Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughter accused of instigating a serious incident. Is she really wrong?

738 replies

wasshereallywrong · 22/03/2023 20:37

I have name changed for this to not link to previous threads as this is outing and I have told people in real life.

I am going to preface this be saying my DD 13 is a gobby little sod so I know she can be annoying and hasn't got the best school record but she has no time for injustice which has led to conflict for her in the past but to todays incident...

My DD has several black friends (we come from a very white area). She was told today that one lad was going around using the N word. This isn't the first time and so she took it upon herself to confront him and tell him it isn't right and it is racist. Like I say she is gobby so I imagine she was heated when she said it. He pushed her away and told her to leave him alone, everyone gathered around and she said she wasn't going to fight and went to move away, he pushed her again and ran off. Two of her friends then caught up with the lad and several punches were thrown. I am not saying the fight was acceptable. It was 2 on 1 and he was hurt and fighting is never ok.

My DD has now been given a day of internal exclusion because she initiated a serious incident. Did she though or did she call out unacceptable racism? Was it not the lad who was using the n word the person who instigated it? I have said that she has to accept that she was wrong to get involved in something that wasn't to do with her but was she wrong? If people don't call out racist behaviour how is it stopped? I am going to be speaking to the head teacher tomorrow as I missed his call today but AIBU to be proud of her for taking a stand against racist behaviour and to be arguing with the punishment for starting this when if he hadn't made the comments it wouldn't have been necessary to 'talk' to him about it. And is the school wrong for punishing someone for calling out this behaviour?

OP posts:
Tomkirkman · 23/03/2023 07:59

rememberthis · 23/03/2023 07:58

@Tomkirkman
*
Your son heard a racist comment and took action. That’s not what happened here.*

Where did she say that her son took action?

He got angry and the teacher sided with him.

So some action took place, even if it was only showing his anger.

rememberthis · 23/03/2023 07:58

@Tomkirkman
*
Your son heard a racist comment and took action. That’s not what happened here.*

Where did she say that her son took action?

Greenfairydust · 23/03/2023 07:58

Has the other party been disciplined as well?

Because if they did use racist language and push your daughter twice then they should also be excluded.

I would be happy of both sides were spoken to and got equal punishments. As well as those ''threw punches''.

They all need to learn that racism is unacceptable but also that trying to resolve arguments with physical violence is not the answer.

BadNomad · 23/03/2023 07:55

It's the race equivalent of men speaking for women. Some women might appreciate it. Other women would rather speak for themselves and don't take kindly to men thinking they can fight their battles for them (because it comes from a sense of power and privilege).

Copasetic · 23/03/2023 07:55

Some kids love a bit of drama. You're daughter instigated it and got it. You see a hero. I see a trouble maker. I can't bear these girls. Having had two girls go through secondary and now a son going through secondary, you can see the type.

Ladybug14 · 23/03/2023 07:53

wasshereallywrong · 22/03/2023 20:46

This isn't the first time he has used the word, I agree she should have maybe spoken to a teacher and was a bit hot headed but she is 13 and doesn't always think, like any 13 year old!

But the boy saying N was hearsay

You dont go barging in, calling someone out, because of hearsay

That's called bullying

So yes, your daughter was wrong to start this and yes, she should be disciplined

Ketzele · 23/03/2023 07:53

This thread definitely stayed up till well past its bedtime.

Dibbydoos · 23/03/2023 07:52

She wasn't wrong at all.

She may have tackled it clumsily, but then she can be taught a better approach.

Excluding her for confronting racism is wrong. Go see the HT and if you get no where ask to speak to the chair of Governors. Educate the school tgey got this very vadly wrong.

Good luck.

BTW a very strong sense of injustice can be an indicator of neurodiversity. It's harder to spot in girls, so pls consider if your DD might be neurodiverse.

Tomkirkman · 23/03/2023 07:48

LuluLehman · 23/03/2023 07:39

Wasn’t she responding to her own personal sense of injustice, though? We all assume her actions were white saviourist but one questions why white people don’t see racism as offensive to all.

Which white people?

The Op clearly talks about how she feels the need to defend her friends.

What you have said here is typical white saviour thinking. Something awful happens to someone else and they step in because they personally find it offensive. Often disempowering the person it actually happened to. Many of us have asked Op why she felt the need to handle something that happened to someone else, in a way that she believed it should be dealt with.

no answer.

On the one hand you argue they have a mind of their own and choose their own actions. On the other hand argue that they couldn’t deal with it themselves and needed the dd to deal with it. Because her feelings were hurt by it.

Why did how she wanted deal with it and her emotions become the priority?

rememberthis · 23/03/2023 07:43

This!!

Daughter accused of instigating a serious incident. Is she really wrong?
KatherineJaneway · 23/03/2023 07:39

Your DD needs to be wary of others using her as it might possibly have been in this case. She did not hear the racist remarks but was told about them and went to confront him. For all we know, this boy upset those that told your DD about his remarks and they used her to get at him. To do their dirty work so to speak.

LuluLehman · 23/03/2023 07:39

Tomkirkman · 23/03/2023 07:17

I agree. They chose those actions.

But it does make me wonder why the dd thought they didn’t have minds of their own and couldn’t deal with in it themselves and needed her to deal with it in a way that escalated it.

Wasn’t she responding to her own personal sense of injustice, though? We all assume her actions were white saviourist but one questions why white people don’t see racism as offensive to all.

2bazookas · 23/03/2023 07:38

If he wasn't using the word at the time she confronted him, then yes she instigated an incident.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 23/03/2023 07:38

StayBased · 23/03/2023 07:33

I hope you don’t teach English. OP’s daughter didn’t even hear the boy she assailed saying anything racist.

Clearly doesn't teach history, either. History is littered with the bodies of entire groups and individuals murdered/exiled on the basis of 'did you hear what they did/said?'.

Tomkirkman · 23/03/2023 07:36

stampitout · 23/03/2023 07:26

She did well for calling out racism and school should be encouraging others to do the same.

My son is a gentle giant. He's literally the only black kid in his school. The only time he got angry at school was when he was called the N word. The Head Teacher said that he didn't blame him!

Please thank her for me!

She didn’t call out anything.

Your son heard a racist comment and took action. That’s not what happened here.

StayBased · 23/03/2023 07:33

JJ456 · 23/03/2023 07:31

As a teacher I can see why they did decide to punish her as the school likely has a zero tolerance policy on this sort of thing that they have to follow.

However as a person I’m really proud of your DD and you should be too! Hopefully knowing she did the right thing will help her get through the exclusion. I bet some of the teachers will go easy on her during it as well because of her actions which they’ll probably support!

I hope you don’t teach English. OP’s daughter didn’t even hear the boy she assailed saying anything racist.

JJ456 · 23/03/2023 07:31

As a teacher I can see why they did decide to punish her as the school likely has a zero tolerance policy on this sort of thing that they have to follow.

However as a person I’m really proud of your DD and you should be too! Hopefully knowing she did the right thing will help her get through the exclusion. I bet some of the teachers will go easy on her during it as well because of her actions which they’ll probably support!

Aprilx · 23/03/2023 07:28

You should no be proud of your daughter, it is no wonder she is a trouble maker when you condone her behaviour. She doesn’t even know for a fact that anything racist was said and who made her judge and jury anyway. It very much looks like she incited an attack on another child and she should be punished every bit as much as the others involved.

stampitout · 23/03/2023 07:26

She did well for calling out racism and school should be encouraging others to do the same.

My son is a gentle giant. He's literally the only black kid in his school. The only time he got angry at school was when he was called the N word. The Head Teacher said that he didn't blame him!

Please thank her for me!

StayBased · 23/03/2023 07:20

Phoebo · 23/03/2023 00:49

Hilarious, yes people pretend someone is being racist so they can bully them Hmm Gosh, now I've heard it all!

Were you never at school? Fabricating reasons to be offended was a classic bullying tactic at mine. One of the reasons I’ll never trust people like that. Good on the leadership of OP’s daughter’s school for having the gumption to Stand up to it and not losing their critical thinking when someone screeches “racism”.

TenTwentyAtCheltenhamSandwich · 23/03/2023 07:19

You can’t knock someone for standing up & fighting for what they believe in. That kid was me years ago. It appears that your daughter’s been made a scapegoat in all of this. I’d be asking questions as to why the racist kid never been pulled up on his behavior.

LuluLehman · 23/03/2023 07:19

sugarspices · 22/03/2023 22:39

@Eyerollcentral I do agree that she didn't deal with what she was told appropriately and shouldn't have confronted the boy, however I do not agree that therefore anything that happens after that point is her fault. Every person in that situation had a decision to make about their own actions, and they all decided poorly.

You've said previously that this isn't a feminist issue however your repeated use of the word "mouth" to describe OPs daughter is telling.

You also said that she was lucky not to be punched for her intervention. Women (or people generally) should be empowered to use their words and are not "lucky" not be physically attacked as a result. It is a basic expectation to be able to express yourself without being on the receiving end of violence.

You have also repeatedly sought to blame her for every dimension of this situation. It seems that you just don't like it that OPs daughter has a lot to say, which is ironic considering how much you like to add your voice to matters.

This!

And all the posts calling her a “gobshite” etc are so offensive. Insults like that are intended to silence women and black people who speak up.

Tomkirkman · 23/03/2023 07:17

LuluLehman · 23/03/2023 07:14

I wonder why many of you seem to think that the two black boys don’t have minds of their own. They made a decision to act as they did. Why do you (and the teachers?) assume that they were being controlled by the white girl?

I agree. They chose those actions.

But it does make me wonder why the dd thought they didn’t have minds of their own and couldn’t deal with in it themselves and needed her to deal with it in a way that escalated it.

LuluLehman · 23/03/2023 07:14

Eyerollcentral · 23/03/2023 00:58

What do you think about a white child winding up two black boys to do the punching whilst scuttling off saying I don’t want to fight you to the alleged racist?

I wonder why many of you seem to think that the two black boys don’t have minds of their own. They made a decision to act as they did. Why do you (and the teachers?) assume that they were being controlled by the white girl?

LuluLehman · 23/03/2023 07:06

sashh · 23/03/2023 02:10

DD had the right motives but her actions were wrong.

She should have taken it to a teacher.

I've no reason to think what I am about to type next happened, just a pause for thought and maybe something others might want to discuss with their teens.

There is a 'thing' going around at the moment where some children sell an 'N word pass' to their friends, this allows the friend to use that word for a day / week.

It's not always an N word, other racial slurs are also 'sold'.

Why would any child want to buy such a thing? Why would a child sell it? Schools should be promoting anti racism, as should parents.

Dd at least has attempted to stand up for something. It is not uncommon for allies of anti racism to become isolated and made into targets themselves. That is presumably why many people choose not to stand up to racists. I would look into the schools’ claims and I wouldn’t take anything they say at face value until I’d examined the facts for myself. Institutional racism has many invidious facets.