Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughter accused of instigating a serious incident. Is she really wrong?

738 replies

wasshereallywrong · 22/03/2023 20:37

I have name changed for this to not link to previous threads as this is outing and I have told people in real life.

I am going to preface this be saying my DD 13 is a gobby little sod so I know she can be annoying and hasn't got the best school record but she has no time for injustice which has led to conflict for her in the past but to todays incident...

My DD has several black friends (we come from a very white area). She was told today that one lad was going around using the N word. This isn't the first time and so she took it upon herself to confront him and tell him it isn't right and it is racist. Like I say she is gobby so I imagine she was heated when she said it. He pushed her away and told her to leave him alone, everyone gathered around and she said she wasn't going to fight and went to move away, he pushed her again and ran off. Two of her friends then caught up with the lad and several punches were thrown. I am not saying the fight was acceptable. It was 2 on 1 and he was hurt and fighting is never ok.

My DD has now been given a day of internal exclusion because she initiated a serious incident. Did she though or did she call out unacceptable racism? Was it not the lad who was using the n word the person who instigated it? I have said that she has to accept that she was wrong to get involved in something that wasn't to do with her but was she wrong? If people don't call out racist behaviour how is it stopped? I am going to be speaking to the head teacher tomorrow as I missed his call today but AIBU to be proud of her for taking a stand against racist behaviour and to be arguing with the punishment for starting this when if he hadn't made the comments it wouldn't have been necessary to 'talk' to him about it. And is the school wrong for punishing someone for calling out this behaviour?

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 23/03/2023 06:55

Zuyi · 22/03/2023 20:45

I agree with PP. If she heard the word firsthand, it would be good to speak up then and there, but to react to gossip is something else entirely. Who knows if the gossip was true or part of a whole bullying thing against that boy who got beaten up.

This. She can’t go about meting out summary justice on the basis of hearsay!

thebestbirtheraccordingtoDD · 23/03/2023 06:53

I don't think she's done anything wrong. Good for her for standing up for what's right.

If people people did that the world would be a better place.

BusyMum47 · 23/03/2023 06:53

Azandme · 22/03/2023 20:41

Yes racist behaviour needs calling out, but there are ways to deal with it, and the way she chose wasn't a good one.

She should have immediately raised it with a member of staff, instead of charging in - because that DID incite the incident.

I'm all for people standing up for what is right, but they need to do it in a way that isn't wrong.

This! Plain & simple. ⬆️

labamba007 · 23/03/2023 06:42

wasshereallywrong · 22/03/2023 21:04

Just so we are clear there are things I am not mentioning that are outing to the child involved and my child. I don't think that calling out this behaviour was a good idea for her safety as much as anything but no I haven't said to her that it's fine so she will learn nothing from this. She will learn from this and already has. She gave her statement to the head of year who according to my DD said that she thought she hadn't really done anything to be punished for. I am aware that from an outsiders perspective this is an innocent angel who has been targeted by a little shit who has got her friends to beat him up. That is far far from the case!

People aren't saying the boy is an innocent angel. But in life we can't go around confronting people based on second hand information. I am sure it's true and this boy will need discipline but it's not your daughters job to judge, jury and executioner.

TheHoover · 23/03/2023 06:42

I agree with how your daughter has dealt with it and believe the school was wrong in treating the fight as a worse misdemeanour than the racism (or at least that’s the message they are giving out).

Those involved in the fight are responsible for their own actions. I don’t agree with punishing an instigator so harshly in any respect but in this particular case it’s outrageous

Mothership4two · 23/03/2023 06:37

Mothership4two · 23/03/2023 00:48

The only thing that the OP knows for sure is that she received a voice message from the headteacher which presumably said that her daughter was going to be excluded.

And I repeat my sentiments from nearly 6 hours ago

Theos · 23/03/2023 06:35

I say this as a head of year. She dealt with it totally wrongly.

Theos · 23/03/2023 06:34

She should have reported it. If you have kids going around school meeting out their own justice as they see it - you get anarchy.

AxolotlOnions · 23/03/2023 06:33

I think she did the right thing, the racist instigated the situation with his racism, then instigated the violence by assaulting your daughter. Calling out racism is the right thing to do. I would get the other side of the story but if your daughter is telling the truth she should not be in trouble and she should not have been accused of causing this situation.

78Summer · 23/03/2023 06:32

Challenging someone in a gobby manner is never going to end well.

Maedan · 23/03/2023 06:26

The boy instigated the incident by using that word and then physically assaulting your daughter when she challenged him on it. I can't see what your DD did wrong, I'd go f***g mad at this.

Whyarewehardofthinking · 23/03/2023 06:03

As a previous poster has said; she started it by shit stiring. Yes her views on racism are right, but that that word out of the situation for a minute.

She confronted someone about something she was told secondhand. It may not be correct. A group of kids then go looking for another kid. Kids being kids means that more will join the group amd then suddenly you have a pack running around trying to find someone to cause shit. That is the issue.

It is something that we are finding a growing problem. Some gossip/bitching gets spread around, everyone gets involved and wants to confront it. Then you get swarms of kids and then fights which are difficult to manage. That age group are becoming a nightmare with it and I know it isn't limited to just my school.

ittakes2 · 23/03/2023 05:53

Also I would like to add please - as a mixed race person myself - I think it would make me feel less empowered if someone took it upon themselves to create an argument about my colour. That person has taken my choice away on how to deal with something that happened to me. Better to ask me what I want done about it.

ittakes2 · 23/03/2023 05:49

You seem to not be giving any importance to the idea that your daughter was told something by a third party. If she was in a conversation and a racist comment was made about her friend I would back her to the hilt that she stood up for them. But some other 13 year old told her something and instead of going to a teacher to sort out she’s taken upon herself to be judge and jury. This is not something to be proud of - sounds like she just wants drama rather than justice.

Tomkirkman · 23/03/2023 05:45

I am not white. I can’t stand it when white people wade in a situation and inflame the situation. I am always completely confused why they believe non white people can’t handle it or are handling it incorrectly, so we must need them to sort it.

I am still non the wiser why Ops dd felt that she had to step in and handle this. Why she felt the boys it happened to couldn’t?

A bit of mob justice wasn’t going to help anyone.

and I am going to guess, again, that Ops dd is often found at the root of loads of trouble or drama.

MerryMarigold · 23/03/2023 03:10

wasshereallywrong · 22/03/2023 21:09

@nokidshere weirdly she can have male friends. The 2 lads that punched him were her friends who he had been using the n word about

Did he use the n word on them? Or was it all hearsay? If he said it directly to them then it would have been between them and not involved your DD. If it's all hearsay (how did your DD know it had been said? Who told her?) then it was basically an incident which someone stirred up, including your DD.

I think your DD has something to learn here and honestly, without the exclusion, do you think your DD would learn it?

Museya15 · 23/03/2023 02:37

The daughter sounds like a nightmare.

emptythelitterbox · 23/03/2023 02:24

Your DD sounds like a bully and troublemaker.

Neither you nor her seem to see that though.

Eyerollcentral · 23/03/2023 02:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’ve tried to answer everything you’ve said so if I haven’t responded to you I’m afraid you’ll have to spell out to me what it is you actually want me to respond to.
‘As someone who was once a black kid in a school filled with people like you, you’re being VERY on brand. Right down to the ridiculing of black people (your responses to @Sillymummy295 while purporting to be worried about the ‘two black kids’ and condemning ‘white saviourism’. ‘ I’m reporting you now. I haven’t ridiculed any black person on this thread or ever. That’s a disgraceful accusation to make of me. I am concerned about two black kids who now are classed as violent after a white girl stirred up a row. Not sure how any response of mine has been more ridiculing to the poster you referred to than any response she has given to any one else. VERY on brand for what? Please spell it out.

EggInANest · 23/03/2023 02:17

she was wrong to get involved in something that wasn't to do with her

No, that wasn’t the problem at all. Good for her: too many people turn away because it’s ‘not to do with them’.

Interesting that the school have held a girl responsible for a violent boy getting beaten up. Are girls supposed to keep quiet and know their place? She refused to fight.

Yes she could better have sought help from staff but their focus seems not to be on the behaviour of racist little thugs.

sashh · 23/03/2023 02:10

DD had the right motives but her actions were wrong.

She should have taken it to a teacher.

I've no reason to think what I am about to type next happened, just a pause for thought and maybe something others might want to discuss with their teens.

There is a 'thing' going around at the moment where some children sell an 'N word pass' to their friends, this allows the friend to use that word for a day / week.

It's not always an N word, other racial slurs are also 'sold'.

WuTangGran · 23/03/2023 01:56

Well done to your daughter for doing the right thing calling out racism.

MrsMikeDrop · 23/03/2023 01:53

Hairday · 23/03/2023 01:38

Her friends chose not to confront this boy, but she forced the confrontation and it escalated and now they are suspended. I don't think she was necessarily a good friend. I relate, because I used to be like that myself. It is a bit white savior though. Racism is more than just bad words in the playground and as a white person it's hard to see what's going on. She should have respected their choice not to confront.

Personally I think it's better when a white person confronts a racist, if people did that more often it wouldn't normalise it. Usually the reason the victim of racism doesn't do it because a. They're used to it and b. They don't want to add 'fuel' or satisfy the person with a reaction. I say good on her for standing up for what's right.

Newhousewhodis · 23/03/2023 01:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hairday · 23/03/2023 01:38

Her friends chose not to confront this boy, but she forced the confrontation and it escalated and now they are suspended. I don't think she was necessarily a good friend. I relate, because I used to be like that myself. It is a bit white savior though. Racism is more than just bad words in the playground and as a white person it's hard to see what's going on. She should have respected their choice not to confront.