Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it BU to ask if it’s ok to do this at my daughters school?

322 replies

FamilyBusiness · 21/03/2023 23:42

Hi all, it’s my little ones birthday in April, she will be six. Her birthday falls on a day she’s in school. My oldest son (10) is in same school, he is booked in for a feeding tube to be fitted (Cystic Fibrosis related) on the 18th of April. So we will be celebrating my daughters birthday a week early. But, WIBU to ask their school if I could pay for an educational animal visit for my daughter & her whole class for her birthday it’s a one hour visit.

As she has Autism & is going to be distraught that her brother is going in hospital (I’m dreading it) & I think it would really cheer her up & take her mind off it especially going in to school on her Bday knowing her brother isn’t there that day. Even though we will be celebrating together the week before, he will be in hospital at the time & so she won’t see him in school that day.

I don’t want to email the headteacher if it’s a bad idea, it will be an educational visit with bunny’s, birds, insects, etc etc. Thanks

OP posts:
Tirrrrred · 23/03/2023 07:16

WiddlinDiddlin · 22/03/2023 17:26

Fucking hell the cereal-pissers are out in force today!

My Dad has reminded me of the time he called my primary school to tell the office that the local railway had just reopened its long shut line and a fantastic steam train would be making a trip through our village (his office was other end of the line), and if the school acted fast, we could all go and see it chuff past...

The whole school (admittedly, not that many kids possibly only 45) was taken out of lessons and we marched down the road in a long crocodile and up the steps and onto the platform and watched the first steam engine to travel that line since something like 1970's

I think we had about an hours warning. School were pleased to have something fun, educational and related to the community and local area to show us.

I realise things have changed a smidgen since the late 1980s but the OP's suggestion seems perfectly reasonable, practical and achievable, despite some peoples determination to read things that simply have not been suggested!

How is this relevant?

45 in the whole school? That's just over one class. There are 700 in my daughters primary. Should her school be expected to do the same?

Richhandcream · 22/03/2023 22:22

MistressIggi · 22/03/2023 16:37

No. Someone could suggest an enriching opportunity to me for every day of the week - none of that makes it my responsibility to say yes to them.
I will have planned appropriate trips and "enrichment opportunities" at the start of the year, and used my time accordingly.

Now you’re being imaginative. I didn’t say the teachers had a responsibility to say yes to Op did I? What I do know is that there are headteachers and staff who would consider something like this. Not with the label of it being a birthday celebration I suspect, but as an activity, definitely.
This is a nasty, negative thread. The obvious answer was simply that there’s no harm in asking. Instead so many have lived up to the MN nest of vipers reputation. Any opportunity to squash someone down and they’re all over it.

SaySomethingMan · 22/03/2023 22:09

I cant believe how nasty some posters are. Ugh!

OP, all the best with your son’s op. I’m sure your daughter will have a lovely birthday, sharing cupcakes for her classmates.

Our primary school does similar for birthdays, mostly sweets but cakes too. The children always come out with an extra dose of excitement on classmates’ birthdays.

I think it would’ve have been a nice experience for the children, provided the teachers get enough notice to consider how to fit it in. I do understand you’ve been out off by your experience here so you might no longer want to ask.

It’s a lovely thought.

AnyBenny · 22/03/2023 20:16

zingally · 22/03/2023 16:45

Speaking as a teacher - lovely idea, coming from a good place, but it will be a polite but hard no.

Imagine if every parent wanted to do something like that? And it's not just an hours activity. It's risk assessments, some liaising between the school and the activity provider, moving the classroom around to accommodate, changing the timetable, dealing with hyped-up kids the rest of the day.

Strangely plenty of other teachers on here have said it’s worth asking, and I described how my DS’s school had happily facilitated something very similar for us a few years ago. Maybe your school would say a hard no, but clearly it’s not true of all schools, so it is therefore worth asking. I do despair of people sometimes - the negativity on this thread is 🤯 particularly in view of the OP’s difficult situation.
If you’re still reading OP, I do hope you do ask - the worst they can say is no, then at least you tried.

Starseeking · 22/03/2023 18:03

If you're already celebrating your DD's birthday a week early, you should just arrange to do this at home, on another day. It's not an appropriate request to make of the school.

MistressIggi · 22/03/2023 17:29

What is that quote - "The past is a foreign country: they do things differently there"

WiddlinDiddlin · 22/03/2023 17:26

Fucking hell the cereal-pissers are out in force today!

My Dad has reminded me of the time he called my primary school to tell the office that the local railway had just reopened its long shut line and a fantastic steam train would be making a trip through our village (his office was other end of the line), and if the school acted fast, we could all go and see it chuff past...

The whole school (admittedly, not that many kids possibly only 45) was taken out of lessons and we marched down the road in a long crocodile and up the steps and onto the platform and watched the first steam engine to travel that line since something like 1970's

I think we had about an hours warning. School were pleased to have something fun, educational and related to the community and local area to show us.

I realise things have changed a smidgen since the late 1980s but the OP's suggestion seems perfectly reasonable, practical and achievable, despite some peoples determination to read things that simply have not been suggested!

2bazookas · 22/03/2023 16:54

Not once did I say I wanted to take over the school. One hour isn’t taking over a 6 hour day.

Actually it is, because whatever else the teacher had planned for that day would have to be rearranged around it, to accommodate an animal visit. With the best will in the world, external visits always take more time than booked; they need access to bring stuff into the classroom and set it up, maybe furniture has to be rearranged, and at the end they have to pack everything and take it all away. Which is distracting to the class of 6 yr olds.

zingally · 22/03/2023 16:45

Speaking as a teacher - lovely idea, coming from a good place, but it will be a polite but hard no.

Imagine if every parent wanted to do something like that? And it's not just an hours activity. It's risk assessments, some liaising between the school and the activity provider, moving the classroom around to accommodate, changing the timetable, dealing with hyped-up kids the rest of the day.

MistressIggi · 22/03/2023 16:37

Richhandcream · 22/03/2023 15:29

You know that part of the work that school staff do is to enrich the learning experience for the children? In other words, if an activity is deemed to be useful then it's part of their job to do risk assessments etc.

No. Someone could suggest an enriching opportunity to me for every day of the week - none of that makes it my responsibility to say yes to them.
I will have planned appropriate trips and "enrichment opportunities" at the start of the year, and used my time accordingly.

Schnooze · 22/03/2023 16:10

manictuesday · 22/03/2023 04:19

Teacher here who arranges such visits.

I don't think it's wrong of you to ask, so long as you do it nicely and state that you understand this might not be possible to accommodate on the specific day.

No issues with risk assessments if they have visited before the school already have one and these companies are professional, it's not just some random rocking up with their pets.

Schools can always find an extra hour in the day if it's something that enriches the pupil experience, the curriculum isn't so packed that there isn't an hour in the that could be dropped.

Budgets are tight so offering to pay could be a bonus for school to save that money from one class and use elsewhere.

You won't be able to take the credit and say it's from you/for DDs birthday to the rest of the class/DD even as that will get around and set a precedent of everyone wanting to do their "party" event at school to save themselves the hassle.

The school know your situation and sound supportive and I think making this last part clear, that you won't publicise to the other parents it's from you/for DDs birthday, is important in increasing your chances of them agreeing.

I hope that everything goes as smoothly as possible for DS and DD.

I was going to say this, but it’s much more eloquently said here.

Richhandcream · 22/03/2023 15:29

WhateverHappenedToMe · 22/03/2023 12:07

Don't be so bloody ridiculous. IF the school were to take Op up on her kind offer they would deal with all of that, as they do on a regular basis.

Whether or not they do it on a regular basis, it's still extra work every time. I'm speaking as someone who takes animals into schools.

You know that part of the work that school staff do is to enrich the learning experience for the children? In other words, if an activity is deemed to be useful then it's part of their job to do risk assessments etc.

leeloo1 · 22/03/2023 15:21

notsayingmuch · 22/03/2023 07:31

No, she wants a teacher who is working 60+ hours a week and responsible for 30 children to be her party planner instead!

No she isn’t asking anyone to be a party planner, she’s asking if she can fund a visitor to school.

I was an early years teacher in an infant school and I’d have been more than happy to accommodate this request as it would have enriched the lives of all the children. Having a visit is almost zero work for the teacher - they may do some planning around it, but not different to what they usually do. There will already be school risk assessments in place for this type of visit that they’ll just update the date and contact details on.

op - please don’t be put off asking the school about it

FamilyBusiness · 22/03/2023 13:58

Zonder · 22/03/2023 13:39

You know what? I've been thinking about this and I don't think there's any harm in speaking to the head teacher, explaining the situation and your thoughts. Even if the head then says no, we couldn't possibly do that, they may have an idea of how to look out for your dd on a potentially difficult day.

I’m probably not going to ask the school now just because, judging by some of the comments I wouldn’t wanna put the teacher on the spot. Wasn’t my intention, just basically a treat for my little girl to enjoy with her whole class/whole school if they’d like that too for her birthday. Albeit I would have been fine to do it without saying to everyone it’s my daughters birthday. I’ll give it some thought for the next few days. Either way, I’ll ask if she can bring her cupcakes in each & a party bag that her class would’ve all been given anyway if we would’ve had a party. They’re a brilliant school so nothing would be to much of an ask.

OP posts:
fairycakes1234 · 22/03/2023 13:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

@LondonPretty what a stinking attitude. Shes not trying to take over the school, what is wrong with people like you

Zonder · 22/03/2023 13:39

You know what? I've been thinking about this and I don't think there's any harm in speaking to the head teacher, explaining the situation and your thoughts. Even if the head then says no, we couldn't possibly do that, they may have an idea of how to look out for your dd on a potentially difficult day.

FamilyBusiness · 22/03/2023 13:24

LadyWindermeresOnlyFans · 22/03/2023 12:37

I originally thought YABU but I've changed my mind now, having read your subsequent posts and the replies I still don't think it's a great idea to ask them to do it for her birthday even if you're paying, but YANBU to consider it. And YANBU to send treats in instead. That's totally normal in my DC school on a birthday! Parents and kids don't expect it but it's always appreciated. In our school teachers can't give them out in class but parents can pass them round the playground.

I understand you just want to do something special for your little girl who's having a tough time. Which of us wouldn't? You're just throwing some ideas out there.

You sound like a lovely mum, trying to juggle both DC needs at this really difficult time for your family.

Hope the day goes well for you all Flowers

Thank you so much for your lovely words. It really was just an idea & id have been more than happy to do it anonymously to the rest of the school/parents. But definitely cake & a party bag instead for each of her class mates. Thanks again xx

OP posts:
LadyWindermeresOnlyFans · 22/03/2023 12:37

Sorry for typos and terrible punctuation

LadyWindermeresOnlyFans · 22/03/2023 12:37

I originally thought YABU but I've changed my mind now, having read your subsequent posts and the replies I still don't think it's a great idea to ask them to do it for her birthday even if you're paying, but YANBU to consider it. And YANBU to send treats in instead. That's totally normal in my DC school on a birthday! Parents and kids don't expect it but it's always appreciated. In our school teachers can't give them out in class but parents can pass them round the playground.

I understand you just want to do something special for your little girl who's having a tough time. Which of us wouldn't? You're just throwing some ideas out there.

You sound like a lovely mum, trying to juggle both DC needs at this really difficult time for your family.

Hope the day goes well for you all Flowers

ImustLearn2Cook · 22/03/2023 12:19

@FamilyBusiness Yanbu to ask the school. They can either say yes or no. It’s a lovely idea and very generous. They might actually appreciate your offer.

WhateverHappenedToMe · 22/03/2023 12:07

Don't be so bloody ridiculous. IF the school were to take Op up on her kind offer they would deal with all of that, as they do on a regular basis.

Whether or not they do it on a regular basis, it's still extra work every time. I'm speaking as someone who takes animals into schools.

Richhandcream · 22/03/2023 12:00

WhateverHappenedToMe · 22/03/2023 11:51

If you book them, would you be prepared to check their public liability insurance and DBS clearance, and complete a risk assessment? Would you be prepared to deal with the fall out from a child being bitten or peed on by an animal?

Don't be so bloody ridiculous. IF the school were to take Op up on her kind offer they would deal with all of that, as they do on a regular basis.
Unfortunately, in spite of the fact that many who actually work in schools say it would be fine to ask, Op has been put off doing that by the vipers.

FamilyBusiness · 22/03/2023 11:52

WhateverHappenedToMe · 22/03/2023 11:51

If you book them, would you be prepared to check their public liability insurance and DBS clearance, and complete a risk assessment? Would you be prepared to deal with the fall out from a child being bitten or peed on by an animal?

The place I’d have been hiring has came to their school quite a few times. They’re well known & liked at the school but I won’t be hiring them now anyway, I wasn’t planning on. I was just thinking about it. & yes they’re full insured etc. They specifically visit schools.

OP posts:
WhateverHappenedToMe · 22/03/2023 11:51

If you book them, would you be prepared to check their public liability insurance and DBS clearance, and complete a risk assessment? Would you be prepared to deal with the fall out from a child being bitten or peed on by an animal?

DappledThings · 22/03/2023 11:49

FamilyBusiness · 22/03/2023 11:41

Okay, I’ll send her in under strict orders that she mustn’t even mutter a word of it being her birthday. Nobody can sing happy birthday, or even look at a cupcake or mention one. Nothing at all. Poker faced all day. Give over she’s 6. Every kid in her class brings in something on their birthday. It’s never once been an issue.

Which isn't what I said at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread