Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 11 stone isn't that heavy unless you're really short?

242 replies

DrinksMenu · 23/03/2023 09:09

When I was losing weight a few years ago I went down from 14 and a half stone to under 13 in the space of 4 weeks. However I then seemed to stick for ages round about the 11 stone mark - my target weight was 8 stone. However o can say that 11 stone felt infinitely different from being in the 14s although I was definitely overweight at this weight.

Anyway shout out and much love to anyone and everyone on a weight loss programme - it's bloody hard !

OP posts:
Netcam · 23/03/2023 12:28

Catspyjamas17 · 23/03/2023 11:55

How do you manage with fibre? Or iron. It sounds very low fibre/iron as well as low carb. I find it much easier to get enough fibre if I incorporate jacket potatoes, Weetabix, wholegrain rice, lentils, wholewheat pasta, wholemeal bread into my diet and have slightly more carbs but usually in the 100-150g a day rather than <100g say, even though I eat fruit like pears which are good for fibre, and green veg like broccoli also- often eight to ten portions a day . If I only have starchy carbs in one meal a day I end up having 18g fibre or day or less instead of the 25 - 30g recommended.

I just think that nutrients like fibre and iron (which often comes hand in hand with these foods) get overlooked these days in favour of keeping calories down and eating low carb and lots of protein. When actually, unless you are vegan, do a lot of weight training and are trying to bulk up, most of us don't really need to worry about protein intake and in face most people have too much protein rather than too little.

Thanks, I eat lots of fibre I think. We eat lots of pulses like beans and lentils, lots of fresh veg. We also have meat once a week and fish a couple of times as well as well as eggs. Any carbs like rice/pasta/bread are wholewheat and porridge oats are a good source of fibre. It's just my teens and DH want huge dinners, so I tend to max out the carbs for them with brown rice/pasta and I just have a bit of it. The rest of the dinner might be homemade fish curry with lots of veg, a big veg and bean pasta sauce and grated cheese, steak mince bolognase with veg on the side. I think we eat pretty well, but I think I just need to eat a bit less of it and exercise a bit more if I want to actually lose 1/2 a stone.

kitsuneghost · 23/03/2023 12:27

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 23/03/2023 12:26

How tall are you then?

5 ft

MyOwnVolt · 23/03/2023 12:27

I’m exactly 5”4 and exactly 11 stone and while my BMI might list me as over weight, I’m not, i’m a size 10 with massive tits.

Advancedpie · 23/03/2023 12:27

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 23/03/2023 09:17

I'm 5ft 5 and 11st is too heavy for me but mainly cos I'm apple shaped so I look like a barrel

I'm the same. Definitely lardy at this weight. I need to lose a solid 1.5-2 stone of fat.

Bimblybomeyelash · 23/03/2023 12:27

I’m 5 foot 7 and 11 stone feels overweight for me. But I don’t feel fat. I’d like to loose a stone but it’s hard once you hit forty.

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 23/03/2023 12:26

kitsuneghost · 23/03/2023 12:24

I don't consider myself short and 11st is obese for me.

How tall are you then?

kitsuneghost · 23/03/2023 12:24

I don't consider myself short and 11st is obese for me.

SaySomethingMan · 23/03/2023 12:17

Nothing to add but i’m always re-surprised when i’m remembered of the average height of women. i used to think it’s 5’7”

WanderingWildflower · 23/03/2023 12:17

I’m fairly short (5’3) and was just over 11 stone when I joined slimming world last year. I felt huge but looking back at photos, I wasn’t really esp not in clothes. I feel much better now at 9.5

Itsmyturnnow1 · 23/03/2023 12:11

I’m 5ft4 and 8st4 and I have a healthy BMI. Depends on your height.

Catspyjamas17 · 23/03/2023 11:55

Netcam · 23/03/2023 11:37

Thanks for the ideas. I do walk quite a lot and walk fast and probably do 3 miles several times a week, but could do more. I also do aerobic exercise on the rebounder 1/2 an hour several times a week. I think you are right about low carb. I tend to have a small portion of porridge or plain yoghurt with banana for breakfast, salad or soup or cheese and fruit, sometimes with 1 slice wholemeal bread, for lunch. Dinner is more difficult as I cook for DH and 2 hungry teenagers. I tend to have a little bit of what they are having with lots of veg, but those things tend to have pasta/rice/potatoes as I have a small amount of that. I was limiting dessert to Friday and Saturday night but have cut that to just Saturday. I occasionally have a square or two of dark chocolate, but generally no daytime snacks. DH do share a bottle of wine over 2 nights at the weekend which is one vice I'd like to keep. I think really I need to up the exercise a bit more and cut my portion of dinner carbs down further and see what I can achieve.

How do you manage with fibre? Or iron. It sounds very low fibre/iron as well as low carb. I find it much easier to get enough fibre if I incorporate jacket potatoes, Weetabix, wholegrain rice, lentils, wholewheat pasta, wholemeal bread into my diet and have slightly more carbs but usually in the 100-150g a day rather than <100g say, even though I eat fruit like pears which are good for fibre, and green veg like broccoli also- often eight to ten portions a day . If I only have starchy carbs in one meal a day I end up having 18g fibre or day or less instead of the 25 - 30g recommended.

I just think that nutrients like fibre and iron (which often comes hand in hand with these foods) get overlooked these days in favour of keeping calories down and eating low carb and lots of protein. When actually, unless you are vegan, do a lot of weight training and are trying to bulk up, most of us don't really need to worry about protein intake and in face most people have too much protein rather than too little.

mummylondon16 · 23/03/2023 11:43

I’m 5ft8. At 11 stone I am a small size 10. I have no boobs, a flat bum, my collar bones are showing. People start to question if I’m unwell. I had a dexa scan and it showed I have very high muscle so 11 stone means I have low body fat( for a woman). I’m currently 12.8 and in a size 14 and chubby. Those who comment as if everyone looks the same at 11 stone are just wrong.

jainirrjones · 23/03/2023 11:40

time of the month, water retention, leg day! It's happened.

Fair enough. Weight training, and other exercise, definitely can make you heavier overall, and without showing it, I.e. you'll still look slim and toned.

Netcam · 23/03/2023 11:37

TeaandCrumpetsforTea · 23/03/2023 11:25

I am post meno.

The only way it works for me is to do low carb and walk 3 miles, fast, 5 times a week.

Low carb is carbs for one meal only. I rarely eat sandwiches- it's homemade soup and /or a salad for lunch, plain yoghurt & fruit, or eggs for breakfast with 1 slice toast or 2 oatcakes, dinner is chunk of fish or chicken made into various things, but with loads of veg and rarely rice, spuds or pasta. YES I do eat those things, but not every day , or 3 x a day. Cake etc is treat and only a small amount.

Thanks for the ideas. I do walk quite a lot and walk fast and probably do 3 miles several times a week, but could do more. I also do aerobic exercise on the rebounder 1/2 an hour several times a week. I think you are right about low carb. I tend to have a small portion of porridge or plain yoghurt with banana for breakfast, salad or soup or cheese and fruit, sometimes with 1 slice wholemeal bread, for lunch. Dinner is more difficult as I cook for DH and 2 hungry teenagers. I tend to have a little bit of what they are having with lots of veg, but those things tend to have pasta/rice/potatoes as I have a small amount of that. I was limiting dessert to Friday and Saturday night but have cut that to just Saturday. I occasionally have a square or two of dark chocolate, but generally no daytime snacks. DH do share a bottle of wine over 2 nights at the weekend which is one vice I'd like to keep. I think really I need to up the exercise a bit more and cut my portion of dinner carbs down further and see what I can achieve.

Rapapampam · 23/03/2023 11:37

HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 11:35

I can see that trying to talk to you like an adult was my first mistake @Rapapampam . I know better now!

Is this your argument? The “adult” card? 😕

Oxbridgetitans · 23/03/2023 11:36

Crabwoman · 23/03/2023 09:20

I am 5"5 and 11 stone. It's definitely overweight for me. My bmi confirms I'm overweight and I look awful. Totally self inflicted due to a stressful year.

I do have a small frame so that might contribute. My face, wrists feet and ankles are still small and slender - so in photos, my head looks like a pea on a fork.

I've lived in dresses for the last year as I look awful in trousers.

I am the exact same and don’t look good anything over 10 stone. I look my best around 9-9.7 stone but not less than 9.

HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 11:35

I can see that trying to talk to you like an adult was my first mistake @Rapapampam . I know better now!

Rapapampam · 23/03/2023 11:34

HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 11:33

"That's a big amount of weight" Yes, it's about 20lb in weight or 9kg if you're a metric type. That's my point. It is a lot of weight, and it doesn't make a difference to how I see myself in the mirror (though it does make a difference to how strong I feel)

I’m sorry but don’t tell me that 9kg plus doesn’t show on you.

HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 11:33

jainirrjones · 23/03/2023 11:30

I weight train too @HarlanPepper Though I've never had a weight fluctuation of 6lbs, up or down, in a single day.

time of the month, water retention, leg day! It's happened.

HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 11:33

Rapapampam · 23/03/2023 11:28

If you are fluctuating between 9.5 and 11 stone, that’s a big amount of weight. I doubt your clothes fit you when you’re that much heavier, unless you have loose tops and stretch trousers.

"That's a big amount of weight" Yes, it's about 20lb in weight or 9kg if you're a metric type. That's my point. It is a lot of weight, and it doesn't make a difference to how I see myself in the mirror (though it does make a difference to how strong I feel)

BigBoysDontCry · 23/03/2023 11:32

I'm 11'11 but have a BMI of 23.6. I'd say my weight is fairly evenly distributed but at 57 I do have a little tummy and C Section pouch. I usually wear 12/14.

I've been much heavier and also much lighter (about 3 stone in either direction) but I've kinda stuck at about this weight for a few years now. I put on and take off a couple of pounds from time to time.

I feel I could be fitter but i think in general they say that as you get older it's better to be nearer the top of your BMI (probably depends where you hold the weight).

So I feel pretty comfortable at this weight though I would have said my target when I was heavier would have been closer to 10.5/11 stone.

I eat fairly healthily, low carb-ish and 16:8 fasting most of the time

jainirrjones · 23/03/2023 11:30

I weight train too @HarlanPepper Though I've never had a weight fluctuation of 6lbs, up or down, in a single day.

Bunnycat101 · 23/03/2023 11:29

I think frame does matter though to how you carry it. I’m a similar height to my mum but her wrists are tiny compared to mine, she has size 4 feet compared to my size 7/8. When she was younger she was always around 71/2 stone. I’d have been ill at that weight. Those are the sort of differences that bmi takes into account when looking at healthy weight. Naturally she very much suited a lower end and me more of mid-upper point of healthy bmi.

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 23/03/2023 11:29

You can see here how there is uproar because 11 stone is considered heavy for most women under a certain weight....which it is.

No uproar. Just challenging the notion that 11 stone is always too heavy, no matter how tall a woman is.

Rapapampam · 23/03/2023 11:28

HarlanPepper · 23/03/2023 11:23

@Rapapampam I'm going to try to talk to you like a grown-up, hope that's OK.

You say 11 stone is too heavy full stop, no matter how tall someone is. Then you say it's all about appearance - ie, not about weight at all. I weight train, and depending on whether I am on a 'cut' or a 'bulk' my weight can fluctuate between 9.5 stone and 11 stone (at 5 foot 9). I wear the same clothes at either extreme - my trousers just feel a little looser or tighter. Because I train, I do keep track of my weight, so I know that it can fluctuate +/- 6lbs in a single day. That's why saying 11 stone is too heavy just... doesn't mean anything. It's silly.

If you are fluctuating between 9.5 and 11 stone, that’s a big amount of weight. I doubt your clothes fit you when you’re that much heavier, unless you have loose tops and stretch trousers.