Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU baby shower gift request

92 replies

Jeffsmama · 22/03/2023 19:41

DPs brother and partner are expecting a baby. We were not sent the Amazon baby gift wish list to choose a gift/ gifts. MIL (DPs mum who has very kindly bought DPs brother and partner a pushchair > £1k) asked us to purchase a baby monitor @ £190 and seemed quite put out when we declined and firmly said we would happily purchase a gift of our choosing in our price range.

We can afford to buy the baby monitor but don’t feel it’s our obligation to buy something on the more expensive side for the baby/ parents - they have chosen to have a baby and we don’t feel it’s our responsibility to meet their expectations of gifting. Should we buy the baby monitor or stick to our guns?

OP posts:
Anotherturnipforthebooks · 22/03/2023 20:52

@Jeffsmama

Are they likely to struggle with money once the baby arrives?

Even if they are, I wouldn't agree that you should buy a £190 monitor (it's totally unnecessary) but it might explain why the MIL is trying to dictate what you buy.

Rainsdropskeepfalling · 22/03/2023 20:51

@inky1991 you're probably right. I didn't buy anything brand new as that way madness lies IMO and I had a hand me down stroller - it did my two kids, my cousin's two kids before hand and it's currently on the 4th baby since I handed it on. We didn't have a big house so didn't use a baby monitor when they were small but did when they were a bit bigger so we'd leave them in the car asleep while we'd go into the house for a cuppa

whatthebejesus · 22/03/2023 20:51

Lol @ £190 on a monitor 😂😂.
Yanbu. There is no need for that amount of money to be spent. Fwiw we recently had a new baby niece. We bought 2 babygrows (nice ones!) some chocolate and a £50 just eat voucher for the new parents.

Parents can buy baby monitors themselves or grandma to be can cough up!

Jeffsmama · 22/03/2023 20:48

ElonsMusky · 22/03/2023 20:19

Are you and your brother on the same page? If he's with you on this then I don't see the issue.

Personally, if my brother was having a baby I'd happily and enthusiastically buy the monitor and then a bunch of other stuff. If my husband had a problem with that I'd be mad.

If it was YOUR sibling having a baby, would you still think the monitor too spendy?

Partner and I are on the same page - we think there is a limit on gifting as it’s their choice to have a baby. We’re not ruling out being involved as auntie and uncle as much as we can be (we are going to set
up an investment account for baby for birthdays and Christmas so when 18 they have a nest egg to help them). That said I had a friend who fell pregnant in her teenage years and I did help financially as I knew she was struggling (I lived at home with a full time job so could afford to and she was a long term friend who I thought really needed the help)!

OP posts:
AsWeWereish · 22/03/2023 20:46

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 22/03/2023 19:49

What?! The clue is in the name - gift. It's a no-strings present, not an obligation. Doubtless you'll be buying other stuff as your DN gets older. I usually buy first-time parents a room thermometer for where the baby sleeps. Not expensive and something they often haven't thought of and do appreciate.

That's a really good gift!

kirsty2023 · 22/03/2023 20:44

That's crap u can get a pram with car seat and carry cot for under that it's just people are fussy and want all things highend

inky1991 · 22/03/2023 20:40

Rainsdropskeepfalling · 22/03/2023 20:24

Who the f### spends £1000 on a pushchair? I bought a car that cost less than that.

And £190 for a baby monitor is crazy too.

To be fair, that is what travel systems cost these days. I imagine it wouldn't just be a pushchair, it would be a carry cot, car seat, isofix base and some litre extras. You'd be hard pushed to find all that for under £800. I know - cause I tried!

Upwiththelark76 · 22/03/2023 20:39

TomatoSandwiches · 22/03/2023 19:48

Baby showers are the epitome of naff and tacky and I wouldn't be seen dead at one. I'd wait until the baby is here and pop a voucher in a card when you visit them.

Agree 100%
baby showers are just cringey . Do not ‘buy into it ‘

jigsaw234 · 22/03/2023 20:36

My go-to gift for a new baby is a selection of books that they can read to the child over the next 2-3 years. most of what they get will be grown out of very quickly

AwayThenBack · 22/03/2023 20:36

I don’t really like baby showers at all and think a £190 monitor is pretty overpriced. However, in terms of “expensive gifts” it sort of was the norm in our family for the first baby. My DP bought the pram system (and then wrapped gifts for me and baby) and my DS bought our first car seat. She fell pregnant 4 months later so we reciprocate and got her her car seat. My cousins also all got quite high value gifts for their first babies from their immediate families (parents and siblings) things like bedroom furniture, cots, car seats, prams etc.

Oddly we do not ever buy high cost gifts for other occasions ever and no lists but for first babies this was the norm. Not sure why really. So just another perspective if your parents family is similar way inclined. Obviously no you shouldn’t be told what to bug or be expected to give a high value item (and I’d never spend that on a monitor!!)

AnyBenny · 22/03/2023 20:32

ElonsMusky · 22/03/2023 20:19

Are you and your brother on the same page? If he's with you on this then I don't see the issue.

Personally, if my brother was having a baby I'd happily and enthusiastically buy the monitor and then a bunch of other stuff. If my husband had a problem with that I'd be mad.

If it was YOUR sibling having a baby, would you still think the monitor too spendy?

Personally I absolutely wouldn’t!! I’ve never spent anything like £190 on a baby present for anyone, although I’m in London professional circles so fairly well off (and as others have said, £190 for a baby monitor is completely ludicrous anyway).
Can’t wait to find out what the MIL has asked everyone else to buy though… 🍿

Daisybee6 · 22/03/2023 20:27

Oh god baby showers have wishlists now? 💀

Missing the point completely but I didn't have £190 to spend on a monitor for my own baby let alone someone else's.

Monstermoomoo · 22/03/2023 20:25

I would do the same as you - buy something off the gift list within the budget you find appropriate. If your budget is £200, get the monitor. If it isn't, get something else. I mean, I love my siblings but would never spend that much on them for any reason 😅

My SIL is like that though. Whenever we ask what their kids want for their birthdays we get sent the exact item to buy... It's never less than £60, usually more around £80, which is genuinely more than we'd spend on any one gift for our own kids.

Rainsdropskeepfalling · 22/03/2023 20:24

Who the f### spends £1000 on a pushchair? I bought a car that cost less than that.

And £190 for a baby monitor is crazy too.

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 22/03/2023 20:22

@ElonsMusky

Fair point but would you be ok with your mother telling you what to buy him?

That seems odd to me but then my family don't have high expectations for gifts.

Fluffodils · 22/03/2023 20:21

Bonkers.

Just buy a cute outfit or something.

What a weird thing for her to do.

Snugglemonkey · 22/03/2023 20:20

Twizbe · 22/03/2023 19:50

No way.

I was brought up that it was unlucky to celebrate a baby before it was born. I hate baby showers.

Stick to your guns and gift what you want to, when you want to.

Me too. I would never have had a baby shower. Mortifying.

kirsty2023 · 22/03/2023 20:20

Jeffsmama · 22/03/2023 19:41

DPs brother and partner are expecting a baby. We were not sent the Amazon baby gift wish list to choose a gift/ gifts. MIL (DPs mum who has very kindly bought DPs brother and partner a pushchair > £1k) asked us to purchase a baby monitor @ £190 and seemed quite put out when we declined and firmly said we would happily purchase a gift of our choosing in our price range.

We can afford to buy the baby monitor but don’t feel it’s our obligation to buy something on the more expensive side for the baby/ parents - they have chosen to have a baby and we don’t feel it’s our responsibility to meet their expectations of gifting. Should we buy the baby monitor or stick to our guns?

I don't do baby showers waste of time and money I always think if ur having a baby them buy what u need it's not for other people to buy it a simply gift after baby is born is fine I've had 5 kids and never had a baby shower for any and told family if they wanted to get something for baby then to make it small I would tell MIL to buy the baby monitor herself it's not ur job to buy them

ElonsMusky · 22/03/2023 20:19

Are you and your brother on the same page? If he's with you on this then I don't see the issue.

Personally, if my brother was having a baby I'd happily and enthusiastically buy the monitor and then a bunch of other stuff. If my husband had a problem with that I'd be mad.

If it was YOUR sibling having a baby, would you still think the monitor too spendy?

sanityisamyth · 22/03/2023 20:14

TomatoSandwiches · 22/03/2023 19:48

Baby showers are the epitome of naff and tacky and I wouldn't be seen dead at one. I'd wait until the baby is here and pop a voucher in a card when you visit them.

This with bells on.

strawberry2017 · 22/03/2023 20:14

The only way I would spend that much money on someone is if I've chosen to myself! Not because it's expected!

Shinyandnew1 · 22/03/2023 20:13

Your MIL is taking the piss!

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 22/03/2023 20:11

SquigglePigs · 22/03/2023 20:06

YAdefNBU. When we had DD my SIL bought some cute outfits and a cuddly - exactly what an auntie should be buying IMO.

The only time I'd say otherwise is if the parents-to-be were really struggling for money and your family was particularly well off then it would be a kindness to buy them something on the more expensive side that they really needed. You can get a decent baby monitor for £40-70 though so even then there's no need for £190 monitor!

I agree with this. The only time I would consider spending that kind of money is if the parents were struggling financially, but in that case I'd be looking to buy a decent essential item, not a £190 baby monitor.

Jeffsmama · 22/03/2023 20:10

What a relief! Glad we have the same thoughts and views. We don’t have children (we have a dog, irrelevant but explains the user name!) and this is the first baby in the family so we are really unsure of what the expectation is. MIL is very excited as this is the first grandchild and is planning the shower with DPs brothers partners mum (grandchild’s other grandma)!

OP posts:
SquigglePigs · 22/03/2023 20:06

YAdefNBU. When we had DD my SIL bought some cute outfits and a cuddly - exactly what an auntie should be buying IMO.

The only time I'd say otherwise is if the parents-to-be were really struggling for money and your family was particularly well off then it would be a kindness to buy them something on the more expensive side that they really needed. You can get a decent baby monitor for £40-70 though so even then there's no need for £190 monitor!