Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 11 stone isn't that heavy unless you're really short?

242 replies

DrinksMenu · 23/03/2023 09:09

When I was losing weight a few years ago I went down from 14 and a half stone to under 13 in the space of 4 weeks. However I then seemed to stick for ages round about the 11 stone mark - my target weight was 8 stone. However o can say that 11 stone felt infinitely different from being in the 14s although I was definitely overweight at this weight.

Anyway shout out and much love to anyone and everyone on a weight loss programme - it's bloody hard !

OP posts:
Bluesheep8 · 23/03/2023 10:04

When I was losing weight a few years ago I went down from 14 and a half stone to under 13 in the space of 4 weeks.
Sorry, not the point of the thread, but how on earth did you lose over 1.5 stone in 4 weeks?

Bunnycat101 · 23/03/2023 10:03

There can be variation in body type. At 9 stone I was looking very thin and everyone thought I weighed at least a stone less but I was exercising a lot so suspect had quite a high muscle mass. 11 stone would be ok for me but not my best. Sadly I’m around 121/2 at the moment and definitely looking chunky especially around my middle whereas at sub 11 it tends to go on my thighs.

Smartiepants79 · 23/03/2023 10:03

11 stone would make me feel overweight and would put my bmi into that category.
I’m only 5’2” though.

TeaandCrumpetsforTea · 23/03/2023 10:01

I think BMI is outdated and also inaccurate to an extent. My BMI is around 19. If I went up to BMI 25 and put on the 3 st necessary to still be 'normal' I'd look, and would be, obese. I only put on 1 stone when pregnant, with 2 DCS, each over 7lbs.

TeaandCrumpetsforTea · 23/03/2023 09:58

It's all a bit meaningless talking about BMI (it's a guide) because it depends on where the weight is distributed.

Belly fat is bad.

I am short and weigh 7st 5. BMI is normal. I do not look 'thin' as in 'unhealthy'.

I once went up to 8st and I had a very fat belly. That's where it all goes on me- the worst place.
I've no bum, slim thighs and tiny hands.

You should measure your waist. It should be no more than 31.5 inches for women otherwise you are at risk of diabetes and heart disease.

Your waist/hip ratio should be under 8. Divide your waist by your hips. eg 27/36 = 0.75

TheOrigRights · 23/03/2023 09:58

ValerieDoonican · 23/03/2023 09:19

BMI is not really a reliable indicator of healthy weight / overweight. Its just an easy one to calculate because weight and height are easy to measure. Don't get too hung up on it.

I disagree, it absolutely IS a reliable indicator.
"Indicate" = suggest as desirable, point out, preferable

For the vast majority of people keeping their weight within the recommended healthy range (which is about 3 stone) is desirable.

Catspyjamas17 · 23/03/2023 09:57

Not heavy for me certainly.

whatevrrrr · 23/03/2023 09:56

I would look like a house at 11 stone, but I'm 5 foot 1 and slight (flat chested etc).

JackHackettsMac · 23/03/2023 09:53

You lost over 21lbs in 4 weeks??

Were you on one of those very low calorie liquid diets or did you cut off a limb?

I worry about people doing extreme diets as it’s not very healthy or sustainable in the long term, but I don’t actually have an opinion on other people’s weight. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Toomuchtoolong · 23/03/2023 09:53

@BarrelOfOtters same,10 stone years ago pre kids and I look back and think wee bit too gaunt but went up to 11 and sat there for years before kids and was great- easy maintained etc. now post kids 13:7 and desperately trying to lose but seems an uphill battle!

slapdashsal · 23/03/2023 09:53

I'm 5'7 approximately and between 10-11st feels right for me. As it stands I'm 12 stone however Blush

Lachimolala · 23/03/2023 09:53

I’m 5ft 1 and 11st is overweight for me, not only do I look overweight but my BMI is 29.5 at that weight. I’ve been trying to live healthier with calorie counting and walking every day since beginning of February, I’m down to 10st 5lb now. Can’t see much of a difference yet but my clothes fit more comfortably and I feel slimmer. Trying to get back down to 9st 7lb which is where I felt happiest.

TheOrigRights · 23/03/2023 09:52

11 stone would put me at 23.3 BMI which on paper is a healthy weight.
However it is 2 stone more than I am now (the weight I have been all my adult life) so for me it would not be a healthy weight, or it would not feel like a healthy weight.

HelloBunny · 23/03/2023 09:51

I’m 5”4. Under 10 stone is best for me. I feel heavy & ungainly otherwise. I’m smaller on top, so extra weight goes straight to my hips & bum. I love walking, so hate the feeling of heavier legs. Lost the baby weight last year, but it’s really not easy maintaining it...

BigFloppa · 23/03/2023 09:50

I start looking skinny at 11 stone. I'm 5ft 9.

TheOrigRights · 23/03/2023 09:50

Coxspurplepippin · 23/03/2023 09:14

At that weight my BMI would be 19.7! As opposed to the 32 it currently is Sad

Are you 6'2"?

fancyfrogs · 23/03/2023 09:49

I'm 5ft9 and at 11st my BMI would be 22.8. I've not been lower than 11st7-ish for a few years but determined to get down to 11 this year. I think I would look ok at that. Currently 12st13 with a BMI of 26.8 and feel too big. 10 weeks postpartum and bf though and I could eat all the snacks all day long. Must start trying harder 😩

GreyTS · 23/03/2023 09:49

soddingspiderseason · 23/03/2023 09:28

Weight and BMI are pretty blunt instruments for measuring overall health. Muscle weighs 3 times as much as fat, so if you exercise regularly and are a fit and muscular 11stone that will be healthier than being an unfit 9 stone with lots of unseen visceral fat. Being healthy and fit is what matters; weight per se not so much.

I love how this always comes up....yeah if you were a heavy built heavy lifting rugby player or power lifter perhaps you could be healthy at a high BMI. But is that ever actually the case with posters here, who is claiming to be so muscle bound it doesn't work for them?? Its really hard to add muscle to your frame, big or small, I've been doing it for years and went from 50kg to 56kg so only 6kg of pure muscle and it's v noticeable. Besides muscle isn't heavier than fat (take a physics class) it's denser, more tightly packed so looks leaner

GoChasingWaterfalls · 23/03/2023 09:48

5ft 4 here and currently 11 stone, trying to lose weight after piling on the pounds due to hypothyroidism.

My BMI is in the overweight category and I definitely look it. I'm much more comfortable when I'm 10 stone.

It's amazing how a couple of inches of height makes such a difference to us all in terms of how we carry the weight etc.

VaulterTech · 23/03/2023 09:46

I don’t know about bmi, but for me 11stone is overweight. I’m 5’7 and around 10stone is my comfy weight.

GoodChat · 23/03/2023 09:45

I'm 5'6" and 11 stone is about right for me.

BooksAndHooks · 23/03/2023 09:44

I’m 5ft 5 and currently 10 stone 7. I am definitely too heavy at this weight. To be a ten I have to be around 8.5 stone.

OliviaPark · 23/03/2023 09:44

I’m 5’6’’ and at 11 stone am a size 12 and feel good. I have a medium frame, big boobs and quite long legs for my height.

At 10 stone I am a size 8/10 and people ask if I am ill all the time.

This thread really shows how we all carry weight differently!

Daffodilfrog · 23/03/2023 09:44

I’m 5 10 and that would give me a bmi of 22 .. I’m currently a bit less but have weighed over a stone less when the kids were tiny - you really couldn’t tell the difference - height disguises a lot

RedToothBrush · 23/03/2023 09:43

The average height for a woman in the UK is 5'4".

Anyone saying 11stone isn't heavy on this thread is over that.

If you were 5'4" and 11stone you would be by definition overweight.

So by definition 11stone is heavy for a woman. But not necessarily unhealthy if you are above average in height. But unhealthy if you are average height or below.