Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nurses, would you vote yes or no to the current offer?

65 replies

FourBoysAndAFeline · 22/03/2023 08:14

On the face of it 5% is insulting.
But since Pat Cullen went into more detail
about what it entails and they also seem to be saying take it, or we might not get a better offer (or words to that effect) I'm dithering between yes and no.
On the other hand, Wales voted no on their 4% offer (I'm unsure if there was any other offers along side that).
Im torn but beginning to wonder if I should vote yes...

YABU - I vote no!
YANBU - I vote yes!

OP posts:
MelchiorsMistress · 22/03/2023 12:02

Not a nurse but I’d vote no. If they can put benefits up in line with inflation at 10% and all the professions dominated by men like firefighters and rail workers are getting even more than that, then they can afford to pay nurses better as well.

5% is insulting.

bookish83 · 22/03/2023 12:02

@spelunky you are not comparing like for like.

Which of the professions you think are getting a good enough deal, are responsible for the care of unwell people? Lose their job over medication errors? Work with unsafe staffing ratios?

I'm not saying the deal is good or bad but a nursing role really does hold a lot of life and death responsibility.

To the posters further down... band 2 and 3 are not 'shafting' nurses. They get low wages for the work they do, especially on wards. If they get £200 more, good on them

reesewithoutaspoon · 22/03/2023 12:01

I think anyone voting yes to this is being deceived.
They are dangling a 2k bonus payment in front of your eyes and saying look a sparkly thing. But in 2 years your pay will have only risen 5% and next year there will be no sparkly object to look at and you lost your chance to get a better long term offer.

Dontwanttowaitanymore · 22/03/2023 12:00

I'll vote no. We are worth more.

IsGoodIsDon · 22/03/2023 11:59

Donotunderestimateme
I feel the same, after 23 years I’m stuck at bottom band 5 bank work as I changed specialities and then had children and can’t afford childcare. My workplace gets so much from me with my 23 years experience but I get peanuts. It will be another 6 years till I can think about a permanent position again and look to go up the bands, I also can’t afford to do a post grad certificate or diploma due to my poor wage and being a bank nurse I won’t get funding.
I get £12.80 per hour basic wage I have to work all nights to make my pay better off. I am so angry as being bank I won’t get any lump sum payment either.
think it’s nearly time to give up the job I love it’s so demoralising.

cornflakesandtea · 22/03/2023 11:58

I'm an ODP and with Unison but when the time comes to vote on the pay I will be voting to reject. I think it's insulting when MPs are happy to give themselves payrise after payrise and enable handouts to their rich mates. Test and trace anyone?

I also don't agree with the new pay spine for nurses that they are "considering". Particularly in my department, I do the same (or more) than the majority of the nurses and potentially getting paid less for it is insulting.

Mrsherdwick · 22/03/2023 11:56

Retired nurse here (40 years service). If I had a vote it would be no.
Currently lying on the sofa in agony with my 5 prolapsed discs probably due to working in chronically short staffed wards with no lifting equipment.

Vintagevixen · 22/03/2023 11:52

I will be voting yes.

strawberryicecreamice · 22/03/2023 11:51

@Donotunderestimateme thank you.

Kazplus2 · 22/03/2023 11:50

Lots of comments about nurses in Scotland earning more than nurses in England and Wales. It's worth remembering that Scotland has higher income tax than England and Wales to fund this (and other things).

Donotunderestimateme · 22/03/2023 11:46

After 21 years in the profession I think I just want to quit now. I feel so down and disrespected. I’m a long time off retirement and I’m currently being treated for PTSD. I don’t think I can carry on. I am not the only one who will make this decision and then all the lower bands will find that they are doing the band 5 roles for peanuts and the government will have destroyed the nursing profession.
The reason nursing has become a degree entry profession is because there is clear evidence that patients are more likely to survive and have good outcomes if their nurse is degree educated. So any members of the public who are happy to see the profession down graded are happy to take their chances when critically unwell.
well good luck to them.

reesewithoutaspoon · 22/03/2023 11:46

https://www.nhsemployers.org/articles/government-and-agenda-change-trade-unions-offer-principle This is the offer

The 2022/23 offer is basically a lump sum which is non-consolidated (approx 7%)
Non-consolidated means its only for that year and doesn't increase the actual base salary because it's removed at the end of the year, so in effect, not a pay rise just a cash lump sump.

So nurses go into 2023/24 negotiations on the same pay scale they were on in 2021/22 as they essentially received no pay rise just a lump sum (which doesnt count towards their pension)
So the 5% rise is 5% over the last 2 years in effect.
Doesn't sound so great now
The lump sum is because they don't want to raise the base salary in case inflation drops. Its also a carrot to encourage nurses to vote yes, because the thought of a lump sum is appealing, but long term it's not going to increase the base salary by much at all.

Government and Agenda for Change trade unions ‘offer in principle’

Details of the government's revised pay offer for staff on Agenda for Change contracts for 2022/23 and 2023/24.

https://www.nhsemployers.org/articles/government-and-agenda-change-trade-unions-offer-principle

beckslovestimmy · 22/03/2023 11:37

We were so close to looking credible with the planned strike with no widespread derogations, the gov finally listened and came to the table.

When negotiating, you never accept the first offer - that is not a negotiation.

Nurses in Scotland are paid more, we should all be on a level playing field.

The other professions mentioned earlier that have been offered more than 5% are all male dominated - a coincidence? I don't think so.

They think we are weak women who should just accept what crumbs we are offered and shut up.

We should be showing we are a strong highly educated profession that deserve to be paid appropriately for the skills we have.

I will be voting no and am happy to be in it for the long game.

They think the lump sum will tempt so many and sadly I think it might.

I will be angry, frustrated and disappointed in my fellow nurses if this is accepted.

GoodChat · 22/03/2023 11:37

I'm not a nurse (or in the medical field at all) but have relatives who are.

There's no way I'd accept 5% if I were, though. They won't just not give you anything. They can't. We need nurses and if there's not a fair increase too many will leave the profession.

IsGoodIsDon · 22/03/2023 11:36

I would vote no if I had a vote. I’m a nurse but not eligible to vote. It’s an absolute shambles and I’m now looking to change unions as the RCN have shown they have no interest in the actual working conditions of nurses and seem to be more concerned about promoting nurse awards or a specific health week than fighting for our pay and conditions.

reesewithoutaspoon · 22/03/2023 11:35

Toddlerteaplease · 22/03/2023 11:32

I am
Probably being thick, but I don't understand why lower bands should get more, in proportion to band fives and above.

It's a divisive tactic. instead of all bands rejecting the offer the lower bands are more likely to accept because its good for them, this divides the vote.

Whenisitsummer · 22/03/2023 11:32

I will vote to accept the offer, it’s better than last years £1400 flat rate which for my band worked out at around 2.8%. So the one off payment and 5% is an improvement. Yes I’d have liked more , in line with firefighters but it’s not going to happen.

Toddlerteaplease · 22/03/2023 11:32

I am
Probably being thick, but I don't understand why lower bands should get more, in proportion to band fives and above.

Donotunderestimateme · 22/03/2023 11:29

Yes @strawberryicecreamice lower bands with a nursing role who are members of the RCN can and did strike and deserve an improvement in their pay as their work is demanding and we need more people in these roles. It is a better deal for lower bands but not a good one for the majority of nursing staff. So if all the lower banded HCSWs say yes the band 5 nurses are being let down by their colleagues.

Toddlerteaplease · 22/03/2023 11:29

Donotunderestimateme · 22/03/2023 10:53

So the nurses went on strike and now the band 2s in all staff groups (this includes staff without a nursing role) are getting a good deal and the nurses are getting shafted again.

Yep.

shakeitoffsis · 22/03/2023 11:11

I'm band 5 and no I won't be voting to accept.

strawberryicecreamice · 22/03/2023 11:11

Is it just nurses who striked ? Can lower bands strike if they're a member of the union?

Reallybadidea · 22/03/2023 11:09

The average includes directors of nursing and band 8's who work in management offices and haven't been near a patient in donkey's years.

Agree on your first point, the pay of higher bands does bring the average up. But there are lots of band 8s who have specialist clinical roles and lots of patient contact. We're not all managers at that level!

Possibly not a popular view, but I am sick of the higher bands being fobbed off with lower percentage pay awards because we've got the temerity to do a job that attracts better pay. It might seem reasonable in the short term but eventually nobody will want to take on those roles because it just won't be worth it financially.

MeinKraft · 22/03/2023 11:02

Not a nurse but 5% sounds like a rubbish offer to me.

reesewithoutaspoon · 22/03/2023 10:59

spelunky · 22/03/2023 08:23

I'm not a nurse, first of all. But I have close friends/ family who are nurses and also in other roles in the NHS, so have some insight.

The average salary of a nurse in the UK (in 2022) is around £35,000. So £36,750 with the 5% rise.

Really, I do think that is in line with other professions of a similar level in the UK. It would be nice to raise that a little bit more, but the NHS is in a crisis and I believe they are saying that any furhter pay rises would have to come out of existing funds (i.e. the government won't be putting more money into it) - so it would mean further cuts to existing NHS services in order to pay for the salary increase.

I think the government should put more money into the NHS.

However, in the context of £36,750 being a decent salary and the current crisis, I think the nurses should take the offer. I don't know anyone who has had more than a 5% pay rise this year in any sector. It's rubbish, but I think pushing this further would not result in anything positive.

Can we bury this lie/propaganda that most nurses earn £35k? they do not.
The majority of nurses are band 5 and their pay range is 27k to 32k.
The average includes directors of nursing and band 8's who work in management offices and haven't been near a patient in donkey's years. So have no idea how difficult it is on the frontline and why recruitment and retention is so bad.

I vote no.
Bus drivers, train drivers, barristers, and firemen have all been offered more. Coincidentally professions that traditionally are male-dominated. Why is nursing being offered a pay cut AGAIN?

Accept this and you're accepting more years of pay cuts and being treated badly.Nothing will change