Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not To Tell My Employer

209 replies

Charliesunnysky10 · 22/03/2023 11:35

I'm struggling financially, but my 9-5 weekday office job pays minimum wage and I'm getting further into debt. In the past 3 months I've had to replace the broken boiler, sort the roof, and pay for repairs on my car until it eventually became unviable and I had to sell it.

I want to work my way out of the debt and also get out in the evenings and weekends so I'm not home worrying, and a job with these hours seemed the perfect solution.

But I asked informally a year ago when a friend suggested I come to work with her in a local coffee shop as they were extending the hours into the evenings for a bar. I was told permission will not be granted because it may impact on my ability to do my day job.

Since then, my financial situation has worsened and I spend hours in the evening with no money to go out and wishing I could put these hours to good use. My friend's bar is now a huge success and she persuaded me to apply. I was interviewed for the job and have been offered it. The manager said they will try to give me weekend hours rather than weekdays when I'm at my day job, but there will inevitably be weekday late evenings here and there. I don't go to bed till after 11pm anyway, so it's not like this will make a big difference and I felt so happy to be getting out and meeting people again.

Today, the manager messaged me to supply reference details. I had planned not to tell my boss and if they ever found out I'd have proved I can do both roles, and I will accept the punishment.

I'm not deceitful by nature, but I'm angry that I'm not allowed to get out of debt and need to put this first. I don't want to leave this job as I've been here 10 years and my co-workers are so lovely. I like the job here too, but it just doesn't pay well.

The problem I have is the reference - can I ask my former manager who left just over a year ago? She can hardly comment favourably on my honesty when I'm being so duplicitous, not asking my current boss - she will wonder why I'm not asking them. And she may know I'm required to seek permission.

I'm in a mess and I don't know where to turn.

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 22/03/2023 13:15

America12 · 22/03/2023 11:50

They've said she can't have a second job

Think she means a previous employer, not the current one.

FishChipsMushyPeas · 22/03/2023 13:13

Lazyteens · 22/03/2023 12:13

I don’t want to worry you unduly, but would your main job be able to tell that you have a second job via your tax code that may change? Perhaps someone with payroll knowledge could comment? I had two jobs last year and it was reflected in my tax code.

Your tax code would only change if you earned less than the personal allowance in your primary job (so less than £12,570 for the current tax year). If it did change it doesnt tell your employer why it has changed just that it has reduced. A reduction in a tax code could be for a short fall of tax for example so a change in the tax code wouldnt necessarily imply a second job.

Kiitos · 22/03/2023 13:12

It’s good advice to speak to ACAS. I’m not sure a clause like that would be enforceable. If the worry is that a second job would tire you out too much, how do they deal with people who have demanding family commitments outside of work? Or people who commit to a time-consuming hobby etc? Would they seek to stop someone training for a marathon or similar?

I would just put cards on the table with my current employer. You need the money and they only pay you minimum wage. It’s not worth worrying about getting into trouble if you get found out. Just try and stop thinking of the second job as a big deal, point out why you need it and reassure them it’s a completely different industry etc

stayathomer · 22/03/2023 13:12

Surely an employer cannot stop you taking on another job if it's outside of your normal hours, not in direct conflict with your day job and not for a competitor? I had a bar job alongside my very boring 9-5 hours for years when I was younger! Even now at 54 I'm considering taking on weekend work to try and make ends meet a little better. They'd better not try and stop me!
but of course they can! While it’s easy to say you think you can work all the hours extra you can, of course it will impact at some stage- you’re not a robot! I used to work with a girl who played soccer at the weekends and helped coaching too and the difference between her work on a Monday and Tuesday to the rest of the week was huge because she was understandably tired and couldn’t give her full attention or energy.

Cerealkillerontheloose · 22/03/2023 13:09

blobby10 · 22/03/2023 11:51

Surely an employer cannot stop you taking on another job if it's outside of your normal hours, not in direct conflict with your day job and not for a competitor? I had a bar job alongside my very boring 9-5 hours for years when I was younger! Even now at 54 I'm considering taking on weekend work to try and make ends meet a little better. They'd better not try and stop me!

It depends what her contract says

what does your contract say about a second job?

Passerillage · 22/03/2023 13:05

You've had lots of amazing advice here, but just to look at your day job for a moment here, you say that you ahve been there for 10 years and are still on minimum wage.

Can you not put your evenings to better use fixing this for starters? If you shopped around, what could you be earning with a different employer firstly. Secondly, are you being held back by not holding any qualifications or something? You're clearly ambitious enough to want to earn more money, so why aren't you trying to do it between 9am and 6pm instead?

I don't think you will out yourself by saying what you do for a living, broadly. What would you need to do to move further up in rank? What qualifications do the people at your worklace who earn 30k have, that you do NOT have, and how can you spend the next whatever number of months getting them?

By all means take the bar job for 6 months to sort out this immediate crisis, but there aren't enough hours in the day for you to work your way out of this if you stay on minimum wage forever. Better to make a salary jump.

Also, have you never had a salary review? It could be that if you have been there for 10 years, you may well be indispensible (indespensible?) and if you go to them with a realistic job offer and salary bump from elsewhere they might (have to) raise your salary to keep you.

OhwhyOY · 22/03/2023 12:59

OP what is the exact wording in your contract around second jobs? If it simply says 'seek permission' then you could argue that you fulfilled that clause by asking. I agree with others that if you had to go to an employment tribunal your employer would have to show how your new job would affect your current one, and why that was so problematic that despite your debt problems they couldn't accept it. If it's not a conflict of interest or overlapping hours then they really shouldn't be able to say no. Agree with other suggestions to discuss with HR rather than your manager. Re reference I'd give your old line manager and explain to the bar manager that your current line manager isn't keen on you taking a second job so you're working that through with him at the moment, hence not giving his details

Purplecatshopaholic · 22/03/2023 12:59

So it’s in your terms and conditions of employment that you must treat their job as your main job, and you must seek permission to take a second job. Therefore if you just take a second job without mentioning it, you will likely be disciplined (if they find out). This is what we would do (public sector). We rarely if ever say no though - as long as you continue to perform well in the main job. If you blatantly didn’t ask though, when you know you should that would likely count against you in the disciplinary process.

DeltaAlphaDelta79 · 22/03/2023 12:55

BrieAndChilli · 22/03/2023 12:51

the tax thing isnt that you are being taxed more on the second job, it is just that you have used up all your tax free allowance on the first job so all of your income is taxed o the second job.

Example below - with simplified figures for ease of explanation - so not real tax amounts)
Say both jobs pay £1000
Tax free allowance is £500

First job you pay £100 tax (1000-500 = 500 which is taxable and 20% of 500 is 100)
Second job you pay £200 tax (you have no tax free allowance so 20% of 1000 is 200)
So overall you take homw £1700 and pay £300 tax.

If you only had 1 job that paid you £2000 you would still pay £300 tax as 2000-500 tax free =£1500. 20% of £1500 =£300. So would still be bringing home £1700 it is just that with 2 jobs it looks like you get taxed more on the 2nd job. Is is not because you have 2 jobs, just that your income has risen. You will pay more tax on any increase of income over your tax free allowance regardless of where it came from.

Thank you for putting that in a way that I have finally been able to get my head around! At the time I was losing around one third of my secondary income in deductions, but could not work out why and no one was ever able to explain to me in a way that I could understand, but that makes sense to me now.

JustWaking · 22/03/2023 12:54

Call ACAS to ask them whether that clause is permitted, and whether your employer can refuse permission in this case.

Sometimes people put things in contracts which can't be legally enforced, and then you're not bound by it (they'll generally put in a severability clause so that even if one bit of the contract isn't valid then all the rest holds)

That type of clause seems intended to stop you from eg working for a competitor.

It doesn't seem at all reasonable for them to refuse it when there is no clash with your working time, and this is purely your choice about what to do with your free time.

And if it isn't reasonable, it might well not be binding. But do check with ACAS.

DeltaAlphaDelta79 · 22/03/2023 12:51

Talia99 · 22/03/2023 12:48

This isn’t necessarily true if both jobs are PAYE. I have two PAYE jobs (no option of claiming to be self employed because I’m clearly not). I am taxed at 20% up to the normal amount of earnings then at 40% on any amount over that. There is no special ‘35% tax in a second job’ rate.

Fair enough. Happy to be corrected. I know that I was losing more than I was expecting on my second job, and it was getting to the point it was becoming not worth my while.

BrieAndChilli · 22/03/2023 12:51

the tax thing isnt that you are being taxed more on the second job, it is just that you have used up all your tax free allowance on the first job so all of your income is taxed o the second job.

Example below - with simplified figures for ease of explanation - so not real tax amounts)
Say both jobs pay £1000
Tax free allowance is £500

First job you pay £100 tax (1000-500 = 500 which is taxable and 20% of 500 is 100)
Second job you pay £200 tax (you have no tax free allowance so 20% of 1000 is 200)
So overall you take homw £1700 and pay £300 tax.

If you only had 1 job that paid you £2000 you would still pay £300 tax as 2000-500 tax free =£1500. 20% of £1500 =£300. So would still be bringing home £1700 it is just that with 2 jobs it looks like you get taxed more on the 2nd job. Is is not because you have 2 jobs, just that your income has risen. You will pay more tax on any increase of income over your tax free allowance regardless of where it came from.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/03/2023 12:49

This is an absolute pisstake. They don't own you and cannot dictate what you do outside of your contracted hours. They may like to think they can, but they can't. Get the reference from your previous manager and if your current work find out and have an issue with it, tell them they can pay you more.

I agree - they aren't your mum, demanding that you go to bed early on a school night. If they deem those evening hours essential for you to be able to meet the demands of your job with them and dictate what you can/can't do with them, they should pay you for them as well; but no, they want it both ways.

Some jobs do have more restrictive requirements and fair 'exclusivity' clauses (albeit normally based around potential conflicts of interest), but they treat you as a professional and pay accordingly.

An employer paying NMW is telling you loud and clear that they wish they could pay you less - in accordance with how little they value you - and the only reason they can't is that the government has actively stepped in to prevent people like them from exploiting you.

Viviennemary · 22/03/2023 12:49

I dont see why the second job needs a reference. Can't you get one from a previous employer and explain your current employer is being awkward about a second job. And ask to be paid cash in hand.

breatheinskipthegym · 22/03/2023 12:49

I’d consider asking HR for permission rather than your manager. Contract/employment law is that clauses are unenforceable if they are not reasonable and proportionate. HR’s understanding of employment contracts (and duty of care towards staff) is likely to be more nuanced than your line manager’s.

As others have said, position it as a casual weekend gig, and explain how a) your financial circumstances make it necessary and b) it won’t impact your current position or ability to perform.

Give the new job details of your HR dept and your previous boss. They may well just be reassured by the fact that you’ve got referees, or they might just call up old boss for an informal chat (even though that’s not good practice, IME it’s often done in hospitality to get a feel for the candidate).

DeltaAlphaDelta79 · 22/03/2023 12:49

Charliesunnysky10 · 22/03/2023 12:48

@DeltaAlphaDelta79 You make a good point about being self employed but it's a whole new world to me and for the time being Id probably just be better taking this local work, till I get in better shape.

Yep completely understand. Just something I hadn't realised when I started. I do appreciate it might not be applicable to your situation tho.

Talia99 · 22/03/2023 12:48

DeltaAlphaDelta79 · 22/03/2023 12:32

Good luck.

One thing to bear in mind is that you will be taxed at a higher rate on a second job, I think I was losing somewhere around 35% of my income when I started my secondary job, so I went self employed and just send an invoice. I can claim my expenses/mileage/uniform costs etc against my earnings and pay less tax, legally and earn more.

I do the self assessment myself, altho a good friend who is accountant looked over the first couple of returns for me. I probably don't claim as much as I could, but its easy enough to do.

If you have the option to do that, it might be worth considering.

This isn’t necessarily true if both jobs are PAYE. I have two PAYE jobs (no option of claiming to be self employed because I’m clearly not). I am taxed at 20% up to the normal amount of earnings then at 40% on any amount over that. There is no special ‘35% tax in a second job’ rate.

Charliesunnysky10 · 22/03/2023 12:48

@DeltaAlphaDelta79 You make a good point about being self employed but it's a whole new world to me and for the time being Id probably just be better taking this local work, till I get in better shape.

OP posts:
DeltaAlphaDelta79 · 22/03/2023 12:47

gertrudemortimer · 22/03/2023 12:43

@SleepingStandingUp that reminds me of the time I had an incredibly drunk guy as a patient when I was a support worker after seeing him drink the night away in the club until 6am. I think he thought he was seeing things when he saw me!

@DeltaAlphaDelta79 I'm not an expert either but nobody should be paying more from two low paid jobs than if that income was from one stream. It should even out so you are paying what you would if it was all one income. Happy to accept I'm wrong though! It wouldn't surprise me if they wanted to punish low paid workers for trying to exist.

I agree nobody should be paying more taxes on a second job, but that was how it seemed to me, plus as mentioned, I did have additional expenses others might not.

Also happy to accept I am wrong too 😀

I found this online which might be useful

second job advice

Second job tax - how much will I have to pay? | reed.co.uk

Not sure how much tax you need to pay on your second job, or how it will affect your wages? We spoke with The Money Advice Service to find out...

https://www.reed.co.uk/career-advice/second-job-tax-how-much-will-i-have-to-pay/

Charliesunnysky10 · 22/03/2023 12:44

@Clarinet1 Yes, it's a possibility, but I'd say that the tax code will be the thing gives it away.

OP posts:
gertrudemortimer · 22/03/2023 12:43

@SleepingStandingUp that reminds me of the time I had an incredibly drunk guy as a patient when I was a support worker after seeing him drink the night away in the club until 6am. I think he thought he was seeing things when he saw me!

@DeltaAlphaDelta79 I'm not an expert either but nobody should be paying more from two low paid jobs than if that income was from one stream. It should even out so you are paying what you would if it was all one income. Happy to accept I'm wrong though! It wouldn't surprise me if they wanted to punish low paid workers for trying to exist.

Clarinet1 · 22/03/2023 12:42

I totally get your frustration at the debt but, if you take the bar job as well without telling the day job, what will you do if the day boss walks in? From what our say about not using public transport to work, home and both jobs must be fairly close together so it could be a possibility.

DeltaAlphaDelta79 · 22/03/2023 12:39

gertrudemortimer · 22/03/2023 12:34

You are not taxed at a higher rate but they tax you for both jobs on the one main income. At least I've never been taxed more! Sometimes your tax may take a while to catch up but they have always reimbursed me.

Sorry, yes I might have got my phrasing mixed up, it might not be the higher tax rate but I definitely paid more tax on my second job than my main job, and I never had it reimbursed. HMRC always told me that I would pay more tax on additional income if both were PAYE.

I do not profess to be an expert but I was paying extra costs, such as petrol, parking, clothing etc for my second job and after seeking advice from my accountant friend (who also did the secondary job with me) it seemed the sensible way forward for my situation.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/03/2023 12:36

blobby10 · 22/03/2023 11:51

Surely an employer cannot stop you taking on another job if it's outside of your normal hours, not in direct conflict with your day job and not for a competitor? I had a bar job alongside my very boring 9-5 hours for years when I was younger! Even now at 54 I'm considering taking on weekend work to try and make ends meet a little better. They'd better not try and stop me!

Been decade or so but I worked in social housing before kids, when I wanted a second job it had to be approved (as per contract) to show it didn't conflict. So working in the local pub, then having to deliver ASBOs to those same people for being loud drunks outside their house after closing hours would be an issue. Being a youth worker was not.

ittakes2 · 22/03/2023 12:35

Why don’t you just be honest with them and say your employer has said in the past no second job (check you are not breaking your contract) and can your friend give a reference for you

Swipe left for the next trending thread