Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is uniform in Girlguides compulsory?

129 replies

GirlGuidesUniform · 21/03/2023 17:18

8yo DD.

I work on Brownies night, so I get her from after school club (who feed her for me), then she takes off school cardigan and wears the Brownies hoodie on top of her uniform for the meeting - she then has a clean school uniform the next day.

She does have a tshirt she wears for weekend events and camps and also a cap she uses for school. Also if a message comes out for full uniform, for example at Christmas when they sang in town or in summer when they did a walk around town I always try and work around it (e.g. the walk around town I asked if she could wear her school trousers and asked the TA running ASC very very nicely if DD could change into her tshirt and hoodie before I picked her up but they can’t do this all the time as the club is open until 6pm and is packed until then so they can’t be changing 50+ kids clothes all the time)

Brown Owl is now saying DD needs to be in proper uniform from after Easter. I asked what this meant and she said brownies tshirt (either long or short sleeve), brownies hoodie or gilet and either brownies trousers or brownies shorts.

I am happy to buy shorts and/or trousers for events but if she has to wear full uniform every week she’ll have to give up, which seems unfair as she absolutely loves Brownies. This is the only group that I can get her to, as it starts at 6pm, I finish work at 5pm and then have 30 minutes commute on public transport, then a walk to the school. If we went home first to change we’d be late for Brownies which I’ve done a few times when unavoidable but DD hates being late.

I’m a single parent so no other help. I drive but don't currently have a car as due to COL I just can't afford it.

This is the only out of school activity DD does due to me working so much so seems a shame to make her give it up.

Is the uniform compulsory? I always thought that the way we did it was fine, but happy to be told wrong

OP posts:
Eggybrains · 29/03/2023 03:15

EmmaDilemma5 · 21/03/2023 17:31

That seems quite exclusive and disappointing of brownies. Surely inclusivity and enabling children to attend is more important than the colour of their t-shirts.

Hell no! Inclusivity is something Girlguiding are not keen on. Have a read of this https://www.girlguiding.org.uk/globalassets/docs-and-resources/diversity-and-inclusion/diversity-and-inclusion-audit-report.pdf

I'd say my personal experience of seeing disabled children discriminated against, and Girlguiding not caring would suggest it's actually got worse, not better since this audit.

https://www.girlguiding.org.uk/globalassets/docs-and-resources/diversity-and-inclusion/diversity-and-inclusion-audit-report.pdf

sashh · 24/03/2023 07:52

Glad you have a sensible solution OP

GirlGuidesUniform · 23/03/2023 20:00

Update:

Have spoken to Brown Owl again. We've compromised on the trousers, DD can wear trousers to school that day and we'll just change into tshirt and hoodie in the leisure centre before we go into Brownies hut apparently DD is not the only one who does this.

OP posts:
LittleOwl153 · 22/03/2023 18:21

Onthenosecco · 21/03/2023 17:46

Ive just looked on the website and they now stock the hoodie from size 3-4! When I checked before (in December) the smallest size was 7! Yay!

GirlGuiding Scotland webshop are usually a good source of small and indeed larger sized uniforms. They currently have 18" waist leggings and 22" chest tops... not sure what that equates to...

WandaWonder · 22/03/2023 04:17

My child changed into the uniform there sometimes

sashh · 22/03/2023 02:44

I agree with the changing but, you mentioned SN, that gives you access to 'reasonable adjustments'.

I know you said there are two schools using the space but primary uniforms are normally fairly similar from the waist down and the difference is in the tops / cardigans / shirts.

So could she a) go in her brownie uniform for school or b) change her trousers at lunch time?

And yes I had the brown dress, belt, badge, cravat etc.

Lunaloud · 22/03/2023 00:34

There must be toilets at school or brownies you can change her in. My dd has T-shirts & hoodie but that’s it, she just wears plain leggings, it’s never been an issue for her or her older sister. I’m guessing Brown Owl is clamping down on lax uniforms.

SE13Mummy · 22/03/2023 00:27

Hopefully Brown Owl will help find somewhere your DD can get changed at the meeting but another idea might be for DD to change into uniform bottoms at ASC. She could keep her school top on, so no complaints about not knowing which school she's from, until you collect her. At that point, she can swap her school sweater for her Brownies hoodie. Another idea might be to ask if she could get changed at the end of ASC, as you arrive to collect her.

One of my DDs is a Guide and is still wearing the old uniform i.e. not the weird neoprene type hoodie with lots of red on it. She can't tolerate the feel of the hoodie next to her skin and doesn't like how it squeaks. It's the only piece of clothing she has ever had issues with and although she does have one of the squeaky hoodies, I think she'd give up Guides rather than wear it. Luckily, the leaders are very understanding. When it was introduced I did wonder about the wisdom of such a weird fabric.

5foot5 · 21/03/2023 22:55

PuttingDownRoots · 21/03/2023 20:40

In the late 90s my uniform was brown culottes and yellow tshirt and jumper.

My DD was a Brownie 2002 to 2005 and wore the culottes and T shirt. I thought they were really nice actually. I seem to remember her having some sort of sash that the badges were sewn on to?

00100001 · 21/03/2023 22:31

GirlGuidesUniform · 21/03/2023 20:22

We have the hoodie with badges on.

On the toilets issue they use the leisure centre next door and have a break half way through where all the girls are taken over to the toilet. It's a tiny building smaller than a portacabin classroom at school, they're outside as much as they possibly can be because of it.

Will look into changing at the leisure centre, and if we can't and BO has no solution will just pull DD out, she loves going though so don't want but you're all right about it being part of it.

I did Brownies (not Rainbows or Guides though) and don't remember having a uniform - this will have been in the late 90s early 00s, my mum can't remember me having a uniform either.

You definitely had a uniform. Would have been a blue shirt

Noodledoodledoo · 21/03/2023 21:46

Both mine go from ASC to Brownies/Beavers, we just take uniform with us and they get changed - it takes no time.

I am a Guide leader, they are both uniformed organisations and most leaders will want the members in uniform, those saying its not inclusive - every unit I have worked with have helped girls who need it with the cost of uniform. Scouts locally is a lot stricter.

It is by far the cheapest activity they do, including the uniform costs.

Smartiepants79 · 21/03/2023 21:23

Guiding has always had uniforms. Yours would have had brown culottes. And a yellow t-shirt with a cap.

PinkTonic · 21/03/2023 21:09

jamdonut · 21/03/2023 17:28

Crikey … when I was a Brownie we had to wear full uniform and have the correct items in our pockets, including a clean handkerchief in an envelope and a 10p for the telephone… and we were inspected! Occasionally we could wear our own clothes if it was a particular event.😏Sorry, I know that’s not helpful to the situation.

I’m quite old and reading through was remembering we had a brass badge that had to be polished, a leather belt with a buckle that had to be polished, dress and neckerchief that had to be ironed, polished shoes…and yes, all the pocket items and inspection. Getting your stuff ready was quite a chore and we were expected to sew our own badges on too. Funny memories of very different times.

IhearyouClemFandango · 21/03/2023 21:02

Have a look at scouts if she does end up leaving (though hopefully brown owl will see sense). Both my big kids go through it, and only the top/necker is obligatory.

myveryownelectrickitten · 21/03/2023 21:01

Our Brownie pack is pretty relaxed - girls normally wear just the t-shirt and hoodie and jeans! Never had any issue. For formal occasions they were just asked to wear school uniform style plain skirt or trousers. It’s difficult to source the skort and leggings, too - I did get some from eBay but they are often not easily available.

Guides (which DD is now in) don’t even have a bottom half uniform any more - the idea is that they just wear their own stuff with the top and hoodie.

The whole organisation is so secularised and informal now compared to what it used to be like 25 or more years ago — I’m surprised they are that bothered about being “uniformed” to that degree for Brownie-aged girls. It’s not like they have in practice any remaining links with churches/other “uniformed organisations” like they used to.

They aren’t even in practice a single sex organisation any more — they recently had a gun-toting transwoman as a leader, who was posting pics of herself wearing a leather fetish outfit complete with riding crop all over social media! Being strict about whether an 8 year old has the right kind of brown leggings I’d say is the least of their problems!

Crazyfaisy · 21/03/2023 20:53

I would talk to Brown Owl - I volunteer at Brownies and we'd hate any girls to miss out because of something like this! All units do it differently - we just request one piece of uniform, either a tshirt or a hoodie, but we're quite relaxed.

Marmite27 · 21/03/2023 20:46

I was a Brownie ‘87 to ‘91. As I moved up to Guides mid-‘91 they changed the uniform. I had the dress for Brownies and a jumper and polo for Guides.

I was in gnomes, and bluebell. My eldest is a Scottish Kelpie and my goddaughter became a gnome this week.

I’m actually a Rainbow leader, we encourage the girls to wear red leggings or shorts because the fit on the official ones is abysmal. They get a t-shirt and badge book with their joining fee. Most have bought the hoody.

PuttingDownRoots · 21/03/2023 20:40

In the late 90s my uniform was brown culottes and yellow tshirt and jumper.

Jules912 · 21/03/2023 20:31

If you can't change there would ASC let her change then put her school jumper on over her brownie uniform - that way they'd still know which school she belongs to and she'd just have to change the jumper when she got there.

GirlGuidesUniform · 21/03/2023 20:22

We have the hoodie with badges on.

On the toilets issue they use the leisure centre next door and have a break half way through where all the girls are taken over to the toilet. It's a tiny building smaller than a portacabin classroom at school, they're outside as much as they possibly can be because of it.

Will look into changing at the leisure centre, and if we can't and BO has no solution will just pull DD out, she loves going though so don't want but you're all right about it being part of it.

I did Brownies (not Rainbows or Guides though) and don't remember having a uniform - this will have been in the late 90s early 00s, my mum can't remember me having a uniform either.

OP posts:
VestaTilley · 21/03/2023 20:19

Can’t you change her in the loos just before she goes in to Brownies, or at pick up from after school club? Talk to Brown Owl; she might relent if she knows it means she might have to drop out.

Blinglover · 21/03/2023 20:15

I have a spare Brownies top, trousers and zip up hoodie that you're very welcome to. I'll post it to you for free. Just PM me.

My DD12 is now in Guides and I just hadn't got round to getting rid of the Brownies uniform!

Jules912 · 21/03/2023 20:09

Onthenosecco · 21/03/2023 17:26

Brown owls / can you maybe give me some advice too? I’ve got a very small 7yo who is in brownies. I can’t get uniform small enough for her! We got her a t shirt which she can kind of pull off but the hoodies and trousers are about 3 sizes too big. She wears size 4-5 usually.

Op, she can surely change herself at after school, or once she gets to brownies?

My DD isn't quite that small ( normally wears 5-6) but I managed by getting the smallest leggings and sewing the waistband over at the back ( there's probably nicer ways to do this but I'm not great at sewing and wanted something I could unpick when she grows). She just rolls up the bottoms.

SammyScrounge · 21/03/2023 19:32

TrashyPanda · 21/03/2023 18:13

my Days as a Brownie predated Velcro on ties! It was a wee button.

and no purses on belts back then - as said, you kept your workbook, 10p and clean hanky in the pockets. Plus a pencil, I think. Actually, it might have been 2p when I started - it was so you could use a phone box.

the tunic was perfectly practical and not at all uncomfortable. And looked much nicer than the current uniform.

I predate the wee.button! We had a triangular scarf which.we had to learn to fold (real Marie Kondo stuff), then turn the folded scarf into a tie which fastened under the collar under the back. And the woollen stocking cap with the pompom! I was in the kingfisher six.
We were all so proud of our uniforms and of our emergency things in the flap pockets. OP,

It's a bit cheeky to join a uniformed organisation and then demand the uniform rules be changed especially for your.child. Your reasons for that are pretty flimsy. You have had several suggestions about how to get round 'difficulties' in changing. What not try them and let your girl have the whole Brownie experience, starting with the uniform which marks her out as one of a special group of girls she can be proud of.

TrashyPanda · 21/03/2023 19:22

I went back to help in 1978, and it was bobble hats then. Stayed for 4 years - I loved it!

Swipe left for the next trending thread