Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 11 stone isn't that heavy unless you're really short?

242 replies

DrinksMenu · 23/03/2023 09:09

When I was losing weight a few years ago I went down from 14 and a half stone to under 13 in the space of 4 weeks. However I then seemed to stick for ages round about the 11 stone mark - my target weight was 8 stone. However o can say that 11 stone felt infinitely different from being in the 14s although I was definitely overweight at this weight.

Anyway shout out and much love to anyone and everyone on a weight loss programme - it's bloody hard !

OP posts:
HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 11:28

jesus christ, sorry about that massive link

HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 11:28

That's not true @TeaandCrumpetsforTea , about being at the lower end of BMI. In fact, for older adults, it's better to be at the higher end or even overweight. There's some interesting studies about it - if you have some reserves, you're better set up for periods of illness. I'm not saying we should all aim for it, just offering a different perspective.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8984168/

What is the Optimal Body Mass Index Range for Older Adults?

Obesity is pathophysiologically complex in older adults compared to that in young and middle-aged adults. The aim of the present study was to determine the appropriate body mass index (BMI) range based on geriatric evaluation parameters in which compli...

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8984168

TeaandCrumpetsforTea · 23/03/2023 11:25

Netcam · 23/03/2023 11:21

I'm 5'3 and 9 stone 3. BMI is 22.8. I have a small frame and really would like to lose 1/2 a stone and get down to 8st 10, I feel and look much better at that weight. But at the age of 53 post menopause I find it really difficult to lose weight and maintain it, even with a good diet and exercise, although I do my best.

I am post meno.

The only way it works for me is to do low carb and walk 3 miles, fast, 5 times a week.

Low carb is carbs for one meal only. I rarely eat sandwiches- it's homemade soup and /or a salad for lunch, plain yoghurt & fruit, or eggs for breakfast with 1 slice toast or 2 oatcakes, dinner is chunk of fish or chicken made into various things, but with loads of veg and rarely rice, spuds or pasta. YES I do eat those things, but not every day , or 3 x a day. Cake etc is treat and only a small amount.

HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 11:23

@Rapapampam I'm going to try to talk to you like a grown-up, hope that's OK.

You say 11 stone is too heavy full stop, no matter how tall someone is. Then you say it's all about appearance - ie, not about weight at all. I weight train, and depending on whether I am on a 'cut' or a 'bulk' my weight can fluctuate between 9.5 stone and 11 stone (at 5 foot 9). I wear the same clothes at either extreme - my trousers just feel a little looser or tighter. Because I train, I do keep track of my weight, so I know that it can fluctuate +/- 6lbs in a single day. That's why saying 11 stone is too heavy just... doesn't mean anything. It's silly.

TeaandCrumpetsforTea · 23/03/2023 11:22

The max weight for me on the BMI scale before I am classed as overweight, is around 9 st and a bit. That would be 2 st above my weight now and more than I was at full term pregnancy. Yes, if I was built differently, it might be ok, but I'm not.

Medics will tell you that we should all try to be at the lower end of healthy BMI not hovering at the top.

I also get a bit annoyed at the tendency now to 'slim shame' when posters know nothing about the person's history. I've not always been slim. I went through a very podgy stage at puberty, couldn't get clothes to fit for my height, and looked awful. I am never going to go back to that especially now I'm older and more concerned about health risks of weight.

Netcam · 23/03/2023 11:21

I'm 5'3 and 9 stone 3. BMI is 22.8. I have a small frame and really would like to lose 1/2 a stone and get down to 8st 10, I feel and look much better at that weight. But at the age of 53 post menopause I find it really difficult to lose weight and maintain it, even with a good diet and exercise, although I do my best.

JellyBabiesSaveLives · 23/03/2023 11:21

I'm 5'5" and the BMI calculator says 11 stone is overweight (just). Apparently 5'3" is the average height for women in the UK today so I maintain that I am not a "shorty".

Catspyjamas17 · 23/03/2023 11:18

For me going between current weight and 11 stone, size 12-14 to size 10 is matter of being about two inches less of me all over. It's a bit "So what?" when you think about it, considering the disproportionate and miserable effect on my life I'd have to undergo to achieve it, all other health indicators being great and then I feel good, am fit, eat a healthy diet, have lots of energy, and look nice in clothes as I am. Hopefully I'll lose weight gradually over time, particularly when hopefully my hormones stop pissing about sometime in my 50s, but I'm certainly not going to go on a crash diet (again) to achieve it, or do anything other than make long term sustainable lifestyle changes.

Spangasspikeywig · 23/03/2023 11:17

I think people have different perceptions of what overweight is. For example a person will show as being obese on the BMI sale but insist they look and feel grand. Others can look in the mirror and know they are overweight just by the way their clothes fit. Others will insist they are curvy when they are very overweight and others will insist that they look gaunt if they go to the weight that is considered healthy. A lot of it is denial and some of it is I can't be bothered to lose weight, I like how I am. A LOT of it is just excuses

You can see here how there is uproar because 11 stone is considered heavy for most women under a certain weight....which it is.

Rapapampam · 23/03/2023 11:14

HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 11:06

Your post doesn't make any sense. BMI is the ratio of someone's weight to their height. It's a more useful metric than just weight alone, though obviously it doesn't tell the whole story.

Then you say 'the mirror doesn't lie' - but that's nothing to do with weight at all. You can't tell how much someone weighs by looking at them.

Just like someone mentioned above, people have lost sight of what a healthy weight is. I personally find 11 stone way too heavy, BMI or not.
Does this bother you because you are on the heavy side?

CharlotteSometimes1 · 23/03/2023 11:14

I’m 5’7” and 11st 1lb I’m just in the healthy BMIzone for the first time in years. I’m definitely feeling happier with my size, but I don’t yet feel that I’ve settled at a good weight yet. I exercise 3/4 times a week and can feel some great muscles forming, but they’re still mostly covered in body fat so I don’t yet look toned. So that’s my goal, I don’t know what weight that will be, but for me it’s about losing the excess fat. Currently I wear a 12.

Nosecan · 23/03/2023 11:12

I am a bit heavier than that currently at 5’8” and feel fat. My happy weight is between 8.5-9 stone, it’s been a few years since I’ve been that. It completely depends on how you carry weight, I know other people at my height and weight can look fantastic.

HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 11:06

Rapapampam · 23/03/2023 10:56

Really? I am quite tall and I find 11 stone way too much. I don’t give a toss about BMI because it’s bullshit. It’s numbers related to each other on a paper. The mirror on the other hand doesn’t lie. If I was 11 stone I would start a diet.

Your post doesn't make any sense. BMI is the ratio of someone's weight to their height. It's a more useful metric than just weight alone, though obviously it doesn't tell the whole story.

Then you say 'the mirror doesn't lie' - but that's nothing to do with weight at all. You can't tell how much someone weighs by looking at them.

GoodChat · 23/03/2023 11:03

WitheredandOld · 23/03/2023 11:01

11 stone is overweight for anyone under 5’7” unless you are a body builder. We’ve all completely lost sight of what a healthy weight is.

Im 10.2 stone at 5’6” and need to lose 6 pounds to not be carrying excess weight. I’m an average build.

A healthy weight for someone who's 5'6" is anything below 11 stone 2

MonZb · 23/03/2023 11:02

The lightest I have been in my adult life is 11 stone. I am 5.8 tall.

WitheredandOld · 23/03/2023 11:01

11 stone is overweight for anyone under 5’7” unless you are a body builder. We’ve all completely lost sight of what a healthy weight is.

Im 10.2 stone at 5’6” and need to lose 6 pounds to not be carrying excess weight. I’m an average build.

anonymous98 · 23/03/2023 10:57

Wanderingowl · 23/03/2023 10:41

It's only not reliable in that it's far, far too broad a range to be reliable. Or for incredibly muscular men. That's it. The average, non-extremely muscular person is still underweight at a BMI of 19 and over-weight at a BMI of 24, but those are included for outliers.

Most people are at an ideal weight of a BMI around 21 (lower for people of Asian ethnicities). But based on natural body shape, bone density and muscularity that will vary from person to person. As a very muscular woman with large breasts and hips/bum I am still obviously somewhat overweight when my BMI is 23 or over. Though I look clearly underweight if it dips too far below 22. 22.5 is currently ideal for me, though that may push up if I keep building muscle. A few years ago, 21 was my ideal as I wasn't especially muscular and my breasts had shrunk back after finishing breastfeeding. So you get to know your own best weight, but the only women who's ideal weight will be over 25, are incredibly muscular.

I had to eat 800 calories a day to get down to a BMI of 21. I don't think that's ideal. It also wasn't sustainable.

Rapapampam · 23/03/2023 10:56

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 23/03/2023 10:50

it's your lack of understanding that appear to be the problem. 11 stone is well within the healthy BMI range for lots of taller women.

Really? I am quite tall and I find 11 stone way too much. I don’t give a toss about BMI because it’s bullshit. It’s numbers related to each other on a paper. The mirror on the other hand doesn’t lie. If I was 11 stone I would start a diet.

maranella · 23/03/2023 10:55

Totally depends on build. I'm 5'4", so probably 'a shorty' by the standards of some [rude] people on here, but if I was 11 stone I'd be huge. Actually, I was 11 stone when I was 9 months pregnant with both my kids, so that shows how much above my normal weight it is. But people who are broader and with larger skeletons can carry more weight and still look good and be healthy. I'd look fat at that weight.

MonZb · 23/03/2023 10:55

11 stone is my ideal weight. I would love to be that again. Even 12 stone.

I looked very slim at 12 stone.

HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 10:54

JeanBodel · 23/03/2023 09:29

To lower the tone, I've just re-read Riders in preparation for the Disney+ launch of Rivals and the amount of fuss about Tori 'hefting' her 11.5 stone around and being too big to fit through a door is off the charts. Things really were different in the 70's. 11.5 stone appears to be the fattest woman they can conceive of.

I would love to be down to 11.5 stone....

Off topic but OMG WHAAT! I had no idea about this. I just found the cast list online though and I am very unsure - David Tennant as Tony Baddingham?! And I suppose Gabriel Byrne is now a bit long in the tooth to play Declan O'Hara but Aidan Turner seems all wrong too.

HealthConcerns · 23/03/2023 10:54

Well that would put my bmi at 27.8 so would be overweight for me. As it goes though I was that weight for years and felt great on it, rather than the 37.2 bmi I have now. And I'm not really short either, 5'3 so a little under average but not much

Elodie09 · 23/03/2023 10:53

I am 5'6" . 10 st 12lbs , my well woman check recently said Bmi of 24.9 so ok , but only just.
The thing is, I lost about 3 stone with SW a few years ago and have kept it off.
My 6ft husband has a smaller wrist measuremnt than I have , I really do have a large, solid frame. At this weight I am a size 12 and feel very happy with that. Bmi does give a good idea but isn't the whole story!

Itsrudemeghan · 23/03/2023 10:53

I’m 5’6 and I’m just under 11 stone at the moment and I feel very chubby

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 23/03/2023 10:50

Rapapampam · 23/03/2023 10:41

What is it you don’t understand?

it's your lack of understanding that appear to be the problem. 11 stone is well within the healthy BMI range for lots of taller women.

Swipe left for the next trending thread