Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughter accused of instigating a serious incident. Is she really wrong?

738 replies

wasshereallywrong · 22/03/2023 20:37

I have name changed for this to not link to previous threads as this is outing and I have told people in real life.

I am going to preface this be saying my DD 13 is a gobby little sod so I know she can be annoying and hasn't got the best school record but she has no time for injustice which has led to conflict for her in the past but to todays incident...

My DD has several black friends (we come from a very white area). She was told today that one lad was going around using the N word. This isn't the first time and so she took it upon herself to confront him and tell him it isn't right and it is racist. Like I say she is gobby so I imagine she was heated when she said it. He pushed her away and told her to leave him alone, everyone gathered around and she said she wasn't going to fight and went to move away, he pushed her again and ran off. Two of her friends then caught up with the lad and several punches were thrown. I am not saying the fight was acceptable. It was 2 on 1 and he was hurt and fighting is never ok.

My DD has now been given a day of internal exclusion because she initiated a serious incident. Did she though or did she call out unacceptable racism? Was it not the lad who was using the n word the person who instigated it? I have said that she has to accept that she was wrong to get involved in something that wasn't to do with her but was she wrong? If people don't call out racist behaviour how is it stopped? I am going to be speaking to the head teacher tomorrow as I missed his call today but AIBU to be proud of her for taking a stand against racist behaviour and to be arguing with the punishment for starting this when if he hadn't made the comments it wouldn't have been necessary to 'talk' to him about it. And is the school wrong for punishing someone for calling out this behaviour?

OP posts:
dawngreen · 22/03/2023 22:14

She needs to learn to go through the proper channels about these things. Not to wade into the middle of trouble because some one said he did. What if he had a knife, and used it?? Even boxers meet their match some day. She needs to pick the right hill to fight on.

DiddyHeck · 22/03/2023 22:13

I am going to be speaking to the head teacher tomorrow as I missed his call today

Then you've started this thread 24 hours too early.

Why have you chosen to do that?

Pointless.

Hankunamatata · 22/03/2023 22:10

I'm guessing she got right in the boys face if he asked her to leave him alone and close enough to be pushed. She inflamed situation then riled her male friends enough to assault this boy - where police could be involved especially two boys hitting one.

Yet you think she hasn't done anything wrong.

DrMeredithGrey2023 · 22/03/2023 22:09

She didn’t even leave the first time she was pushed.

op says she went to move away after he pushed her the first time

FrippEnos · 22/03/2023 22:08

Elvis1956 · 22/03/2023 22:01

We are reading the ops drop feed. Firstly, why did the dd need to mention afight. I've never come across a right minded female who's mentioned, even suggested fighting a male. I bet everyone at school knows she boxes...I find it strange that the op mentioned her boxing ...in an earlier post I surmised that it makes her feel invincible.
Secondly, she heard from a third party that he had been racist. Would you accuse me of being racist if someone told you I was? I expect you would ask me calmly if I was.
Third, even the op admits that her dd is gobby, has her own track record in school.
Finally, we have the fact that 2 boys are also in trouble as a result of her actions. The o p hasn't mentioned how badly the boy who was hit was injured. The 2 boys could have been in a lot of trouble because the DD acted as she did....she instigated everything

The only bit that @Elvis1956 has missed is that it was the two boys that hit the other boy that told her that he had said the n word.

Veryverycalmnow · 22/03/2023 22:07

cantstopthefeeling · 22/03/2023 20:54

Seriously, she called out racist language and said it wasn't right. He pushed her, she went to go away and he pushed her again. If what the OP says is right she didn't charge in with violence. His behaviour, a boy being told by a girl that what he said wasn't right, started a violent response, towards a girl. I'm sorry but she has done the right thing. Yes she can speak to teachers and she should do that as well but if we want to change how language is used whether it is racist, homophobic or misogynistic then kids calling it out and showing up poor behaviour is how we do it. He had the opportunity to say he didn't say it or walk away, he didn't...he pushed a girl TWICE, once after she walked away saying she wasn't going to fight. He upped the violence not her. Calling out bad language is not violent, it's the only way to stop it being accepted.

^I agree. It's not always best to tell a teacher. Sometimes young people respect their peers opinions more than a teacher talking to them. Maybe the fact it's not the first time he's said things like this suggests he thinks he can get away with it.
OP's DD backed away, after calling this kid out on their racism. I think she did the right thing, but it then led to other people making bad choices.
She said she wouldn't fight. She didn't actually do wrong! Racists need to be told it's not ok.

Ireallycantthinkofagoodone · 22/03/2023 22:06

Scienceadvisory · 22/03/2023 20:42

Except she doesn't even know for sure this boy said anything racist. She just heard it from someone else and then went running round causing trouble. If she actually cared she would have reported to a teacher. But she just sounds like a hot-head who enjoys drama. I wonder if the person who told her about the alleged comments did so because they know its easy to wind your daughter up.

This ⬆️

DrMeredithGrey2023 · 22/03/2023 22:06

@Elvis1956 I would imagine she mentioned not wanting to fight because he was physically aggressive towards her when he pushed her the first time.
How I would react in any situation is not going to be the same way that a 13 year old child would react, so what I would do is irrelevant.
She isn't in control of her friends actions.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 22/03/2023 22:05

OP needs to go into the school or actually talk to the head and get all the facts about what actually happened and her daughter's actions.

We can all froth all we want for the next 20 pages, based on third hand half info, but then we're just like the kids in the playground really.

AliceOlive · 22/03/2023 22:04

YouTarzan · 22/03/2023 21:41

This thread has it all!

How could we expect children to have perfect judgement when adults go nuts just reading about a situation?!

Quveas · 22/03/2023 22:04

Soapboxqueen · 22/03/2023 20:50

Your dd challenging someone using the N word in front of her would be one thing but this was at the very least second hand knowledge. She didn't know at that point how true it was or if someone else was just stirring.

She then decided to confront this person in a less than calm and controlled manner.

She should have raised this with a member of staff.

She did start that altercation.

I agree. If someone says something racist in front of you then there are CALM ways of dealing with it. She heard some gossip, and true or not she decided to start a conflict. She was wrong and the subsequent incident was caused by her.

Eyerollcentral · 22/03/2023 22:02

TiredandHungry19 · 22/03/2023 21:56

Irrelevant to whether or not a girl very clearly refusing to fight - even when she’s being assaulted - is responsible for male violence. It’s victim blaming.

It’s not victim blaming. She started the row. She had a means through the school or dealing with her concerns. She decided to start a row. She had only heard someone else say that this other child had used that word. Were you never at school? How many rumours did you hear every day at 13? How many fights did you see start over them? I couldn’t even tell you how many I saw, and that was at an all girl’s convent school. The OP’s daughter needs to learn to stop getting in people’s faces, not least of all because of she continues one day she will accuse the wrong person and will have to deal with the consequences. I don’t even think it’s so much the girl refused to fight, she was happy to have a verbal row, she just didn’t like it when she realised oh actually I could get my face punched in here. She didn’t even leave the first time she was pushed. Have you never seen a physical fight?

Iam4eels · 22/03/2023 22:02

She called him on his racism.

She sought out another pupil and publicly confronted him based on gossip. She had no proof he had actually said this word, she didn't witness it herself, she was acting on information carried to her secondhand by other pupils.

Calling him out publicly in front of a group of other pupils then spread that gossip to everyone watching. As a result of her calling him out two other pupils took it upon themselves to dish out some punches, an action they might not have taken had she not gathered a crowd and let everyone know what this boy had said.

Except she had zero proof that he said it.

She triggered of an incident by reacting to gossip.

Elvis1956 · 22/03/2023 22:01

DrMeredithGrey2023 · 22/03/2023 21:49

What are people reading??

He didn't have to push her twice to get her out of his face - he pushed her, she said she wasn't going to fight, went to move away and he pushed her again.

OP - your daughters heart was obviously in the right place. I have told my children that we must always call out peoples use of slurs, I guess her crime here is that she called him out without hearing it first hand, but tbh, if someone has previous I would probably believe second hand information too.

We are reading the ops drop feed. Firstly, why did the dd need to mention afight. I've never come across a right minded female who's mentioned, even suggested fighting a male. I bet everyone at school knows she boxes...I find it strange that the op mentioned her boxing ...in an earlier post I surmised that it makes her feel invincible.
Secondly, she heard from a third party that he had been racist. Would you accuse me of being racist if someone told you I was? I expect you would ask me calmly if I was.
Third, even the op admits that her dd is gobby, has her own track record in school.
Finally, we have the fact that 2 boys are also in trouble as a result of her actions. The o p hasn't mentioned how badly the boy who was hit was injured. The 2 boys could have been in a lot of trouble because the DD acted as she did....she instigated everything

sugarspices · 22/03/2023 22:01

I can see that you're proud of your daughter for calling out (alleged) racism. I would be proud of my child for recognising/challenging it too.

The issues have been repeated on here dozens of time so I won't bother, but you have accepted that she didn't handle things in the right way. She's 13 and kids don't always get it right. Her being punished is a good thing, as hopefully she will learn how to deal with this more effectively in the future.

It should be made clear to her that she isn't being punished for challenging (alleged) racism, but she is being punished for not challenging it appropriately.

It's possible to be simultaneously proud of your daughter for the sentiment, but cross with her for the execution.

TemporaryNaming · 22/03/2023 22:00

Meh - your daughter thought she was doing the right thing. She will learn through this punishment it's actually the wrong response she used. It sounds like she is being punished for being involved in something that didn't concern her and led to several others being in trouble (she didn't witness the alleged slur) however, to put another perspective across, if someone publicly accused my child of saying something racist, in front of their peers, when they hadn't done so and my child was then assaulted by a further two children I would be furious. I'm not saying the boy did or didn't use a racist slur, but I can imagine the other parents have a different view.

Wisteriaroundthedoor · 22/03/2023 21:57

Interesting thread. I think you’re missing the point. She is being punished for instigating a serious incident, there is absolutely No doubt she did.

if the boy said it then she retaliated it would be different, but that’s not what happened, she has heard he has said it at some point, so she went and confronted him.

The teachers are trying to tell both you and her, this is not ok. It was after the event of him saying it. She has never witnessed him saying it, it’s not about whether he has or hasn’t, it’s about it wasn’t at that time and she personally has never heard him say it. It wasn’t during this altercation at all,she reacted angrily over a rumour. After the event, instead of speaking to a teacher and letting them handle it, to see if it was true and to manage it accordingly.

and as she decided to angrily confront him, when she’d personally never heard him say such a thing, it has resulted in this fight and the boy got hurt. Two kids beat him.

so yes. Your daughter instigated a serious incident and she is part;h culpable for what happened. And with the other kids, she should be punished.

your child needs to learn to manage situations, her emotions, her behaviour. She needs to understand the best way to approach things and at 13 she should have a fair grasp on this appropriate for her age. But I guess it’s not so impressive to the other kids, to quietly speak to a teacher about what she heard.

the last thing she needs is a parent whooping in the corner and trying to kid themselves she’s some sort of crusading vigilante. What she does need is a parent who can explain to her why this punishment happened and why she is culpable in this,

Iam4eels · 22/03/2023 21:57

Lately we have had a lot of students 'being told' that other people have used that word.

This is currently a thing at eldest DCs school too. DC was accused of saying it and a pupil tried to have a go at him about it except DC wasn't even in the lesson where he was alleged to have said it as he was doing work elsewhere with his 1:1.

This is why staff need to deal with incidents, not pupils, because rumours spiral.

Oblomov23 · 22/03/2023 21:57

I disagree with many on this thread. I agree with Lamelie, the first post:

"She’s not wrong and if it is as you describe I’d be all over it."

If it's true.

I'd ask for Head Meeting. Sit and wait ti hear what he says. And then I'd insist that she's doing nothing wrong at all. Inciting? She called him on his racism. She can not be held responsible for her 2 friends then taking it much further, their choice. I'd be expecting Head to thus conclude that a punishment is appropriate. But you expect ahead to thus reduce the punishment significantly.

FrippEnos · 22/03/2023 21:57

Given that the school will have asked the pupils that witnessed the DD "talking" to this boy, she may not be as innocent as the OP would like.

Hiddenvoice · 22/03/2023 21:56

She stood up against racist behaviour but she did instigate this fight. I know she is 13 but she should have spoken to a teacher or even you for you to report it to the school. She started the discussion which must have been heated for this lad to start pushing her. He is of course in no way innocent but he was attacked by 2 others. They should all be penalised for their engagement in this. Yes she stood up for her friends which is great but I guess now she will know that there are better ways to go about it in the future.
This kid is trouble so your daughter should stay awah from him, anything she hears him saying she should report and not get involved with him directly.

TiredandHungry19 · 22/03/2023 21:56

Eyerollcentral · 22/03/2023 21:55

What words did she use? How did she say them? Do you think she went gently in to have a discussion or did she rush in and start shouting the odds? The OP interestingly hasn’t clarified that, she has described her own daughter as gobby. She was punished for instigating the whole row, which she did and she should have been.

Irrelevant to whether or not a girl very clearly refusing to fight - even when she’s being assaulted - is responsible for male violence. It’s victim blaming.

MelsMoneyTree · 22/03/2023 21:56

Also excusing her behaviour as having no time for injustice is bullshit. She didn't care about the injustice of calling someone out for something based solely on gossip.

Eyerollcentral · 22/03/2023 21:55

TiredandHungry19 · 22/03/2023 21:51

I didn’t quote you and I haven’t even read any posts by you but cool story thanks for sharing.

Did you miss the part where the girl used words and refused to fight, and nor did she set her friends to fight the other kid? She is not responsible for any of the boys resorting to violence in this incident. They are responsible for their own actions.

What words did she use? How did she say them? Do you think she went gently in to have a discussion or did she rush in and start shouting the odds? The OP interestingly hasn’t clarified that, she has described her own daughter as gobby. She was punished for instigating the whole row, which she did and she should have been.

princesssugarless · 22/03/2023 21:54

Lately we have had a lot of students 'being told' that other people have used that word. Usually the gobby ones who will do something about it. It is a lot of the time an excuse to try and start a fight that the whole year group will love to watch. It then takes the focus off the racist behaviour (which has happened in some cases and has not in others - nasty rumours designed to her students into trouble) and makes it difficult to investigate true issue. She may have been punished under a joint enterprise rule - this can happen in real life.

The racism needs reporting to school and the school need to deal with it - students should not be judge and jury.

Swipe left for the next trending thread