Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if this doesn't upset you, nothing will

306 replies

ThirdWorld · 21/03/2023 19:21

I've name changed for this as it's very identifying.

I live in a small village and and as a treat after a long hard day at work popped into my local pub for dinner.

Lying on the floor was an elderly woman. She was covered with a warm blanket. She had tripped and fallen at lunchtime, and obviously badly hurt herself.

An ambulance was called at 12:30, she is still lying there in the middle of the pub waiting for an ambulance.

I've obviously read about how broken our NHS is and even read the thread on here where a poster had written about her aunt who had fallen and was waiting for about 12 hours for an ambulance. But reading about it and actually seeing it for real is even more heartbreaking.

This poor old woman has been lying on a cold wooden floor for 7 hours! The owners and bar staff have been amazing and are looking after her. Well as much as they can.

I can't tell you how useless I feel. There is nothing anyone can do. The woman has obviously been refusing food or fluid in fear of wetting herself.

I know from reading the thread I mentioned previously that there is nothing anyone can do but wait.

As we left they were getting her a pad to relieve herself. In the middle of a pub!!!

This is 21st century Britain! I don't know what I'm expecting from this thread, am tempted to call the local press to see if the publicity could hurry things along, but that would probably be even more humiliating for her.

This woman has no family and is cold, miserable and in pain lying in the middle of a pub.

I just can't believe our country has fallen to this. God knows when an ambulance will arrive. She will end up getting more dehydrated and probably go into shock. And there is nothing anyone can do.

So distressing to see and my heart bleeds for the poor woman. Just prey that none of your relatives ever have a fall.

Let's hope an ambulance comes soon.

OP posts:
Ukrainebaby23 · 23/03/2023 02:48

ThirdWorld · 22/03/2023 23:37

She's had 2 operations - one for a broken hip and one to do with complications from lying on a cold wooden floor for nearly 12 hours.

She's "comfortable" but in a hospital about 50 miles away, so can't visit. I wanted to send her flowers instead but I believe you can't do that now?

Glad shes recovering, yes EVERYONE should be upset by this, even if you dont have elderly parents or friends, one day likely you'll be the elderly person. Long lies, as they are called in the health service are well known to be extremely dangerous and increase complications in what is already a high risk population. Broken hips are high risk too and mixed with a long lie, increase fatalities. It also lengthens hospital stays and recovery is less likely and longer.
The amb crews get upset about having to provide such poor service and get stressed, it's inevitable. I believe it was also a cause of their striking.

So YES, YOU, WE, EVERY MUMSNETTER should be getting upset with the amb/nhs/politicians whoever you want to blame. It's both dangerous and uncompassionate to even attempt to move someone with a broken hip, so no, she couldn't just get put in a car/van.

Btw, Flowers, usually a no unless its a community rehab hospital then its a maybe. Nice thought though, and I think you and the pub people acted very well. Maybe send a chocolate parcel?

Phoebo · 23/03/2023 01:45

ThirdWorld · 22/03/2023 23:37

She's had 2 operations - one for a broken hip and one to do with complications from lying on a cold wooden floor for nearly 12 hours.

She's "comfortable" but in a hospital about 50 miles away, so can't visit. I wanted to send her flowers instead but I believe you can't do that now?

Gosh that's horrible 😢

theblackradiator · 23/03/2023 01:24

TheUsualChaos · 21/03/2023 19:56

It's awful and happening daily.
The Tories have been hell-bent on pushing the public towards wanting a privatised system for years. And now here we are, 2023 and approaching the end game. An NHS failing so badly that soon people will be begging for a new privately run system to save our broken health care system.

Then, years down the line, when people realise how they were manipulated and lied to and people of all ages are dying because they can't afford treatments which would once have been provided for by the NHS without question, the government will shrug and say "this was what the public wanted".

This exactly. the future is frightening in the UK.

Feuillemille23 · 23/03/2023 01:23

You'll never get a Tory voter to acknowledge their level of complicity - or complacency at best - in the current state of the NHS (and education, social care, general maintenance amongst so many others). There's an example in my circle of someone who retired on a big fat pension in the late 1980s and is now too infirm with too expensive a condition for private health care so has had to have NHS input. Doesn't stop his mouth flapping almost non stop about how bad the NHS is though.

I remember the NHS from about 1999 to about 2010 as being a fairly good place to work - not perfect, but decent. Can't quite recall what happened in 2010 but I vaguely remember some turncoat Tory enabling Lib Dems floating about a rose garden in snazzy tailored suits...

TooBigForMyBoots · 23/03/2023 00:54

I am so glad this woman received the surgical care she needed so quickly.

My mum's friend fell and broke her hip at the start of the year. The ambulance arrived quite quickly, but it took 2 days for her to get a bed on a ward and a week before she had the op.

The op only happened after her family kicked up about her being left on a bedpan for 45 minutes on day 5. 45 minutes on a bedpan with a broken hip! She is on the mend now but only because she had people to fight advocate for her.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 23/03/2023 00:36

I wonder if there was some way she could’ve been gently and slowly moved… how undignified to leave her there like that. At the least I feel a screen of some sort could’ve given her some privacy.

An awful lot of talk about what should have happened with zero insight into how it could have happened. OP has made it clear the bar area was closed.

T1Dmama · 23/03/2023 00:35

ThirdWorld · 22/03/2023 23:37

She's had 2 operations - one for a broken hip and one to do with complications from lying on a cold wooden floor for nearly 12 hours.

She's "comfortable" but in a hospital about 50 miles away, so can't visit. I wanted to send her flowers instead but I believe you can't do that now?

Phone the hospital and ask their policy… I’m sure she’d appreciate a card and kind words as much as anything else x
what a lovely thing to do. Poor woman!

T1Dmama · 23/03/2023 00:33

Really really sad!
I remember watching a documentary on TV where an elderly gentleman had fallen in his flat and was laid on the floor, Every-time an ambulance was on its way to him they called out to a more urgent case (heart attack/stoke/choking etc) it was heart breaking and he ended up waiting a ridiculous amount of time!
I wonder if there was some way she could’ve been gently and slowly moved… how undignified to leave her there like that. At the least I feel a screen of some sort could’ve given her some privacy.
I hope the government starts ploughing more money into health and education…. Both are lacking at the moment and both are crucial. Yet we have billions to donate each year… doesn’t make sense

Mothership4two · 23/03/2023 00:28

In December FIL (87) on floor for 13 hours with broken hip in excruciating pain, then 5 hours stuck in the ambulance and then another 4/5 hours until actually seen. He was distressed and demoralised. I know there will be similar and worse incidents.

Sugarfree23 · 23/03/2023 00:22

Why not send a card or balloon?
In our area no flowers has been a thing 20 years plus.

Womencanlift · 22/03/2023 23:45

ThirdWorld · 22/03/2023 23:37

She's had 2 operations - one for a broken hip and one to do with complications from lying on a cold wooden floor for nearly 12 hours.

She's "comfortable" but in a hospital about 50 miles away, so can't visit. I wanted to send her flowers instead but I believe you can't do that now?

Oh that’s awful that she has had additional injuries because of the wait, just shocking

Regarding the flowers, I don’t know if it varies per hospital but I had family members in hospital over 10 years ago and the no flowers thing was in place then. So certainly in our trust that’s not a recent change

ThirdWorld · 22/03/2023 23:37

She's had 2 operations - one for a broken hip and one to do with complications from lying on a cold wooden floor for nearly 12 hours.

She's "comfortable" but in a hospital about 50 miles away, so can't visit. I wanted to send her flowers instead but I believe you can't do that now?

OP posts:
Swiftbushome · 22/03/2023 23:15

@ScotsBluebell most of us can't leave anyway thanks to Brexit

ScotsBluebell · 22/03/2023 23:11

Worrying that so many people think you can just move somebody with a broken hip. The pain alone would probably kill an elderly person, presumably with other health conditions. The UK has gone to the hell in a handcart in all possible ways. We are literally, and metaphorically in the shit and I see no way out. If I were younger, I'd leave.

neilyoungismyhero · 22/03/2023 23:10

Newtoitallreally · 21/03/2023 21:07

I don’t understand how it’s come to this in the U.K., can someone explain to me please? I’m in Portugal, a much poorer country, but an ambulance would arrive quite swiftly…I don’t understand

There are 68 million people in the UK.
10 million in Portugal.
Is it really that hard to understand?

anon666 · 22/03/2023 23:04

Rebel2 · 22/03/2023 22:39

@anon666 but generally it's not
In front of the people on the floor, presuming they're not on the floor because or with any of the following are
Drowning, hanging, choking, cardiac arrests, giving birth imminently, chest pain, breathing difficulties, anaphylactic reaction, stroke, severe bleeding, unconscious, amputations, open fractures, fitting.....
If the ambulances are all at those, they can't go to someone on the floor. And by the time they come free, there's another 10 priority calls waiting

On the floor with a broken ankle/bruising/small cuts/no injury is way down the list, it's not life threatening at that minute
Yes it can cause complications especially with a broken hip but at that very second the call is made, their life is not in danger

No, absolutely. I'm not disagreeing that the capacity of the whole system needs to increase.

But we need to plan capacity using a prioritisation protocol that includes falls like these in a higher category than they currently sit.

For example are these declared as serious incidents? Are RCAs and harm reviews taking place to establish what happened?

My impression is that the Tories have watered down a lot of the governance.

Rebel2 · 22/03/2023 22:39

@anon666 but generally it's not
In front of the people on the floor, presuming they're not on the floor because or with any of the following are
Drowning, hanging, choking, cardiac arrests, giving birth imminently, chest pain, breathing difficulties, anaphylactic reaction, stroke, severe bleeding, unconscious, amputations, open fractures, fitting.....
If the ambulances are all at those, they can't go to someone on the floor. And by the time they come free, there's another 10 priority calls waiting

On the floor with a broken ankle/bruising/small cuts/no injury is way down the list, it's not life threatening at that minute
Yes it can cause complications especially with a broken hip but at that very second the call is made, their life is not in danger

anon666 · 22/03/2023 22:32

Rebel2 · 22/03/2023 22:26

It's not that the protocols are wrong, it's that the ambulances are all tied up at hospital or with more serious jobs. There are too many calls and not enough ambulances, and they're at hospital for too long

Not always true. Yes the ambulance service is massively overstretched. However, the reason people are left on the floor like that is that they are categorised as a non-life-threatening situation.

All I'm saying is they need to review how they prioritise falls like this based on the amount of harm that is being done, albeit the person may not drop dead before they arrive.

I'm not saying that all of the other reasons you state aren't also legitimate, because of course they are in addition.

anon666 · 22/03/2023 22:26

Honeyroar · 21/03/2023 20:37

I’m not a conservative voter, but I don’t think it was that good under labour either. The NHS has been failed for years and years. Wards closed, hospitals closed, nursing made so difficult to get into. It’s just been twisting figures, smoke and mirrors to seen like they’re hitting targets for years. When labour was in I was sent to a private hospital for a shoulder op just so they hit targets of getting everyone’s ops done in six months - how much must that have cost… I despair of them all.

I have to set you straight here. I've worked in finance in the NHS since 1997 and it is this simple. In 1997 the Labour govt inherited a service that was threadbare from years of Tory mismanagement and underfunding. Labour took over at a point where hospitals would shut down their elective surgery for 6 months when they ran out of funds, causing huge waste.

At the time I remember regular talk radio debates about the "unviability" of "free" healthcare.

Labour funded it and reformed it and put power into patients hands. It was anazing. Yes they funded through private healthcare to increase capacity. The private hospitals earned the same as NHS hospitals for each case but usually cherry picked the easier cases to make it viable. the NHS improved beyond imagination, to the point where an international report showed it to be the best health service in the world. And a relatively cheap one.

Andrew Lansley, who in my opinion should be in jail, was hellbent on an arrogant, misjudged and disastrous reform agenda. It started to destroy the NHS and the Tories have kept it in a complete state of change ever since. They've eroded every single aspect of high quality and ethics from health. They have no ideological support for the NHS and have successfully defended and destroyed it piece by piece.

They've created unbelievable working conditions for all the front line staff, and all the back office staff have to reapply for their own jobs on a one or two year rotation.

This is an eye witness account over the past 26 years.

Rebel2 · 22/03/2023 22:26

anon666 · 22/03/2023 22:08

I agree with you. They simply have to stop this happening. It's inhumane. I doubt people would leave an animal in that much distress.

I have no idea how they haven't already changed ambulance protocols as these are clearly wrong if they are routinely allowing this to happen.

It's simply not okay and I hope every single one of these people takes legal action if that's what it takes to establish change.

Maybe we should all be writing to our MPs

It's not that the protocols are wrong, it's that the ambulances are all tied up at hospital or with more serious jobs. There are too many calls and not enough ambulances, and they're at hospital for too long

anon666 · 22/03/2023 22:08

I agree with you. They simply have to stop this happening. It's inhumane. I doubt people would leave an animal in that much distress.

I have no idea how they haven't already changed ambulance protocols as these are clearly wrong if they are routinely allowing this to happen.

It's simply not okay and I hope every single one of these people takes legal action if that's what it takes to establish change.

Maybe we should all be writing to our MPs

Bunnyfuller · 22/03/2023 21:39

Obviously how? So often the public go on the old ‘don’t move them’ when actually the mechanism couldn’t have resulted in a serious injury, and someone is left freezing on the floor for no reason. Or left to die from a compromised airway because ‘don’t move them’.

If someone suspected serious injury (sadly broken hip in the elderly isn’t counted as such) why didn’t they relate that to ambo? ‘Badly hurt’ what does that mean?

Makingupfactstosuitmyagenda · 22/03/2023 21:20

@Bunnyfuller from the OP’s very first post;
Lying on the floor was an elderly woman. She was covered with a warm blanket. She had tripped and fallen at lunchtime, and obviously badly hurt herself.

Bunnyfuller · 22/03/2023 21:06

Unless she had fallen from height or was elderly it is doubtful her injuries would have necessitated no movement. Help her up and transport fgs!

Nurgleturtle · 22/03/2023 20:47

i currently work for the NHS, and called 999 for a patient having a stroke in an outpatient unit, we were told 2 hour wait for an ambulance for a code red situation. I took him to a&e to be seen.