Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that DH is selfish over my jury service?

470 replies

SeekChase · 23/03/2023 08:14

Hi Ladies...
So, around 2 months ago I was sent a Jury Summons. As I am a mum to 2 small (1&4) children, and with the Jury Service being set for first week or half term ( no preschool), I tried to get out of it, but to no avail. I do understand that they always invite a surplus of potential Jury candidates and there is a chance of getting out on the day...
However, I did give my DH plenty of notice (he is a roofer) and asked that he takes that week to 10 days off to look after the kids (I am normally the stay at home mum) - while I do the Jury Service IF I can't get out of it.

HE AGREED.
Well, last night, bearing in mind I have a week or so before the Jury service starts, he told me he wants to work and its tough. He said I'll have to not go. I said I can get fined £1000 for not showing up, he said "yes it's stupid isn't it" - but won't budge.
I have family but they are actually going away on a prearranged holiday, my DH said they will have to cancel and its not his problem. I am fuming. AIBU?

OP posts:
cruisebaba1 · 23/03/2023 18:32

SeekChase · 23/03/2023 08:14

Hi Ladies...
So, around 2 months ago I was sent a Jury Summons. As I am a mum to 2 small (1&4) children, and with the Jury Service being set for first week or half term ( no preschool), I tried to get out of it, but to no avail. I do understand that they always invite a surplus of potential Jury candidates and there is a chance of getting out on the day...
However, I did give my DH plenty of notice (he is a roofer) and asked that he takes that week to 10 days off to look after the kids (I am normally the stay at home mum) - while I do the Jury Service IF I can't get out of it.

HE AGREED.
Well, last night, bearing in mind I have a week or so before the Jury service starts, he told me he wants to work and its tough. He said I'll have to not go. I said I can get fined £1000 for not showing up, he said "yes it's stupid isn't it" - but won't budge.
I have family but they are actually going away on a prearranged holiday, my DH said they will have to cancel and its not his problem. I am fuming. AIBU?

You can’t not go!!!! I had to attend every day for two weeks and had to sit around in case I was needed. I didn’t get picked for the first jury group but still had to attend, then get told when you can go home. The courts aren’t interested in childcare, shift patterns , you are expected to be there if not, you are in contempt of court. Your husband is being a twat.

cruisebaba1 · 23/03/2023 18:28

MintJulia · 23/03/2023 08:19

Call the local nanny service and get a quote for five days full time. Send him the quote and tell him this will be what is happening if he will not take the week off because you are not prepared to be held in contempt of court.

This!!!

Greyarea12 · 23/03/2023 18:25

He sounds like a selfish, self centred arsehole. Does he realise how serious not turning up is? My friend didn't turn up. She was arrested and spent a night in the cells. She was also fined.

Itsbytheby · 23/03/2023 18:07

MarkWithaC · 23/03/2023 18:05

So a bit like magistrates? That might work better - ‘real’ judges/legal types to keep the lay people on the straight and narrow in terms of knowledge and process, and maybe the lay people would guard against the corruption a PP very astutely points out as a potential issue.

I would say generally the risk of corruption is fairly low. There are very strict rules and processes regard impartiality or judges in the non-criminal sphere. I don't see why that couldn't also be applied in criminal cases.

Itsbytheby · 23/03/2023 18:05

GoodChat · 23/03/2023 18:04

This is another thing. People imagine you are sitting through murders, drug offences and rapes and what nots. When you are sitting through a 14 day trial on financial fraud with 8 folders of evidence, how many of the jury do you think (1) really understand the detail (and often the devil is in the detail with these things) and (2) aren't bored out of their heads with it. Again, that's not looking down on the jurors, but it is often really complicated and it is often very boring.

Is it not the responsibility of the judge and/or legal representative to put anything complex into layman's terms?

I've never served on a jury so genuinely don't know.

Yes it is. But still. It can be really complicated stuff, you have to really be able and motivated to listen and take in all the information.

MarkWithaC · 23/03/2023 18:05

Itsbytheby · 23/03/2023 17:57

Jurors are lay people and more often than not will not understand the purpose of application of laws. They are really suseptible to bias too, especially in an information overload age. That is just human nature. Not to mention people who are morally unsuitable like you mention (racist, homophobic, etc).

Many countries have lay judges, so people who are specifically trained to be judges and understand the considerations they need to take into acount. They will often sit with "proper" judges, so you have a combination. I think that is a far superior system.

So a bit like magistrates? That might work better - ‘real’ judges/legal types to keep the lay people on the straight and narrow in terms of knowledge and process, and maybe the lay people would guard against the corruption a PP very astutely points out as a potential issue.

GoodChat · 23/03/2023 18:04

This is another thing. People imagine you are sitting through murders, drug offences and rapes and what nots. When you are sitting through a 14 day trial on financial fraud with 8 folders of evidence, how many of the jury do you think (1) really understand the detail (and often the devil is in the detail with these things) and (2) aren't bored out of their heads with it. Again, that's not looking down on the jurors, but it is often really complicated and it is often very boring.

Is it not the responsibility of the judge and/or legal representative to put anything complex into layman's terms?

I've never served on a jury so genuinely don't know.

Itsbytheby · 23/03/2023 18:02

whatevrrrr · 23/03/2023 17:59

Btw I'm doing it in Autumn, and absolutely don't want to do it. There are some things in particular that I'd really struggle with, and I don't feel I could be impartial or logical about those things. And other things would be so boring that I won't be able to concentrate because I'll start to get drowsy. I so, so, so, hope I'm not actually chosen when it comes to it.

This is another thing. People imagine you are sitting through murders, drug offences and rapes and what nots. When you are sitting through a 14 day trial on financial fraud with 8 folders of evidence, how many of the jury do you think (1) really understand the detail (and often the devil is in the detail with these things) and (2) aren't bored out of their heads with it. Again, that's not looking down on the jurors, but it is often really complicated and it is often very boring.

whatevrrrr · 23/03/2023 18:01

Many countries have lay judges, so people who are specifically trained to be judges and understand the considerations they need to take into acount. They will often sit with "proper" judges, so you have a combination. I think that is a far superior system

This would be a better system - I wasn't thinking very clearly or intelligently about professional jurors. Of course that would not be a good idea. I am not sure that the 'being judged by peers' idea works either, though, as I have come across many, many people over the course of my life and work whose views are very deeply held and completely repugnant.

User4891 · 23/03/2023 18:00

19lottie82 · 23/03/2023 17:20

Is your OH self employed? I understand how difficult it could be for him to take time off.
personally I’d just show up to JD with your two children.

You're at least the 2nd person to suggest this. Are you so woefully ignorant to what jury duty entails that you genuinely think this is a good idea or are you just taking the piss? Either way why are you giving advice when you clearly aren't qualified to?

whatevrrrr · 23/03/2023 17:59

Btw I'm doing it in Autumn, and absolutely don't want to do it. There are some things in particular that I'd really struggle with, and I don't feel I could be impartial or logical about those things. And other things would be so boring that I won't be able to concentrate because I'll start to get drowsy. I so, so, so, hope I'm not actually chosen when it comes to it.

Itsbytheby · 23/03/2023 17:58

Itsbytheby · 23/03/2023 17:57

Jurors are lay people and more often than not will not understand the purpose of application of laws. They are really suseptible to bias too, especially in an information overload age. That is just human nature. Not to mention people who are morally unsuitable like you mention (racist, homophobic, etc).

Many countries have lay judges, so people who are specifically trained to be judges and understand the considerations they need to take into acount. They will often sit with "proper" judges, so you have a combination. I think that is a far superior system.

Sorry for all the typos - multitasking, not an idiot ;)

Jonei · 23/03/2023 17:58

I don't think there should be professional jurors, it rather defeats the point on being judged by your peers. A professional jury would end up being corrupt.

Itsbytheby · 23/03/2023 17:57

MarkWithaC · 23/03/2023 17:51

Slight derail perhaps, but I’m really interested in this. What do you think would be a better system? I’m woefully uninformed about legal process in countries that don’t have the jury system; are there any that you can point to that you believe are better?

I did jury service a while ago and, while many of our 12 took it seriously and applied ourselves, some barely contributed and someone said they were bored rigid and would rather just be at work! Not to mention the man (quite young, which rightly or wrongly I found particularly Shock who said completely seriously that maybe women just aren’t as interested in work fields like science as men… I did think, would I like to have my fate decided by this lot?

Jurors are lay people and more often than not will not understand the purpose of application of laws. They are really suseptible to bias too, especially in an information overload age. That is just human nature. Not to mention people who are morally unsuitable like you mention (racist, homophobic, etc).

Many countries have lay judges, so people who are specifically trained to be judges and understand the considerations they need to take into acount. They will often sit with "proper" judges, so you have a combination. I think that is a far superior system.

whatevrrrr · 23/03/2023 17:56

Itsbytheby · 23/03/2023 17:40

i'm a lawyer so have a fair amount of knowledge about the judicial system. I don't think we should use a jury. It sounds fair in principle, but I am just not sure it's the best way to enforce the law. The way it's set up is so super shit for people who have to do it too.

I agree with this as well. I think there ought to be professional jurors who are properly trained to do it as an actual job, and who ought to be demonstrably intelligent.

The only reason I think everyone should do jury service unless they absolutely can't is that this is the very imperfect system that we have (even though it shouldn't be), and juries would otherwise consist solely of people who have no jobs or children or other responsibilities. This is not an appealing idea.

YearsOfStagnation · 23/03/2023 17:54

MarkWithaC · 23/03/2023 17:51

Slight derail perhaps, but I’m really interested in this. What do you think would be a better system? I’m woefully uninformed about legal process in countries that don’t have the jury system; are there any that you can point to that you believe are better?

I did jury service a while ago and, while many of our 12 took it seriously and applied ourselves, some barely contributed and someone said they were bored rigid and would rather just be at work! Not to mention the man (quite young, which rightly or wrongly I found particularly Shock who said completely seriously that maybe women just aren’t as interested in work fields like science as men… I did think, would I like to have my fate decided by this lot?

My friend’s 19y girl was called last year. I was torn between thinking wtf, she is too young and, well at least she is super bright so that might help!

MarkWithaC · 23/03/2023 17:51

Itsbytheby · 23/03/2023 17:40

i'm a lawyer so have a fair amount of knowledge about the judicial system. I don't think we should use a jury. It sounds fair in principle, but I am just not sure it's the best way to enforce the law. The way it's set up is so super shit for people who have to do it too.

Slight derail perhaps, but I’m really interested in this. What do you think would be a better system? I’m woefully uninformed about legal process in countries that don’t have the jury system; are there any that you can point to that you believe are better?

I did jury service a while ago and, while many of our 12 took it seriously and applied ourselves, some barely contributed and someone said they were bored rigid and would rather just be at work! Not to mention the man (quite young, which rightly or wrongly I found particularly Shock who said completely seriously that maybe women just aren’t as interested in work fields like science as men… I did think, would I like to have my fate decided by this lot?

Itsbytheby · 23/03/2023 17:40

i'm a lawyer so have a fair amount of knowledge about the judicial system. I don't think we should use a jury. It sounds fair in principle, but I am just not sure it's the best way to enforce the law. The way it's set up is so super shit for people who have to do it too.

smashinggrapes · 23/03/2023 17:33

Why are you a SAHM if your marriage is at its final straw?

Get a job! You're going to need one. As for the jury service, I'd leave the house before he's awake and ask to be excused giving the reasons of no childcare.

Jules912 · 23/03/2023 17:22

@PrettyMaybug I did actually find jury service quite interspersed but in no hurry to do it again. And very very glad I was excused from the 3 month murder trial they originally tried to assign me due to being pregnant.

19lottie82 · 23/03/2023 17:20

Is your OH self employed? I understand how difficult it could be for him to take time off.
personally I’d just show up to JD with your two children.

YearsOfStagnation · 23/03/2023 16:57

PrettyMaybug · 23/03/2023 16:54

@Anotherturnipforthebooks

When I was on jury service the people who were excited about being there were the most unfit to serve.

@YearsOfStagnation

Yes I agree with that. The few people who I know who get excited and want to do it over and over again are quite prejudiced and certainly not my first choice of neutral juror.

Yeah this. I can never understand people who get 'quite excited' at the idea of doing jury service. It will surely be either.

a) ... as boring as fuck.

or

b) ... grim and disturbing, and possibly traumatising/upsetting.

I have never been called up, and never will. I won't say why. But I am SO glad. I would HATE to do it.

I imagine the people saying they would LOVE to do it, and find the thought of it 'exciting,' to be exactly like Norris Cole or Blanche Hunt from Coronation Street. (Proper busybodies, and gossips, who will probably decide someone is guilty just by looking at them, and will judge them instantly if they come from a 'rough' area.) Wink

Yes. That’s exactly it. The ones I know are retired busybodies and full of black and white views on people.

I hope I never get called. I would do it of course but have no burning desire at all.

PrettyMaybug · 23/03/2023 16:54

@Anotherturnipforthebooks

When I was on jury service the people who were excited about being there were the most unfit to serve.

@YearsOfStagnation

Yes I agree with that. The few people who I know who get excited and want to do it over and over again are quite prejudiced and certainly not my first choice of neutral juror.

Yeah this. I can never understand people who get 'quite excited' at the idea of doing jury service. It will surely be either.

a) ... as boring as fuck.

or

b) ... grim and disturbing, and possibly traumatising/upsetting.

I have never been called up, and never will. I won't say why. But I am SO glad. I would HATE to do it.

I imagine the people saying they would LOVE to do it, and find the thought of it 'exciting,' to be exactly like Norris Cole or Blanche Hunt from Coronation Street. (Proper busybodies, and gossips, who will probably decide someone is guilty just by looking at them, and will judge them instantly if they come from a 'rough' area.) Wink

PrettyMaybug · 23/03/2023 16:38

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 23/03/2023 12:11

Thanks for getting a man to validate what we're thinking. I'm never sure of my position until a man I've never met agrees with me.

😆 LOLOLOLOL!!! We can all sleep peacefully tonight, knowing that at least SOME of da menz agree with us.

Newestname002 · 23/03/2023 14:51

@SeekChase

If you haven't already I suggest you get back to whoever summoned you to jury service and ask for a deferral. Explain your childcare has fallen through and explain what you've already tried. Email ASAP and follow up with a phone call. If/when you speak to someone ensure you have their full name in case you need that later. 🌹

Swipe left for the next trending thread