Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to OH increasing child maintenance

629 replies

Nastyurtium · 22/03/2023 15:26

Need a sanity check here.

OH pays maintenance at CMS level to his ex for their three children. We have them every other weekend and half the holidays and provide everything they need whilst they’re here, as well as paying half of school uniform and trip costs.

I earn double OH’s salary and pay around 75% of our household costs. He is paying off joint debt from his first marriage; I pay for the children’s holidays, clothes and hobbies whilst with us. We live ninety minutes from the children (his ex moved after the split and this is as close as we can be with OH working in his field - if we weren’t worried about proximity, we could both earn double living further away in the UK).

His ex has been commenting a lot on the children costing more as they grow up (they’re primary age), the cost of living going up and the fact that she’s had another baby so can’t work as much, and I’m expecting a formal request for more maintenance money soon. We have a cordial relationship. She has a partner, who is self-employed and she works some hours for his business. I don’t know a lot about their finances but they take more holidays than us and seem to have a similar lifestyle, albeit in a cheaper region. We’d happily have the children for more of the holidays or even full-time but this has always been refused.

AIBU to just say no? If OH was paying half our living costs, it’d be his choice, but he isn’t and has nothing left at the end of each month, so realistically any increase would be coming from my salary.

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 24/03/2023 13:26

YaWeeFurryBastard · 24/03/2023 13:19

Presumably if he wasn’t spending so much time renovating the OP’s house he’d be able to further his career and increase his earnings and therefore the amount of maintenance?

£400 is not a lot for 3 children (debts aside as from your posts that ends soon). I think it’s incredibly unfair to have another baby when he’s not providing very much for the ones he’s already got - that goes for the ex too, but sadly you can’t control what she does only your own actions.

It doesn’t seem like your partner can afford another baby and it’s very unfair to refuse to increase maintenance to have another one instead of prioritising the children he already has! I can guarantee you won’t take on any of this advice though as your want for a baby trumps the needs of his existing children 🙄.

Them having a baby does not mean paying for it will come out of his income. Most likely, OP will pay for it.

amiold · 24/03/2023 13:25

YaWeeFurryBastard · 24/03/2023 13:19

Presumably if he wasn’t spending so much time renovating the OP’s house he’d be able to further his career and increase his earnings and therefore the amount of maintenance?

£400 is not a lot for 3 children (debts aside as from your posts that ends soon). I think it’s incredibly unfair to have another baby when he’s not providing very much for the ones he’s already got - that goes for the ex too, but sadly you can’t control what she does only your own actions.

It doesn’t seem like your partner can afford another baby and it’s very unfair to refuse to increase maintenance to have another one instead of prioritising the children he already has! I can guarantee you won’t take on any of this advice though as your want for a baby trumps the needs of his existing children 🙄.

So op shouldn't have her own baby so the ex can get more money? Really 🥴

YaWeeFurryBastard · 24/03/2023 13:19

Presumably if he wasn’t spending so much time renovating the OP’s house he’d be able to further his career and increase his earnings and therefore the amount of maintenance?

£400 is not a lot for 3 children (debts aside as from your posts that ends soon). I think it’s incredibly unfair to have another baby when he’s not providing very much for the ones he’s already got - that goes for the ex too, but sadly you can’t control what she does only your own actions.

It doesn’t seem like your partner can afford another baby and it’s very unfair to refuse to increase maintenance to have another one instead of prioritising the children he already has! I can guarantee you won’t take on any of this advice though as your want for a baby trumps the needs of his existing children 🙄.

T1Dmama · 24/03/2023 10:17

I think any request for more money should be met with a firm NO!!
He’s already paying the recommended amount, plus clothes/shoes/school trips etc!!.. what is her new partner covering?!
He is also lying off her half of the debt, which he should get in writing and should actually be reduced each month off the child maintenance…. I’d have said right so my CM is £400, debt is £200, your debt that I’m paying for is another £200…. So I’ll pay the £400 debt plus £200 CM to you! Plus all the other extras that he doesn’t ‘have to’ pay for!
Her telling the kids that he can buy them this and that is disgraceful, I would very politely tell the children that Daddy pays mummy a huge amount every month and leave it there.
She sounds horrible tbh, clearly puts her own needs before the childrens, if she can afford another baby and several holidays a year then she doesn’t need more money, and quite frankly shouldn’t be dropping hints. I would get OH to politely reply to future ‘hints’ that he’s already paying her half of the debt and actually her finances are no longer his concern, he pays above what he needs to for the children and any future increases will mean less towards other things.

Pubesofsoberness · 24/03/2023 09:17

RedToothBrush · 24/03/2023 08:04

He's paying his way to ex whilst living it up with new wife.

And from what op has said she's living it up with her shag buddy

Pubesofsoberness · 24/03/2023 09:15

jenjenlinks · 23/03/2023 22:31

baggage free...no. But most of us women here haven't left three kids behind us and moved on to try and make a new family with someone with more money.

We can judge.

She left because she was having an affair and moved herself and the children straight in with the ap who she's had another child with

Yet he's the bad one?

whumpthereitis · 24/03/2023 08:29

RedToothBrush · 24/03/2023 08:04

He's paying his way to ex whilst living it up with new wife.

He’s paying what he can afford from his own income whilst also covering their joint debt. If OP wants to share her finances with him that’s her choice to so do so, but sharing her finances with him does not mean sharing them with his ex wife.

RachaelN · 24/03/2023 08:20

Her choice to have more children. He is paying the recommended level. My ex pays the recommended level and hardly ever sees the kids, but I wouldn't ask for more.

RedToothBrush · 24/03/2023 08:04

Yamaha1819 · 24/03/2023 00:44

He does pay the recommended amount as set by CMS plus an additional £200 debt to cover his ex wife's portion of a debt she says she can't afford. The ex wife is not taking a financial hit. Where did you get that from? She's not meeting her own obligations by paying for a joint debt yet decided to have another child.

He's paying his way to ex whilst living it up with new wife.

Weedoormatnomore · 24/03/2023 07:28

Nastyurtium · 23/03/2023 10:46

To address a few points:

Living costs: the split would be fair even without the children because the house is primarily mine and I earn double. If we split, I have a big renovated house. He gets what he’s put in. My money is protected. The risk is to him doing unpaid work, but the current living situation benefits him more, so it’s balanced.

What I pay towards the children is the nice-to-haves. I love them and I am choosing to spend money on things like family holidays and days out because I want to. If I stopped, that’d be fine too. OH could afford their basic needs and keep up with his essential payments.

Animosity: we only communicate by email with his ex so the children shouldn’t be aware of it, however it’s hard to feel much empathy when you have young children coming out with “mum says you have lots of money and you like spending it so you need to buy us new football shoes” and “mum says dad doesn’t give her any money and he should.” I’ve tried to be friendly but she doesn’t seem to respect us and at this point it’s mutual. We are cordial.

I could afford a child by myself, but I don’t want to do that. And there’s other men available, but have you found one in their late 30s who is childfree but wants children, is kind and loving, wants a settled relationship, earns 80k yet is on flexible hours to do school pick ups, works full-time and is willing to do about 30hrs a week on top of that doing renovations, and has zero baggage lately? Yes, OH is lucky to have me, as are the children, but I feel lucky to have them too.

The ex sounds so money grabby. Reminds me off my brothers ex. On the cms calculator do you have recorded how many nights you have the kids. It reduces the payments. My brother had his a lot but she reported to cms he never had them. Also when they are 11 then can tell court where they want to live unless there are any real concerns court take into consideration.

Weedoormatnomore · 24/03/2023 07:01

Definitely not sounds like she needs to learn to live within her means. He is paying cms then contributing towards things the kids need and paying her half off the debt which sounds quite a bit if once the debt has gone he can up his contributions to your household by 25%. You have offered to gave the kids more guessing refused as her cms would reduce.

CoffeeBean5 · 24/03/2023 06:29

Inthedeep · 23/03/2023 17:34

Dad contributes £600 a month to his ex wife towards his children’s keep (£400 directly to her, plus paying £200 for her half of their shared debt), ex wife should also contribute £600 so that’s a combined total of £1200. The OP mentions that the youngest gets 30 hours free childcare and as the Mum is a SAHM she shouldn’t require any wrap around childcare. Thats more than fair for 3 children with no childcare costs. Plus she gets the child benefit.

I’m not sure why everyone is being so hard on the ex-husband (OP’s partner). His ex wife had an affair and left him, then moved the children across the country and the OP and her partner had to move too to accommodate the Ex-wife’s wishes. OP has mentioned that this has limited their earning potential, so why on earth should he pay more? Equally they’ve offered (and would actually prefer) a more equal custody split, the Ex wife doesn’t want this, therefore she should foot the additional costs without demanding more maintenance. The ex wife could have got a job to support her kids, she choses not to work.

If the boot was on the other foot and this was a woman who’s husband had an affair, he then left her, shacked up with OW, demanded more maintenance whilst also withholding equal custody, having made the ex wife move across the country to be near her children (hampering her career in the process) which she only got to see every other weekend people would be up in arms at the injustice of it all.

I agree with everything here! The ex wife needs to get a job. She can’t afford a fourth child? Well that’s the dad (the affair partner) of that child’s responsibility, not OP and her boyfriend. OP also covers the costs of family holidays, school uniforms and hobbies for dc that aren’t hers, so the ex wife doesn’t really have much to pay for. I’m assuming the £600 from her ex, her affair partner’s financial contribution and her benefits will cover food, bills, and the holidays she seems to be able to afford.

I’m also confused why OP moved across the country and bought a house just for her DP to be closer to his dc.

Comii9 · 24/03/2023 04:53

Skynorth · 24/03/2023 04:42

But her current partner is the father of her latest baby surely and he is responsible for it financially. The ex isn’t financially responsible for some other man’s child.

True. I don't agree with a lot of these comments. But OP should of really thought about having a baby with this man. Everyone is entitled to move on of course I don't know why MORE kids need to be added though ultimately it's not fair on them when it goes to shit.

Skynorth · 24/03/2023 04:48

Oh dear…..
This is what happens when you get with someone who already has kids from a prior relationship.
Those kids are HIS responsibility financially, not yours and not for you to interfere with any decision.

Skynorth · 24/03/2023 04:42

But her current partner is the father of her latest baby surely and he is responsible for it financially. The ex isn’t financially responsible for some other man’s child.

Yamaha1819 · 24/03/2023 00:44

Oh and on top pays for extras too

Yamaha1819 · 24/03/2023 00:44

RedToothBrush · 23/03/2023 22:38

He's a cocklodger who has kids he can't provide the recommended amount for AND pay his debts AND fund his current lifestyle without it being supplimented by the OP.

OP has allowed a situation to arise where he's effectively not paying his way. And she's so committed to him she wants a change with him.

The problem here is that he's living beyond his means and you enable this.

And you now want his kids / mother of his kids to take the financial hit for him choosing to led a lifestyle with you that's beyond his means.

You need to scale back your ideas of what he can afford or accept that you will have to fund it. You can't take away from the kids on the days they aren't with you, just so you can have this lifestyle.

He can't afford the lifestyle you want without you funding it. You need to consider downsizing to satisfactionllly

He does pay the recommended amount as set by CMS plus an additional £200 debt to cover his ex wife's portion of a debt she says she can't afford. The ex wife is not taking a financial hit. Where did you get that from? She's not meeting her own obligations by paying for a joint debt yet decided to have another child.

Shauny098 · 24/03/2023 00:44

Bootlass · 22/03/2023 16:01

@AnneLovesGilbert what am I making up? If its done through the courts, everyone's income will be taken into account, including new partners/spouses are cohabiting and sharing expenses.

And please refrain from calling me ridiculous. Its not called for whatsoever. Grow up and discuss topics in am adult, reasonable fashion or don't comment at all

The court has no jurisdiction for maintenance alone when the NRP earns less than 3k per week UNLESS there are special circumstances such as a severely disabled child. You are indeed chatting crap.

Yamaha1819 · 24/03/2023 00:38

Inthedeep · 23/03/2023 17:34

Dad contributes £600 a month to his ex wife towards his children’s keep (£400 directly to her, plus paying £200 for her half of their shared debt), ex wife should also contribute £600 so that’s a combined total of £1200. The OP mentions that the youngest gets 30 hours free childcare and as the Mum is a SAHM she shouldn’t require any wrap around childcare. Thats more than fair for 3 children with no childcare costs. Plus she gets the child benefit.

I’m not sure why everyone is being so hard on the ex-husband (OP’s partner). His ex wife had an affair and left him, then moved the children across the country and the OP and her partner had to move too to accommodate the Ex-wife’s wishes. OP has mentioned that this has limited their earning potential, so why on earth should he pay more? Equally they’ve offered (and would actually prefer) a more equal custody split, the Ex wife doesn’t want this, therefore she should foot the additional costs without demanding more maintenance. The ex wife could have got a job to support her kids, she choses not to work.

If the boot was on the other foot and this was a woman who’s husband had an affair, he then left her, shacked up with OW, demanded more maintenance whilst also withholding equal custody, having made the ex wife move across the country to be near her children (hampering her career in the process) which she only got to see every other weekend people would be up in arms at the injustice of it all.

Spot on 100%

Volhhg · 23/03/2023 23:30

I guess it's up to him what he pays to his family but it's up to you about how much you want to be involved in this financial scenario. I think if you're getting annoyed now then you should think again about having a child with this man and bringing a 5th child into this family financial mix.

SemperIdem · 23/03/2023 23:01

I’m baffled by this attitude.

The information required to check out the CMS calculations is all here.

He is providing for his children. If his ex wasn’t so irresponsible and was paying her part of the joint debts instead of having a child she can’t actually afford, then he would be able to contribute more to the children directly. But either way he’s contributing above and beyond.

RedToothBrush · 23/03/2023 22:38

jenjenlinks · 22/03/2023 15:56

He can't afford to contribute fairly to the three children he already has and you're planning on having another one with him?

He's a cocklodger who has kids he can't provide the recommended amount for AND pay his debts AND fund his current lifestyle without it being supplimented by the OP.

OP has allowed a situation to arise where he's effectively not paying his way. And she's so committed to him she wants a change with him.

The problem here is that he's living beyond his means and you enable this.

And you now want his kids / mother of his kids to take the financial hit for him choosing to led a lifestyle with you that's beyond his means.

You need to scale back your ideas of what he can afford or accept that you will have to fund it. You can't take away from the kids on the days they aren't with you, just so you can have this lifestyle.

He can't afford the lifestyle you want without you funding it. You need to consider downsizing to satisfactionllly

DrMarciaFieldstone · 23/03/2023 22:35

jenjenlinks · 23/03/2023 22:31

baggage free...no. But most of us women here haven't left three kids behind us and moved on to try and make a new family with someone with more money.

We can judge.

The ex wife left with their 3 kids and moved in with her affair partner, then had another baby with him, then used the baby as an excuse why she needs more money as she can’t work as much.

We can judge.

jenjenlinks · 23/03/2023 22:31

Nellylongstocking · 23/03/2023 22:26

This isn't really a nice judgement to make, is it.
Are you and everyone in your world, baggage and history free?
I sure wish my ex was more like him.

@Nastyurtium in fact your OH sounds like a dad doing his best for his kids and also considerate and supportive of his ex partner.
He's a keeper ❤️.
Setting a great example that he's in it for the long stretch when you have your own child👏🏻.

baggage free...no. But most of us women here haven't left three kids behind us and moved on to try and make a new family with someone with more money.

We can judge.

Nellylongstocking · 23/03/2023 22:26

jemimapuddlepluck · 22/03/2023 16:10

So 3 kids and debt. What a catch 🙄

This isn't really a nice judgement to make, is it.
Are you and everyone in your world, baggage and history free?
I sure wish my ex was more like him.

@Nastyurtium in fact your OH sounds like a dad doing his best for his kids and also considerate and supportive of his ex partner.
He's a keeper ❤️.
Setting a great example that he's in it for the long stretch when you have your own child👏🏻.

Swipe left for the next trending thread