Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to OH increasing child maintenance

629 replies

Nastyurtium · 22/03/2023 15:26

Need a sanity check here.

OH pays maintenance at CMS level to his ex for their three children. We have them every other weekend and half the holidays and provide everything they need whilst they’re here, as well as paying half of school uniform and trip costs.

I earn double OH’s salary and pay around 75% of our household costs. He is paying off joint debt from his first marriage; I pay for the children’s holidays, clothes and hobbies whilst with us. We live ninety minutes from the children (his ex moved after the split and this is as close as we can be with OH working in his field - if we weren’t worried about proximity, we could both earn double living further away in the UK).

His ex has been commenting a lot on the children costing more as they grow up (they’re primary age), the cost of living going up and the fact that she’s had another baby so can’t work as much, and I’m expecting a formal request for more maintenance money soon. We have a cordial relationship. She has a partner, who is self-employed and she works some hours for his business. I don’t know a lot about their finances but they take more holidays than us and seem to have a similar lifestyle, albeit in a cheaper region. We’d happily have the children for more of the holidays or even full-time but this has always been refused.

AIBU to just say no? If OH was paying half our living costs, it’d be his choice, but he isn’t and has nothing left at the end of each month, so realistically any increase would be coming from my salary.

OP posts:
Meadowflower2023 · 23/03/2023 21:50

@Nastyurtium apologies I've only skim read after the first few pages but just wanted to say you sound like you have your head screwed on and are a really kind and generous person. The children are lucky to have you as a SP.
I would think it is an absolute no to any future additional request for money, you are not a walking bank for this woman. Also I think as others have probably said, it's actually very little to do with the costs of things increasing but more to do with the extra children she's knocking out (except like you've said if OH wants to give more when debts are paid but even then 😬)
Enjoy your renovated home and good luck with TTC xx

taxpayer1 · 23/03/2023 21:48

Pubesofsoberness · 23/03/2023 21:08

Its always the same on here

Ops dp doesn't sound like a bad man or father yet she shouldn't have children with him 🙄

I've not seen anyway bring up the fact that she left because she was shagging about and took her children to live with the ap straight away!

If you are a single mother on here and you introduce the kids to a new partner before a year into the relationship you get your arse handed to you

Finally some common sense. Not every man is bad and every woman is a martyr.

mandlerparr · 23/03/2023 21:47

I am a bit torn on this because of unknowns that you don't know either. First, the debt. If he is earning the same or more now than what he was earning when they were together, that debt is mostly food, heating, children stuff, clothes, transportation costs, school costs, etc. But possibly she spent a lot more on just herself. IDK and neither do you. But if it is household debts, since their arrangement was that she stay home and he pay the bills, then he should be the only one paying the debt. And household debt does include her having some clothes and fun sometimes, just not extravagant. I am sure he did.
Child maintenance. 400 is a laughable amount. I don't care what you claim, you can't support 3 kids on 800, which is what the amount would be if she matched his. And sure, you all feed them every other weekend and on some holidays. But that is nothing compared to every day. He gets them, what, 80 days per year? 100 being generous? That still leaves more than 250 days on her plate alone. So, let's say that his load is 400 and hers is 600. You still can't really raise 3 kids on 1000 per month. Not without being in poverty conditions. You also don't know that her newer car cost more than yours. My car goes for 12000-14000 on average and I paid 6500 plus about 1000 on repairs.
And you are probably 100% percent correct that her new man is not paying for things for the kids. You also cannot know how much the trips they are taking cost. There are tons of ways to travel low cost if you want to badly enough.
I am really torn because I am heavily of the belief that parents who have limited or no custody of their kids should be paying a lot more than they do in child maintenance or support. Because they are also usually not doing sick days, doctor/dentist/eye/etc visits. They are not putting in the day-to-day work. They aren't doing nearly as much cleaning, cooking, etc. And they certainly are not putting in 50% of the childcare duties. We can claim "they said no" all we want, but that is what courts are for.
I cannot tell you how many times some man told me fairy stories about his ex, especially if they had a child together and how many times he was exaggerating if not outright lying. And maybe your guy is not this, but frankly, most people, even the nicest, downplay their bad role in past relationships and exaggerate how bad their ex was.
It is up to you if you want to fund his lifestyle, including the one he had previous to you. Unfortunately, there are a lot of things you don't know and possibly never will. I also have a heavy bias, so I am inclined to side with her on the kids needs vs what he and yourself think they need and how you all think she should run her life.
You should know that I was going to be way more on you and your OH side until you plopped down the number of 400 for child maintenance for 3 kids, even if he does have them around 27% of the time. And let's all be honest, that high percentage probably has more to do with you than him.

Pubesofsoberness · 23/03/2023 21:08

Wellillsayitifnoonelsewill · 23/03/2023 20:55

It’s honestly getting on my nerves this. If this was a man earning double his girlfriend and insisting she paid 50:50 into a house she didn’t own and had no financial recourse to everyone would be up arms about it and telling her to get her ducks in a row. It’s the complete misandry (which I’ve just had to look up the word for 🤣)

Its always the same on here

Ops dp doesn't sound like a bad man or father yet she shouldn't have children with him 🙄

I've not seen anyway bring up the fact that she left because she was shagging about and took her children to live with the ap straight away!

If you are a single mother on here and you introduce the kids to a new partner before a year into the relationship you get your arse handed to you

Wellillsayitifnoonelsewill · 23/03/2023 20:55

Lizzt2007 · 23/03/2023 20:14

Exactly this ! It's like dads aren't allowed to have another relationship once they have kids, even if the first one ended due to no fault of their own !

It’s honestly getting on my nerves this. If this was a man earning double his girlfriend and insisting she paid 50:50 into a house she didn’t own and had no financial recourse to everyone would be up arms about it and telling her to get her ducks in a row. It’s the complete misandry (which I’ve just had to look up the word for 🤣)

Lizzt2007 · 23/03/2023 20:38

Chamelion · 22/03/2023 20:40

Too much irrelevant back story.

If she has one, two, three or more babies and how many hours she works doesn’t not affect the fact that if she can demonstrate their children is costing more, the amount of child maintenance she would be receiving could potentially be adjusted.

I was not going to comment on your private lives but since you chose to share, I think you should have thought about it before choosing a man who has already 3 kids from a previous marriage. And you can’t be sure you can earn double if you lived further away - you can’t be really sure of that.

She earns double what her partner earns, not they partners ex and new partner earn. And no, cam is based on a percentage of the non resident parents earnings, an increase in costs for the resident parent has absolutely no effect on maintenance.

FUSoftPlay · 23/03/2023 20:34

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/03/2023 19:44

It doesn't matter if the mum is a millionaire, a father is equally responsible for his children.

Hes providing £600 pcm, He’s also buying extras, what about that is unequal?

Foxface21 · 23/03/2023 20:15

Each to their own but if I wanted to start a family it wouldn’t be with a man with 3 children (primary age), debt and no way of funding a new life with me. 🤷‍♀️

Lizzt2007 · 23/03/2023 20:14

Wellillsayitifnoonelsewill · 22/03/2023 17:14

Why is everyone slating the op for paying more to their household? She earns double…

Plus he’s doing a heck of a lot in terms of renovating her house etc.

Hes also paying off £400 in debts that his ex has left to him cos she “can’t afford it” but can afford to have another kid and £400 maintenance to said ex (who also again can’t afford the current kids but had another).

he sounds like a decent dad who does as much as possible - why is everyone beating him down??

Exactly this ! It's like dads aren't allowed to have another relationship once they have kids, even if the first one ended due to no fault of their own !

Lizzt2007 · 23/03/2023 20:10

Babyroobs · 22/03/2023 16:51

YABU. They have more costs and no doubt her partners earnings will affect any benefits they can claim so he will largely be paying for your partners kids also.

Or, and this is a wild idea, instead of being a sahm and having another child she can't afford the mother could get a job and support her own children 🤔

Lizzt2007 · 23/03/2023 20:00

Bootlass · 22/03/2023 16:12

And not once has OP said he's paying off all marital debt, just half. As he should. Debts arose jointly and should be paid accordingly. It now sounds like he largely lives off OP, having quite a good lifestyle, while he he's paying off old debt and avoiding paying a decent amount for his DC. He's hit lucky, hasn't he?

No, she’s not paying off the joint debts because she says she can’t afford to and defaulting would impact OH’s credit rating too, so he’s just paying it. It should be cleared in a few years at which point he’ll a more equal amount to our household’s costs.

on one of ops posts. Ex partner isn't paying any of the joint debts, he's paying it all.

wentworthinmate · 23/03/2023 19:59

As PP has said, imagine if you weren’t around! His ex would be absolutely screwed.

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/03/2023 19:44

FUSoftPlay · 23/03/2023 12:45

It’s not equal though if one party is reliant on the state and the CMS though is it?

It doesn't matter if the mum is a millionaire, a father is equally responsible for his children.

LoisLane66 · 23/03/2023 19:02

Mum also gets £216.97pm child benefit. If she can't afford the kids she has then she shouldn't be having more.

LoisLane66 · 23/03/2023 18:51

So he earns £2400pm net out of which he pays £800 leaving £1600 to contribute to his own home expenses. That's about £400pw. Surely that's enough for two people to live on if the OP, the higher earner, paid the mortgage. Even if the OP earned the same as her partner, their monthly income minus his CM is £4,000 Even counting mortgage repayments and bills for 2 working people (at least one not WFH) that's a good income.
I certainly don't think the OP should make up the extra CM his ex is asking for.
I'd never get involved with a partner's CM payments...ever, nor their debts.
Luckily I never fell for men who had children before meeting me. Too much aggro over everything.

LoisLane66 · 23/03/2023 18:35

@Harriyet & @coffeecupsandwaxmelts
Agree 100% with comments from above posters.

cushioncovers · 23/03/2023 18:31

Mum23amazingkids · 23/03/2023 18:21

If £400 is all he pays for 4 kids and he only sees tem twice a months in 2 weekends then with all due respect he should be paying more as that is not enough

It's 3 kids not 4

Crimeismymiddlename · 23/03/2023 18:29

No, you’re not being unreasonable. If his ex was paying equally towards the shared debt then yes it would be fair for her to ask for more as the primary residence. She isn’t so it stays the same until the debt is paid. You should not have to pay for for your partners children.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 23/03/2023 18:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 23/03/2023 18:25

Children are a joint responsibility. Both parents choose to have them, both parents should support them. We are in a very similar situation to you OP, same arrangements, payments are over CMS levels and we still buy school schools, trainers, school trainer, pay half for trips, etc. in the same way you do. Same situation with time spent, etc. We live closer though (30 mins) and, as they have 2 other DC (we don’t) we do all the collect/drop off as it just makes it easier for them in terms of bed/bath, etc for their other DC.

Both households have similar incomes, me and ex’s DH are main earners, but my DH and ex earn around the same as each other too. Both I and ex’s DH spend money on SS too as we both love him, so why would we not? We even had his brother at ours and fed him one afternoon last week, it really doesn’t always have to be that bloody difficult if everyone just tries to be reasonable, after all the children didn’t bloody choose this and it’s about them, not what the adults want to try and have control over. Control is ALWAYS the thing that causes problems in separated families!!!

Sounds like with him paying her half of the debt too, on top of all of the maintenance and paying for half of activities, uniform, etc. that you are being very fair to maintain a workable relationship. Therefore I would politely say no if asked. After all your household costs have also increased.

Blossomtoes · 23/03/2023 18:23

Mum23amazingkids · 23/03/2023 18:21

If £400 is all he pays for 4 kids and he only sees tem twice a months in 2 weekends then with all due respect he should be paying more as that is not enough

Try reading the thread or at least OP’s posts.

Mum23amazingkids · 23/03/2023 18:21

If £400 is all he pays for 4 kids and he only sees tem twice a months in 2 weekends then with all due respect he should be paying more as that is not enough

Pubesofsoberness · 23/03/2023 18:19

People are bonkers ! The ex is also responsible for housing the children and herself as well, ops dp isn't responsible for her! If she didn't have children she would still have housing costs etc for herself

She also has a partner living with her who is responsible for his housing /cost of living and responsible for the baby who is also living in the house!

Mum23amazingkids · 23/03/2023 18:18

My partner also earns considerably less than me ( 3 time ) and I pay 85% if the household stuff , while he has always paid child maintenance for his kid himself I truly believe it’s up to both parents to help each other and I have recently suggested that I start paying the internet so he can increase CM a bit ( he pays more than he should already but cost of living is a thing to everyone ) his ex was actually fair and told us to just send the child ( now a teen ) more money directly so he can get his clothes himself and that way decrease her costs so we have been sending a extra £60 ( my stepson lives in another country so would be equivalent to £100 or thereabouts ) .
Its all about balance

Inthedeep · 23/03/2023 18:17

Yourcatisnotsorry · 23/03/2023 17:58

Please think long and hard before having a baby with this man. He sounds like a massive sponge.

You see, I don’t see this. Yes the OP’s partner earns less than her, yet he pays for his children’s maintenance, pays off his bad debt and contributes to the household finances. The OP owns 90% of the house, therefore should pay 90% of the mortgage. Yes the bills, food etc should be split as equally as possible, however if the roles were reversed I very much people would be saying “she’s a massive sponge, don’t have kids with her”.

He also puts in lots of hours renovating the house, saving £1000s of which 90% financially OP gets the benefit of. You aren’t all jumping on her saying she should pay for his labour. In a relationship, when building a life together everyone brings different things to the table to make the relationship work and be fair. Yes the OP might bring more money, however the OP’s partner is contributing through his time and skill working on the house. Surely to a certain extent their finances should be joint household income, they are obviously in a serious relationship and want to build a family together.