Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled by this new system at the GPS

206 replies

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 09:11

Haven't had to go for a while but my DC needs to see a doctor. We used to call up in the morning to get a same day appointment or we could book in advance.. usually a two week wait. Called up this morning and told next available appointment is over a 4 week wait. I asked what happens if you need to someone more urgently. Was told that what happens is a paramedic will phone you and triage you over the phone. They then decide if you need to see a doctor. Wtf. I hate this stupid country.

There are so many conditions whereby you don't need urgent care but you also can't wait a month for help. Also, what about work and school. How do you know if you are going to be granted access to a doctor that day after your phone call from the paramedic? Do you keep your DC off school, do you take the day off work just in case they can see you?

As for myself I have several minor health niggles and in all honesty, it's not worth even trying to see a doctor so I just live with it. However, I obviously wouldn't do that when it comes to my DC.

To be fair, I felt sorry for the receptionist. No wonder so many people just turn up at A&E.

OP posts:
KnittedCardi · 22/03/2023 11:47

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 11:24

What else makes people confused is that a lot of these telephone consultation and triaging systems were brought in because of covid. A lot of people are left wondering why we are still doing it.

Because before Covid doctors were resisting the change. They actively campaigned against on-line GO's as they feared they would be out of a job.

Effectively forced into doing it because of Covid, it has, generally speaking, been a much better system. Many people actually prefer it. All the youngsters I know don't have GO's any more, they all subscribe to on-line services.

It will just take time to settle down, for everyone to get used to it, and for the Covid backlog to filter through.

TerfIngOnTheBeach · 22/03/2023 11:47

It’s taken me a while but I think I have it sussed now.

-ring GP at 8:00 AM avoid Mondays
-wait in queue for half an hour
-be told all urgent appointments have gone
-explain politely that I have a urine infection/acid reflux/boil on my bum and ask what is the best way to get some medical attention if there are no appointments available
-Receptionist has without fail then offered me a phone appointment the same day
-wait by the phone for a three hour slot for GP or nurse practitioner to call me (cut off Teams call “accidentally” if GP calls when I’m on one.
-GP will do consultation over phone then offer a prescription to collect or ask me to call in with a sample or for face to face.
-explain I work 20 miles away, surgery will then accommodate me at an evening or early morning appointment.

It is exhausting but it seems to work once you understand it and can manage your expectations.

Not perfect but it does cut out a lot of unnecessary face ti face visits. DS would rather have all phone appointments if possible, I don’t need a face to face to tell me I have cystitis and I don’t need an urgent same day appointment for that cyst on my neck that I’ve had for six months.

Wishiwasatailor · 22/03/2023 11:46

@TheVanguardSix lol the nurses in general practice are sat around drinking tea for the majority of the day 😂
Most GPNs are now managing all asthma and diabetes, contraception reviews, hypertension reviews, smears, all childhood vaccinations, dressings, all the ECGs/bloods/swabs that the GPs request, reviewing bloods and filing results, escalating any concerns. Sounds like an easy job I wonder why there is such a shortage for GPNs

80sMum · 22/03/2023 11:41

Our GP surgery has a similar system in place - and has done since a few years before the pandemic, so it wasn't that which triggered the change.

With ours, it's not a paramedic who calls you back, it's one of the GPs. They then decide if they need to examine you in person (in which case they offer an appointment) or whether you can have the consultation over the phone.

I can understand why they adopted this system, as previously they had an awful lot of time wasters, ie people making appointments for trivial matters that could be dealt with by over-the-counter meds or a quick chat with a pharmacist and people making appointments and then not turning up. However, it does have its downsides, namely:

  1. you never know when you'll get the call back from the GP and it could be at a very inconvenient moment, such as in the middle of a work meeting, while you're driving, while you're in the loo, while you're in the supermarket etc.

  2. it's so much less personal than a face to face chat. I find it much harder to say what I want to say.

  3. it's no good for people, like my DH, who have hearing loss and mishear things on the phone.

  4. it's not good for people, like me, who simply don't like talking on the telephone.

Wishiwasatailor · 22/03/2023 11:38

@jigsaw234 do you have consultants triaging in a&e or are they treating patients? What happens in nurse led urgent care settings? Paramedics and ANPs have advanced qualifications in assessment some with prescribing abilities. Totally appropriate for paramedics and ANPs to be triaging

Natsku · 22/03/2023 11:31

YANBU
Phone triage in itself is a good thing, but having to wait an indefinite time for a call back to find out if you need to take the day off or not is not good. That's not a system that works well.
Here I can call and a nurse answers the phone to triage over the phone, or I can go on the app and do an online consult with a nurse who can arrange an appointment if needed, or consult a doctor and get a prescription/treatment advice. Or if I know for sure my issue is urgent I can call the urgent number and get a same day appointment.

But a working system requires better and more appropriate funding.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 11:30

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 11:24

What else makes people confused is that a lot of these telephone consultation and triaging systems were brought in because of covid. A lot of people are left wondering why we are still doing it.

Demand for GP appointments has gone up since covid. Apparently total appointments in the three-month period September to November were up by 10% or more in a lot of areas compared with 2019. That’s not taking into account covid vaccinations. At the same time, GPs and other medical professionals are burning out and reducing their working hours.

2023Hope · 22/03/2023 11:29

it's a 7.5 week wait for a routine appointment where I live. Very depressing and worrying. Especially for those not able to question what they're being told by a surgery and just be accepting of what they've been offered, which sometimes will be to their detriment health wise.

My parents were like that, I swear I prolonged their lives by being pro active on their behalf and getting them seen when they really needed to be.

Sad times.

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 11:24

What else makes people confused is that a lot of these telephone consultation and triaging systems were brought in because of covid. A lot of people are left wondering why we are still doing it.

OP posts:
ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 11:19

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 11:15

An average person does not know this

We all have to learn new things when things change. Doesn’t mean the change is bad. As you’ll have read on this thread, plenty of other GP surgeries haven’t changed from the old system in response to greater pressure and not enough GPs to keep doing it the old way, and if you’d been registered with one of these you’d have been told to just call back tomorrow as no appointments were available.
Glad your dc is being seen, OP.

SmileyClare · 22/03/2023 11:18

I agree for low level infections (for eg) requiring a prescription delivered remotely, the system works adequately and saves time/resources.

Fir that sort of thing perhaps pharmacists should be permitted to issue anti biotics?

However, a friend continually rang and asked her doctor’s surgery to be seen for a catalogue of worrying symptoms: abdominal pain, constipation, fatigue etc. She was continually given phone appointments and diagnosed with IBS, constipation, even anxiety. When eventually referred fior an MRI months later she was diagnosed with late stage bowel cancer and died weeks later.

I can’t help think if she’d been seen by a gp who knew her, had built up a relationship with her (remember when that was a thing!) and didn’t assume she was being neurotic or anxious then they may have been more cautious or thorough in investigating, or at least seen her in person in the early stages!

This system is a blunt tool in dire circumstances but it’s failing a lot of people.

Hbh17 · 22/03/2023 11:18

Just wanting something done quickly does not make it "urgent" - very, very few things would actually fit that definition.
GPs have suffered for years because of the demands of "the worried well", so anything that properly prioritises access must be an improvement.
If only the cost of setting up and administering a payment system weren't so prohibitive, I'd say there are good arguments for asking people to pay for GP services - it would focus everyone's minds.

Beseen22 · 22/03/2023 11:18

I remember being triaged by a medical receptionist for a Dr appointment in 2008 when I collapsed at work so it is nothing new. It has now moved to an AHP/ANP triaging and I am much happier with that. That is a healthcare professional with a degree and registered under a professional body with significant experience and a further masters degree in advanced clinical practice.

My Gp is excellent, I put my request on the online chat in the morning and they will get back to you that day. For example the last time I spoke to them they booked me in with the phleb, then once results were back GP called and we had a phone appointment. The old system would have had me book in with GP, then another appt for bloods then another appt to discuss. That would have been 3 wasted appointments for me and for them. I have had another appt for backpain which was triaged and I was booked directly in with the physio that week, again saving wasting a GP appt. We have a pediatric ANP and pediatric GP and my children have never not been seen on the day if required. If my generation is able to use the online triage system effectively it frees up the phone lines for people with cognitive impairment/elderly who can't.

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 11:15

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 11:13

WHAT IS A PARAMEDIC. 'A paramedic works autonomously as a generalist clinician across a range of healthcare settings, usually in emergency, primary or urgent care. They may also specialise in clinical practice, education, leadership or research.

An average person does not know this

OP posts:
Comedycook · 22/03/2023 11:14

Ok, so they are seeing my ds today. I have calmed down a bit! I still thinks it's a crap system but I think a lot was lost in translation. The whole paramedic thing massively confused me...made me think it was like 111 were they just tell you to go to A&E...I assumed that's what they'd do. I'm not great under stress so my first thought was, they will see him in a month or they will send to a&e. What a choice! It's very horrible when your DC needs help and you feel that every step is a battle

OP posts:
Brunilde · 22/03/2023 11:14

TheVanguardSix · 22/03/2023 11:07

So granny can lie there with a broken hip at the bottom of the stairs for 7 hours waiting for a paramedic... the same guy who is now supposed to be readily available to 'triage' a worried mum through the more urgent matter of her son's earache (something the GP/nurse should just be available for!). Am I understanding these latest shenanigans correctly?
I was married to a GP. He'd been one for 30-plus years. Believe me, they have the fucking time to see their patients. They really do. And nurses... nurses in GP practices have loads of time. There is so much more they can be shouldering. It is ridiculous that the service of GPs and nurses is being outsourced to paramedics. How absolutely absurd.

No you aren't understanding at all.

They work at different places. The GP paramedic is not employed by the NHS or ambulance service. That's like expecting a tesco employee to jump on the till in Asda because there is a queue.

And just because your husband used to have loads of time doesn't mean that the majority of GPS do now. How ridiculous to think that one example from the past of reflective of a nationwide service.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 11:13

WHAT IS A PARAMEDIC. 'A paramedic works autonomously as a generalist clinician across a range of healthcare settings, usually in emergency, primary or urgent care. They may also specialise in clinical practice, education, leadership or research.

RemoteControlDoobry · 22/03/2023 11:12

Obviously the nhs is falling apart although I have to say that the ambulance service worries me far more than GP appointments. A few years ago people would have been concerned about a ten or fifteen minute wait and now we’ve kind of all accepted thirty two hour waits (which effectively means there is no service at all). You’d think there would be protests but people seem to have just sleepwalked into this rubbish and (conveniently) the government have made it far more difficult to protest.

Our GP will call back…they don’t specify a time usually but they’re pretty flexible about calling after school hours. Then if it’s necessary they will see us face to face immediately or they will book us an appointment within a week. I prefer this because it’s more convenient for me to not have to go in, it’s nice and quiet in the waiting room and I imagine it saves GPs a lot of time.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 11:10

TheVanguardSix · 22/03/2023 11:07

So granny can lie there with a broken hip at the bottom of the stairs for 7 hours waiting for a paramedic... the same guy who is now supposed to be readily available to 'triage' a worried mum through the more urgent matter of her son's earache (something the GP/nurse should just be available for!). Am I understanding these latest shenanigans correctly?
I was married to a GP. He'd been one for 30-plus years. Believe me, they have the fucking time to see their patients. They really do. And nurses... nurses in GP practices have loads of time. There is so much more they can be shouldering. It is ridiculous that the service of GPs and nurses is being outsourced to paramedics. How absolutely absurd.

No, you’re not understanding it correctly. Because it’s not the same guy that is supposed to be picking granny up off the floor. It’s someone who happens to have the same job title but works in a GP surgery. A bit like a ‘doctor’ doesn’t have to just work in a hospital.

TheVanguardSix · 22/03/2023 11:07

So granny can lie there with a broken hip at the bottom of the stairs for 7 hours waiting for a paramedic... the same guy who is now supposed to be readily available to 'triage' a worried mum through the more urgent matter of her son's earache (something the GP/nurse should just be available for!). Am I understanding these latest shenanigans correctly?
I was married to a GP. He'd been one for 30-plus years. Believe me, they have the fucking time to see their patients. They really do. And nurses... nurses in GP practices have loads of time. There is so much more they can be shouldering. It is ridiculous that the service of GPs and nurses is being outsourced to paramedics. How absolutely absurd.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 11:07

Deathbyfluffy · 22/03/2023 11:03

I'd be happy to have the system your GP has, OP - with ours you're pretty much just told 'no appointments left, ring again tomorrow'.
Seeing them for an ear infection was absolutely awful, in the end it was 111 who arranged the appointment for me (after being on hold for 45 minutes).

The whole system needs re-jigging - we need to look at a system like some European countries use where seeing a GP is £20 or so, but if you have a chronic condition or you're a child you are exempt.
I'd happily pay that to actually be able to see someone when I'm ill.

Well exactly, this is how I imagine it would be at our surgery without a triage system. If you only have a certain number of GPs, and you allow non medically qualified patients (or receptionists) to decide whether it’s a GP, or other medical professional, they need to see, in person or otherwise, then the result is that more appointments with the GP are used unnecessarily, and there will be fewer appointments available for all.

DannyZukosSmile · 22/03/2023 11:07

I agree, it is pretty crap @Comedycook . Like you, I used to be able to get a doctor's appointment the same day. And a face to face appointment within probably 5 to 8 working days. You could turn up at the surgery at 8.15am to 8.20am (10 to 15 minutes before the phone lines opened,) and there'd be anything between 8 and 16 people in the queue at the door.

You would put your name down to be seen by a doctor and by 9.30am to 9.45am, pretty much everyone was seen. They had 2 doctors allocated for the people who turned up 8.15-8.20am who would be dedicate that first hour, to hour and a half, to the people who came to the surgery. There was never more than 20.

It's not like that anymore. You have to ring dead on the dot of 8:30am or dead on the dot of 2.00pm to get callback from the doctor. THAT is just a call back, not an appointment. The the doctor (when he/she calls) will decide if they need/want to see you. If you ring 30 seconds after 8.30am or 2.00pm, you'll be like 25th in the queue, and there is very strong chance that you won't get a call back. (And you will not be seen!0

Unfortunately, I think we have to accept this is the way it is now. It's never going to be the same. There is a shortage of GP's, the population of the country is a lot more than it was 20-25 years ago and beyond, and I don't think things are ever going to be same again.

It's like with everything. Some 35-40 years ago you used to be able to pick what Council house you wanted. If you were on the list even just a few weeks, and you told the council you liked a particular house, then three to four weeks later, you would be offered that house. (In MY county anyway.) This was pre 1990s... Now you're lucky if you get housed within five years. AND you have to have what you're given.

AND you used to be able to guarantee an NHS dentist anywhere and everywhere you went. Now you're lucky to get one within a 10 mile radius, and even then they probably turn away two out of three people that want to join, as they are at capacity with their patients.

A&E waiting time now is between 10 and 12 hours - sometimes more. In our hospital when I took our kids (once or twice when they were little, maybe 25 years ago,) we spent maybe two hours from start to finish in A & E. DH went back in 2006 I think ... He was only in 3 hours from start to finish.. I know people now who are in there between 12 and 16 hours now.

You can't get half the stuff you want anymore. Half the food is missing, and what IS there is really expensive. Haircuts at the hairdressers costs three times more, and food costs double. Electric and gas is between double and triple. Mortgages are becoming unaffordable, private rents have doubled, and nothing is the same.

Nothing ever lasts. Electrical items only ever last two to three years instead of the original 15 to 20 years+ they did years ago. Clothes and shoes only last a year or two. I have several items of clothing that have lasted 20 to 30 years. Now I would be lucky to get 20 to 30 months out of an item of clothing.

Tldr. Just a little bit of a rant, but yeah, I'm with you. It is SHIT, but I don't think it's going to change anytime soon. I think we're stuck with this now. I'm knocking on for 60 now and to be quite honest I'm glad I am in the early winter years of my life. I don't think I could live another 50-60 years with life as shit as it is right now. I feel sad and disillusioned and worried for the NHS, and if I will have enough money to live on as a pensioner. SO many pensions have tanked. What if mine does? What if the STATE pension does?

Dark times indeed.

Deathbyfluffy · 22/03/2023 11:03

I'd be happy to have the system your GP has, OP - with ours you're pretty much just told 'no appointments left, ring again tomorrow'.
Seeing them for an ear infection was absolutely awful, in the end it was 111 who arranged the appointment for me (after being on hold for 45 minutes).

The whole system needs re-jigging - we need to look at a system like some European countries use where seeing a GP is £20 or so, but if you have a chronic condition or you're a child you are exempt.
I'd happily pay that to actually be able to see someone when I'm ill.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 22/03/2023 11:00

It is shit, and I believe just as much time is wasted on triage episodes first online, then a call from a nurse, then a call from a registrar, then you need to make an in-person appointment...in the past you would have been in and out in 5 minutes. But this way their activity looks huge (when activity of any real value is low) and patients' time is wasted freely because it has no cost to the surgery.

NannyR · 22/03/2023 10:59

Thriwit · 22/03/2023 10:21

My GP surgery is almost unusable now. You have to call at 8am, keep redialling. If you get through, the receptionist asks lots of questions, and tries to talk you out of needing a GP. If you get past that stage, a doctor will probably call you back at some point that day. That doctor then might decide they need to see you, maybe that day, maybe tomorrow. If you don’t take the exact appointment you’re given, they won’t offer any others. If you miss a call, you have to start again the next day.

I start work at 8am, and I work predominantly in labs. I can’t keep redialling all morning, and I can’t always answer my phone. If DC are ill, they usually stay home with DH - but he’s not their father therefore doesn’t have PR so can’t take them to the doctor.

The surgery don’t have any e-consult, won’t deal with emails, and don’t book future appointments.

I find it frustrating that some surgeries seem to be much more accessible

A bit of a derail from the thread, but you don't have to have parental responsibility to take a child to the GP - as a nanny, I regularly take my charges to medical appointments, you need to have a signed letter from the parent for vaccinations but I've never been asked for one for a GP appointment and I always make it clear that I am not the child's parent.