Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Very rich parents

636 replies

jennybrightcandle · 21/03/2023 20:56

I honestly don’t know if I’m being unreasonable here or not. I may be a terrible person and am willing to be told so if that is the case.

When I was growing up, my parents had a fairly average income. I had a fairly “normal” upbringing: 3 bed semi, camping holidays, state schools etc. However, over time, my parents have become very rich. Partly luck of course, but also a lot of very hard work.

They are now in a position where they can go on multiple holidays a year (they’ve just booked two cruises for this summer, for example). They own two properties outright (one they live in, one they rent out). They are fairly open about their finances and so I know that as well as claiming a final salary pension, my dad is also still bringing in around 100k a year in investments and consultancy work. They have told me that they have full holdings in premium bonds etc etc.

We are fairly typical of our generation in that we both work full time in order to pay our mortgage. Neither of us particularly enjoy our jobs but we can’t career change or reduce hours as we need the money. We haven’t been on holiday overseas since 2015. We are doing fine and not on the breadline, but things are tight. We don’t currently have any savings although hopefully that will change soon as our youngest will be starting school (previously we were paying around 18k a year on childcare!!)

This is where it gets a bit embarrassing but am I being totally unreasonable to think our parents could maybe…help us out a bit?! I mean, I look at some of my peers who have had significant parental help towards buying a house or free childcare etc. And I just find it a bit odd that they haven’t thought to do the same.

I know I shouldn’t expect it and that they have no obligation whatsoever to provide anything now that I’ve left home but I just find it kind of hurtful. They have so much money and we live fairly hand to mouth each month. I honestly can’t imagine being like this with my own children and plan to help them out as much as I can.

So…am I being horribly unreasonable, materialistic and grasping 😬?

OP posts:
WeAreBorg · 22/03/2023 18:23

NeshNamechanger · 22/03/2023 17:59

Where has she said she can't sleep at night?
Honestly stop making things up
Can't get over someone earning 80K thinking they are hard done by !

‘Not being able to sleep at night’ is a figure of speech. In this context if OPs boiler exploded she would be fucked. If her parents gave her a sliver of their annual income of over £200K as a one off she wouldn’t be fucked.

@TheyAreMadeOutOfMeat articulated the point better

TheyAreMadeOutOfMeat · 22/03/2023 18:10

Can't get over someone earning 80K thinking they are hard done by !

Oh dear, there's always someone who wantsto begin a "Four Yorkshiremen" sketch.

In some parts of the country you'll be extremelyhard pushed to provide for children and pay a large mortgage required to live there to maintain those job and pay childcare etc on those salaries. Not to mention how much of that will go on tax!! Taxes were much, much lower for Boomers as well.

And simultaneously we have people claiming that OP's parents are not rich, with no mortgage or childcare expenses and an estimated £220k income plus rental income plus zero commuting costs etc.

Again, the cognitive dissonance is huge.

The amounts are not really that relevant for me in the issue I am interested in, which is that these people are happy for OP's family and her grandchildren to be significantly, proportionately, much much poorer than them when they could actually afford to pay off a large chunk of her mortgage (also preserving that money as a family asset to be passed down later to DGC) and still easily afford their lifestyle of multiple holidays per year, private healthcare etc. While improving their child and her children's circumstances and making the family as a whole therefore much better off in perpetuity, giving their child and DGC an easier and better life, wasting far less money than they would keeping everything then paying huge tax bills. Why would anybody choose not to do that? You'd have to have a very strange mentality to think that was a good idea.

Shudacudawuda · 22/03/2023 18:08

YANBU OP.

My PIL helped us out with a house deposit, not loads but it got us on the ladder. Rents have gone up so much since, I dread to think how we would be coping if we were still renting.
I regularly tell them how they changed our lives with that help, and how that will enable us to hopefully help our children in a similar way as we can now save money since our mortgage is less than rent would be, plus the house is gaining equity.
I know PIL get real satisfaction from how much their help has been appreciated.

I don't understand parents who wouldn't do this if they could and can understand feeling hurt when you know they have spare money.

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 18:04

Can't get over someone earning 80K thinking they are hard done by !

Well at least you'll re not one of those claiming OP's parents are just getting by. 😄

NeshNamechanger · 22/03/2023 17:59

WeAreBorg · 22/03/2023 17:49

Yes for sure, some people don’t work hard or are fundamentally unsuccessful and bitter about the success and wealth of others.

But the bank of mum and dad is the biggest lender eh. OPs parents don’t have to give her much just to take the edge off for her, maybe they can’t max out both their ISAs for one year and have to put in a measly £30K between them. The return is that their child can sleep at night

Where has she said she can't sleep at night?
Honestly stop making things up
Can't get over someone earning 80K thinking they are hard done by !

TheyAreMadeOutOfMeat · 22/03/2023 17:58

Also something in this point that those from wealthy backgrounds don't behave like that. And people who have always had little don't behave like that: both tend to be extremely generous to family and children in particular, with whatever they can. This seems to be specific mainly to a group of people who grew up relatively poor, lived a working life that coincided with the most favourable economic conditions ever known, and have somehow become as a result very possessive about money and lack any generosity of sense that the whole point of having better circumstances is to spread them to family, a view not shared (again, big generalisations but certainly the trend is there) by most of the people poorer or richer than them, or by people older of younger than them, or by people elsewhere on Earth. It's a very interesting phenomenon, this Smaug-like "it's mine until I die on the heap of gold" idea.

As I say not like this in my family at all, and really feel for the people whose families are like this. Strange they can live with the logical disconnect between claiming they love their families then choosing to let them struggle. Confused But I do think it is interesting from a sociological perspective because it is by no means a natural human instinct to view family relationships in such a way.

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 17:57

*It's because I can afford it and want to.

I certainly don't think my parents loved me less because they didn't fund my wedding or give me a shit load of cash to put towards a mortgage. What an odd thing to think.*

I'm not talking about your parents. I'm talking about what you are giving your kids.

I'm not sure it's an indicator of love as such. I don't think spending money on a person is an indicator that you love them more. Love is shown in a multitude of ways.

Of course.

But it indicates something. Even if you can't get yourself to actually admit it. 😄

EffortlessDesmond · 22/03/2023 17:57

I haven't voted, but I've read the OPs posts, and being quite close to her parents in age (if not in wealth, though far from impoverished) I think they are probably rather proud of you for making good progress at standing on your own feet.

If I may throw a few thoughts into the conversation, don't forget that your parents won't always have your DF's consultancy income, and that they may well need care for their last years. On our experience of DMIL's three years in residential care, it soaks up a lot of money alarmingly fast... £50k in her last year, so in the worst situation, it could easily hit £100k pa apiece.

That said, I do feel they are being a bit tight with the spondulicks: clearly they could well afford to treat you all to a lovely holiday, and it would be kind to gift you money in an emergency, if your boiler blew up, the car needed replacing, or you needed extra help for medical care or educational needs. But as soon as your youngest no longer costs you £18k in childcare, your finances will improve rapidly while working full time will have kept your career on the front foot and at 35, you have yet to discover that your peak earning days are likely to be those from 40 to 60, so you have time on your side. I hope you won't let this sour your relationship with your parents.

lifeturnsonadime · 22/03/2023 17:52

Hmmmm. Yes. Not sure it's usually demonstrated by enjoying luxuries while people you purportedly love are stressed and exhausted and worried about money and you could easily take those problems away without any negative impact whatsoever on your own life. 🤣

Well what a stretch that is.

How is OP struggling. She can afford holidays just not foreign?

She can't afford to work part -time?

I mean you'd think the way you are going on she couldn't afford to eat or clothe her kids or something. But no.

Very soon she's going to have an additional £18k per year that she's not going to have to spend on childcare costs. Which can fund the lifestyle she thinks she's entitled to.

She's hardly piss poor is she? She just resents her parents and thinks they should pay for her to have better things.

I mean when does it end? When she can afford a 2 week holiday abroad will she be moaning that if they helped her she could have a 3 week holiday?

LooksLikeASugarInAPlum · 22/03/2023 17:51

OP you sound rather half empty, you’re 35, you are married, have DC, a home you’ve bought, a job, healthy parents, 80k per year joint salary. That’s a lot to be thankful for.

WeAreBorg · 22/03/2023 17:49

NeshNamechanger · 22/03/2023 17:39

Giving of your own free will is very different to expecting.
It's the eyeing of what other people have and feeling bitter and jealous that's the issue.
It's not reasonable at all!

Yes for sure, some people don’t work hard or are fundamentally unsuccessful and bitter about the success and wealth of others.

But the bank of mum and dad is the biggest lender eh. OPs parents don’t have to give her much just to take the edge off for her, maybe they can’t max out both their ISAs for one year and have to put in a measly £30K between them. The return is that their child can sleep at night

TheyAreMadeOutOfMeat · 22/03/2023 17:47

I'm not sure it's an indicator of love as such. I don't think spending money on a person is an indicator that you love them more. Love is shown in a multitude of ways.

Hmmmm. Yes. Not sure it's usually demonstrated by enjoying luxuries while people you purportedly love are stressed and exhausted and worried about money and you could easily take those problems away without any negative impact whatsoever on your own life. 🤣

Obviously people have other ways of showing love AS WELL and most people would do both if they could. But to deliberately NOT help a child or GC financially when you can and it would make a huge difference to their lives is not exactly showing love is it? Love isn't a feeling, it's about what we do.

TheyAreMadeOutOfMeat · 22/03/2023 17:42

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 17:13

I've had no handouts when my parents could have handed out. The difference is I don't think they owe me anything.

Why are you going to be giving your kids handouts?

You seem more focused on the fact that you never had handouts.

But seem to think it's a good thing to be doing for your children. Why bother?

You never had any.

Hmmmm yes there seems to be an insight here in what you've said: that it's often people whose parents could not help them because they were not in a position to do so (but also seem jn many cases to have been the type who absolutely would have if they could have), who then seem to have an idea that helping their own children when they are able to would be a bad thing. Extremely odd, you'd think it would be the opposite: surely the whole point of working hard to earn more money in the first place is to avoid future struggles for your family, not see it as some sort of moral virtue to make them suffer, too, when not needed.

I find it very strange and it is totally at odds with how most cultures view family wealth at any level, in that the general view in mosf cultures I'm familiar with is that its entire purpose is to help the following generations. Not to make you feel superior to them while you boast about cruises. 🤣 Also very interesting that people with very significant wealth going back generations take the absolutely opposite view to these people who want to hang on to it all until they die: in families with significant generational wealth it's always been about conserving that wealth and how to pass it down to children and grandchildren in the most effective way.

I think it is something perculiar about a generation (again not all, but a large proportion of them have these views that other UK generations and other cultures do not generally share) who largely became far, far wealthier than their parents, primarily due to extremely favourable economic circumstances during the period of their working lives. Basically if you are aged 60-80 then unless you were very lazy or very unlucky it was highly likely you'd end up comfortable at least, if not rather well off and much better off than your parents (assuming you didn't come from an already wealthy family). Grammar schools, free university, cheap housing, jobs boom, inflate away mortgages, so much made of high interest rates but for a short period of time plus MIRAS!!!, possible to live on one salary so no extortionate childcare cost, cheap foreign travel as you hit middle age, final salary pensions for many, even much higher compound growth on savings and investments... the list goes on. So perhaps some weird kind of cognitive dissonance where there is some assumption that because this was possible for almost anybody in those economic conditions it must therefore be the same now? Obviously silly but this is why when people bang on about "lived experience" rather than analysing data it can lead to such false conclusions, because by definition it gives you a very myopic and limited perspective.

The "not understanding" is just about excusable, because that type of cognitive dissonance is a well-researched thing. The assertion that you want your children to suffer like you (believe you) did instead of wanting their lives to be better than yours was (if you have the means to make that happen), make things easier and happier for them, is peverse at best. Seems to be a huge empathy bypass among many and some very unusual levels of selfishness and strange views about family wealth that just do not translate to common views across the world or to other generations in the UK.

Again, obviously there are many exceptions and people that age who do not think or behave this way! But a disproportionate amount do seem to, compared to others, and I wonder why that is. It's interesting. I wonder if any psychologists have ever done a study on it. I do also wonder when these people reach the end of their lives whether they'll still believe, deep down, that treating their families in such a way was a good idea. I find it quite alien.

NeshNamechanger · 22/03/2023 17:39

WeAreBorg · 22/03/2023 17:36

Parents who don’t help their children out, adult or otherwise, are pretty shit tbh. I couldn’t think of anything worse than swanning off on a cruise several times a year while my children and grandchildren were struggling.

My parents very kindly helped me and my sibling, they gave generously to charity and their attitude to money has rubbed off on all of us. My kids have JISAs etc., they give pocket money to charities and they will most definitely get house deposits off me and help with whatever else I can manage.

OP you are entirely reasonable!

Giving of your own free will is very different to expecting.
It's the eyeing of what other people have and feeling bitter and jealous that's the issue.
It's not reasonable at all!

lifeturnsonadime · 22/03/2023 17:38

while my children and grandchildren were struggling.

How is OP struggling.

Her examples are having to take UK holidays not foreign ones and not being able to work part time and not yet having savings, they will have an additional £18K when they lose their childcare costs very soon.

That's not struggling at all. It's wanting more than they can currently afford.

WeAreBorg · 22/03/2023 17:36

Parents who don’t help their children out, adult or otherwise, are pretty shit tbh. I couldn’t think of anything worse than swanning off on a cruise several times a year while my children and grandchildren were struggling.

My parents very kindly helped me and my sibling, they gave generously to charity and their attitude to money has rubbed off on all of us. My kids have JISAs etc., they give pocket money to charities and they will most definitely get house deposits off me and help with whatever else I can manage.

OP you are entirely reasonable!

Kisskiss · 22/03/2023 17:35

They don’t sound particularly rich, you don’t sound particularly poor.. I think their job was to bring you up with an education so you can stand on your own two feet financially.. not sure why you expect them to pay for you now so you can relax a bit more?
They should be enjoying their retirement .. as you said yourself they worked hard for their money.. they are probably expecting you to do the same? you sound fairly comfortable and maybe they don’t think that you are at a point where you need parental subsidy..

NeshNamechanger · 22/03/2023 17:34

Feeling bitter because your parents haven't given you money is so odd to me, I don't feel bitter in the way the OP does because I never felt entitled to my parent's money as an adult
This is the crux of it.
Some people feel entitled to other people's time, resources and money and others don't.
It's a Narc trait, extreme jealousy and entitlement.

lifeturnsonadime · 22/03/2023 17:34

It's because I can afford it and want to.

I'm not sure it's an indicator of love as such. I don't think spending money on a person is an indicator that you love them more. Love is shown in a multitude of ways.

I certainly don't think my parents loved me less because they didn't fund my wedding or give me a shit load of cash to put towards a mortgage. What an odd thing to think.

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 17:31

@lifeturnsonadime

I'm not grasping anything.

I'm curious why you are making that provision for your kids as young adults?

I'm guessing ( forgive me if I'm wrong ) it's because you love them and want the best start for them.

I imagine that OP is struggling to understand why even though it seems her parents have wealth they haven't ever chosen ( as you have ) to share any of it with them.

The choice is the thing here. And what that choice implies.

Regardless of how entitled your kids turn out to be, you have chosen to do that for them.

lifeturnsonadime · 22/03/2023 17:23

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 17:19

Yes because I want to, that is my choice.

Of course it is.

Why though? Why do you make that choice?

Clearly not every parent does, even when they are able to. See OPs parents.

I'm not sure what you are not grasping here.

Because I want to, not because I'm morally obliged to.

No adult should feel entitled to their parent's money. It is up to the parents to decide how to spend their money.

Feeling bitter because your parents haven't given you money is so odd to me, I don't feel bitter in the way the OP does because I never felt entitled to my parent's money as an adult.

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 17:23

After income tax it'll be around £50k for two people - do you think a couple earning £50k each are rolling in it?

Without dependents, or mortgage they will still be better off than many many people in this country.

God help the rest of the retirees not on £100k plus a year. 😄

LooksLikeASugarInAPlum · 22/03/2023 17:21

OP are you DH’s parents alive, have they helped you?

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 17:19

Yes because I want to, that is my choice.

Of course it is.

Why though? Why do you make that choice?

Clearly not every parent does, even when they are able to. See OPs parents.

ladykale · 22/03/2023 17:18

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 15:48

Two holidays a year & 100k income + rental income isn't really rolling in it. Did your mum work or is that their total income?*

To be clear though , you don't think £100k a year and the rest, plus no dependents or mortgage isn't a great lifestyle?

I know 'rich and rolling in it are subjective but I think that's very very decent.

Like the average UK salary is £38,000.

MN blows my mind sometimes.

After income tax it'll be around £50k for two people - do you think a couple earning £50k each are rolling in it?