Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 11 stone isn't that heavy unless you're really short?

242 replies

DrinksMenu · 23/03/2023 09:09

When I was losing weight a few years ago I went down from 14 and a half stone to under 13 in the space of 4 weeks. However I then seemed to stick for ages round about the 11 stone mark - my target weight was 8 stone. However o can say that 11 stone felt infinitely different from being in the 14s although I was definitely overweight at this weight.

Anyway shout out and much love to anyone and everyone on a weight loss programme - it's bloody hard !

OP posts:
TheTurn0fTheScrew · 23/03/2023 10:49

Rapapampam · 23/03/2023 10:23

Sorry but 11 stone it is heavy, even for a tall woman.

This is nuts. I'm 5'9", and at 11st I'm a size 10 on top, 12 on the bottom and BMI of 22.8. I don't look fashion model slender, but healthy without visible excess fat.
(unlike now at 13 and a half stone).

anonymous98 · 23/03/2023 10:48

I'm 5'6 and looked a bit pudgy at 11 stone but I'm not athletic, nor do I carry weight well. I'm built like a rectangle with no boobs so look best around 10 stone.

VivaciousRadish · 23/03/2023 10:48

I think it’s the perfect weight

Breezycheesetrees · 23/03/2023 10:47

I'm 6' and nearly 12 stone, I'm fairly slim.

WithIcePlease · 23/03/2023 10:47

11 stone would be way too much on me
I'm 5'5"
Currently 8 stone 7. I look brick like around my trunk at over 9 stone. No boobs. Body fat currently est 20-23%

PrettyMaybug · 23/03/2023 10:46

HEAVY not heave! Oh FFS MN get an edit button.

anonymous98 · 23/03/2023 10:45

JeanBodel · 23/03/2023 09:29

To lower the tone, I've just re-read Riders in preparation for the Disney+ launch of Rivals and the amount of fuss about Tori 'hefting' her 11.5 stone around and being too big to fit through a door is off the charts. Things really were different in the 70's. 11.5 stone appears to be the fattest woman they can conceive of.

I would love to be down to 11.5 stone....

Ha, yes. First thing I thought of as well.

When I read Riders I was just over 11 stone and Jilly Cooper truly couldn't have made me feel worse about myself. If Tory is supposedly fairly tall, say 5 ft 7, eleven stone isn't even technically overweight at that height.

Oh, the 70s.

PrettyMaybug · 23/03/2023 10:45

WHOOPS 11 stone ISN'T massively heave unless you're less than 5 ft 2!!!

PrettyMaybug · 23/03/2023 10:45

It's really quite a difficult question to answer, but yeah, I would imagine unless you're less than 5 foot 2, then 11 stone is massively heavy. I'm 5 foot 5 ish. And 11 stone 3, and a size 14, and I wouldn't class myself as fat or particularly that overweight.

Dacadactyl · 23/03/2023 10:45

I'm 5 foot 7 inches and would definitely be overweight at 11 stone.

The problem is that 11 stone I would probably look reasonable-ish to quite a few other people because we are so used to seeing overweight people. But I know I'd be overweight and would 100% see it and feel it.

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 23/03/2023 10:45

It's within the healthy range for me - I'm 5'8.

blahblahblahandblahsomemore · 23/03/2023 10:44

I'm 5ft 7 and 10 stone and even though rationally I know I'm not, I do feel big at the moment. At my thinnest I was 8 1/2 stone which in hindsight made me look a bit gaunt (and old in my 40s) so ideally I'd like to be somewhere around 9 stone 2ish. Dieting not going my way at the moment and finding weight really hard to shift.

GirlInTheDryShirt · 23/03/2023 10:44

Unless you're very tall, 11 stone is quite a high weight. A woman of that weight and 5 foot 6 would no way be a size 10/12 regardless of how she carried her weight - I'd say vanity sizing might have something to do with that. When I was a teen in the UK in the 1990s I weighed 8 and a half stone (at 5 foot 6) and I was a 10. That would probably be equivalent to a size 6 in today's UK sizes.

emmathedilemma · 23/03/2023 10:43

I'm 5ft 6 and around that weight now which puts me in the healthy BMI range but towards the top of it. I'm wearing size 10 on the top, 12 on the bottom. clothes, sometimes even an 8 on my top half but I'm carrying too much weight around my middle for my liking. Nurses are always surprised by how much I weigh so hopefully some of it is muscle ;)

User839516 · 23/03/2023 10:41

I’m 5ft 6in and 11st would be way too heavy for me. 9st is about right for me, around a size 10. Totally depends on your height and build!

Rapapampam · 23/03/2023 10:41

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 23/03/2023 10:40

this makes no sense

What is it you don’t understand?

Wanderingowl · 23/03/2023 10:41

ValerieDoonican · 23/03/2023 09:19

BMI is not really a reliable indicator of healthy weight / overweight. Its just an easy one to calculate because weight and height are easy to measure. Don't get too hung up on it.

It's only not reliable in that it's far, far too broad a range to be reliable. Or for incredibly muscular men. That's it. The average, non-extremely muscular person is still underweight at a BMI of 19 and over-weight at a BMI of 24, but those are included for outliers.

Most people are at an ideal weight of a BMI around 21 (lower for people of Asian ethnicities). But based on natural body shape, bone density and muscularity that will vary from person to person. As a very muscular woman with large breasts and hips/bum I am still obviously somewhat overweight when my BMI is 23 or over. Though I look clearly underweight if it dips too far below 22. 22.5 is currently ideal for me, though that may push up if I keep building muscle. A few years ago, 21 was my ideal as I wasn't especially muscular and my breasts had shrunk back after finishing breastfeeding. So you get to know your own best weight, but the only women who's ideal weight will be over 25, are incredibly muscular.

Theelephantinthecastle · 23/03/2023 10:41

There are more categories than slim and vast. At 11 stone and 5ft 5, I am not slim but I am definitely not huge, I have a 28 inch waist. I don't look tiny but I really don't look like a whale either

RobertsRadio · 23/03/2023 10:41

JeanBodel · 23/03/2023 09:29

To lower the tone, I've just re-read Riders in preparation for the Disney+ launch of Rivals and the amount of fuss about Tori 'hefting' her 11.5 stone around and being too big to fit through a door is off the charts. Things really were different in the 70's. 11.5 stone appears to be the fattest woman they can conceive of.

I would love to be down to 11.5 stone....

Things were definitely different in the seventies, I was 5ft 7" and fit and went up to 11 stone and I felt fat, was definitely considered fat by everyone else, and was told by my GP that 11 stone was "a bit over the odds" and that I needed to lose weight. I starved myself (didn't know how else to lose weight) and got down to 9st and felt great, but couldn't maintain it so went back up to 10st where I stayed for a long time, but was still considered on the heavy side.

I'd kill to be 10 stone now.

Bluebirds1987 · 23/03/2023 10:41

I think it's all really relative and depends how tall you are! 11st would be really heavy for me, but I'm 5"2 so quite short. I've always been about 9.5 stone and I still look quite overweight/ pregnant (2 kids under 4) and have a huge tummy. A healthy mid BMI weight for me would be about 8.5st I think. But that's totally unrealistic and I have to work really hard to not put more on!

However, I think weight is only a small part of wellness in general. Your fitness levels, happiness and the choices and lifestyle you live are all factors, and you've clearly done an incredible job so far losing weight. I don't think it's heavy for your height - It's just a number and the bigger picture is how you feel! Xxx

Abra1t · 23/03/2023 10:40

I would look overweight at 11 stone and 5''7". I look bigger than I like to be at much over 10 stone and prefer to be around 9'11".

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 23/03/2023 10:40

Rapapampam · 23/03/2023 10:23

Sorry but 11 stone it is heavy, even for a tall woman.

this makes no sense

ArmchairAnarchist2 · 23/03/2023 10:39

I'm 5'4 and have a really low BMI due to illness but at 11 stone I looked overweight and felt it. What do you class as a shorty? At 8 stone I look slim, am in the healthy range and would
be happy with that. I'm currently just over six and look terrible. I think my BMI is about 16, although I haven't looked for a long time. It works both ways but generally a healthy BMI (although a bit outdated) is ok as a rough guide. I think we've lost sight of what a healthy weight looks like, buoyed up by vanity sizing. I picked up a size eight jacket in Sainsbury's the other day (I'm classy like that) and it drowned me. I can imagine in Topshop it would have been at least a 12, clothing sizes doesn't tell you much.

Wombats23 · 23/03/2023 10:38

Would love to be 11st again but my set weight is way higher and it's a real struggle to get anywhere these days. Even though I'm short, 11st is on the skinny side for me and I really do feel thin at that weight. I'm naturally very solid. :-)

Stravawindow · 23/03/2023 10:38

I am 5'7 and 10.5. I feel and look overweight at 11 stone. That said, when I put weight on it goes on my face and boobs first so it's not a gradual all over weight gain. It's evident when I put weight on.