Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled by this new system at the GPS

206 replies

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 09:11

Haven't had to go for a while but my DC needs to see a doctor. We used to call up in the morning to get a same day appointment or we could book in advance.. usually a two week wait. Called up this morning and told next available appointment is over a 4 week wait. I asked what happens if you need to someone more urgently. Was told that what happens is a paramedic will phone you and triage you over the phone. They then decide if you need to see a doctor. Wtf. I hate this stupid country.

There are so many conditions whereby you don't need urgent care but you also can't wait a month for help. Also, what about work and school. How do you know if you are going to be granted access to a doctor that day after your phone call from the paramedic? Do you keep your DC off school, do you take the day off work just in case they can see you?

As for myself I have several minor health niggles and in all honesty, it's not worth even trying to see a doctor so I just live with it. However, I obviously wouldn't do that when it comes to my DC.

To be fair, I felt sorry for the receptionist. No wonder so many people just turn up at A&E.

OP posts:
CoffeeWithCheese · 22/03/2023 14:50

Our GP practice has gone to second-bottom in the county for actually seeing patients face to face post-covid. I used to be a big fan of their ability to ring and request a telephone appointment if it was something that you just needed a yes or no or point of clarification for - but it was backed with the ability to actually get an appointment face to face if one was needed with either the GP or nurse.

Now you can't get a telephone appointment and you have no chance of a face to face consult - you get told someone will call randomly at some point during the day (which can go as late as 9pm) and often no one will even call and you repeat this for days at a time... I had to have a prescription medication review which they wanted to do over the phone - a month wait for the unspecified some point in the day appointment slot over the telephone, which then wasn't kept and then I got shunted back for a good week and a half - by which point I was dangerously near running out of the prescription I'd booked in to have reviewed as soon as I was told I needed to do so! It was not a prescription I should risk stopping cold turkey either without consequences - so very very stressful, and also really hard to do my own job when I have to be on standby in case of a phonecall for a good week+ at a time while seeing my own patient list! In the end when I did get to speak to them I had to plan how to taper off the medication anyway as I couldn't risk being put in this situation next time the computer decided I needed a medication review... so I'll take raging depression, anxiety, reduced ability to function and shitty quality of life instead now.

I currently have an ear infection - I've paid to go have my ears microsuctioned privately as I had fuck all hearing at all left, one was blocked with wax so I now at least have one functioning ear, but the other has a clear infection in it (I've seen the camera stills and sat in on enough audiology lectures on my own degree) - GP prescribed antibiotics over the phone but they've not fully shifted it and can't get to see/speak to them at all to see if it needs more treatment. It's a mess.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 14:47

latetothefisting · 22/03/2023 14:36

The idea of a triage system is fine
The basic principle of splitting medical issues into

  1. need treatment NOW (i.e. a&e job)
  2. need treatment as soon as possible (gp -urgent, to be seen today)
  3. need medical attention in the near future (gp - advance appointment)
  4. time wasters who can be put off Is fine

The problem is when the difference between 2 and 3 isn't a few days but at least a month!
There are a lot of things that can wait a day or two but not 4-6 weeks!

I'm thinking things like find a lump in your breast/elsewhere, suspected tonsillitis, anxiety or other MH concern where theres not an immediate danger to life but similarly you cant wait 4 weeks to even start trying antidepressants/get referred to support services/need an abortion/ear infection/abscess or boil that won't heal/need a sick note/ongoing or repeated issues like stomach upset/constipation/etc that wouldn't need medical attention as a one off but as an ongoing or repeated issue might be indicative of something more dangerous/need a sick note for work etc.

If there’s an immediate danger to life it’s an A&E job, no? My experience of my GP is that a lot of the examples you give would be classed as urgent. Some of the others would be triaged away - sick notes you request online, our GP surgery has a mental health nurse….

latetothefisting · 22/03/2023 14:45

jackstini · 22/03/2023 12:40

Did you go to the pharmacist?

Our GP has a notice up specifically asking that for certain things, that the pharmacist should be the first port of call, to try and free up appointments for things that definitely need to be seen by a doctor

Noone should go to the GP for any of the below:
Cough/cold
Headache/migraine
Sickness
Aches/pains
Rash
Emergency contraception
Diarrhea or constipation
Cystitis
Red eye
Earache
Teething
Athlete's foot

If everyone stopped going to the docs with these, there would be far more appointments for everyone!

Agree with others who have said you can't have a list of absolutes

E.g. obviously there's no need to go to the gp for 1 headache/migraine but at some point you will need to be seen to get anti migraine medication prescribed. If you have repeated heavy headaches all of a suddent of course you need this checked out because it could be indicative of a brain tumour!

Diarrhea or constipation for a day is not a GP issue - diarrhea for several days is incredibly dangerous and can lead to death due to dehydration

Rash - could be sepsis

Even things like emergency contraception - obviously ideally you should buy it but if you can't afford £25/£35 so need a GP to prescribe it for free, the cost of a one-off very short appointment for that is flipping cheaper to the NHS overall than having a baby! If pharmacists could prescribe it for free thats a different matter but only a few can.

latetothefisting · 22/03/2023 14:36

The idea of a triage system is fine
The basic principle of splitting medical issues into

  1. need treatment NOW (i.e. a&e job)
  2. need treatment as soon as possible (gp -urgent, to be seen today)
  3. need medical attention in the near future (gp - advance appointment)
  4. time wasters who can be put off Is fine

The problem is when the difference between 2 and 3 isn't a few days but at least a month!
There are a lot of things that can wait a day or two but not 4-6 weeks!

I'm thinking things like find a lump in your breast/elsewhere, suspected tonsillitis, anxiety or other MH concern where theres not an immediate danger to life but similarly you cant wait 4 weeks to even start trying antidepressants/get referred to support services/need an abortion/ear infection/abscess or boil that won't heal/need a sick note/ongoing or repeated issues like stomach upset/constipation/etc that wouldn't need medical attention as a one off but as an ongoing or repeated issue might be indicative of something more dangerous/need a sick note for work etc.

thinkfast · 22/03/2023 14:35

Wow. I think we are so lucky at our GP atm. I rang them one morning last week to book an advance appointment and was able to book one for that afternoon. While I was waiting a man came into book an appointment and was able to be seen in 15 mins. Perhaps it was just a quiet day....

jigsaw234 · 22/03/2023 14:24

Astrabees · 22/03/2023 14:22

We have given up with our GP. Although it is £120 for half an hour or £60 for telephone consultation I now see a lovely private GP who takes a very holistic approach. She works part time in an NHS practice and private part time too.

And that's the crux of it. In the NHS we get £120 per patient per year. Whereas the realistic cost is £120 for a single half-hour appointment. how can we ever provide the service that people want?

Astrabees · 22/03/2023 14:22

We have given up with our GP. Although it is £120 for half an hour or £60 for telephone consultation I now see a lovely private GP who takes a very holistic approach. She works part time in an NHS practice and private part time too.

Rebel2 · 22/03/2023 14:20

jackstini · 22/03/2023 12:40

Did you go to the pharmacist?

Our GP has a notice up specifically asking that for certain things, that the pharmacist should be the first port of call, to try and free up appointments for things that definitely need to be seen by a doctor

Noone should go to the GP for any of the below:
Cough/cold
Headache/migraine
Sickness
Aches/pains
Rash
Emergency contraception
Diarrhea or constipation
Cystitis
Red eye
Earache
Teething
Athlete's foot

If everyone stopped going to the docs with these, there would be far more appointments for everyone!

Of course they should - sometimes

Rash - I've been because they wanted to check a rash on my breast wasn't cancer, and because I needed a referral for urticaria
Cough - chest infection and needed antibiotics
Cystitis - had a UTI, needed antibiotics
Pain in my shins - low vitamin D that needed a blood test

jigsaw234 · 22/03/2023 14:02

When we did pre-book appointments our rate of people not turning up was close to 20%.......that's a lot of wasted dr time

Grumpybutfunny · 22/03/2023 13:55

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 13:20

After reading this thread, I think I don't actually object so much to the idea of a triaging system. I can understand why it helps and weeds out people who don't need to be seen. What I find so frustrating is spending my whole morning whilst trying to organise two kids for school on hold for over half an hour....I'd happily fill out an online form.

Same at ours now I'm looking to move GP as most of the partners have left and the new lot don't seem interested in anything but same day appointments. It's a shame as it was good

inloveandmarried · 22/03/2023 13:52

We had the phone triage system during covid and it's now reverted back to being seen on same day appointments.

Having sadly needed to see the GP a lot in the last few years I can absolutely say the triage system worked well.

I found that speaking to someone within an hour or so was much more useful than an open GP clinic where you all queue outside at 8.30 and are all seen before lunchtime having sat in the surgery waiting room all morning.

Many times the need could be met rapidly without seeing a doctor but being authorised by a doctor. During the triage if you needed a face to face appointment you were booked in straight away.

You may find it works out well.

SmileyClare · 22/03/2023 13:51

Fair points @saraclara
Im sorry to read that about your husband Flowers

saraclara · 22/03/2023 13:47

SmileyClare · 22/03/2023 13:36

I don’t think anyone can disagree that it’s a system put in place out of necessity due to staff shortages, an ever increasing population, an obesity crisis and an enormous elderly community, a mental health explosion and no resources allocated to it, a woeful lack of funding and mismanagement from the top.

Its a basic net which filters out non urgent cases, the “worried well” (although I find that term used condescendingly)and “time wasters”.

The fact is many patients who need symptoms investigating are falling through the net, like my friend who struggled to be seen in person for months with her symptoms and was only referred for an MRI when she had a violent seizure at home and was vomiting blood. She died of advanced bowel cancer weeks later aged 43.
She was basically treated as a “worried well” on the phone and flung various tablets and laxatives to treat her symptoms without investigating a cause.

Sadly it was far from unusual to be misdiagnosed before phone apppointments came in. My DH was diagnosed with stage 4 incurable bowel cancer 18 months after he first went to the doctor about his symptoms. He was fobbed off with a diagnosis of piles.

In general I think this system is better. Oddly enough I've found the phone appointments less rushed than face to face ones. Maybe because they're more efficient? But of course anyone feeling that the phone appointment hasn't covered things well enough, can ask for a face to face one at the end. It might not be that day, but at least things are set in motion.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 13:43

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 13:20

After reading this thread, I think I don't actually object so much to the idea of a triaging system. I can understand why it helps and weeds out people who don't need to be seen. What I find so frustrating is spending my whole morning whilst trying to organise two kids for school on hold for over half an hour....I'd happily fill out an online form.

I was thinking about this, because I’ve been frustrated by this too. My GP used to do econsult and I loved it but they don’t now, I don’t know why. At a guess though, based on how many people in my own line of work can’t specify a fcking problem properly (“It’s broken”. How, in what way is it broken?!), I’d wonder how many of those econsults led to people having to be phoned back to get enough details to triage properly, and then you’re back to the problem of people being called back at inconvenient times. Or an extended electronic “conversation”
that takes many more times as long as a phone call would. I dunno. It’s shit. We need more GPs. But until the government does something about why we don’t have enough now, I have to give the GP surgeries the benefit of the doubt that they are managing demand and capacity as best they can.

SmileyClare · 22/03/2023 13:36

I don’t think anyone can disagree that it’s a system put in place out of necessity due to staff shortages, an ever increasing population, an obesity crisis and an enormous elderly community, a mental health explosion and no resources allocated to it, a woeful lack of funding and mismanagement from the top.

Its a basic net which filters out non urgent cases, the “worried well” (although I find that term used condescendingly)and “time wasters”.

The fact is many patients who need symptoms investigating are falling through the net, like my friend who struggled to be seen in person for months with her symptoms and was only referred for an MRI when she had a violent seizure at home and was vomiting blood. She died of advanced bowel cancer weeks later aged 43.
She was basically treated as a “worried well” on the phone and flung various tablets and laxatives to treat her symptoms without investigating a cause.

Sidge · 22/03/2023 13:30

@TheVanguardSix when were you married to a GP - 1962??

I'm quite insulted at your comments about practice nurses having nothing much to do. I'm an NP in a GP surgery - I've seen 19 patients this morning, just eating my lunch whilst doing my emails and admin tasks and have another 14 patients to see this afternoon.

I assess, treat, prescribe, manage and review patients with acute and chronic conditions, as well as doing all the other things practice nurses do. I have a specialism so teach student nurses and F2s in practice.

I'm hardly scrabbling around looking for work to do...

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 13:20

After reading this thread, I think I don't actually object so much to the idea of a triaging system. I can understand why it helps and weeds out people who don't need to be seen. What I find so frustrating is spending my whole morning whilst trying to organise two kids for school on hold for over half an hour....I'd happily fill out an online form.

OP posts:
ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 22/03/2023 13:20

Phone triaging makes complete sense and is a good use of resources.

EmmaDilemma5 · 22/03/2023 13:20

There aren't enough GPS. The ones that do exist tend to be aging and leaving due to the pressures on them.

It's a broken system. The first thing that needs to change is incentivising studying medicine and staying in the UK to practice. Many graduates go to Saudi, Dubai, Australia etc because the pay is massive and responsibility and pressure less.

The government need to focus on training and retaining staff. Otherwise, unfortunately, it's a case of managing resource as you've experienced.

If we privatise healthcare, we'll have to pay through the nose to get enough doctors to the country. I hope to god we keep the NHS, people would be scared at the costs of a private system.

stringbean · 22/03/2023 13:18

We have to do an e-consult to get an appointment - fill in a form online and they call you back within 48 hours. Last time I did this the e-consult system wasn't working - unbeknown to me - and they never called me. It wasn't urgent, but still something I needed to talk to a dr about - so I phoned the surgery (30 mins listening to music) and managed to secure a phone call appointment - this was for a date more than 6 weeks after my original e-consult request.

I have this week been prescribed something for the initial reason which prompted me to request an appointment in the first place - the whole process has taken 4.5 months. Required some blood tests (wait 2-3 weeks for this), then a call with GP to discuss (another 2 weeks), some blood results weren't processed so repeat the whole thing again. The whole system is utterly broken.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 13:16

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 13:15

Like on the GP surgery website, (before covid,) you could select your own appointment, but since March 2020 - 3 years now, online booking for doctor's appointment is still suspended. Why? Why is it still suspended?

Because there aren’t enough GPs to allow for enough appointments to allow everyone to book an appointment with the GP because they want one, when they want one. So they’ve put a system in to try to filter out the folk that are booking an appointment with the GP but actually need to see a physio. Or a nurse. Etc. I’ve been registered at GP surgeries that had online booking and no triage system, and they would make the appointments available, and people would book them, and then there would be no more. So someone who actually needed to be referred on for an appointment with the physio might get to see the GP unnecessarily, but someone else, who did need to see the GP, might miss out.

I don’t disagree that in an ideal world we would have enough GPs for that. I’d love that too. But we don’t.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 22/03/2023 13:15

Like on the GP surgery website, (before covid,) you could select your own appointment, but since March 2020 - 3 years now, online booking for doctor's appointment is still suspended. Why? Why is it still suspended?

Because there aren’t enough GPs to allow for enough appointments to allow everyone to book an appointment with the GP because they want one, when they want one. So they’ve put a system in to try to filter out the folk that are booking an appointment with the GP but actually need to see a physio. Or a nurse. Etc. I’ve been registered at GP surgeries that had online booking and no triage system, and they would make the appointments available, and people would book them, and then there would be no more. So someone who actually needed to be referred on for an appointment with the physio might get to see the GP unnecessarily, but someone else, who did need to see the GP, might miss out.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 22/03/2023 13:14

Lcb123 · 22/03/2023 09:24

Seems very sensible to me, my GP does this via a form on the website first. So much can be sorted via phone or message.

I wish my GP was that advanced, nothing can be done electronically - they stopped using email and any other electronic system.

You have to phone and, if you get through, explain what's wrong to the receptionist who in my experience doesn't write it down properly. The GP then calls back (no particular time, just wait and hope) and goes through it all again.

saraclara · 22/03/2023 13:10

Instead of calling, our GP now has a message triage service. You message with the issue via their website, a doctor reads it,triages, and in a short amount of time you get a text with a time frame that day for a phone appointment. If that phone appointment indicates that you need to be seen face to face, then that's arranged (or might be from the off if the message indicates it, but mine haven't needed it so I'm not sure).

It's pretty new, and at first everyone was convinced it was a stupid idea. But it's massively massively better, and our normally grumpy community FB page is full of praise for it. No hanging on the phone at 8am, and really prompt communication. Lst time I used it, I got the text back ten minutes after I messaged, and the phone appointment an hour later.

I'm all for the triage system, to be honest. And the phone appointments have been excellent, and saved a load of time and travelling to and from the surgery.
Obviously (older?) people without the tech ability can still call and the receptionist will do it all for them. But at least they'll be able to get through.

DannyZukosSmile · 22/03/2023 13:08

jackstini · 22/03/2023 12:40

Did you go to the pharmacist?

Our GP has a notice up specifically asking that for certain things, that the pharmacist should be the first port of call, to try and free up appointments for things that definitely need to be seen by a doctor

Noone should go to the GP for any of the below:
Cough/cold
Headache/migraine
Sickness
Aches/pains
Rash
Emergency contraception
Diarrhea or constipation
Cystitis
Red eye
Earache
Teething
Athlete's foot

If everyone stopped going to the docs with these, there would be far more appointments for everyone!

This is the most ludicrous post on this thread. Confused