Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel vindicated regarding recent news articles concerning early introduction of allergens

129 replies

Wafflington · 22/03/2023 11:59

Several news articles recently have highlighted data from studies pointing out that early introduction of allergens (eg peanuts) from 4-6months of age significantly reduces formation of allergies

It feels like a relief somehow. I have a background in immunology and have been aware of these studies for a long time out of personal interest. However I have, countless times, been absolutely ripped to shreds by other mums on social media/forums/etc for daring to suggest that early introduction of allergens reduces the risk of allergies. Literally been called all sorts of horrible names by people who insist you absolutely cannot EVER give ANY kind of solids before 6 months, and absolutely never give any allergens like peanuts before at least 12 months. That if you dare to do this or suggest it, you're a shit mum and should rot in hell and all your children will grow up allergic to everything under the sun

Feels somewhat vindicated now to see news reports on the TV agreeing with me I suppose

Not really sure why I'm posting this to be honest, other than I hope NHS guidelines consider the latest data and make any necessary changes to recommendations on infant feeding 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
3WildOnes · 22/03/2023 12:08

Chickenly · 22/03/2023 12:03

YANBU. I have a postgraduate degree in biology. DD was desperate for food and when I actually looked into it, there’s an abundance of research showing that waiting until 6 months is actively harmful to babies and that the NHS guidelines should be reviewed. This is especially true for EBF babies who should move onto solids earlier. I couldn’t believe how the NHS guidelines are so adamantly declaring 6 months when it’s not at all evidence informed and I’m glad I have the background to conduct sufficient research myself. It’s a minefield for parents to know what’s best and it’s disappointing that the standard advice is so far off piste with what the research recommends. The rules absolutely do need to change.

This. Breast fed babies often have depleted their iron stores before 6 months.
There used to be quite a bit of information in the EU Who about weaning but I think it has since been removed. But basically there is no evidence of harm weaning between 17 and 26 weeks.

PlateBilledDuckyPerson · 22/03/2023 12:05

I know nothing about the medical/scientific side of this at all, but it seems to make sense.

In my youth (70s) there was no widespread concern about giving children things like peanuts - they were a staple of childhood parties, in fact. Nut allergies in my generation are rare. It seems that there are far more allergies since parents were told to avoid these foods.

Of course, there might be other environmental factors in play, but from an unscientific, anecdotal perspective, it doesn't seem that limiting exposure has achieved anything.

TheVeryHungryTortoise · 22/03/2023 12:04

I feel you OP. I'm a junior doctor, had my son in med school and introduced allergens from 4 months based on studies that I had read too. We have atopy in the family and I wanted to minimise the allergies cropping up in my son. I tried talking to some Mum friends at the time about it who totally dismissed it and after that just kept it to myself.

Chickenly · 22/03/2023 12:03

YANBU. I have a postgraduate degree in biology. DD was desperate for food and when I actually looked into it, there’s an abundance of research showing that waiting until 6 months is actively harmful to babies and that the NHS guidelines should be reviewed. This is especially true for EBF babies who should move onto solids earlier. I couldn’t believe how the NHS guidelines are so adamantly declaring 6 months when it’s not at all evidence informed and I’m glad I have the background to conduct sufficient research myself. It’s a minefield for parents to know what’s best and it’s disappointing that the standard advice is so far off piste with what the research recommends. The rules absolutely do need to change.