Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU baby shower gift request

92 replies

Jeffsmama · 22/03/2023 19:41

DPs brother and partner are expecting a baby. We were not sent the Amazon baby gift wish list to choose a gift/ gifts. MIL (DPs mum who has very kindly bought DPs brother and partner a pushchair > £1k) asked us to purchase a baby monitor @ £190 and seemed quite put out when we declined and firmly said we would happily purchase a gift of our choosing in our price range.

We can afford to buy the baby monitor but don’t feel it’s our obligation to buy something on the more expensive side for the baby/ parents - they have chosen to have a baby and we don’t feel it’s our responsibility to meet their expectations of gifting. Should we buy the baby monitor or stick to our guns?

OP posts:
Eyerollcentral · 22/03/2023 23:00

Jeffsmama · 22/03/2023 19:41

DPs brother and partner are expecting a baby. We were not sent the Amazon baby gift wish list to choose a gift/ gifts. MIL (DPs mum who has very kindly bought DPs brother and partner a pushchair > £1k) asked us to purchase a baby monitor @ £190 and seemed quite put out when we declined and firmly said we would happily purchase a gift of our choosing in our price range.

We can afford to buy the baby monitor but don’t feel it’s our obligation to buy something on the more expensive side for the baby/ parents - they have chosen to have a baby and we don’t feel it’s our responsibility to meet their expectations of gifting. Should we buy the baby monitor or stick to our guns?

Sorry but as you can afford it and there are no other children I think it’s really tight of you. I don’t think that is a particularly extravagant present for your nephew. There’s something about your wording that says it’s not really about the cost it’s that you resent them having a baby in some way. You certainly don’t seem to be someone who sees this baby as part of your partner’s family, which the baby is. The baby is your partner’s nephew not just your partner’s brother’s son. You do come across coldly sorry.

lv884 · 22/03/2023 22:37

YANBU. £190 is an extremely generous amount and probably more like four or five times as much as one might spend on a niece or nephew when they’re born. Fair enough if you spend more or less than this - point remains.

The growing cost of occasions (especially things like hen parties) is starting to make me dread them slightly. Even kids’ parties are no longer tea parties at home, with a few cousins and close friends and a homemade cake. We got invited to these Kardashian style kids’ parties in venues with balloon arches before we even had kids…

Onthenosecco · 22/03/2023 22:29

Sparkleshine21 · 22/03/2023 22:26

I think baby showers are pretty tasteless tbh, and grabby. I didn’t have one!

It depends on whether gifts are expected; I guess. For me, it was about celebrating our rainbow baby. We already had what we needed!

Onthenosecco · 22/03/2023 22:28

LoveBluey · 22/03/2023 21:40

I saw a baby bank charity post on social media that they'd had a big donation from someone who had a baby shower and asked all of their guests to buy something for the baby bank instead of a gift. It instantly made me think of Mumsnet and how that would be the only acceptable type of baby shower!

That’s a great idea!

I had two baby showers for my first pregnancy - one organised as a surprise by a friend, where people brought small token gifts (think a baby grow/towel etc) and one organised by my parents where people were specifically asked not to bring gifts (although some close family members gave us sentimental but low value gifts like hand-me-down baby jewellery)

I had no baby showery got my second but would have loved to celebrate my pregnancy and donate to the baby bank!

Sparkleshine21 · 22/03/2023 22:26

I think baby showers are pretty tasteless tbh, and grabby. I didn’t have one!

TallTrees78 · 22/03/2023 22:16

I spent several hundred pounds for my siblings first child as it was the first baby in the family for decades, I love my sibling dearly, they were struggling for money, and I wasn't at the time. It was my choice though and they didn't ask. 2nd baby they had, I only spent £25 as my financial position had changed. They were still very happy with the cheaper gift though.

breakfastbagel · 22/03/2023 22:12

I think MIL being put out is unreasonable, but it's ok that she suggested a gift. Obviously everyone has their own financial limits but it's really nice to be able to help out a new family if you're able to, especially if they're close relatives. It doesn't mean they can't afford it themselves, it's just a kind gesture.

MyLoveIsYourLove0xO · 22/03/2023 22:05

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 22/03/2023 20:52

@whatthebejesus

We bought 2 babygrows (nice ones!) some chocolate and a £50 just eat voucher for the new parents.

The perfect new baby gift!

That's a great gift!

Nosleepforthismum · 22/03/2023 22:04

No, your MIL is being silly. Also you save money for your own lives and own kids. Much as I love my nieces and wish to spoil them when I see them, I don’t set aside money for them for when they turn 18. I would be careful of starting something you can’t keep up with further nieces/nephews or the arrival of your own kids.

Most siblings buy a cute outfit/teddy for new babies in the family which is plenty in my opinion. I think most couples also prepare/save for at least nine months for the basics they will need for their baby. It would be very weird to rely on your siblings to pay for some of the big ticket items and I don’t know anyone in real life like this.

Mariposista · 22/03/2023 21:54

sanityisamyth · 22/03/2023 20:14

This with bells on.

Totally agree

Chias · 22/03/2023 21:50

This is really up to your DP. It will be his brother and mother who you will be upsetting.

LoveBluey · 22/03/2023 21:40

I saw a baby bank charity post on social media that they'd had a big donation from someone who had a baby shower and asked all of their guests to buy something for the baby bank instead of a gift. It instantly made me think of Mumsnet and how that would be the only acceptable type of baby shower!

MrsKeats · 22/03/2023 21:29

Is literally everything about money now?
So grim.

CraneBoysMysteries · 22/03/2023 21:17

In the fence and ON the fence 😆

CraneBoysMysteries · 22/03/2023 21:17

Sort of in the fence here

All the posters calling your BIL and SIL grabby are unfair I think. Baby showers (whatever you think of them) are not uncommon and many people put gift lists together to stop getting lots of the same thing

It's entirely your choice what you spend but it sounds like MIL organised the baby shower and MIL suggested the gift. MIL is also the one 'put out' so I don't think your poor BIL and SIL are unreasonable or grabby at all

You also say several times 'it's their choice to have a baby' and imply you shouldn't have to financially pay for expensive things. While that's right, it's a bit of an extreme way to look at what is the first baby on DPs side. Are you looking forward to being an Aunty?

Your MIL is just a bit over excited I think.

Luredbyapomegranate · 22/03/2023 21:16

Dear God stick to your guns.

What a time to be alive..

JenniferBarkley · 22/03/2023 21:10

kirsty2023 · 22/03/2023 21:07

I'm sorry but if u plan on having a baby make sure you can pay for the baby it's not down to family to buy stuff family can support by helping with cooking and stuff but buying big main items for baby is down to them end of sorry

In fairness I think there's a huge difference between

"I'm going to have a baby even though I can't afford it, my family will pick up the bill"

And,

"How exciting that I'm getting a new grandchild, I wonder if son 1 has decided what to get son 2 for the baby yet, I wonder if they'd like to buy the monitor"

We don't know yet which it is.

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 22/03/2023 21:09

@kirsty2023

I don't know why you're saying sorry to me, it's not my baby!

kirsty2023 · 22/03/2023 21:07

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 22/03/2023 21:01

@kirsty2023

In general terms I agree with that but money being tight enough that you appreciate some help from family for a couple of years isn't the same as not being able to afford to support a baby at all.

But I do agree that no one should expect their family to pay for this stuff, I just wondered why the MIL might be suggesting it.

I'm sorry but if u plan on having a baby make sure you can pay for the baby it's not down to family to buy stuff family can support by helping with cooking and stuff but buying big main items for baby is down to them end of sorry

ThisIsWednesday · 22/03/2023 21:01

This would be a HELL NO! How cheeky.

It reminds me of when my neighbour's son was having their first grandchild and the DIL insisted that everything bought for the baby must be approved by them and must be purchased from one of two overpriced baby boutiques she liked. She wanted a crib for example. Let's call it the Mama and Papas XYZ. In the boutique it was £260 but in Argos the very same Mama and Papas XYZ was on sale for £140. She wouldn't accept the Argos one despite it being the exact same item. Not a knock off, not a similar model, not the same one but different colour, it was the exact same one. They had to buy it from the boutique and they did not do non-faulty returns either so it wasn't for the cash or credit.

What was really funny was that the DIL and DS were skint. They lived in a £300ish pcm Council house, barely made the rent and couldn't even afford groceries most weeks. When my neighbours offered to help on occasion, they turned their noses up at the co-op detergents and Aldi food items stating that they couldn't possibly use those and demanding they buy this and that name brand stuff. My neighbours were disabled and retired living on the breadline themselves. One week they bought a few bits and when they left, DIL called and said, "Did you forget something? There's no formula tins in these bags!"

CF stories when it comes to baby gifts always remind me of those two. Sad for the neighbours at the time but Christ, the stories were entertaining!

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 22/03/2023 21:01

@kirsty2023

In general terms I agree with that but money being tight enough that you appreciate some help from family for a couple of years isn't the same as not being able to afford to support a baby at all.

But I do agree that no one should expect their family to pay for this stuff, I just wondered why the MIL might be suggesting it.

JenniferBarkley · 22/03/2023 20:55

I'm going to go against the grain - a little - here.

First, as a PP pointed out, it was MIL that asked, so don't hold that against BIL.

On both sides of our family, the siblings have bought bigger gifts than they would for friends - we bought my sibling a Tripp Trapp chair when they were expecting their first. No obligation on anyone, just the way it's done. It may well be that MIL was genuinely surprised that you weren't giving a generous gift.

Provided it's dropped by MIL and BIL, I'd forget all about it and move on.

kirsty2023 · 22/03/2023 20:54

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 22/03/2023 20:52

@Jeffsmama

Are they likely to struggle with money once the baby arrives?

Even if they are, I wouldn't agree that you should buy a £190 monitor (it's totally unnecessary) but it might explain why the MIL is trying to dictate what you buy.

If they are short for money then don't have a baby it's as simply as that if u can't afford a baby don't have one

Luckyluv · 22/03/2023 20:53

You say you can afford it, if you couldn't that's different but.... here goes

All my siblings/spouses, Grandparents, Parents put in big money when we welcomed our kid. There are other Grandkids in the family too - and it's all been the same.

No one in my family is struggling for money per se, I.e no one wouldn't have been able to buy their child everything they need. But when a child is born into the family it's part of the wider family and I wouldn't blink at buying a £200 monitor.

I'd be fully wanting to spend that sort of money so I'd be asking the parents - what can we get? How about £250 John Lewis vouchers or is there something you specifically need?

Baby showers are naff though as are gift lists.

So I guess I'm asking - are you annoyed about spending the money, or was it the expectation that you could simply be tossed an item to buy and told to get to it? Rather than being the people who approached and asked the parents-to-be - because I completely understand why you'd be miffed at that, it does come across entitled and I would be resentful too!

I'm tired not sure if my post makes sense, haha. But hopefully you see what I mean.

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 22/03/2023 20:52

@whatthebejesus

We bought 2 babygrows (nice ones!) some chocolate and a £50 just eat voucher for the new parents.

The perfect new baby gift!

Swipe left for the next trending thread