Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughter accused of instigating a serious incident. Is she really wrong?

738 replies

wasshereallywrong · 22/03/2023 20:37

I have name changed for this to not link to previous threads as this is outing and I have told people in real life.

I am going to preface this be saying my DD 13 is a gobby little sod so I know she can be annoying and hasn't got the best school record but she has no time for injustice which has led to conflict for her in the past but to todays incident...

My DD has several black friends (we come from a very white area). She was told today that one lad was going around using the N word. This isn't the first time and so she took it upon herself to confront him and tell him it isn't right and it is racist. Like I say she is gobby so I imagine she was heated when she said it. He pushed her away and told her to leave him alone, everyone gathered around and she said she wasn't going to fight and went to move away, he pushed her again and ran off. Two of her friends then caught up with the lad and several punches were thrown. I am not saying the fight was acceptable. It was 2 on 1 and he was hurt and fighting is never ok.

My DD has now been given a day of internal exclusion because she initiated a serious incident. Did she though or did she call out unacceptable racism? Was it not the lad who was using the n word the person who instigated it? I have said that she has to accept that she was wrong to get involved in something that wasn't to do with her but was she wrong? If people don't call out racist behaviour how is it stopped? I am going to be speaking to the head teacher tomorrow as I missed his call today but AIBU to be proud of her for taking a stand against racist behaviour and to be arguing with the punishment for starting this when if he hadn't made the comments it wouldn't have been necessary to 'talk' to him about it. And is the school wrong for punishing someone for calling out this behaviour?

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 23/03/2023 09:04

Dotjones · 23/03/2023 08:48

No, I disagree. If children sort it out amongst themselves the school has no record and no knowledge that its pupils are using racist language. Leave it to the adults to investigate and deal with things properly.

As this incident clearly shows, vigilante justice often leads to violence.

Absolutely, and what if someone a lot more aggressive and violent hears the daughter's tale and decides its true and decides to enact their own violence on this child? According to some here that's OK because of what's basically gossip!

AllOfThemWitches · 23/03/2023 09:01

Hoppinggreen · 23/03/2023 08:58

Not true.
Even if I believed the daughters version of events I still think she acted badly

Well it is true, your whole 'even if I believed her' thing clearly suggests as much.

AllOfThemWitches · 23/03/2023 09:00

Jonei · 23/03/2023 08:56

The truth is, the op and her daughter dont know the truth.

I'm inclined to think if a kid is capable of violence towards girls, he's capable of being a racist little shit. I mean, we all knew a boy like this in school.

Hoppinggreen · 23/03/2023 08:58

AllOfThemWitches · 23/03/2023 08:54

The problem here is that posters have decided OP/her daughter is lying. Funny how some posts are taken at face value and others aren't.

Not true.
Even if I believed the daughters version of events I still think she acted badly

Jonei · 23/03/2023 08:56

AllOfThemWitches · 23/03/2023 08:54

The problem here is that posters have decided OP/her daughter is lying. Funny how some posts are taken at face value and others aren't.

The truth is, the op and her daughter dont know the truth.

AllOfThemWitches · 23/03/2023 08:54

The problem here is that posters have decided OP/her daughter is lying. Funny how some posts are taken at face value and others aren't.

Jonei · 23/03/2023 08:53

Is it really ok to go and accuse someone of racism when there is no actual evidence? Just based on hearsay? And those actions then cause another child gets injured because of it? To the adults here cheering that behaviour on?

Is that really where we're at now?

How would you feel if your child had been accused and subsequently attacked? Based on some kangaroo court set up?

Is that really ok? Do some of you even know the difference between right and wrong? Is the the role model you want to be for your children?

Mothership4two · 23/03/2023 08:49

Lilyrose84 · 23/03/2023 08:40

I would suspect your daughter's previous school record / antics have led the school to come to this conclusion. If it is as you say it is, then your daughter is not in the wrong. The instigator is the boy who used that awful language.

How can the OP say if it is as you say it is? She wasn't there! All she has to go on is a 13 year old's version of why she is being excluded which she seems to 100% believe (along with quite a lot of posters on here).

Hoppinggreen · 23/03/2023 08:48

TenTwentyAtCheltenhamSandwich · 23/03/2023 07:19

You can’t knock someone for standing up & fighting for what they believe in. That kid was me years ago. It appears that your daughter’s been made a scapegoat in all of this. I’d be asking questions as to why the racist kid never been pulled up on his behavior.

Maybe because there is no evidence he is racist?
OPs daughter was reacting to something she was told he said.
Perhaps he is racist and if he is heard to use this word he should be told it’s not acceptable and then reported to a teacher.
OPs daughter acted as judge and jury here

Dotjones · 23/03/2023 08:48

JackHackettsMac · 23/03/2023 08:45

Your daughter sounds like me at that age and I’m an adult in my fifties and still have the same personality traits.

As far as I’m concerned, if you think there’s an issue you deal with it by speaking directly to the other person and having a conversation. Children are just as entitled to raise difficult issues amongst their peers without having adults hovering to police their interactions. I’d also firmly point out that she isn’t responsible for the actions of the other students who decided to start a physical fight.

No, I disagree. If children sort it out amongst themselves the school has no record and no knowledge that its pupils are using racist language. Leave it to the adults to investigate and deal with things properly.

As this incident clearly shows, vigilante justice often leads to violence.

Dotjones · 23/03/2023 08:46

Yes, she was wrong and deserves to be punished. Her actions led to a child being assaulted. She should have spoken to a teacher and left it with them to investigate. Regardless of whether the boy actually said it or not, children cannot be allowed to sort these things out amongst themselves. Either he said it, in which case the school need to address it properly, or he didn't in which case a group of thugs picked a fight with someone for no reason.

JackHackettsMac · 23/03/2023 08:45

Your daughter sounds like me at that age and I’m an adult in my fifties and still have the same personality traits.

As far as I’m concerned, if you think there’s an issue you deal with it by speaking directly to the other person and having a conversation. Children are just as entitled to raise difficult issues amongst their peers without having adults hovering to police their interactions. I’d also firmly point out that she isn’t responsible for the actions of the other students who decided to start a physical fight.

Iyjd · 23/03/2023 08:44

Oysterbabe · 22/03/2023 20:41

I think that yabu. She was involved in the whole thing. The school can't encourage vigilante justice, she should have spoken to a teacher about him.

I’m a teacher and there is very little we can do if we don’t hear it.
Someone else has said it, she’s turned down a fight, someone else has had a fight. Why is she in trouble?

SorryButThatsAFact · 23/03/2023 08:44

Terrible take. You made this about sexism when it's clearly 'girl with previous history of behaviour and attitude problems instigates violent incident based on hearsay.' If she hadn't have caused a confrontation, it wouldn't have happened. End of.

Lilyrose84 · 23/03/2023 08:40

I would suspect your daughter's previous school record / antics have led the school to come to this conclusion. If it is as you say it is, then your daughter is not in the wrong. The instigator is the boy who used that awful language.

Ohdofuckofdear · 23/03/2023 08:39

Good for her,I'm on your Daughter's side!

I stood up against crap like that at school when I was a similar age and younger and I'm still friends with those I stood up for(and I'm nearly 48)and they've never forgotten about the arseholes who treated them like that and they've never forgotten about the one who stood up for them and stood with them.

If you're Daughter didn't hit him, didn't push him and didn't incite other students to hit him then I don't believe she should be getting punished! The boy that thinks its acceptable to be racist is the one who should be dealt with harshly!

AllOfThemWitches · 23/03/2023 08:38

ReadersD1gest · 22/03/2023 23:23

Nobody has done any such thing.

Don't be silly

SorryButThatsAFact · 23/03/2023 08:36

As a WOC, I'm appalled by this take. You're condoning a serious incident based on nothing more than hearsay.

BadNomad · 23/03/2023 08:29

LuluLehman · 23/03/2023 08:16

Not necessarily. If we believe in anti racism then it is also the responsibility of non black people to call out anti black racism - the burden doesn’t rest with black people alone.

I think of white saviourism as a way of drawing attention to whiteness (white superiority) and is therefore not anti racist. I assume this girl is genuine but who knows?

I apologise in advance for using such “black and white” language but am open to being corrected if I should be using other terms.

The girl didn't even hear any racist comments. She just went off on one based on hearsay because she's the type of person who likes to hear her own voice. We all know someone like that. Full of opinions and no facts. She wasn't "calling out racism". She didn't witness any racism to call out. She just wanted to act like Billy Big Balls in front of her friends.

Fukuraptor · 23/03/2023 08:24

They are all young and learning how to behave and how their actions can have consequences that they did not foresee.

I don't think it's that your daughter was the person most in the wrong here - so much as she should be encouraged to think about what she was trying to achieve by her actions, what the actual result was and whether there was a course of action that would have been more effective/sensible in light of that.

Standing up for your friends is an understandable instinct and a good impulse. I don't think she is responsible for the choices the other three boys made and it was maybe difficult for her to think about how everyone would respond to her actions. But her choices did escalate the conflict rather than de-escalate it and I can understand why the school want her to learn that seeking people out to confront them in public about something they might have said isn't helpful.

She wanted this boy to learn that racism is wrong. And it is. But I worry that will not be the message he takes away from the day's events. It needed careful handling by the school.

LuluLehman · 23/03/2023 08:21

LuluLehman · 23/03/2023 08:16

Not necessarily. If we believe in anti racism then it is also the responsibility of non black people to call out anti black racism - the burden doesn’t rest with black people alone.

I think of white saviourism as a way of drawing attention to whiteness (white superiority) and is therefore not anti racist. I assume this girl is genuine but who knows?

I apologise in advance for using such “black and white” language but am open to being corrected if I should be using other terms.

If men see their peers exhibiting sexist behaviour then I think they should call it out.

There have been so many times in my own life when I have been the only poc in a workplace and have had to deal with racism and sexism on my own. It takes a mental and physical toll. I would have loved for at least one person to stand with me. It would have been such a relief.

Hoppinggreen · 23/03/2023 08:19

Lamelie · 22/03/2023 20:43

Very similar incident happened to one of my dcs. He’d put up a poster arranging a meeting about an extremely problematic x event arranged by the school and was told I would be called. He said ‘she’s waiting for you call as she has serious concerns about x at school’
They never called 🥹

That’s not similar. It was a poster and No violence was involved

Howdoyoulikeyoureggsinthemorning · 23/03/2023 08:18

To your question, I don't think your daughter has done something that warrants an exclusion, if her version of events matches the truth. That said, she definitely hasn't handled it in the best way.

Looking at the wider picture though, some things come up in your posts that might be worth reflecting on. You call her "gobby" a few times, and you say you feel "proud" of her - both of these are examples of how you might be (albeit unknowingly) encouraging her behaviour, rather than helping her become a calm, reasonable adult who doesn't end up in situations like these. For example - she doesn't have to be gobby. But a mentality of "that's just the way she is", rather than active encouragement to be less confrontational, will make her believe nothing can be changed.

Not trying to criticize, just saying that your choice of words in how you express your judgement of these things is super important to her development. Especially at 13.

LuluLehman · 23/03/2023 08:16

BadNomad · 23/03/2023 07:55

It's the race equivalent of men speaking for women. Some women might appreciate it. Other women would rather speak for themselves and don't take kindly to men thinking they can fight their battles for them (because it comes from a sense of power and privilege).

Not necessarily. If we believe in anti racism then it is also the responsibility of non black people to call out anti black racism - the burden doesn’t rest with black people alone.

I think of white saviourism as a way of drawing attention to whiteness (white superiority) and is therefore not anti racist. I assume this girl is genuine but who knows?

I apologise in advance for using such “black and white” language but am open to being corrected if I should be using other terms.

Newmumatlast · 23/03/2023 08:14

cantstopthefeeling · 22/03/2023 20:54

Seriously, she called out racist language and said it wasn't right. He pushed her, she went to go away and he pushed her again. If what the OP says is right she didn't charge in with violence. His behaviour, a boy being told by a girl that what he said wasn't right, started a violent response, towards a girl. I'm sorry but she has done the right thing. Yes she can speak to teachers and she should do that as well but if we want to change how language is used whether it is racist, homophobic or misogynistic then kids calling it out and showing up poor behaviour is how we do it. He had the opportunity to say he didn't say it or walk away, he didn't...he pushed a girl TWICE, once after she walked away saying she wasn't going to fight. He upped the violence not her. Calling out bad language is not violent, it's the only way to stop it being accepted.

Agree with this.

The only slight difference would be depending on the way she said it. If she was aggressive and used abusive language in saying what she said, cornered him prompting the push away or anything like that then she escalated things. But if it is as she says it went, then no he had plenty of opportunity to explain the situation and didnt need to push etc.

OP I would be cautious that with young teens there's often more to it that they say and I know when I was at school I saw situations with the gobby kids where they would 'passionately' go for someone verbally until there was a physical reaction.