Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He's not a grandparent?

157 replies

biankss · 22/03/2023 08:42

Yesterday I took DS to the park, and uploaded some pictures of him onto facebook. In the midst of comments my DH saw a comment from his step-dad saying something along the lines of "My beautiful grandson, whom i love very much". He never really says this, perhaps scared to overstep a boundary. However, MIL always encourages him to call himself grandad or when DS is over she says "go to grandad".

I've really got no opinion on it really, I've seen families where this happens and children have 4 grandparents and they're all very happy, including the biological grandparents. But, I noticed yesterday by DH reaction to the comment he wasn't happy and said something like "My mother really needs to stop telling Paul (not actual name) to say things like this". I could tell he was getting annoyed.

Part of me thinks he's in his right to think this, perhaps he's not comfortable with DS having another grandparent, when DH and his dad have a perfectly good relationship. The other part of me thinks maybe it's not a big deal, but I guess it's also dependent on DH's dad and how he feels in this situation.

I also don't think I should speak on the matter, as it's really none of my concern. I guess just looking for someone's perspective and maybe address with DH to avoid conflict, he's got a bit of a fiery personality, and would hate for there to be a falling out because everyone simply adores our DS.

OP posts:
Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 22/03/2023 09:55

On another thread, a MIL is being (rightly) roasted because she expects her DIL to sign her mothers day card. Lots of "but you're not her mother!" posts. sooo not the same!
It's normal isn't it for a long term live in partner or husband of the grandparent to be called grandparent? They are a grandparent by marriage not blood, which is same as calling the wife of an uncle your aunt. You don't have to be blood to be family. Unless there is a back story of step dad being unpleasant, then its lovely, and how its should be, that he looks at your ds the same way as his blood gc.

MarchMadness23 · 22/03/2023 09:54

@saraclara

If DH doesn't see his stepdad as his father, that translates to him not seeing step dad as his children's grandfather either. And it's okay for him to feel that way.

I don't agree with that either. My Dad died a few years ago. If my Mum remarried I wouldn't see the bloke as my father and it would hurt to hear my children calling him Grandad, BUT if he was nice & would be a good grandad to them I'd be fine with them calling him Grandad (but I'd use a slightly different title (pops/grandpa or whatever) to ease my pain a little.

you need to put the children first, not the adult

@biankss ^^this is why I think your DH is wrong, he should have said, 'well we have Grandad already, so let's say 'Grandpa' instead Mum. Or Grandad 'relevant fact'

kilked me when my exes nieces and nephews started calling his mum Nana Trout! She was a completely nasty bitch, and the title was as fitting as you could allow!! But actually it was because they lived near a trout farm! Still made me smile!!

Phoebo · 22/03/2023 09:45

So your DH is getting annoyed that someone loves and cares about your DC. He needs to get some perspective and get a grip. How lucky your DC is to be loved by so many people

saraclara · 22/03/2023 09:44

On another thread, a MIL is being (rightly) roasted because she expects her DIL to sign her mothers day card. Lots of "but you're not her mother!" posts.

If DH doesn't see his stepdad as his father, that translates to him not seeing step dad as his children's grandfather either. And it's okay for him to feel that way.

The trouble is that there wasn't a conversation about names when the baby was born or OP was pregnant. It's too late now to address it without causing hurt to both his mum and stepdad.

Kam610 · 22/03/2023 09:42

My children call my MIL's husband grandad. He is so lovely and such a great grandad to them. He treats my husband like his son too. It would be strange to me for my children to call him by his name as he is such a huge part of their lives.

Saying that though, my FIL has also re-married and my children don't call her granny. But that's because she has no involvement in their lives whatsoever and has only met them once. She never comes with FIL to visit us or see our children so I wouldn't allow them to call her granny.

LakeTiticaca · 22/03/2023 09:38

If its his mums boyfriend who she's been seeing for 6 months then it's not OK. If he's been part of the family for many years then I see no problem with him being grandad. As pp's have mentioned above, lots of posters complaining that the step grandchildren are treated differently!!

GlitteryGreen · 22/03/2023 09:36

I think it's harsh tbh, but depends on how long Paul has been around. I have 2 SCs - since they were 2 and 6 - and I'd be gutted if they reacted like this.

SNWannabe · 22/03/2023 09:28

Your husband is being a bit of an arse tbh. Surely it’s more confusing to have a Granny who isn’t married to grandad and to call him “Paul” seems a little off for a young child to address someone so casual. I’m in the camp of “the more the merrier” as many kids have loads of grandparents as often great grandparents stay the same name for the next generation too (my mum is Nanny for grandchildren and great grandchildren) so my grandkids have erm… 11-12 “grandparents” between step dad and great grandparents still alive…

twoandcooplease · 22/03/2023 09:24

We lost my grandad last November and he was my step grandad
Married my gran when my mum was 15 and was the only consistent man in my life. He was my favourite person and we were so close
My mums husband is the same to my son as my grandad was to me. Sometimes the family chosen are better than the family you get
If he loves your dc and treats them great that should be all that matters. He isn't going anywhere hopefully

Thea91 · 22/03/2023 09:18

My DS has 4 sets of grandparents. He calls my MILs husband Grandad and actually sees him a lot more than his other 2 Grandads. It just came naturally.

I think it depends on your husband's relationship with Paul. For example both mine and my partners Dad's have wife's but my DS doesn't call either of them Nan/Grandma as he doesn't see them enough and it feels a bit odd to me.

MimiSunshine · 22/03/2023 09:18

It clearly makes your DH feel uncomfortable but he needs to realise that ‘Paul’s’ relationship with your DS is entirely different to his with him.

yes MIL may be pushing it a bit but really what benefit would it do your son to have a distinction made that Paul is not grandad?
It doesn’t reduce the love he has for DHs dad in the way that having a 2nd child doesn’t reduce a parents love for the 1st.

have a gentle word with him and make him realise that his own feelings about Paul and probably even his parents not being together shouldn’t be out on to his son.

stopringingme · 22/03/2023 09:16

When our DD was born we asked my Husbands step mum if she wanted to be called Nanny or by her name.

She is married to Grandad so it just seemed natural as she was in the family before DD was born.

If she had come into our lives after the birth she would not have had a choice and would have been called by her name.

AnneLovesGilbert · 22/03/2023 09:12

Is Paul an involved and positive presence in DS’s life? Or is he a hands off Facebook type?

If it’s the former then tbh I think your DH is being pretty childish and churlish. Paul is happy and proud to be part of DS’s family and that’s a good thing.

CindyAndTheSaltySnacks · 22/03/2023 09:11

I've never liked my mother's husband. I would never refer to him as my stepfather, he's not "my" anything. My children have never called him granddad. If your husband doesn't have a great relationship with his mother's husband I can understand him having an issue with the Facebook comment.

NHStyptypey · 22/03/2023 09:09

In our family step grandparents are just "grandparents"

When i was a kid in the 80s and 90s - I had step grandparents and they treated me like their own grandchildren. I was forever grateful and felt loved by them.

steppemum · 22/03/2023 09:08

my kids had a step granny, slightly different as Dh's mum died before we met.

We always just called her Granny to the kids.
My FIL married very late too, they were 65 ish, married after my ds was born.

We just saw it as all people who care enough to want to be Granny/Grandad was a good thing

Wenfy · 22/03/2023 09:07

Your husband needs to seperate his relationship with his stepdad from your son’s. To your son he is grandad.

DeltaAlphaDelta79 · 22/03/2023 09:07

I have a dad, and also my mother's partner whom she met when I was an adult so not really my step dad. He was with my mum long before DC was born and we asked him if he was ok being referred to as grandad, which he was. So to DC he is Grandad X, and my dad is Grandad Y, and DWs dad is Grandad Z.

DC is fully aware of the situation now and all Grandad's treat them the same as other grandchildren, where blood or not (we have large families on both sides with step parents, step siblings etc).

I think it does depend on your DH's relationship with Paul tho and perhaps if there is/was animosity over you DH's parents breakup. If DH really doesn't like it tho, he needs to discuss it with his mum and the sooner the better so your DC doesn't get confused.

TheNoodlesIncident · 22/03/2023 09:06

I don't understand his issue tbh. What does it matter if they're not biologically related, they still have a relationship? The more positive relationships a child has the better really.

My mum's partner is "grandad [name]" to her grandchildren, there's no harm in it. It doesn't exclude anybody and there's no law on the maximum grandparent figures a child can have.

I only had one grandparent growing up, more would have been lovely. The others were deceased or ignoring us, so maybe I'm biased towards "the more the merrier" for that reason. But I don't see that there's a downside or anything wrong with it? Does he feel his dad is being excluded or bested in some way?

RudsyFarmer · 22/03/2023 09:06

First of all children can never have too many people who love them in their lives. So the fact that the husband of your MIL considers your child family and as long as he is acting loving and appropriate then that’s a good thing.

Your husbands reaction is no doubt a protective mechanism in relation to his actual father, the child’s biological grand parent, and whether this social media outpouring devalues his dad’s role. My natural reaction is ‘no it doesn’t’ but I don’t know these people and only they can decide how they feel.

BingoBonus · 22/03/2023 09:05

It's lovely that he cares about your ds and wants to be considered a grandparent. Would your husband feel more comfortable with it if he was called grandad Peter rather than grandad?
The more loving and supportive adults a child has around them the better, your husband needs to think about this from your DS point of view rather than focusing on "he's not really his grandparent".

Picklewicklepickle · 22/03/2023 09:05

I think it depends on when he came into your DH’s life and their relationship. DH’s stepdad met his mum when he was about 11, he’s never tried to be his dad but they have a good relationship and he is very much one of our DC’s grandads, they just have 3 of them!

LondonPretty · 22/03/2023 09:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Peppermint81 · 22/03/2023 09:04

Think your husband is being childish!
Your child is so lucky to have an extra grandparent in their lives.
Paul is part of the family now whether he likes it or not. Why would he want to upset his mother also?

Fluffodils · 22/03/2023 09:02

You see a lot of posts on here where people moan that the step grandparents aren't treating the kids the same as their non step grandchildren. So he needs to think hard about what he wants.he can't have it both ways.