Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Colleague bringing scales to office - weighing others.

389 replies

SFG112112 · 23/03/2023 11:17

I work in an office with around 20 other people. A colleague has started bringing in scales so that he and others can weigh themselves in front of others.

Everyone stands in a circle around the scales and watches while they take it in turns to weigh themselves.

So far I have managed to avoid being asked to weigh myself in front of the others, perhaps because I am overweight.

Management don't seem bothered and are even joining in with the weighing.

Not really sure why posting, just wanted to hear what others think.

OP posts:
GoodChat · 25/03/2023 07:25

MeMyselfandMorris · 25/03/2023 03:55

it depends on the context. I don't see the harm but you don't say how they reacted when you refused to weigh yourself. Did you feel pressured at all? If so, then yeah this is a thing, but if not, no big deal and even might be good for team morale.

She said they haven't even asked her

Notamumsym · 25/03/2023 06:33

I think if its their choice and you're not being pressured to join in, it's up to them. I'm guessing they're all participating in some sort of slimming campaign and it's an accountability thing? Some of them did this at my work, didn't last long, the lure of the sandwich cart containing tasty treats was too much for most😅

Ukrainebaby23 · 25/03/2023 06:13

I've worked places where similar weighing goes on. I always respond with 'I don't weigh myself as I've had issues with food in the past' which is true but not as dramatic as it might sound. However, gets folk off my back.

rwalker · 25/03/2023 06:05

Unless there’s an expectation or pressure to join in leave them to it

MeMyselfandMorris · 25/03/2023 03:55

it depends on the context. I don't see the harm but you don't say how they reacted when you refused to weigh yourself. Did you feel pressured at all? If so, then yeah this is a thing, but if not, no big deal and even might be good for team morale.

TheOrigRights · 25/03/2023 00:30

LoisLane66 · 24/03/2023 23:37

@TheOrigRights
I dare because people like you don't understand that just because I hold that view, it doesn't stop you from having a different opinion.
If you're comfortable being lean with small breasts then fine. I'm not advocating that everyone should agree with me. The world would be a dull place indeed if we all had the same views. I can say that Katie Price looks XYZ and some would agree, others think it's fine. IMO skinny people's skin shows their age faster than plumper/fatter people. Fat isn't a bad word. We prefer plump chickens and the fat on bacon or roast pork. Fat keeps the person warm as well as filling out the skin. Start losing the fat and you're left with shrivelled skin.
I myself prefer to be around 11st. 14-16. Age tends to have the effect of reducing your fat levels so I have to walk more to keep the muscle from losing tone. Sometimes it's a losing battle.
Have a great weekend and forget about your size or womanliness. If you're happy then no-one else's view matters.

If someone has always been lean, their skin fits their body. At 52 I have some lines obviously, but I absolutely do not have shrivelled skin. If I put on weight and then lost it I imagine I would.
I agree that what people find attractive differs, obviously, and whether an individual feels comfortable varies hugely as well. But you said larger women are more womanly, which I find rude. I understand you don't care what I, or anyone thinks of your opinion though.

Vulvasaur · 25/03/2023 00:07

I work in eating disorders. This is super fucked up and you would be justified in raising a complaint. People don't go to work to have their bodies evaluated and god, women have enough of that shite to contend with without this kind of nonsense at work too.

LoisLane66 · 24/03/2023 23:37

@TheOrigRights
I dare because people like you don't understand that just because I hold that view, it doesn't stop you from having a different opinion.
If you're comfortable being lean with small breasts then fine. I'm not advocating that everyone should agree with me. The world would be a dull place indeed if we all had the same views. I can say that Katie Price looks XYZ and some would agree, others think it's fine. IMO skinny people's skin shows their age faster than plumper/fatter people. Fat isn't a bad word. We prefer plump chickens and the fat on bacon or roast pork. Fat keeps the person warm as well as filling out the skin. Start losing the fat and you're left with shrivelled skin.
I myself prefer to be around 11st. 14-16. Age tends to have the effect of reducing your fat levels so I have to walk more to keep the muscle from losing tone. Sometimes it's a losing battle.
Have a great weekend and forget about your size or womanliness. If you're happy then no-one else's view matters.

SFG112112 · 24/03/2023 23:35

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 24/03/2023 23:02

Are they fat?

Who? The ones weighing themselves? I have already stated several times that not one of them is overweight, in fact most of them are very slim and/or petite.

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 24/03/2023 23:18

LoisLane66 · 24/03/2023 22:42

Everyone seems to have a point at which a remark lights the blue touch paper. 'Offended' and 'triggered' seem to be the barriers erected against any comment that doesn't align with that person's view of the subject.
Get over it.
Nothing in the world could offend me. It's just someone else's view which they're entitled to have regardless of my take on it.
In the real world there are very thin and very fat people and every size in between. It's a fact that the plumper you are, the fewer lines are noticeable. Science tells the facts and many men do prefer women to look and feel womanly. Not androgenous, sans boobs and butt and without a decent covering of flesh.
I myself can see the difference if I lose weight. It shows in my face, thighs and butt if I go under 10-10lbs . My height is 5-6 and size 14 or M. To be so obsessed with weight as to take scales into work, is laughable. They're advocating being slim, rather than a weight which is comfortable and suited to the individual. Not a good idea for the workplace but then, call centres...nuff said.

And still you go on. How bloody dare you say I am not womanly because I am lean and small breasted. I am every bit as womanly as well ever other woman.

LoisLane66 · 24/03/2023 23:02

@Ruffpuff
I totally agree. Well said. 👏

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 24/03/2023 23:02

Are they fat?

Ruffpuff · 24/03/2023 23:00

@LoisLane66 I agree with the sentiment of what you said, it’s true. It shouldn’t be brought into work.

However, I don’t think we should ever justify weight with male preferences. Women have chopped and changed their bodies to be slimmer or curvier in order to cater to what they perceive as male desire, and sometimes risk their health to do so. Some men prefer thinner women, others curvier or larger. Studies actually indicate it’s not weight, but waist to hip ratio that increases attractiveness in women in straight males. Women as a whole shouldn’t change themselves to suit this, I think straight male preference is irrelevant.

LoisLane66 · 24/03/2023 22:42

Everyone seems to have a point at which a remark lights the blue touch paper. 'Offended' and 'triggered' seem to be the barriers erected against any comment that doesn't align with that person's view of the subject.
Get over it.
Nothing in the world could offend me. It's just someone else's view which they're entitled to have regardless of my take on it.
In the real world there are very thin and very fat people and every size in between. It's a fact that the plumper you are, the fewer lines are noticeable. Science tells the facts and many men do prefer women to look and feel womanly. Not androgenous, sans boobs and butt and without a decent covering of flesh.
I myself can see the difference if I lose weight. It shows in my face, thighs and butt if I go under 10-10lbs . My height is 5-6 and size 14 or M. To be so obsessed with weight as to take scales into work, is laughable. They're advocating being slim, rather than a weight which is comfortable and suited to the individual. Not a good idea for the workplace but then, call centres...nuff said.

Verylongtime · 24/03/2023 21:12

nuttynet · 24/03/2023 20:30

I love how someone said to notify HR🤣

What they gonna do? Enforce the no
Weighing at work policy?

It sounds a bit old skool at your place of work

Er, of course HR would enforce a no weigh-in policy… Because it’s unprofessional, exclusionary, damages staff morale, solidifies and increases discrimination, is harmful to mental health, possibly physical health, could create a toxic environment rife with bullying. If you want to join a slimming club with your colleagues, do it out of the office in your own time.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 24/03/2023 21:01

ConfusedNT · 23/03/2023 11:19

That's not on, if they want to do it they should go somewhere private not out in the office in front of everyone. That could be incredibly triggering for anyone who has or has had an eating disorder

It's also unprofessional it's work not weight watchers

Yes I agree with this.

emmetgirl · 24/03/2023 20:52

@ConfusedNT thank you for responding to @SunshineGeorgie
My daughter has been hospitalised twice with an eating disorder and although quite well now she still struggles to stay that way.
If this happened in an office I worked in I'd do my f'ing nut. Weigh yourselves all you like but not in the office

GoodChat · 24/03/2023 20:48

@mustgetoffmn because it's much easier to lose weight if you've got the support of people doing it with you, who'll cheer you on and encourage you when you falter?

Ruffpuff · 24/03/2023 20:35

That’s so odd. I can’t imagine this happening anywhere I’ve worked.

I have a history of ED and my bmi is 18. I eat fine now and just try to avoid the topic of weight. However, I just know if the office were doing this I wouldn’t be able to stop myself- I’d want to compare. Heaven forbid some people in the office were lighter than me (their height wouldn’t matter), I know I’d stop eating until I was the lightest. Yes, it’s not rational or healthy- but eating disorders aren’t.

nuttynet · 24/03/2023 20:30

I love how someone said to notify HR🤣

What they gonna do? Enforce the no
Weighing at work policy?

It sounds a bit old skool at your place of work

BustyLaRoux · 24/03/2023 20:20

I have an ED and this wouldn’t bother me at all. I just wouldn’t join in because I know that behaviour isn’t helpful for me.

mustgetoffmn · 24/03/2023 20:13

JellyfishandShells · 24/03/2023 19:40

A cheap and easy way of mutual motivation and accountability , which is basically what you get with a slimming club, minus the selling of products.

Not appropriate in some settings but unless it is getting in the way of doing the actual work or in an annoying manner to non participants then could well be a good idea.

Crikey has weight obsession come to this?

mustgetoffmn · 24/03/2023 20:10

SFG112112 · 24/03/2023 18:41

And completely irrelevant to this thread.

As a “skinny” I find this remark offensive. Are you a “fatty”? Many if not all would find it offensive to be called that, same for “skinnies” take your ignorance elsewhere

mustgetoffmn · 24/03/2023 20:06

GoodChat · 24/03/2023 18:55

The guy whose idea this was simply thought it would be good to know how much everyone weighs and to react accordingly. There is no SW/WW club involved.

But they've done it more than once so surely their reactions are then based on weight fluctuation?

Why would this be a good idea? Why would it be good for him to know how much everyone weighs? Bizarre. Intrusive. Inappropriate.

mustgetoffmn · 24/03/2023 20:03

What a weird thing to do. What’s going on with this colleague? Does he think he’s doing everyone a favour as they probably can’t afford scales? Lol. Ignore. If anyone dares to try get you to join in say you think it’s weird and speak to manager.