Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled by this new system at the GPS

206 replies

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 09:11

Haven't had to go for a while but my DC needs to see a doctor. We used to call up in the morning to get a same day appointment or we could book in advance.. usually a two week wait. Called up this morning and told next available appointment is over a 4 week wait. I asked what happens if you need to someone more urgently. Was told that what happens is a paramedic will phone you and triage you over the phone. They then decide if you need to see a doctor. Wtf. I hate this stupid country.

There are so many conditions whereby you don't need urgent care but you also can't wait a month for help. Also, what about work and school. How do you know if you are going to be granted access to a doctor that day after your phone call from the paramedic? Do you keep your DC off school, do you take the day off work just in case they can see you?

As for myself I have several minor health niggles and in all honesty, it's not worth even trying to see a doctor so I just live with it. However, I obviously wouldn't do that when it comes to my DC.

To be fair, I felt sorry for the receptionist. No wonder so many people just turn up at A&E.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CoffeeWithCheese · 27/03/2023 20:20

I actually got asked on a call to the GP today - what I thought the problem was (in my case I do know, backed up by pretty solid evidence - and private ENT staff have looked at the images and verified that it's an ear infection), what I wanted to do - did I want more antibiotics or did I want the GP to "look at it"

I fear for those without that knowledge, or those who are drug seeking, or just those who still think antibiotics cure everything.

Welshmonster · 26/03/2023 11:08

please book your smear tests. It could save your life.

Whattodonut · 24/03/2023 14:17

But then at our GPs they do divide morning and afternoon. So if you call in the morning and its traiged as urgent (which children generally are) they'll call back before lunch.

Whattodonut · 24/03/2023 14:16

We have this system.
I quite like it. Its like a&e triage but not emergencies.
I'll give an example of it working:
My daughter has thrush. I wasnt sure it was but she was sore and red. She went to school. I called GP at 10ish. The paramedic called me back at lunchtime and talked it through with me. She agreed was worth seeing a doctor and found me an appointment within 2 days after school with a female GP. GP looked, prescribed cream.
A week later it wasn't clearing up so I called back. Receptionist tried to book me a face to face with GP but DD was in school and I said phone call would be better- then GP can decide if they need to see her or not.
They prescribed a new cream over the phone and said if it hadn't cleared up to call back in a week and outlined next steps.
Totally fit around us. No need to miss school. Less GP time used. All good

WalkingOnTheCracks · 24/03/2023 13:47

Starting at one minute to eight.......twenty-five minutes re-dialling every ten seconds until I don't get an engaged signal.

"Surgery."

"Hello, can I make an appointment for my daughter to see a doctor today please?"

"Is it an emergency?"

"I don't know."

"What are the symptoms?"

"Stomach pain and vomiting in the early hours."

"Might it have been something she ate?"

"I don't know. No one else in the family has got it."

"Is she still vomiting?"

"No, but she's still in pain. Can she be given an appointment?"

"Someone will call later on."

"When?"

"Between three and six."

"But she's in pain now. You mean no one's even going to assess her for - at best - six and a half hours, maybe ten?"

"Well, if it gets worse, take her to A&E."

"If it gets worse?"

"Or just take her anyway."

"What would I have to have said to have got her an appointment this morning?"

"You should have called at eight."

"I did call at eight."

"We're very busy. There's only two of us to answer the phone."

"I know this isn't your fault - but it's crap, isn't it?"

"Do you want a callback or not?"

"Yes, thank you. What choice do I have?"

"Well, as I say, you can take her to Accident and Emergency."

"I thought I was only supposed to do that if it's an emergency. Is it an emergency?"

"I don't know. I'm not a doctor."

"Neither am I! Actually, forget it. I'll take her to A&E. It's probably only a five or six hour wait. More importantly, if she does get worse, there will be doctors around the place. Though obviously we'll be increasing the wait for everyone there."

"Is there anything else I can do for you?"

"Else?.."

KnittedCardi · 24/03/2023 11:49

MaryMcCarthy · 24/03/2023 10:14

This is what a decade of neglect of public services looks like.

You can readily get a GP appointment in France, Germany, Italy, Spain, etc...

I disagree. All of these issues have really been compounded by Covid. Before Covid there were issues, yes, but nothing like what we have now. You could certainly contact a GP easily, get an appointment, and hospital waiting lists weren't that bad. Other countries managed to not entirely close down their health systems during Covid. We did. We are still, despite record funding, nowhere near the pre-Covid levels of service. We now are living with the consequences.

Geppili · 24/03/2023 10:16

Tories want the system to fail.

MaryMcCarthy · 24/03/2023 10:14

This is what a decade of neglect of public services looks like.

You can readily get a GP appointment in France, Germany, Italy, Spain, etc...

SoShallINever · 24/03/2023 10:12

GPs are consultants in primary care. They get paid the same as a cardiologist, oncologist, surgeon or psychiatrist.
I think they are wasted prescribing antibiotics for sore throats and these types of conditions should absolutely be screened out by prescribing nurses or paramedics. I'm also amazed at how many appointments are for the repeat signing of sicknotes. It's good that this can now be done by other professionals.
The system is underfunded and is still abused by frequent flyer patients, and also by the govt. Who abuse the goodwill of staff.
I'm a HCP and have seen so many GPs utterly burn out.

Dinosaurus123 · 24/03/2023 09:44

I hate this system too, since covid my doctors done this, I don't mind a call back but I sit in a queue for an hour to be told they have no more call backs.. everytime! Sitting in a queue while trying to get my 3 ready and driving to school is a PITA too, mine do econsult but takes at least 3 days for a response! I ended up going private recently but I understand its very expensive, I think you can do one off private appointments if you have a Google?

5mummy87 · 24/03/2023 06:06

I absolutely agree with you, system is CRAP, my little child got misdiagnosed over the phone, and my OH had wrong diagnosis too having to send photos of his condition.. as for convenience for a mum it's ridiculous I absolutely agree with you !

Cupofteaaa5 · 23/03/2023 22:09

I feel very grateful for my GP surgery after reading some of the replies on here. My surgery has the ring at 8am for urgent system (and to be fair, every time I've called I've managed to get an appointment - even on 28th December after they'd been closed over Christmas - I didn't get through til 9am but they still gave me an appointment)
They also do econsult where you do an online form and get a call back from a GP by the end of the next working day.
And sometimes, when they're in a quiet period, they put prebookable appointments online a week in advance. I've just booked one today, for next Wednesday, face to face with GP.

So not all GP surgeries are failing. Mine seem to be really trying as hard as possible to keep their service good. I hope that things will improve in future and all surgeries can offer better options!

Karatechopp · 23/03/2023 21:43

I know it's frustrating at times, I had the same recently. My daughter had been 'off' for a couple of days with a sore throat and runny nose. Then as I was getting her ready for school noticed a few blisters around her mouth. I knew it was hand foot and mouth disease, did an econsult and sent pictures and stated I thought it was hand foot and mouth, I just wanted clarification really for school, I was utterly surprised when given a same day appointment with a Paramedic. I took her to the appointment and he was looking through a textbook and clarified it, it did feel like a waste of time as someone else could have had the appointment (also he said he can assess but not prescribe). On the flip side I've tried contacting the GP to request antibiotics for myself for a UTI and been told I need to be seen, but at 36 I know the symptoms and just want to be prescribed the antibiotics and go about my day without having to factor in an unnecessary trip to the GP.

itsjustnotok · 23/03/2023 19:48

Comedycook · 22/03/2023 09:30

If you think it's a good system you must have Stockholm syndrome.

I bet if you told someone from any developed country that in the UK, you can't routinely take your child to see a doctor, they'd be horrified.

We are not wealthy but we're reasonably comfortable...DH just said worse comes to the worse, we will have to see a gp privately and suck up the cost. I feel like this is exactly what they want. We already pay for private speech therapy because the NHS discharged us.

OP I get where you are coming from but if your child isn’t well enough for school the surely someone will be with the child to take a call? If they are well enough for school…is it urgent? There is always an inconvenience for people waiting for calls and I get that it’s a pain, but there are people who don’t need an urgent same day appointment and this wheedles them out. It’s not an amazing system but I have found it to be quicker than waiting on the phone to be told there aren’t any more appointments. I don’t think there is a simple solution. Too many patients and not enough doctors by any measure 😔

Hiouo · 23/03/2023 18:13

No you’re not understanding this correctly. The paramedics at the GP surgery are employed on the ARRS scheme along with other roles such as physician associates, healthy and wellbeing coaches, social prescribers and clinical pharmacists. They aren’t employed by the normal ambulance system so they aren’t being taken away from ambulances, they are people that are highly qualified and can deal with minor conditions and generally prescribe. (And generally worked as a paramedic on a van previously and have been worked to death and want out) the problem is NHS England have taken on these roles with no publication and the general public don’t understand, I’m ARRS and even I get confused as to who I work for! I’m paid by NHS England, employed by a federation and work in a surgery who have no have a choice whether I am there or not but have to provide me with a consultation room! It however works in practice and hours of GP time is saved by additional roles. You wouldn’t believe the utter shite people claim is “urgent” and “is definitely needing a GP”

JustDanceAddict · 23/03/2023 17:56

Never heard of that.
I can get an urgent appt that day (may be an out of hours phone call) if. Have to ring at certain times of day - 8am or 2.30pm. I only use this if absolutely necessary.
Routine appts - if not fussy on doctor can sometimes get within a week or two. Can call to book and the ask if f2f or phone required. Same w nurse appts.?
I can also book on the nhs app but there’s less choice of slot.

MajorCarolDanvers · 23/03/2023 17:52

We've had a nurse do triage calls on all urgent requests for the last 15 years.

It works really well and we always get an appointment if we need one.

cansu · 23/03/2023 17:52

all this bollocks about what a great system!
Of course it isn't great. If a paramedic was able to diagnose then they would have done the same training as a GP. A four week wait in unacceptable.

Qazwsxefv · 23/03/2023 17:51

So you have one doctor working. They can see 48 patients in a day (6 patients per hour for 8 hours). You know that about 90-100 patients will call for appointments. How would you decide who to give the appointments to?

only way to fix it is to employ more GPs

Jaxhog · 23/03/2023 17:44

I think this system is fine. It deals with timewasters and the worried well, giving GPs more time for those who really need it.

My elderly Mum's GP surgery operates like this. I called them this morning for her, got through straight away and a Doctor called her within 10 mins. Saved time for everyone.

angielizzy1 · 23/03/2023 17:39

My Dr you can book a same day appointment or one in 2 weeks. There are no online consultation except to ask for sick notes or test results etc. They can usually fit you in with a face to face appointment that day if needed, they tell me anything that can't wait 2 weeks can be books as an emergency appointment. When I phoned at 2:30 in the afternoon thinking I had a UTI they got me to bring in a sample asap and the Dr would check it when they had time. By 5 the Dr had phoned and given me a prescription for antibiotics. I was very impressed as was expecting to be sent to 111 or a walk in centre. When I've needed an emergency appointment one always been able to get one.
At one stage it was a nightmare and they said they were going to turn off econsults to fix it. I was sceptical but it seems to have worked.

Chessetchelsea · 23/03/2023 17:03

Called the Dr last week. Fobbed off over ‘phone. Ended up with DC needing an ambulance ride to the ER. If they’d been seen in person, they would have believed me when I said something was wrong.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/03/2023 16:53

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 23/03/2023 16:41

I find it astonishing that anybody would prefer traipsing down to the surgery rather than having a two minute call. So many times I've had to waste an hour of my life, not to mention petrol, going to an appointment where a physical exam is unnecessary.

But how do you know a physical exam is unnecessary? Also it's not as if the two minute calls are even that quick or convenient. Most of the time when I've had them you wait hours, a GP calls and if you miss the call they make no attempt to get back in touch with you. Most people who work in offices can't justify keeping the phone free for hours on the of chance a doctor will call. At least a physical appointment guarantees you will get the attention of a GP.

TizerorFizz · 23/03/2023 16:43

@Thepeopleversuswork
40 years of working is fine. That takes doctors to over 60. They don’t do that long though in many cases. The pensions are golden. Better than virtually anyone else’s.

I agree that poor triage wastes time for busy people who are also working hard for long hours doing important jobs. We put the NHS on a pedestal. Then we dare not criticise it when it doesn’t work. At £160 billion pa it’s eye watering expenditure.

We pay for all training other than the student loan. It is very very expensive. Nurses often don’t get near paying the loan off. The public do need to know money is spent wisely on services. My GPS close many days a year for training. A school has 5 inset days. The doctors are double that. No company earning money could afford to shut down like that in addition to holidays.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 23/03/2023 16:41

I find it astonishing that anybody would prefer traipsing down to the surgery rather than having a two minute call. So many times I've had to waste an hour of my life, not to mention petrol, going to an appointment where a physical exam is unnecessary.