Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm in court tomorrow. Feel like I'm living a nightmare.

188 replies

FamilyCourtNightmare · 22/03/2023 21:10

This is very outing but I really need advice. I've been in family court for over 4 years now. I left my ex when my child was 4 months old. Now 4 years. Lovely little boy, thriving, happy, etc etc. His dad abused both of us, and was found in a finding of fact to have perpetrated coercive control, harassment, Intimidation, rough handling of our son (stupid way of minimising the word 'assault'), racial abuse against both of us (me and my son are both mixed race).

Initially I suggested that he go on a domestic abuse perpetrator programme, but the cafcass section 7 said he wasn't suitable as he was in denial of the facts found against him. It was only after this point, after two years of court hearings and denials that he suddenly changed his tune and 'saw a sea of change' and was referred onto the course. I disagreed with this as it was clearly not genuine and he was just out of options. I'd like to mention that I had to get 3 non molestation orders against him, one after it was recommended he attend the DAPP.

Now cafcass have changed their section 7 as he has passed the DAPP with flying colours. I requested the DAPP report and it is littered with lies and fabrications. I've pointed this out and am able to prove some. He also stayed in his statement and in the DAPP risk assessment that I have depression and suicidal tendencies, which I have already provided a letter to say this isn't the case.

Despite all of this, cafcass are recommending contact go ahead. I have contested this in my statement (which I must say is well written and balanced) and am awaiting a hearing tomorrow to see if contact should go ahead.

I can't cope with this. I feel like my abuser is about to be back in our lives and I'm living a nightmare. He is still a very angry person and his daughter from a previous relationship doesn't want to see him anymore because he is 'so angry all the time'. I am not allowed to evidence this in court as it has come from his family members who are not willing to testify. They are honest people and estranged from him.

How do I move forwards? He hasn't seen our son in 4 years. I'm so scared.

OP posts:
OakTreex · 22/03/2023 23:02

@Hotvimto3 I completely agree.

OakTreex · 22/03/2023 23:00

Everything crossed for you OP.

My advice is to show an element of willing - e.g. "While I recognise that X has made some progress, I cannot be satisfied that direct contact is suitable for X due to X, Y and Z inconsistencies which demonstrate an unwillingness to change," or similar. You don't want to be seen as shutting down the idea of contact or appear hostile - it's a death knell for mother's in FC.

oblada · 22/03/2023 23:00

FamilyCourtNightmare · 22/03/2023 21:21

I believe they go with cafcass recommendations 99%+ of the time

Family courts do tend to go with CAFCASS but definitely not always and not 99percent of the time. Make your case, raise your concerns. Good luck.

Hotvimto3 · 22/03/2023 22:59

FamilyCourtNightmare · 22/03/2023 22:59

Cafcass are recommending supervised in the first instance

So did mine. They went against it

FamilyCourtNightmare · 22/03/2023 22:59

Hotvimto3 · 22/03/2023 22:56

Lets hope you even get supervised. Probably you won't my love im so sorry

Cafcass are recommending supervised in the first instance

OP posts:
Hotvimto3 · 22/03/2023 22:59

cato40 · 22/03/2023 22:56

SweetSakura nailed 100% there. Adults in abusive relationships are advised to stay away from their abusers, but children HAVE to have contact. Where's the logic there?

Because the mens needs override the risk to child. Many documented cases where father got contact at family court against soc serv and mums concerns cos 'alienation from a parent is worse than sexual or physical abuse' then they have gone on to commit heinous crimes. But as long as dad is ok hey.

Hotvimto3 · 22/03/2023 22:56

FamilyCourtNightmare · 22/03/2023 22:54

Supervised contact is a means to an end and we can only get 6 sessions. This does not seem reasonable considering the history

Lets hope you even get supervised. Probably you won't my love im so sorry

cato40 · 22/03/2023 22:56

SweetSakura · 22/03/2023 22:17

Strange how we encourage women to leave their abusers, often judge them if they don't, but don't believe children have the same right to live free from abuse.

SweetSakura nailed 100% there. Adults in abusive relationships are advised to stay away from their abusers, but children HAVE to have contact. Where's the logic there?

BubziOwl · 22/03/2023 22:55

I will be thinking of you tomorrow! Flowers I hope it goes as well as it possibly can. You sound like a great mum.

FamilyCourtNightmare · 22/03/2023 22:55

I'm wondering how they will mitigate the fact that he lives 3.5 hours away also.

OP posts:
FamilyCourtNightmare · 22/03/2023 22:54

bellabasset · 22/03/2023 22:53

Of course your son should have some contact with his father. But he's only 4 and I hope with the history of abuse it will be supervised contact. Good luck for tomorrow.

Supervised contact is a means to an end and we can only get 6 sessions. This does not seem reasonable considering the history

OP posts:
Cm078 · 22/03/2023 22:53

My sister has been going through similar for the past 2 years. With cafcass aswell etc.
Unfortunately the dad has been given every other weekend (including overnight)
He is an abuser, I have witnessed on many occasions, even some of it is on police record.
I am so sorry you're going through this, it is very scary. I hope it goes your way for you and your son

bellabasset · 22/03/2023 22:53

Of course your son should have some contact with his father. But he's only 4 and I hope with the history of abuse it will be supervised contact. Good luck for tomorrow.

Hotvimto3 · 22/03/2023 22:52

America12 · 22/03/2023 22:51

He racially and physically abused him and hasn't seen him for years????

They will allow contact and probably lecture mum for being abusive by not allowing it. Zero risk assessment and zero safeguarding

America12 · 22/03/2023 22:51

Member869894 · 22/03/2023 22:00

Would it be so bad if your son were tbe givwn the chance to begin to build a relationship with his father provided it could be done safely and at a pace with which your son is comfortable?

He racially and physically abused him and hasn't seen him for years????

Hotvimto3 · 22/03/2023 22:50

OakTreex · 22/03/2023 22:47

I won't labour on my experiences but the sad and sorry facts are that family court is a broken system in desperate need of reform (it was spoken about in parliament today - much needed) and I know of cases where even men convicted of sexual harm against children are granted contact.

It's fucked up and laypeople who don't know the system would never believe quite how fucked up it is, institutionally. The family court asset strips parents and traffics children into abuse and if you think that's 'nonsense' or a wild conspiracy theory you've no idea. Imagine being court ordered to face your rapist eh!

You haven't said what kind of contact they have suggested. If pushed, you could suggest letterbox contact as a final order or other indirect contact? You don't want to seem entirely hostile to all contact (and yes, I know that's hard, but you have to play the game).

Im sorry to say but everything you say in my experience is 100% true

FamilyCourtNightmare · 22/03/2023 22:49

Hotvimto3 · 22/03/2023 22:48

I really hope this helps. I was infront of a woman judge and thought this might help. She actively cracked jokes with the other party and fawned over him.

That sounds awful. I've never experienced that. I've been very lucky.

OP posts:
SweetSakura · 22/03/2023 22:49

Glad it's a DJ op, you are right that they are more likely to have the guts to depart a bit from cafcass recommendations.

If you can, put forward a sensible list of counter proposals. My relative who is a judge says one of the hardest things is when people can't articulate what they do want to see in the court order. As others have said , I'd focus on gently slowing things down (the older he is the better) and building in safeguards.

Hotvimto3 · 22/03/2023 22:48

FamilyCourtNightmare · 22/03/2023 22:44

I'm in front of a district judge as opposed to magistrates due to the extent of the abuse.

I really hope this helps. I was infront of a woman judge and thought this might help. She actively cracked jokes with the other party and fawned over him.

FamilyCourtNightmare · 22/03/2023 22:47

Hotvimto3 · 22/03/2023 22:46

In my experience even with pages and pages of evidence i was critisized for denying a relationship. They seem blind to abuse and automatically asume as the victim you are lying

This hasn't been my experience. The judges so far have been very compassionate and he hasn't been granted any contact for 4 years. Will just have to see what happens tomorrow.

OP posts:
OakTreex · 22/03/2023 22:47

I won't labour on my experiences but the sad and sorry facts are that family court is a broken system in desperate need of reform (it was spoken about in parliament today - much needed) and I know of cases where even men convicted of sexual harm against children are granted contact.

It's fucked up and laypeople who don't know the system would never believe quite how fucked up it is, institutionally. The family court asset strips parents and traffics children into abuse and if you think that's 'nonsense' or a wild conspiracy theory you've no idea. Imagine being court ordered to face your rapist eh!

You haven't said what kind of contact they have suggested. If pushed, you could suggest letterbox contact as a final order or other indirect contact? You don't want to seem entirely hostile to all contact (and yes, I know that's hard, but you have to play the game).

Hotvimto3 · 22/03/2023 22:46

monsteramunch · 22/03/2023 22:40

You sound like you're an amazing mum @FamilyCourtNightmare and exactly the kind of mum who will help stop that internalising of abuse, because you're making it crystal clear it's unacceptable and providing a safe place for your son to live and be loved free of his father - even if he ends up having to have some contact centre time etc.

You should be really bloody proud of yourself, your son will be too when he's older and understands how much your fought for his wellbeing Flowers

In my experience even with pages and pages of evidence i was critisized for denying a relationship. They seem blind to abuse and automatically asume as the victim you are lying

SweetSakura · 22/03/2023 22:46

snitzelvoncrumb · 22/03/2023 22:45

Wishing you the best for tomorrow. I wonder if there has been or ever will be a huge class action against the courts by people who were forced to have contact with abusive parents as children?

And /or against cafcass. Yes, I think that this is what is required to inject some balance back into decision making

Justgorgeous · 22/03/2023 22:45

@Member869894 FFS. Read the original post and then read your post back to yourself.

snitzelvoncrumb · 22/03/2023 22:45

Wishing you the best for tomorrow. I wonder if there has been or ever will be a huge class action against the courts by people who were forced to have contact with abusive parents as children?