Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Very rich parents

636 replies

jennybrightcandle · 21/03/2023 20:56

I honestly don’t know if I’m being unreasonable here or not. I may be a terrible person and am willing to be told so if that is the case.

When I was growing up, my parents had a fairly average income. I had a fairly “normal” upbringing: 3 bed semi, camping holidays, state schools etc. However, over time, my parents have become very rich. Partly luck of course, but also a lot of very hard work.

They are now in a position where they can go on multiple holidays a year (they’ve just booked two cruises for this summer, for example). They own two properties outright (one they live in, one they rent out). They are fairly open about their finances and so I know that as well as claiming a final salary pension, my dad is also still bringing in around 100k a year in investments and consultancy work. They have told me that they have full holdings in premium bonds etc etc.

We are fairly typical of our generation in that we both work full time in order to pay our mortgage. Neither of us particularly enjoy our jobs but we can’t career change or reduce hours as we need the money. We haven’t been on holiday overseas since 2015. We are doing fine and not on the breadline, but things are tight. We don’t currently have any savings although hopefully that will change soon as our youngest will be starting school (previously we were paying around 18k a year on childcare!!)

This is where it gets a bit embarrassing but am I being totally unreasonable to think our parents could maybe…help us out a bit?! I mean, I look at some of my peers who have had significant parental help towards buying a house or free childcare etc. And I just find it a bit odd that they haven’t thought to do the same.

I know I shouldn’t expect it and that they have no obligation whatsoever to provide anything now that I’ve left home but I just find it kind of hurtful. They have so much money and we live fairly hand to mouth each month. I honestly can’t imagine being like this with my own children and plan to help them out as much as I can.

So…am I being horribly unreasonable, materialistic and grasping 😬?

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 22/03/2023 13:44

I don't live in particularly super affluent area but I do see grandparents taking families on holiday. It really isn't uncommon.

How do you know who is paying for the holiday?

wwyd2021medicine · 22/03/2023 13:43

I'm well of but I never do anything without a voucher code
Got £142 off DD's upcoming holiday yesterday by combining site and voucher schemes 🤷🏼‍♀️ why not?

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 13:42

OP agree with @ZacharinaQuack . Your parents just might not get it.

Things have changed SO much since they were in your position.

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 13:40

Still laughing at " lifestyle choices" - honestly would that just be a nice holiday?

😄

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 13:39

The small amount of money set aside to assist with a property purchase is the limit of what we intend to give.

Unfortunately none of us have crystal balls for the future though.

In years to come and if you are able, you might think "i'd love to take the younger dimes on a lovely holiday - they need a break...."

Hardly " funding lifestyle choices" 😄

I don't live in particularly super affluent area but I do see grandparents taking families on holiday. It really isn't uncommon.

cptartapp · 22/03/2023 13:36

PIL are well off but still everything done on the cheap. Eating out for example wouldn't be done without a voucher. They don't travel. Kitchen and bathroom over fifty years old. GC got a £30 cheque for their 18th.
They generously though gave SIL £20k for her house deposit and paid for all her wedding. DH got nothing for either.
Don't get it.

jennybrightcandle · 22/03/2023 13:32

lifeturnsonadime · 22/03/2023 13:28

There are different types of “struggling” and you can be coping ok (as we are) but still exhausted, stressed, juggling everything etc and knowing a little extra money would help. Surely you recognise this as presumably you will help your kids out even if they can still feed and clothe their kids. I don’t think it is a red herring at all.

I have no intention of funding lifestyle choices in my adult children. They are being taught to live within their means. Just as we do. If it means we can't afford it or have to tighten the purse strings according with COL rises than that is what everyone has to do.

The small amount of money set aside to assist with a property purchase is the limit of what we intend to give. We work hard and expect to enjoy our retirement. We may put money in trust for any grandchildren for education purposes or for property purchase, if means allow. We certainly won't be paying for foreign holidays or handing our so that our kids can have a better lifestyle.

I had no expectations my parents would fund nice clothes or holiday or sub my mortgage so that I can work part time nor has any adult that I know.

You don’t seem to understand my point and I don’t understand your logic so we’ll probably never agree on this.

OP posts:
theGooHasGone · 22/03/2023 13:30

I don't think you're unreasonable for feeling the way you do. It was a lot easier for their generation to buy houses as the prices were far lower (even though interest rates were terrible in the 80s) and salaries were more representative. Final salary pensions were still a thing too. The cost of living has increased ridiculously over the last 30 years and incomes aren't going up to match.

They don't have to help you but it'd be nice if they would. I suspect they're isolated from the "real world" and somewhat ignorant about how you can't just "do the same thing they did" and "try a bit harder". Many people of that generation would rather believe it's laziness that's preventing success, rather than a material change in the world.

ZacharinaQuack · 22/03/2023 13:28

I think you are BU mainly because it sounds like you know a lot more about your parents' financial position than they do about yours. If they are, as you say, generally open about money, they may well assume that you'd do the same and actually tell them if you needed help. But you also say that your mum was surprised to learn recently that your childcare costs are so high, and that you have no savings. Your parents have likely been assuming that you are doing fine, and if they think about it at all, probably assume that you don't go on many holidays because it's hassle with small children.

I was lucky enough to receive help with a house deposit from my parents when I was in my 20s (now in my 40s). But my parents had more assets than yours, though lower retirement incomes, so they had that cash available - yours may not have done. Once I was working and had a house, they wouldn't have thought to offer me money unless I'd said I needed it - they'd have assumed I didn't. And in fact (like your mum) my dad was surprised to find out how low my salary was in a professional job that used to be better paid before many years of below-inflation pay rises...

Anyway, if your parents genuinely are open about money and happy to talk about it, it's probably the right time for you and your sibling to have a frank discussion with them about estate planning. You're likely to end up as executors anyway. And as your parents have a high income, it's likely they're not spending it all and could avoid some IHT by paying for some of your DCs' expenses etc. You could mention as part of that discussion that you're actually quite stretched.

jennybrightcandle · 22/03/2023 13:28

SomeUnspokenThing · 22/03/2023 13:25

OP, I think I understand where you're coming from. I can imagine that you look at your children and want to support them in any way you can for as long as you can because you love them and they mean the world to you. But your parents don't appear to have the same attitude and perhaps that stings? It's not about them paying for holidays or giving you a handout. Of course, I could be way off base! Personally, I am of the same mind as you. I am actively planning for my daughter's future and hope to support her for as long as I can, whilst still expecting that she'll be a fully-functioning independent adult with her own life carved out.

Exactly this. I just think if I am able to help my children out when they’re older, I will. Because why wouldn’t I? I just can’t see why I wouldn’t.

They have chosen not to help us out, even though I think they could afford it (although I know one or two posters seem to think they can’t).

I don’t understand why they have made that choice.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 22/03/2023 13:28

There are different types of “struggling” and you can be coping ok (as we are) but still exhausted, stressed, juggling everything etc and knowing a little extra money would help. Surely you recognise this as presumably you will help your kids out even if they can still feed and clothe their kids. I don’t think it is a red herring at all.

I have no intention of funding lifestyle choices in my adult children. They are being taught to live within their means. Just as we do. If it means we can't afford it or have to tighten the purse strings according with COL rises than that is what everyone has to do.

The small amount of money set aside to assist with a property purchase is the limit of what we intend to give. We work hard and expect to enjoy our retirement. We may put money in trust for any grandchildren for education purposes or for property purchase, if means allow. We certainly won't be paying for foreign holidays or handing our so that our kids can have a better lifestyle.

I had no expectations my parents would fund nice clothes or holiday or sub my mortgage so that I can work part time nor has any adult that I know.

SummerWillow · 22/03/2023 13:27

Regular gifts out of income which do not affect lifestyle are free of inheritance tax. Also with a significant level of capital surprised your parents aren't taking advantage of inheritance tax planning. Perhaps their spending is very high and they don't have spare income.

Also as newly well off, perhaps the mindset of being wealthy hasn't got to them yet. Are they afraid of losing their funds? Do they think that they worked for it and worry about making you 'lazy' with gifts?? There are some very wealthy people out there who are deliberately not leaving much to their children for this reason.

SomeUnspokenThing · 22/03/2023 13:25

OP, I think I understand where you're coming from. I can imagine that you look at your children and want to support them in any way you can for as long as you can because you love them and they mean the world to you. But your parents don't appear to have the same attitude and perhaps that stings? It's not about them paying for holidays or giving you a handout. Of course, I could be way off base! Personally, I am of the same mind as you. I am actively planning for my daughter's future and hope to support her for as long as I can, whilst still expecting that she'll be a fully-functioning independent adult with her own life carved out.

TheyAreMadeOutOfMeat · 22/03/2023 13:24

That is utter appalling @JockTamsonsBairns

What vile, selfish people. Some people really do not deserve children and grandchildren.

TheSingingBean · 22/03/2023 13:21

JockTamsonsBairns · 22/03/2023 00:31

My PiLs are the wealthiest people I have ever come across. DFiL spent his entire career working in oil, and his pension and investments are insanely lucrative. They own 14 properties in London outright, and I wouldn't like to even guesstimate what rental income they get from them.

Six years ago, my DH lost his job very suddenly and unexpectedly. I'm a care worker, and I ramped up my hours to 7am until 10pm, six days a week, in order to cover the essentials.
My DD (their GDD) was 7 at the time, and I owed £50 fees to her dance club. DH refused to ask his parents to help out as he said they would refuse. I didn't believe him, so I phoned MiL myself. Unbelievably, he was right enough. She said that DDs dance wasn't essential, and therefore she would need to stop going. I got a lesson over the phone in "affordability" and working hard to earn money. I felt embarrassed and ashamed that I'd asked.
The irony was, MiL has never had a job. She left school, started dating FiL, then married him and became a homemaker.
I'll give her some credit, she's been an incredible homemaker over the years.
But I really didn't need a lecture on how I should work hard for my money.

DD had to stop dance lessons, as I couldn't meet the monthly fees.
I won't pretend it hasn't affected how I view them.

How hurtful. This kind of attitude is so difficult to understand.

jennybrightcandle · 22/03/2023 13:19

alwayscheery · 22/03/2023 13:16

Do you have siblings?
Because x 3 or x 4 for several siblings is very different to helping an only child.

I have one sibling.

OP posts:
sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 13:18

YANBU to expect help but the income you describe is not "very rich" to be honest. Owning two properties is not a huge deal especially if only one is rented out. Any income will be taxed so they'll end up with 60% at best. Cruise holidays are also far from a luxury, most people take 2-3 holidays a year if their income permits and it's not really extravagant or selfish to spend money on that.

Please give it a rest.

jennybrightcandle · 22/03/2023 13:18

lifeturnsonadime · 22/03/2023 13:08

I'm struggling to understand why you think they owe you.

Perhaps it's the examples you've used of foreign holidays and working part time.

It is their money. It is up to them to do what they want with it.

We didn't get a hand out. I haven't moaned. I don't expect my mum to fund a better life style than I can afford.

The fact that we are choosing to do something for our kids is a red - herring , it's irrelevant. The correct comparison is that I don't moan that my mother has nicer clothes than I do and was a SAHM with a tiny mortgage, the result of which means that she is cash rich in her 70s. Good for her. I don't want, need or expect her money.

If I couldn't feed myself or my kids it would be different. But it isn't. This is about a lifestyle you believe you are entitled to on the back of your parent's hard work. They don't owe you a lifestyle.

I think it would be kind of them to share their wealth. As many, many parents do. As you plan to do and as I plan to do. It is a kind thing to do for your offspring if you can afford it.

There are different types of “struggling” and you can be coping ok (as we are) but still exhausted, stressed, juggling everything etc and knowing a little extra money would help. Surely you recognise this as presumably you will help your kids out even if they can still feed and clothe their kids. I don’t think it is a red herring at all.

OP posts:
alwayscheery · 22/03/2023 13:16

jennybrightcandle · 22/03/2023 13:01

*No don't think that's it. Just thinks it's a bit weird they don't share it a bit more.

Which is completely different from " resenting them enjoying their retirement "*

Exactly this. For example, if they gave us 10k as a one off (DISCLAIMER - this is for illustration purposes and I am not saying I expect them to give us 10k) it would have a massive impact on us.

It would mean we wouldn’t have to stress about going into debt if the boiler breaks down. It would mean we could do some of the house repairs we’ve had to put off for years. It would mean we could overpay the mortgage and shave some time off the 31 year term. It would mean I could buy some new clothes rather than Vinted for a change.

And they could easily afford it, if they wanted to. I’m not saying they should, I’m not saying I expect it, but they could afford it and have made a choice not to.

Do you have siblings?
Because x 3 or x 4 for several siblings is very different to helping an only child.

sunglassesonthetable · 22/03/2023 13:14

The fact that we are choosing to do something for our kids is a red - herring , it's irrelevant. The correct comparison is that I don't moan that my mother has nicer clothes than I do and was a SAHM with a tiny mortgage, the result of which means that she is cash rich in her 70s. Good for her. I don't want, need or expect her money.

Ah it's the moaning for you.

Rather than the 'choosing not to.'

Even though you have chosen to make provision for your kids. And share your money in that way, unlike OPs parents.

OnAPostItNote · 22/03/2023 13:13

Have you ever asked them for money, even in a roundabout way?
As people get older they seem to hoard more.

TheyAreMadeOutOfMeat · 22/03/2023 13:10

Choconut · 22/03/2023 13:02

I can't imagine not helping my dc as much as possible, what's the point of money if not to do that?

Exactly.

waterlego · 22/03/2023 13:10

My parents were in a very similar situation to yours. Both from working class families, both worked very hard and then had some luck/made some good decisions which resulted in them becoming very wealthy. I never expected anything from them but was very grateful when they helped my brother and I to buy our first properties, as well as giving us a small cash gift every year to help ‘keep the wolf from the door’. They also occasionally invited us on holidays or trips with them which they would often pay for (or pay for flights). They also very kindly contributed to the cost of childcare when I went back to work (without which I would have delayed returning to work because the cost of childcare would have made it pretty pointless in financial terms).

I was really lucky and appreciated their help very much. I would do the same for my children if I was in a position to.

lifeturnsonadime · 22/03/2023 13:08

jennybrightcandle · 22/03/2023 13:05

I’m sorry, I’m just really struggling to take you seriously since you’ve said you’ll help your own children out.

You clearly see the value in doing that so I just can’t understand why you can’t see why I’d be hurt that my parents have chosen not to 🤷‍♀️

That’s ok though as we don’t have to agree 😊

I'm struggling to understand why you think they owe you.

Perhaps it's the examples you've used of foreign holidays and working part time.

It is their money. It is up to them to do what they want with it.

We didn't get a hand out. I haven't moaned. I don't expect my mum to fund a better life style than I can afford.

The fact that we are choosing to do something for our kids is a red - herring , it's irrelevant. The correct comparison is that I don't moan that my mother has nicer clothes than I do and was a SAHM with a tiny mortgage, the result of which means that she is cash rich in her 70s. Good for her. I don't want, need or expect her money.

If I couldn't feed myself or my kids it would be different. But it isn't. This is about a lifestyle you believe you are entitled to on the back of your parent's hard work. They don't owe you a lifestyle.

Moanranger · 22/03/2023 13:06

I find these responses bewildering. I grew up with generational wealth. My grandfather owned the equivalent of a FTSE 500 company. It goes without saying that all the generations subsequent were gifted. In a proportional and systematic way.
By my generation, this was not a whole lot of money (lots fo descendants) but it meant that I and my various cousins would have access to funds for key expenditures, education, weddings, house deposits. This is how my ancestors would think about wealth, and it is how I would also.
OPs parents don’t actually have a lot of wealth, basically just two properties and their investments. DB pensions have a value, but when the beneficiary dies, they are gone. The OPs parents do have quite a good income.
It is this difference between capital & income is why the OPs parents don’t think about helping their offspring. In my family, it would be normal ( but not so much in hers)
My children will inherit wealth, and I would hope that they would conserve it. But their income and spending decisions are up to them.
I do think the OP should open a conversation with her parents, about assisting them, perhaps with childcare - onerous ATM. It will largely depend on their values and what they feel might help their DC/GDC the most.