Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled by this new system at the GPS

206 replies

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 09:11

Haven't had to go for a while but my DC needs to see a doctor. We used to call up in the morning to get a same day appointment or we could book in advance.. usually a two week wait. Called up this morning and told next available appointment is over a 4 week wait. I asked what happens if you need to someone more urgently. Was told that what happens is a paramedic will phone you and triage you over the phone. They then decide if you need to see a doctor. Wtf. I hate this stupid country.

There are so many conditions whereby you don't need urgent care but you also can't wait a month for help. Also, what about work and school. How do you know if you are going to be granted access to a doctor that day after your phone call from the paramedic? Do you keep your DC off school, do you take the day off work just in case they can see you?

As for myself I have several minor health niggles and in all honesty, it's not worth even trying to see a doctor so I just live with it. However, I obviously wouldn't do that when it comes to my DC.

To be fair, I felt sorry for the receptionist. No wonder so many people just turn up at A&E.

OP posts:
DannyZukosSmile · 22/03/2023 13:06

@Natsku

Phone triage in itself is a good thing, but having to wait an indefinite time for a call back to find out if you need to take the day off or not is not good. That's not a system that works well.

Well, exactly this. As somebody said (sarcastically) further back in the thread... 'They can't just make a note of whatever time Susan or Jeff are available, like one's available 10.30 to 11am, and another's available between one and two pm.. lalala' But it's true, some people CANNOT just sit there and wait for a phone call that will be between 8.30am and fucking 6 at night!

The fact is, most people will be at work and are not fortunate enough to work from home in an admin kind of field, or even working in an office. Many are not able to sit next to their phone on their desk, and are not just going to be able to answer a random call from a doctor (when they don't know when it's coming.)

What about people that work on the frontline, like at checkouts or behind the counter in a shop or in a pharmacy or a bakery or butchers or supermarket, or whatever. They can't just stand there with their bloody mobile phone and answer the doctor, in the middle of serving somebody. I am sure some people think that most people are doing nothing with their day, and don't work. Some schools are the same. Assume every parent (mother usually) has fuck all else to do but work around THEM.

Another thing that doesn't work, and is a stupid stupid idea is the 'hospital admin team/bookings team'... just sending out random appointments to people for a specialist...or a certain clinic appointment. They need to do what they used to do and send a letter with a code name and a password for people to select a time and a date themselves.

Like on the GP surgery website, (before covid,) you could select your own appointment, but since March 2020 - 3 years now, online booking for doctor's appointment is still suspended. Why? Why is it still suspended? Absolutely ludicrous. It was so much easier booking online to suit YOU. Why have they not resumed this? And why have hospital bookings teams not resumed this?

But yeah, with them sending out 'specialist' appointments with appointments convenient for them and not for you, this does not work! Almost every time myself and my husband (and quite a few people I know of,) have a hospital/clinic appointment, we have to ring up and change it because we're at work and can't get the time off. And then what they do is they will send you another appointment, and of course that's fucking inconvenient as well.

My DH has had a second or third appointment and it's still inconvenient - and he just ends up booking the morning or afternoon off. And then at least one in three times it ends up being cancelled on the day of the appointment when he booked the time off. Absolutely infuriating.

I remember somebody complaining profusely about this on a thread once, (about 4-5 years ago,) and they got absolutely slaughtered. Told they were horrible, and vile, and an ungrateful twat, and they didn't deserve the NHS and there were a DISGRACE for complaining - about constantly getting these times and days that were inconvenient for them and they wish they could choose.

I mean, we pay for the National Health Service, I think we have a right to complain about it. Yes, it's great to have a National Health Service, but it isn't perfect, and it does have its flaws, and I think we have a right to say that.

SouthCountryGirl · 22/03/2023 13:00

Natsku · 22/03/2023 12:58

Sometimes you need to see a GP for those things. I had headaches, if I had gone to a pharmacist I'd have been directed to the appropriate painkillers but nothing else (and probably told to go to the doctor anyway if they don't help) but I went to the doctor, got a thorough examination to rule out anything serious and a referral to physiotherapy because the cause was musculoskeletal - painkillers wouldn't help in that situation.

Exactly. I've had migraine for over 10 years now. The pharmacy won't be able to do anything. And the last time I had constipation I had to speak to my GP as it was the medication I was taking.

Natsku · 22/03/2023 12:58

jackstini · 22/03/2023 12:40

Did you go to the pharmacist?

Our GP has a notice up specifically asking that for certain things, that the pharmacist should be the first port of call, to try and free up appointments for things that definitely need to be seen by a doctor

Noone should go to the GP for any of the below:
Cough/cold
Headache/migraine
Sickness
Aches/pains
Rash
Emergency contraception
Diarrhea or constipation
Cystitis
Red eye
Earache
Teething
Athlete's foot

If everyone stopped going to the docs with these, there would be far more appointments for everyone!

Sometimes you need to see a GP for those things. I had headaches, if I had gone to a pharmacist I'd have been directed to the appropriate painkillers but nothing else (and probably told to go to the doctor anyway if they don't help) but I went to the doctor, got a thorough examination to rule out anything serious and a referral to physiotherapy because the cause was musculoskeletal - painkillers wouldn't help in that situation.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 12:54

SmileyClare · 22/03/2023 12:31

Well no . Patients could be put in a (virtual) queue and told an approximate window of time in the day when they should expect the call.

For example, “a doctor will ring you between 5- 6pm” The patient can fit their day around that, taking an hour or so off work, instead of a whole day.

To be fair, that is what my GP does. But you’d still have people complaining that they can’t be free at that time 🤷‍♀️ And it also means you have to be pretty confident about how long it’s going to take you to phone each person in that virtual queue. Person 1 takes 3 minutes. Person 2, 5. Person 3, oh they didn’t answer. Now I have to call them back. By the time you get to person 30, what time is it? I think that’s pretty hard to calculate, and if you do try, and get it wrong, person 13 is now complaining that you missed their window and they had to go back to work. It’s never going to be perfect, and I agree, some do it better than others.

MrsPnut · 22/03/2023 12:48

Our GP surgery has been using a triage system for many years - as long as we have been at the practice and that's 10 years pre covid.

The current triage hours are 8-11 and 2-4 daily - you just call and ask to be added to the triage list then a GP or Nurse Practitioner call you back and either advise, prescribe or ask you to attend a f2f appointment the same or next day.

You can also do an online consult which can included adding a photo if required.
I did an online consult for my teenager yesterday because she has been getting progressively worse since she had a UTI 2 months ago that she had antibiotics for (done via triage). The Nurse Practitioner sent a secure text reply to say that she wanted her to have a f2f appointment and urine dip.
I called at 6pm last night and was given an 8:30am appointment for today. We've been, given antibiotics, urine dipped and sent off for culture. bloods appointment made for post antibiotics and if the culture comes back positive then they will arrange an ultrasound for her. Bloods will also check her iron and vitamin D because of other issues we discussed today.

Our surgery is amazing and they manage a huge caseload with 3 GP's and 3 Nurse Practitioners because this system frees up so much of their time.

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 12:48

jackstini · 22/03/2023 12:40

Did you go to the pharmacist?

Our GP has a notice up specifically asking that for certain things, that the pharmacist should be the first port of call, to try and free up appointments for things that definitely need to be seen by a doctor

Noone should go to the GP for any of the below:
Cough/cold
Headache/migraine
Sickness
Aches/pains
Rash
Emergency contraception
Diarrhea or constipation
Cystitis
Red eye
Earache
Teething
Athlete's foot

If everyone stopped going to the docs with these, there would be far more appointments for everyone!

I'm not sure about this list. When my dd was younger she had long term constipation. The sachets of stool softener that were suitable for children were only available on prescription. I actually asked the pharmacist for them and they said I needed a prescription.

OP posts:
Sensibletrousers · 22/03/2023 12:42

Our practice have an online system - you click through it selecting who you need to see (nurse / GP / face to face / phone) and the nature of the problem, it then gets triaged internally and you either get a text with a future appointment or a call to come into a Rapid Access appointment.

Just yesterday morning I sent my online request to see a nurse for wound care and they called me within an hour and I had a nurse appointment at 5pm.

Same for whenever I need an appointment for one of my DC - if you are specific about what you need they usually can offer the appropriate appointment... and no hanging on for an hour listening to hold music and "you are 18th in the queue"...

It's not the triage part that is the problem - that works well - it's the telephone part.

jackstini · 22/03/2023 12:40

Did you go to the pharmacist?

Our GP has a notice up specifically asking that for certain things, that the pharmacist should be the first port of call, to try and free up appointments for things that definitely need to be seen by a doctor

Noone should go to the GP for any of the below:
Cough/cold
Headache/migraine
Sickness
Aches/pains
Rash
Emergency contraception
Diarrhea or constipation
Cystitis
Red eye
Earache
Teething
Athlete's foot

If everyone stopped going to the docs with these, there would be far more appointments for everyone!

Thriwit · 22/03/2023 12:38

NannyR · 22/03/2023 10:59

A bit of a derail from the thread, but you don't have to have parental responsibility to take a child to the GP - as a nanny, I regularly take my charges to medical appointments, you need to have a signed letter from the parent for vaccinations but I've never been asked for one for a GP appointment and I always make it clear that I am not the child's parent.

I said similar at the time! What about nannies etc. I was told they’ll only see DC with someone with PR, because someone with PR would have to agree to any treatment, so it would be a waste of time seeing children unless alongside someone with PR. It’s very frustrating!

HootyMcBooby76 · 22/03/2023 12:31

Our GP surgery is terrible.
You have to phone up at 8am, where you are instantly put in a queue after listening to a literal 3 minute speech about Covid government mandates etc.
I've been connected at 8am and was already somehow number 50 something in the queue. If you get through and there are no appointments left - tough. Try again tomorrow.
If you are lucky enough to get an appointment, you are allocated 10 minutes and no more. If you run out of time, you need to go through the whole rigmarole again to get another appointment. Case in point, I was there to discuss some worrying symptoms. I'm NEVER at the doctors, there have been spaces of 7 years or more when I've not been to the GP. During the appointment the GP decided to take bloods, but had run out of time. I was told to make another appointment to do bloods so had to do the whole thing again (anyone decent at taking bloods can do it in about 30 seconds). Then I couldn't get another appointment for TWO weeks.
To my mind it just clogs up the system and takes up more appointments, I cannot see the logic in it at all.

When I eventually got the blood results, the doctor phoned me and told me they needed to see me face to face to discuss them. I asked if I could make an appointment while they were on the phone. Nope. Phone at 8am tomorrow morning........

And to top it off, EVERY time I've been there in the past few months, the waiting room has literally been DEAD. Maybe one other person.
I'm not sure what is going on but it's not the service I remember from what was once a great practice.

justteanbiscuits · 22/03/2023 12:31

We're not saying it's tickity. Or it's brilliant.

We're saying there is a massive shortage of GP's and there are not enough appointments to go round. That, sadly, isn't something that can be changed easily, and it will get worse and worse. They can't create extra appointments out of thin air. The only way to have phone triage to remove those that don't need an appointment.

When people are bitching about too many GP's going part time - remember, a 40 hour week is what a "part time" GP would work. 60+ hours for full time. This isn't what they're paid for, obviously, but it is the reality.

Sadly, we need to find the best way of working with what we have - not what we wish we had.

SmileyClare · 22/03/2023 12:31

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 11:52

The argument about the call back being at any time. Don’t get me wrong, I get that it’s frustrating, it is for me too. But what’s the alternative? Bob works in a job where he only has his phone at lunchtime. Right, triage person can call him at lunchtime. Jane has a break at 10.30 because she works in a school. Right, they need to be called at 10.30. Hang on, now we have an appointments system to be triaged for the appointments system…..So we might as well just revert to one appointments system. Except, oh yeah, we don’t have enough GPs for that. So we’re back to ‘sorry, no more appointments, you can have one next month, or call again tomorrow for the limited number of same day appointments.’ Or, we throw (huge amounts of) money at the problem, and have more GPs (I’ll ignore the fact that this takes time, and they need to come from somewhere). Huge amounts of money isn’t something this country has at the moment, and if we throw it at this, to allow for everyone to be able to make a GP appointment when they want, based around their own personal schedules and circumstances, and regardless of whether it’s actually a GP they need to see, then it won’t be available for other things. Personally, I think that it’s probably a good compromise.

Well no . Patients could be put in a (virtual) queue and told an approximate window of time in the day when they should expect the call.

For example, “a doctor will ring you between 5- 6pm” The patient can fit their day around that, taking an hour or so off work, instead of a whole day.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 12:31

justteanbiscuits · 22/03/2023 12:25

Someone disagrees and they must have Stockholm syndrome. 🙄

Yes, and since in most European countries you have to pay to see a GP, I bet if you told someone in one of those countries that people in the UK expect to be able to see a GP on demand completely for free, they’d also be amazed.

jigsaw234 · 22/03/2023 12:28

Wishiwasatailor · 22/03/2023 11:38

@jigsaw234 do you have consultants triaging in a&e or are they treating patients? What happens in nurse led urgent care settings? Paramedics and ANPs have advanced qualifications in assessment some with prescribing abilities. Totally appropriate for paramedics and ANPs to be triaging

A&E is different as the triage is to do with whether it's an emergency or not - triage is more complex in primary care. I'm not saying that it's wrong for paramedics to do it, I was replying to the idea that it's a waste of senior staff time to do triage, which isn't the case.

justteanbiscuits · 22/03/2023 12:25

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 09:30

If you think it's a good system you must have Stockholm syndrome.

I bet if you told someone from any developed country that in the UK, you can't routinely take your child to see a doctor, they'd be horrified.

We are not wealthy but we're reasonably comfortable...DH just said worse comes to the worse, we will have to see a gp privately and suck up the cost. I feel like this is exactly what they want. We already pay for private speech therapy because the NHS discharged us.

Someone disagrees and they must have Stockholm syndrome. 🙄

Idontgiveagriffindamn · 22/03/2023 12:24

We’ve had this system (nurse / doctor triage rather than paramedic) for a few years and it works fine for us. I’ve never been able to not get an appointment if needed. My surgery’s definition of urgent is broad - basically something that cannot wait for 4 weeks.
Plus there is now more flexibility around telephone appointments. Also if I just need a prescription often that’s dealt with at triage rather than taking a doctors appointment.

HurryShadow · 22/03/2023 12:15

I haven't had to call the doctors for a long time, thankfully, but I've just looked on their website for what the process is and it's as clear as mud!

Surgery opening times 8.30 - 18.30
Telephone lines open from 8.00 for emergencies and 8.30 for everything else

Urgent appointments are available for emergencies only, please telephone early (after 8.30am) if you need an urgent appointment

I do like the idea of a triage system so that only people that really need an appointment get seen (rather than someone that could wait 3 weeks stating that they have an "emergency" just to get seen), but I understand OPs issues with what do you do in the meantime.

In an ideal world, the person doing the triaging would be the one answering the phone in the first place but I suspect that would put even more pressure on the system as the queue gets longer while people wait.

GabriellaMontez · 22/03/2023 11:58

Of course it's rubbish. Some people will defend anything. My Gp is excellent. Nothing like this. Have you tried elsewhere?

tenbob · 22/03/2023 11:56

KnittedCardi · 22/03/2023 11:47

Because before Covid doctors were resisting the change. They actively campaigned against on-line GO's as they feared they would be out of a job.

Effectively forced into doing it because of Covid, it has, generally speaking, been a much better system. Many people actually prefer it. All the youngsters I know don't have GO's any more, they all subscribe to on-line services.

It will just take time to settle down, for everyone to get used to it, and for the Covid backlog to filter through.

It’s a lot more complex than that…

GPs were resisting the emergence of non-geographic online GP services who were allowed to accept and reject patients.

A community GP is obliged to accept any eligible patient and can’t turn someone away if, for example, they will need lots of appointments for a chronic health condition.

The way most GPs balance their workload is by having a cross section of patients on their books - the ones who have loads and loads of appointments but also the ones that hardly ever come in.

But the online GPs have been set up to take all the low-maintenance patients and all their funding, and leaving all the high-maintenance ones for the local practice

The government reformed the system to allow the online services to come in and cherry pick patients but didn’t have any answer for how it would impact the traditional practices

and at the same time, they hadn’t given any clear instructions on how a traditional GP could start offering video appointments without a multi-million pound app to deliver it

Nocaloriesinchocolate · 22/03/2023 11:55

My GP did something very sensible a few weeks ago. I had a phone appointment at which my ailment was identified and she prescribed far more tablets than needed for that bout (its not a ‘complete the course’’ medication, but a ‘take while symptoms last’ one) because, as she said, I could take the tablets when the ailment recurred without needing to approach the surgery.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 22/03/2023 11:52

elevenplusdilemma · 22/03/2023 09:34

Same at our Drs. It's a nightmare. First time we did it, I sent child to school (5 miles from home in one direction) and went to work (10 miles in the other direction). Paramedic called at 9:30 and said child needed to be seen by Dr, offering a 10am appointment. I explained that it was not possible for me to leave work, collect child from school and return to surgery in the next 30 mins and asked if I could have an appointment later that day (or even next day or two as not really urgent). Reply was no. I'd have to do the whole thing again the next day if I couldn't accept the offered appointment.
So following day, kept child home, booked day off work and repeated the exercise. Waited until 2pm for the call back and got offered a 5pm appointment meaning we'd both stayed home for nothing. School asked for evidence of medical appointment and so we got served a warning for having unauthorised absence as the appointment fell outside of school hours.

And this demonstrates why it is so difficult for many, many people.

It's not acceptable. I don't want to live like a boiled frog, accepting more and more and more . . . . It's a mess.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 11:52

The argument about the call back being at any time. Don’t get me wrong, I get that it’s frustrating, it is for me too. But what’s the alternative? Bob works in a job where he only has his phone at lunchtime. Right, triage person can call him at lunchtime. Jane has a break at 10.30 because she works in a school. Right, they need to be called at 10.30. Hang on, now we have an appointments system to be triaged for the appointments system…..So we might as well just revert to one appointments system. Except, oh yeah, we don’t have enough GPs for that. So we’re back to ‘sorry, no more appointments, you can have one next month, or call again tomorrow for the limited number of same day appointments.’ Or, we throw (huge amounts of) money at the problem, and have more GPs (I’ll ignore the fact that this takes time, and they need to come from somewhere). Huge amounts of money isn’t something this country has at the moment, and if we throw it at this, to allow for everyone to be able to make a GP appointment when they want, based around their own personal schedules and circumstances, and regardless of whether it’s actually a GP they need to see, then it won’t be available for other things. Personally, I think that it’s probably a good compromise.

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 11:51

I was on hold for over half an hour before anyone answered the call. Luckily dh took our other DC to school this morning

OP posts:
LakieLady · 22/03/2023 11:49

twinkleto · 22/03/2023 09:32

It's a disgraceful system. I understand that it helps to stop "time wasters" booking a face to face consultation with a GP but it's at the detriment of most other people. I also am not able to sit at my phone ringing 20+ times to get through and then if I do get through, have my phone on me at all times to answer a call from the GP at some point that day. They refuse to ring back a second time if you miss it.

The refusal to ring back if you miss the call is pretty poor, unless they ring you bang on the appointed time.

My GP will keep trying till they get hold of you. They realise that people may be busy at work etc. And it's just as well, as sometimes they're a couple of hours late ringing you.

WhatHaveIFound · 22/03/2023 11:48

We have a 6-12 week wait for pre-booked appointments though I managed to book my DS a same day one last week (on the third day I'd tried). Unfortunately they won't let me book the further tests he needs because the doctor forgot to add it to his notes that he had agreed he was happy for me to arrange these.

The whole system is struggling on but as long as people keep voting Conservative it won't get any better!

Swipe left for the next trending thread