Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a bit resentful of sister

38 replies

Kay286 · 22/03/2023 15:50

My parents are comfortably well off not rolling in it but not struggling. Enough to enjoy a very good lifestyle.
There is me and one sibling.
She has not done so well in life partly as has made poor life choices and partly due to mh issues - my mum ALWAYS bails her out financially, pays for holidays , meals out car repairs etc.
Financially I’m significantly better off than her and don’t need support.
My sister has a 4 year old kid and I have a 10 year old son.
To be clear my parents have treated us in the past with holidays meals out too so not tight.

However when they visit us my mum hard balls my what I will pay for towards them visiting, ! (We live far away to there is significant cost to visit and we don’t sit in we always plan nice things) and also brings my niece along and my mum is paying for them every time .
My parents gifted them 30k equity from a house and when my mum has spoken about her will she has said leaving this amount to my niece etc as she will need it as sister is basically useless. (No mention of my kid) just me sister and niece .

I understand it’s their money to do as they please but I can’t help really a bit resentful that because I have done well for myself I always being asked to cough up money whilst my sister has it thrown at her. I think the bit which hurts the most is putting money aside for my
niece but no mention of my kid because they won’t need it the same.
Also when visiting us how much will I pay for this and that but knowing my mum is paying for niece (she is closer to them as live much closer aswell) it not because they can’t afford either but I feel like as they no I can afford it also like to squeeze me !
When visiting it’s always scheduled around when niece can come along too during school holidays and always don’t want them to miss out - sometimes that’s hard as it’s like can’t you just prioritise seeing your grandchild that you don’t get to see every week ?!! They take niece on multiple holidays alone every year aswell.

unsure if I’m being bitter about someone living off benefits that I have a much better life than - but I’m almost made to feel less important

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kay286 · 23/03/2023 00:06

@TrashyPanda I don’t know, I’m guessing she is closer to dn as has helped raise her (and not bonded the same with my ds as moved abroad) basically she obviously does love and favour her more which I guess is really why I feel hurt.

OP posts:
TrashyPanda · 23/03/2023 00:01

Why does your mum always bring DN?

why doesn’t she want to spend time with your son, who lives far away, so she doesn’t see him nearly as often? And with the age gap, it’s not like she and your son are going to really have the same interests.

my friends mother is exactly the same. 1 grandchild is the favourite, she prioritises him over my friend and her 2 children. They are all adults now and the favouritism is ridiculous. Obviously my friend and her kids are very hurt and it’s negatively affected their relationships with her

Kay286 · 22/03/2023 23:20

@Sceptre86 yes sorry I didn’t realise your first message was in 2 parts ! I think the dynamic between relationships seems very similar between our mothers/sisters. I just need to accept it and enjoy my relationship with my mum as we do have a good one. Unfortunately don’t see each other often due to
distance… I guess that may play a small part that I’m like can’t I be prioritised for once with my kid it . But it is what it is. I of course don’t want my niece to suffer but resent paying flights to enable to bring her along of which they can afford anyway !

OP posts:
Kay286 · 22/03/2023 21:57

@Badger1970 it’s funny you say that I ac don’t feel she is the golden child . They have a really poor relationship, don’t get on , fall out a lot dont do much together etc , mum 100% prefers spending time with me. I guess it’s the niece who is golden child and probably throws money at my sister to compensate for her mh issues and basically crappy life and thinks money is the only way to support her ?

OP posts:
Kay286 · 22/03/2023 21:13

@QueenBee1234 I could but they know it’s probably not true and also it technically benefits me them visiting as I only pay 1 flight but If I fly home it’s all of us ! And I do want to see them.
I just find it annoying I’m expected
to pay something when I know they can afford it and are paying dn flight and multiple holidays for her !

OP posts:
HotSauceCommittee · 22/03/2023 21:06

I think this isn't about money, but love and any future inheritance is love, portioned out. Your parents are seemingly loving your child less than your sister's child.
If you separate it from money and need, when someone close to you dies, all they can leave is money/assets and memories and this WILL unsettle (at the very least) when the inevitable happens.
Might it be that when your parents do die, you might have to be a back up as your niece, OP? Not necessarily as a child, but as a young adult. So this unequal dividing up of love will have implications in family dynamics going forward.
Your parents need to understand this. After this explanation, tell your folks that you need to look after your own and cannot fund any part of their trips to you, just as they feel that they need to do for your sister and her family.

Kay286 · 22/03/2023 21:06

@Hongkongsuey I understand were you’re coming from , I dont really begrudge the money as such but hate the way it’s make my child feel like a second thought.
Also as I’ve explained dn does have a hard working supporting father which provides for them (in a house with 30k equity gifted by dp)
Gets taken on multiple holidays by dp (without us coming obviously)
But to visit us and their other grandkid is all expensive to I have to stump up for one of the flights ( they are still paying for dn though ) or
i am I suppose ! But will not come without her so she doesn’t miss out !
The disparity is just very jarring and i enjoy seeing them so I have to pay towards it , even though they can actually afford!
dn also get taken on holiday by dad ! I think I’ve probably painted her situation worse than what it is !

OP posts:
QueenBee1234 · 22/03/2023 20:14

Personally I would start pleading a little bit of poverty myself, especially when it comes to paying for/towards their flights.
Just say cost of living has hit you harder than you expected.
Your parents seem a bit grabby to me. If they can't afford the flight (whilst going on multiple holidays per year with your niece) they can't afford to visit you (get a cheap holiday out of you!!!)

Hongkongsuey · 22/03/2023 20:06

Bootlass · 22/03/2023 17:58

Surely you're DP coming to visit in school holidays benefits your family just as much as your DS and niece? Would you prefer they come when your DC is in school and so doesn't get to enjoy the visit and outings etc?
If it bothers you that much, tell your DP that you'll pay half for outings and they pay half, which will include them and niece. They pay for own travel and accommodation if they're not staying with you. What else are they asking you to pay for on these visits? Or you go visit them maybe?
As for inheritance, surely you're not going to spend rest of your life being bitter and resentful towards a young child for being in a position where her DM can't provide or look after her as much as you can for your DM? Wouldnt you just be grateful and proud that you've carved out a good life for yourself and your son and that he's not going to want for anything? Can't you be grateful tjat your DP are in a position to step forward and provide for your niece and she is well looked after? Would you rather niece is left alone with a mum who has MH problems, is struggling financially, while you, your DC and DP are having wonderful littlw holidays together?Hopefully your parents will live for many years to come and when the grandkids are all grown up, with lives, careers and families of their own, they will be seen as equals and Will might be changed.
Or God forbid, your DP become ill and need care in their old age and every penny of their assets and savings will need to be used for this and you've spent decades fuming about who is going to get their non-existent money.
Enjoy the visits with your parents and niece, more so if you live so far away and only see them sporadically. If you can afford to pay for a day out, do you really begrudge a little girl a fairground ride and a bit of candyfloss?
In the meantime, enjoy your life, keep your own DC happy and comfortable and concentrate on what YOU can provide for him, rather than what others can.

What a wonderful post. I agree-they’re ensuring niece isn’t left at a strong disadvantage-especially if they are her only grandparents. You are very comfortable and your children have well off grandparents on their father’s side. Why would you begrudge your niece the extra money? Be glad your parents are explaining the rationale behind their decision.

Goldbar · 22/03/2023 19:55

They can spend their money how they please but tell them to butt right out of spending yours.

If you don't feel you can be open about needing them to get their grubby little mitts out of your bank account, might I suggest dropping hints that you are having financial problems or maybe asking them for a handout yourself? I imagine that will stop them mentioning it again as they scramble to avoid giving you a penny.

Itstimeforlunch707 · 22/03/2023 19:52

YANBU op. Imho, as far as humanly possible, there should always be absolute parity when parents are giving adult DC money and time, regardless of illnesses, mh, different earnings and financial circumstances. Anything else can causes potentially huge ructions between siblings, not least because adult DC equate time and money with love and recognition.

Kay286 · 22/03/2023 19:51

@Bootlass sorry yes I realise it was a bit ! Not intensional I felt I waffling a lot already and just trying to give examples of the things making me feel like this without writing 5 pages ! Agree I just need to get over it and accept it.

OP posts:
Briallen · 22/03/2023 19:46

I think you’ve got 2 separate issues and you need to decide which one to broach first. I would say to parents that you’re sorry but you can’t afford a flight for them as money is tight. Also if they choose a time to come where your ds is in school then I would say sorry that doesn’t work for us as ds is desperate to spend time with you and will be in school.
if you keep paying for everything they’re going to think you’re loaded. The will issue wouldn’t bother me as much but I would see it as a separate issue and broach the expectation on you to pay for things first.

Shinyandnew1 · 22/03/2023 19:45

Kay286 · 22/03/2023 18:52

@Shinyandnew1 towards flights or one whole flight . Or car hire / accommodation if we book a trip somewhere. It’s expensive to visit I get that so they are always asking what I will pay for as they can’t afford to spend loads …. But can always pay for dn (flights costs similar for adults and children as it’s trans Atlantic)

Say no or say you’ll go halves on the whole trips. I’d stop suggesting any expensive trips/meals out when they come and stay and if they suggest it, so no and suggest something more reasonable.

Badger1970 · 22/03/2023 19:44

My sister is the "golden child" and not only has Mum given her half of her business, but I'm fairly convinced that Mum has also done an equity release on her house as my sister suddenly had lots of building work done that she couldn't afford before... Honestly, it really pisses me off but there's absolutely nothing I can do about it. So I choose my battles, maintain a level of contact that doesn't stress me out and I am proud to be in my 50s and not financially dependant on my parent still...

However I would say to your DM that you don't always want your DN around when they visit... I think that's OK to say.

Bootlass · 22/03/2023 19:41

So, it's a drip feed story then? None of what you said about living abroad or your DN living with her dad was in original post. Surely all this is relevant if you wanted an honest, fair opinion/advice. You made it sound like DN was living in poverty with a DM who was struggling with MH and that's why your DP were taking on responsibility for her.
You never mentioned transatlantic flights either but apologies if we assumed it was a quick trip up the M1 or something. On this point, you just say that you will pay for your own flights and accommodation when you go visit them and they pay for flights and accommodation when they come and see you, any days out and meals are split evenly.
And if we didn't know you lived abroad, we wouldn't have known school holidays were different.
But it still stands, stop worrying bout what they might do with their money years down the land, you're ruining your enjoyment of your own life and any visits you get with your family with all the bitterness.

Widowtoaworkaholic · 22/03/2023 19:40

I don't h to ink you're being unreasonable. If they can afford to go on holiday multiple times per year they can at least afford to make one trip to see you as part of that without you having to pay for flights. I think they see themselves as de facto parents for your DN hence the 3 way split. I don't think they want to cut out your sister but equally know she is irresponsible and want your niece to be secure. It's clear it's not the money that's the issue (though it would annoy me) but it's the way it makes you feel and that's perfectly valid.

Lollypop701 · 22/03/2023 19:37

Id tell my mum that I understand the situation but she needs to leave your child something, it doesn’t have to be equal but needs to be fair. Dn is getting loads now and that’s fine but to get it now and after is not ok

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 22/03/2023 19:31

Kay286 · 22/03/2023 18:52

@Shinyandnew1 towards flights or one whole flight . Or car hire / accommodation if we book a trip somewhere. It’s expensive to visit I get that so they are always asking what I will pay for as they can’t afford to spend loads …. But can always pay for dn (flights costs similar for adults and children as it’s trans Atlantic)

Now this does feel a bit like they are taking advantage and/or making assumptions about your finances. If you're feeling a bit resentful (and I can see why you would!), you could broach the subject with them.

It's one thing for them to try to fill in some of the financial gaps that your sister isn't capable of providing for, but it's a whole other thing for them to just assume that you'll step in financially as well. Nobody likes being taken for granted.

Sceptre86 · 22/03/2023 19:05

@Kay286 I meant that it doesn't sound like you would want to live your dsis's life.

Kay286 · 22/03/2023 18:52

@Shinyandnew1 towards flights or one whole flight . Or car hire / accommodation if we book a trip somewhere. It’s expensive to visit I get that so they are always asking what I will pay for as they can’t afford to spend loads …. But can always pay for dn (flights costs similar for adults and children as it’s trans Atlantic)

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 22/03/2023 18:48

my mum hard balls my what I will pay for towards them visiting

What do you mean here?

I wouldn’t be paying for them for things-what exactly are they asking you to pay for?

Kay286 · 22/03/2023 18:40

@Sceptre86 why wouldn’t you want mine ? Yes dn is at a disadvantage however does have a stable parent they live with (see above )

OP posts:
Kay286 · 22/03/2023 18:37

Bootlass · 22/03/2023 17:58

Surely you're DP coming to visit in school holidays benefits your family just as much as your DS and niece? Would you prefer they come when your DC is in school and so doesn't get to enjoy the visit and outings etc?
If it bothers you that much, tell your DP that you'll pay half for outings and they pay half, which will include them and niece. They pay for own travel and accommodation if they're not staying with you. What else are they asking you to pay for on these visits? Or you go visit them maybe?
As for inheritance, surely you're not going to spend rest of your life being bitter and resentful towards a young child for being in a position where her DM can't provide or look after her as much as you can for your DM? Wouldnt you just be grateful and proud that you've carved out a good life for yourself and your son and that he's not going to want for anything? Can't you be grateful tjat your DP are in a position to step forward and provide for your niece and she is well looked after? Would you rather niece is left alone with a mum who has MH problems, is struggling financially, while you, your DC and DP are having wonderful littlw holidays together?Hopefully your parents will live for many years to come and when the grandkids are all grown up, with lives, careers and families of their own, they will be seen as equals and Will might be changed.
Or God forbid, your DP become ill and need care in their old age and every penny of their assets and savings will need to be used for this and you've spent decades fuming about who is going to get their non-existent money.
Enjoy the visits with your parents and niece, more so if you live so far away and only see them sporadically. If you can afford to pay for a day out, do you really begrudge a little girl a fairground ride and a bit of candyfloss?
In the meantime, enjoy your life, keep your own DC happy and comfortable and concentrate on what YOU can provide for him, rather than what others can.

We live in a different country , so school terms are different. Therefore they wouldn’t come when my kid is off school just to see them as dn would not be and therefore can’t bring them.
They happily take dn abroad several times without my ds.
Summer they can all come and I’ve been asked to pay for a trans Atlantic flight (mum pays dn) sometimes also car hire and sometimes towards accommodations if we take trips. Not insignificant.
Mostly we go for dinners and split bills they pay dn I pay my ds etc
my dn lives with dad - dp purchased a house rented to him at cost nonprofit and have sold it him with 30k equity so dn has a stable providing parent.
I think if you re-read I’m not grabbing over the money it’s more how it’s makes me feel im struggling with !
of course this is not about a about a bag candy floss day out expense , my ds loves seeing my niece as so I , it’s about the feeling of always coming last

OP posts:
Kay286 · 22/03/2023 18:16

@GulfCoastBeachGirl Thank you, this really
does make sense , I need to make peace with it.

OP posts: