Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH thinks friend who has live in nanny is a 'joke'

563 replies

princemarry · 23/03/2023 06:59

I have a close friend who's recently had her second baby and hired a live in nanny/ au pair.

She found having just one child incredibly challenging and decided that this was the right thing for her family.

I think it's great and I'm happy for her.

My DH called her a joke.

I think that says a lot about him. Nothing good.

I think he thinks motherhood is completely killing you self for your family and he didn't feel my friend is doing that, so he thinks she's a joke.

Obviously it's not his place or anyone's to judge, but he did.

What does everyone else think ?

OP posts:
Notamumsym · 25/03/2023 06:41

I think if she can afford it then do it, nobody shames the royals for for having help with their children.

hourbyhour101 · 25/03/2023 06:33

@princemarry you know that your husband's abusive right ?

Like I know this term is bandied around here like water but what your describing is abuse. Abusive people can be nice and pleasant (look up the abuse cycle) and I know your probably rolling your eyes at this and thinking well he's never raised a hand to me.

But think about it he doesn't need to. You already do what he wants because he takes you down a few pegs by comparison. I do work in this area I know what I'm talking about sadly.

You are being gaslit and that's why your permanently in a state of confusion (because confused tired people are easier to control).

Just because you wanted your child to have a sibling it doesn't mean that you signed up to be his personal maid/nanny/sec thingemotional beating bag ect

So practicalities - how little are your kids ? Do you earn your own money ? Married ? Finances how are they split ? (Does he control oversee all money ?) can you hatch a get away fund ? What about your support network ? Do they know about this guy/ anyone you trust? (Please tell me he hasn't isolated you from to many friends)
With small children getting away is hard but school age is much easier. Remember no matter what he threatens- your the primary cater for those children so he will be unlikely to be given primary care status over your should your split ?

Before you compare yourself to his mum and yours - remember a lot of these women suffered and stayed through abuse because society did not accept divorce and they would be out on streets. Society has changed thankfully now.

Watch the maid on Netflix -you aren't alone. They always say things in "anger" but remember most abusive people are in control all of the time even when angry. They just give themselves permission to say these things because they can. Not because they are out of control.

Goodread1 · 25/03/2023 06:31

It's all so bla bla bla predictable that he is a male who hardly bothers with childcare with his children,

He Sounds Crap 💩💩🤡💩💩🤡🤡🤡

He sounds as useful as someone who has rigor mortois
Another words Corpose,

Goodread1 · 25/03/2023 06:25

I will be honest,
If I could have afforded it like this woman, who has hired a home help,

I too would have done the same as her, or had a Au pair

Goodread1 · 25/03/2023 06:23

Lucky woman , she sounds astute about stuff ,
I am must admit quite envious of her,
Why not if you can afford it, and she still ensures she spends quality time with her child,
its not like she is just dumping her child on someone else,
the live in Nanny sounds more like mothers help type of thing,
its giving her more time to bond, connect with her child effectively,
whithout constantly allmost feeling permanently exhausted, for some time !

Especially if she hasn't got a mother or family who are not much good, not involved that much,
Who don't want to /can't be Arsed to bother supporting as a new 🙄 mum,

not everybody's got good supportive family members who they can turn to on tap,you know, !
some women /some people have lets face it, tell it as it is,
some people have just have misfortune, of having Crap family support /Crap toxic Narastistic type /selfish self absorbed family members or mother or fathers,!

@IAmTheWalrus85 @TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl

Like ubove said, !

Why are women's struggles are Only valued if we are struggling all or most of the friggin time then?🤨😕😤😤😤

Messenger123 · 25/03/2023 06:22

Gosh genuinely surprised by the amount of people on this thread who sound just as judgy as the original husband! If someone wants to get a live in nanny, great, leave em to it. And the number of women asking why she had another if she found the first one so hard? Children are bloody hard work! Yes they are amazing but they’re also a bomb that goes off in your life. If someone needs extra help, why not?!

Ukrainebaby23 · 25/03/2023 05:56

MultipleVeganPies · 23/03/2023 07:07

Clever her, she found herself a wife

I would too if I could afford it.
Good luck to her

Goldbar · 25/03/2023 05:41

@princemarry . Are you happier when he isn't around? What's your financial position? Could you get by on your own? What maintenance would you be entitled to from him?

I'm leaning towards saying LTB, because this goes beyond the nanny issue. It honestly sounds like he thinks you're some sort of slave or wifebot who should have no free time or thoughts of her own and who exists only to serve him. It sounds like he doesn't see you as a person - you're simply a combination of nanny, housekeeper, sex toy, PA... I would say that this borders on the abusive. I imagine it's tough with your younger one being so small and needy (mine is too), but I'd definitely start making plans. You deserve better. And so do your children. They deserve to grow up in a house without an atmosphere where their father doesn't treat their mother like shit.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 25/03/2023 05:29

princemarry · 25/03/2023 05:05

Yes I do turn it around all the time and then he just gets angrier. That's when it really starts tbh. I don't take his comments lying down..

I said, how about you take out the bin then ? And how about you put the tea bags you left in the sink for me to put in the bin, in the bin ? Who does that ? I'm not your slave.

That's when it gets really nasty between us.. then he says I'm always moaning / whingeing. What do I even do ? I make such a big deal out of normal every day things. He also has a hard life always being at work and never home etc.

It escalates very very quickly into pretty nasty stuff ' you're a joke ' he'll say... ' no you're the joke ' I say... and on it goes...

How can you live like this?

CheekyHobson · 25/03/2023 05:25

That's what his mum did, his aunts did, his friends mums did. That's all he ever saw. That's what mums did, full stop. It's just so ingrained that I'm falling below that standard.

I very much doubt that his mum and aunts and friends all did it “perfectly”. That’s just a story he (and they) tell now.

At the very least, the emotional needs of the kids would be minimized in favour of getting the housework done, which is why men like him focus on working and earning money — visible achievements and worldly success are how kids of emotionally bereft “perfect families” learn to get attention and approval and validation.

princemarry · 25/03/2023 05:10

CheekyHobson · 25/03/2023 04:51

He sounds like an absolute twat.

Do you realise that the anger explosions are actually because he can't even look after his own personal life properly, and feels embarrassed about it (full bins, no socks to be found), but he redirects his anger at you, his wife who he supposedly loves, who is trying to look after herself, two totally dependent children and also in part her husband.

My ex was mostly useless with the kids when they were small, and if I ever spoke of feeling exhausted and in need of some help or just care while working and looking after two-under-two, he would say utterly unempathetic things like "Tiredness is just a mother's lot" and "I never ask for sympathy, asking for sympathy is pathetic". You never do forget those scathing comments.

Men like this hate nannies because they're a constant reminder that parenting is actually frequently a two-person job, but they're expecting (I would even say needing) their partner to pretty much do it on her own. A nanny is a real-life symbol of their own failure to show up.

His anger explosions are partly for that but also he just doesn't get why I can't always live up to what he wants. Ie: have a baby and toddler and cook great meals every night, set the table every night for him, do alll his laundry perfectly, run the household perfectly etc. and no complaints.

That's what his mum did, his aunts did, his friends mums did. That's all he ever saw. That's what mums did, full stop. It's just so ingrained that I'm falling below that standard.

And I do everything at home, partly because, like I said - he really isn't home much. But at least when he's home, he could have a bit of appreciation / respect for me and he could show a bit more proper attention to the kids.

OP posts:
princemarry · 25/03/2023 05:05

Goldbar · 25/03/2023 04:41

@princemarry. Have you tried turning it around on him when he makes comments like that?

"This place is a shitshow...". "I know, I've been wondering when you're going to step up and do something about it, after all you're a dad now. It's tough, deal with it".

"You haven't done my laundry...". "If you're doing laundry, can you do the kids' stuff too? After all, you're a dad now. You don't get free time. What did you expect?"

"I'm going out on Saturday." "No you're not, I need you here to help. Guess what, you're a dad now, you need to step up. If you go out, you're leaving someone else to parent your kids and that's pathetic".

Rinse and repeat. Maybe he'll eventually realise how ridiculous he sounds.

Yes I do turn it around all the time and then he just gets angrier. That's when it really starts tbh. I don't take his comments lying down..

I said, how about you take out the bin then ? And how about you put the tea bags you left in the sink for me to put in the bin, in the bin ? Who does that ? I'm not your slave.

That's when it gets really nasty between us.. then he says I'm always moaning / whingeing. What do I even do ? I make such a big deal out of normal every day things. He also has a hard life always being at work and never home etc.

It escalates very very quickly into pretty nasty stuff ' you're a joke ' he'll say... ' no you're the joke ' I say... and on it goes...

OP posts:
CheekyHobson · 25/03/2023 04:51

He sounds like an absolute twat.

Do you realise that the anger explosions are actually because he can't even look after his own personal life properly, and feels embarrassed about it (full bins, no socks to be found), but he redirects his anger at you, his wife who he supposedly loves, who is trying to look after herself, two totally dependent children and also in part her husband.

My ex was mostly useless with the kids when they were small, and if I ever spoke of feeling exhausted and in need of some help or just care while working and looking after two-under-two, he would say utterly unempathetic things like "Tiredness is just a mother's lot" and "I never ask for sympathy, asking for sympathy is pathetic". You never do forget those scathing comments.

Men like this hate nannies because they're a constant reminder that parenting is actually frequently a two-person job, but they're expecting (I would even say needing) their partner to pretty much do it on her own. A nanny is a real-life symbol of their own failure to show up.

Goldbar · 25/03/2023 04:41

@princemarry. Have you tried turning it around on him when he makes comments like that?

"This place is a shitshow...". "I know, I've been wondering when you're going to step up and do something about it, after all you're a dad now. It's tough, deal with it".

"You haven't done my laundry...". "If you're doing laundry, can you do the kids' stuff too? After all, you're a dad now. You don't get free time. What did you expect?"

"I'm going out on Saturday." "No you're not, I need you here to help. Guess what, you're a dad now, you need to step up. If you go out, you're leaving someone else to parent your kids and that's pathetic".

Rinse and repeat. Maybe he'll eventually realise how ridiculous he sounds.

AgentJohnson · 25/03/2023 04:33

I’m confused, given his lack of expertise at being a mother and the pressure that comes with it, who gives a flying fuck what this twat thinks.

princemarry · 25/03/2023 02:32

hourbyhour101 · 24/03/2023 22:03

Egh you know just as a women who has birthed two children.

I'm not sure if my DH had said this after the birth of my first whether there would be a second or even a marriage. There's low standards and then there's your DH

Op some women believe a woman's role is home and kids - that's their choice. What's weird is people seemed to think that any choice they make for their family, makes them superior some way.

Also I know you can afford a nanny but you couldn't actually get one could you ? Because your husbands 1950s dickhead that believe his 10 seconds of action is equal to your 18 years life long service (min per child) to child rearing. With no further action required from him. Talk about a imbalance.

Out of all the people I would call pathetic on this thread including your friend. The only person I can see is pathetic is your DH

He sounds deeply unpleasant. But part of you must agree since your having a second and are well informed on what he expects from you ?

Personally I couldn't ever find a man who equates his wife to unpaid nanny/cleaner/childrearer particularly appealing. What a depressing thought to be honest. Guess he wants you to work and provide as well as do all this stuff ?

At least in 1950s the man worked and the women only had the home and kids to deal with.

I think that's why people are asking you why you posted. Maybe you wanted validation that people agree with him. Well plenty of people have unpleasant views on all sorts of topics. And as most people know dickheads walk amongst us (and some are married to them)

The really interesting question I have (which given my fairly negative view I have on your DH which may make you not respond to this question - which is fair)

I'm guessing that your DH has some fairly "interesting" dickheadish thoughts on other things too - if so do share ? As I have found dickheadishness tends to spread across the personality.

That said if you think like you have posted your DH is just a prat. Aren't you slightly worried about how this will play out with your kids and what that teaches them ? Why put you with it ? Surely you know your worth is more than a mum/maid/unpaid whatever?

If he doesn't value the work you do, then surely you know he doesn't value you a lot at all.

Your self worth must be on the floor ?

Well, he's not outwardly a misogynist at all times.

He pretends like he's not. He makes the right moves. He changes some nappies/ looks after the kids for brief periods and he takes care of the home stuff ( admin / bills / investments / mortgages ) etc. he shares some of the load with the life admin stuff.

But does he actually know what it's like to look after them on his own - when they're born screaming at the same time and you only have two hands to help. No, he has zero idea. He's never taken his kids anywhere alone, he's only watched them for a couple of hours alone at home. The older one gets stuck in front of the iPad anyway. So he really doesn't know.

The situation is complicated also by his work. Yes, perhaps he hides behind that. But he's not home a lot at all. So there aren't many opportunities at the moment for him to do much more.

We are in a cycle at the moment where things will be ok. Then something will set him off.. like he has run out of socks or can't find his shirt or the bin is full and I haven't emptied it and he'll then show his true colours and in his anger he will say something really horrible. Like ' this place is always a shit hole, when are you going to snap out of it ? You're a mum. Deal with it. You're a joke like Sarah. What did you guys expect ?'

That's extremely hurtful. I'll not talk to him for a while and then he'll apologise and promises to not do that again and that he didn't mean it because he's angry.

Rinse and repeat. He'll have outbursts like that every couple of months. It's usually about his laundry not being done properly / on time or his dinner being not what he wanted or me not wanting sex / being tired or moody / run down.

It sounds absolutely awful when I write it down.

I posted because sometimes I just don't know if I should just get on with it and people who have help are a bit ridiculous. I really don't think so, but he makes me doubt myself sometimes. My mum did what I do and more- so did his mum. So do most mums I know. Sarah stands out as being someone who isn't in the same position and I'm happy for her.

Why did we have two kids. Because I wanted my child to have a sibling.

OP posts:
ReallyTryingTo · 25/03/2023 01:30

He sounds jealous to me.

Mamanyt · 24/03/2023 22:54

I, also, had a D(?)H who thought that women should do all of the housework and childcare, even if she did work. A care-giver was only for any hours the wife might be working. He was absolutely unmovable on that until I was hospitalized for 10 weeks due to a really nasty, antibiotic-resistant kidney infection. I came home to a full-time housekeeper/nanny. He told me he lasted one week...although it was closer to 5 days. Nothing like a crash-course in "Mummying" to change a man's mind about how "easy" it is.

Chilloutsnow · 24/03/2023 22:15

@Justalittlebitduckling

I found being pregnant challenging. Lots of sickness and pelvic pain. I liked giving birth (really). I mean it was painful to a degree but I loved the process and the excitement and my births were straight forward. Newborns I find easy. I do however have a husband who did 50 percent of the work.

Justalittlebitduckling · 24/03/2023 22:11

iusedtobeasize8 · 23/03/2023 07:11

Why would she have another child if she the first challenging ?

Does anyone NOT find being pregnant, giving birth and then raising a newborn challenging?!

hourbyhour101 · 24/03/2023 22:03

Egh you know just as a women who has birthed two children.

I'm not sure if my DH had said this after the birth of my first whether there would be a second or even a marriage. There's low standards and then there's your DH

Op some women believe a woman's role is home and kids - that's their choice. What's weird is people seemed to think that any choice they make for their family, makes them superior some way.

Also I know you can afford a nanny but you couldn't actually get one could you ? Because your husbands 1950s dickhead that believe his 10 seconds of action is equal to your 18 years life long service (min per child) to child rearing. With no further action required from him. Talk about a imbalance.

Out of all the people I would call pathetic on this thread including your friend. The only person I can see is pathetic is your DH

He sounds deeply unpleasant. But part of you must agree since your having a second and are well informed on what he expects from you ?

Personally I couldn't ever find a man who equates his wife to unpaid nanny/cleaner/childrearer particularly appealing. What a depressing thought to be honest. Guess he wants you to work and provide as well as do all this stuff ?

At least in 1950s the man worked and the women only had the home and kids to deal with.

I think that's why people are asking you why you posted. Maybe you wanted validation that people agree with him. Well plenty of people have unpleasant views on all sorts of topics. And as most people know dickheads walk amongst us (and some are married to them)

The really interesting question I have (which given my fairly negative view I have on your DH which may make you not respond to this question - which is fair)

I'm guessing that your DH has some fairly "interesting" dickheadish thoughts on other things too - if so do share ? As I have found dickheadishness tends to spread across the personality.

That said if you think like you have posted your DH is just a prat. Aren't you slightly worried about how this will play out with your kids and what that teaches them ? Why put you with it ? Surely you know your worth is more than a mum/maid/unpaid whatever?

If he doesn't value the work you do, then surely you know he doesn't value you a lot at all.

Your self worth must be on the floor ?

toomuchlaundry · 24/03/2023 21:51

The friend works

Comii9 · 24/03/2023 21:35

I'm not sure what you want from this OP.

I find having one hard but having a live in nanny. Come on OP!

Doesthepopeshitinthewoods · 24/03/2023 21:23

The posters who are vehement judging this woman and calling her names (pathetic, a lame duck) are mostly, if not all women, and absolutely riddled with internalised misogyny. They’re holding the woman solely responsible here.

What a very sorry state of affairs.

restingbitchface30 · 24/03/2023 21:19

But they are SAHMs while the husband is working. I’d think the same if it was a SAHD and the mum was out working