanding?

It’s a SHAME that if you breastfeed 95% of the time but use some formula then you are discounted from breastfeeding statistics as they only focus on exclusively BFing.

Personally I think this makes breastfeeding figures look lower than they are in reality. I’m not a purist, I think it still counts as breastfeeding if you also use some formula.
I also don’t care if people use exclusively formula.

I agree I think those statistics make breastfeeding seem really unobtainable whereas the picture is actually far more nuanced.

7Worfs · 24/03/2023 12:25

I disagree. I was going to give up on multiple occasions if I wasn’t prodded encouraged to endure the first few weeks, as it gets so much easier.

I’m so glad I had DH badgering me to keep trying in the first two weeks - breastfed my first until 2.5yo.

Tayegete · 24/03/2023 12:09

I don't think that many women aren't aware that it is an option, particularly as it's pushed so much by the NHS/NCT/ literature/ other mums - from experience from if my children/ colleagues' and friends children) over the past 16 years.

It's just that advocates of bfeeding are so bloody evangelical about it. I thought I morally had to with my first DC and felt like I'd failed when it didn't work. However DC and I were both significantly happier when we stopped. Having some well meaning people constantly trying to convince you to carry on isn't helpful. Women are intelligent enough to make their own decisions and seek out help if they want to carry on without it being pressed upon them. I

7Worfs · 24/03/2023 11:54

Parker231 · 24/03/2023 09:17

Why are people bothered by how others decide to feed their babies ? Everyone’s reason is 100% valid for them and nothing makes their decision wrong.

It’s not about being bothered. It’s a topic that needs attention and understanding - too many women want to breastfeed, but lack knowledge, support etc and either suffer in silence, or reluctantly move to formula.
And as mentioned multiple times on this thread, whole groups of women (deprived areas/very young mums) don’t even know breastfeeding is an option to them, because it was never done around them.

Albiboba · 24/03/2023 10:12

Reugny · 24/03/2023 10:09

It's because you use the word "shame" in relation to using formula.

I have family and close friends who work in pediatrics with babies, plus I was on a hospital postnatal ward with mothers/babies that were considered high risk.

As far as my family members, close friends and the medical staff treating us were concerned they want babies fed. They don't want babies back in hospital due to issues around feeding.

Maybe read the full comment instead of foaming at the mouth over one words without actually understanding?

It’s a SHAME that if you breastfeed 95% of the time but use some formula then you are discounted from breastfeeding statistics as they only focus on exclusively BFing.

Personally I think this makes breastfeeding figures look lower than they are in reality. I’m not a purist, I think it still counts as breastfeeding if you also use some formula.
I also don’t care if people use exclusively formula.

Reugny · 24/03/2023 10:09

Albiboba · 24/03/2023 09:48

I don’t really understand how this is directed at me?

It's because you use the word "shame" in relation to using formula.

I have family and close friends who work in pediatrics with babies, plus I was on a hospital postnatal ward with mothers/babies that were considered high risk.

As far as my family members, close friends and the medical staff treating us were concerned they want babies fed. They don't want babies back in hospital due to issues around feeding.

Albiboba · 24/03/2023 09:48

Parker231 · 24/03/2023 09:17

Why are people bothered by how others decide to feed their babies ? Everyone’s reason is 100% valid for them and nothing makes their decision wrong.

I don’t really understand how this is directed at me?

Parker231 · 24/03/2023 09:17

Albiboba · 24/03/2023 08:39

It was low compared to my antenatal experience where easily 9/10 were breastfeeding but equally these stats don’t include women who breastfeed but who use any amount of formula. Which I think is a shame.
A few of us used a bottle of formula from around 8 weeks ish which is a shame Imo.

Not that women use some formula but a shame that breastfeeding for 90% or more of the time is discounted if the baby has some firmly.

Why are people bothered by how others decide to feed their babies ? Everyone’s reason is 100% valid for them and nothing makes their decision wrong.

Albiboba · 24/03/2023 08:39

Allthingsfloralandpatterned88 · 24/03/2023 00:30

I live in an affluent area and I'd say the vast majority of mothers breastfeed until at least one and those who don't it's usually for a medical reason e.g. their milk supply was very low. I don't know anyone who chose to formula feed from the outset. So I think demographics make a huge difference.

I fed DS until 14 months however he had formula the first week of his life and then some more sometimes in the day when I was back at work at 9 months. So even though I fed him round the clock for over a year he'd not be considered EBF which might explain the stats!

It was low compared to my antenatal experience where easily 9/10 were breastfeeding but equally these stats don’t include women who breastfeed but who use any amount of formula. Which I think is a shame.
A few of us used a bottle of formula from around 8 weeks ish which is a shame Imo.

Not that women use some formula but a shame that breastfeeding for 90% or more of the time is discounted if the baby has some firmly.

Allthingsfloralandpatterned88 · 24/03/2023 00:30

I live in an affluent area and I'd say the vast majority of mothers breastfeed until at least one and those who don't it's usually for a medical reason e.g. their milk supply was very low. I don't know anyone who chose to formula feed from the outset. So I think demographics make a huge difference.

I fed DS until 14 months however he had formula the first week of his life and then some more sometimes in the day when I was back at work at 9 months. So even though I fed him round the clock for over a year he'd not be considered EBF which might explain the stats!

Kuiper · 24/03/2023 00:08

It must depend a lot on the area/demographics - I live in an affluent part of London and 50% seems low from what I've seen at baby groups. But I never ask about people's choices as I know it's a touchy subject - for all I know they could be feeding expressed milk in a bottle and breastfeeding at home.

We have lots of breastfeeding support around here too (free, council funded). Never went to any of them as I never had any issues (breastfed DD1 until 3.5, probably will do same for DD2). I think I rarely breastfed out of the house beyond a year old though, as it was mainly in the mornings/evenings. I don't think even my family (outside my household) knew I was still breastfeeding as I don't make a point about it.

SwordToFlamethrower · 23/03/2023 23:41

I can't wit to get to the 13 month mark breastfeeding my daughter because my mil told me when I was first introduced to her that it is child abuse/pedophilia to breastfeed past that age, pahahaha!

4 months in and she is telling us we need to start her on purees now!

Classic mother in law stuff, pure gold 😆

DementedPanda · 23/03/2023 22:55

I breast fed dc1, then when dc1 was 16 months I gave birth again dc2 ams I struggled and wasn't gaining. Midwife offered us a place at a after birth care centre to get breastfeeding established but I couldn't leave dc1 so declined and did mixed feeding

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/03/2023 21:14

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 20:12

None of that is new though really. Women have had to deal with all of that since the dawn of time.

But on your points

Having to return to work relatively quickly - you have to take at least two weeks off. Nearly everyone I know who has returned quickly has been at least 6-12 weeks. About 80% of them have breastfed and expressed. All were self employed.

having responsibilities outside the home or for older children that have school or club commitments - older children aren't a barrier to breastfeeding.
so can’t nap in the day so want a good sleeper - bottle feeding has no scientific basis for 'good sleeping' my EBF baby slept through my night from 8 weeks. My combi fed baby did not
or no cluster feeding - all babies cluster feed, that's an instinct. It might not last as long initially for formula fed babies. They might still do it during growth spurts
not being able to wear what you want on the top half - I could wear what I liked really. I do tend to wear lots of wrap tops or vests under jumpers even now years after feeding.
having to completely always look after your baby in case he/she needs feeding and won’t take a bottle - my bottle refuser was a very easy baby to leave. I just timed my day around it. As they get older they go longer between feeds like all babies. Once weaning starts it can go longer.

A lot of this is assumption and not based on scientific evidence

My 3 month old hasn't cluster fed so far. Every 3 hours during the day like clockwork since birth.

We'll see if any of that changes when the 4 month sleep regression hits.

I went back to work very recently and I knew it would be possible to express and work but formula feeding from the start felt easier. Of course, I didn't want to breastfeed anyway so it just felt like another pro to me.

Babyboomtastic · 23/03/2023 20:48

I'm glad this discussion had stayed a lot more friendly than other similar ones on here. Interestingly effort my ff baby did sleep a lot better (and we shared the nights so I really wasn't tired at all), babyhood is such a short period.

They are 3 and 5 now. They are now both equally bad sleepers 😂

Blanketpolicy · 23/03/2023 20:34

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 20:00

@Albiboba I neither agree or disagree. I was curious to know what she meant.

Returning to work at 9 months is no barrier to breastfeeding.

With both mine at that age I could (and did) leave them for a working day with feeds just morning and night.

I returned to work FT at 7 months and also continued to feed morning and night until he was a year old and he self weaned.

Everyone should make their own choices, but there are a lot of perceived "barriers" if you don't have experience of other mums successfully managing bf and work.

When I was the only one in my circle bf I got lots of questions about how hard it must be (well for first 8 weeks it was) and then being surprised when I explained how straightforward it was once established. Some voiced regrets saying if they had known they would perhaps considered different choices.

Albiboba · 23/03/2023 20:27

Personally I don’t understand why combi feeding isn’t counted in the stats.
What is it about having the odd bottle that supposedly undoes any goodness from breastfeeding?
Exclusively breastfeeding at 6 months is apparently 1% but combined feeding is 34% so not that tiny at all!
Why is it good is a baby has one or two feeds a day from the breast but if they have one bottle as well as two breastfeeds in the day it’s suddenly ‘sad’ or ‘horrendous’?

YukoandHiro · 23/03/2023 20:15

To put it another way, half of women stop before their babies are even two months old. The lack of support (and realism about what bf entails in those early weeks) is responsible.

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 20:12

None of that is new though really. Women have had to deal with all of that since the dawn of time.

But on your points

Having to return to work relatively quickly - you have to take at least two weeks off. Nearly everyone I know who has returned quickly has been at least 6-12 weeks. About 80% of them have breastfed and expressed. All were self employed.

having responsibilities outside the home or for older children that have school or club commitments - older children aren't a barrier to breastfeeding.
so can’t nap in the day so want a good sleeper - bottle feeding has no scientific basis for 'good sleeping' my EBF baby slept through my night from 8 weeks. My combi fed baby did not
or no cluster feeding - all babies cluster feed, that's an instinct. It might not last as long initially for formula fed babies. They might still do it during growth spurts
not being able to wear what you want on the top half - I could wear what I liked really. I do tend to wear lots of wrap tops or vests under jumpers even now years after feeding.
having to completely always look after your baby in case he/she needs feeding and won’t take a bottle - my bottle refuser was a very easy baby to leave. I just timed my day around it. As they get older they go longer between feeds like all babies. Once weaning starts it can go longer.

A lot of this is assumption and not based on scientific evidence

Mexicola · 23/03/2023 20:04

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 18:52

@Mexicola that's a really interesting perspective. I'm curious about how breastfeeding doesn't fit with modern life.

Having to return to work relatively quickly, having responsibilities outside the home or for older children that have school or club commitments so can’t nap in the day so want a good sleeper or no cluster feeding, not being able to wear what you want on the top half, having to completely always look after your baby in case he/she needs feeding and won’t take a bottle…

110APiccadilly · 23/03/2023 20:01

My personal experience is that the majority (but by no means all) of the other mums I know breastfed until somewhere past six months. A reasonable number combi fed and I know that sometimes doesn't get counted in the stats.

I also know a lot of people who breastfed past a year, though in many cases you wouldn't know unless they told you as it was only at bedtime! (Personally I fed to just past a year - but under 13 months.)

However, I suspect that the mums I know are disproportionately middle class, and I know social class has a big influence on breastfeeding rates. So if a survey says about 50% breastfeeding at eight weeks, I'm willing to believe it.

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 20:00

@Albiboba I neither agree or disagree. I was curious to know what she meant.

Returning to work at 9 months is no barrier to breastfeeding.

With both mine at that age I could (and did) leave them for a working day with feeds just morning and night.

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 19:59

@Milksheikha I was curious about what that poster meant about how that has changed.

FWIW the average length of maternity leave in the uk is 39 weeks. 45% of women take more than that.

shakeitoffsis · 23/03/2023 19:45

Absolutely none of my friends nor I have breastfed our kids. We just simply didn't want to.

Albiboba · 23/03/2023 19:32

Twizbe · 23/03/2023 18:52

@Mexicola that's a really interesting perspective. I'm curious about how breastfeeding doesn't fit with modern life.

You disagree? I would have thought this was a fairly universal point of view.
Relatively short poorly paid maternity plus a high cost of living means the majority of women return to work at 9 months when smp ends. For most babies 9 months is too early to drop to only a bedtime feed so they are transitioned onto formula ahead of the return to work as a full time job and commute is typically not comparable with breastfeeding.