Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can a volatile relationship ever change?

30 replies

Daffydaff · 21/03/2023 14:03

Inspired by another thread, I'd love opinions on my relationship. I'm aware this is AIBU but am feeling robust enough to take any inevitable criticism on the chin.

This is potentially very outing too so I'll try to be detailed enough whilst also being vague, bear with me!

My partner and I only met a few times before I found out I was pregnant. Yes yes, irresponsible I know, no judgement required. I decided to keep the child, despite us not having a solid relationship at that time, giving a few options to him, e.g. I'd go it alone, or we could co-parent, or else we could make a go at creating a family unit.

We chose this last option, but it has been hard. I mean really hard. We are not naturally compatible, and there are traits in him that I would not choose in a partner usually, both superficial (e.g. I am a deep thinker and love a debate, he really only gets animated about cars) as well as substantial (e.g. I feel he doesn't really listen to me). I'm not faultless (I can be chaotic, demanding, and over sensitive when I’m tired) and he also brings out some bad behaviour in me too when we argue (which I’ll come on to in a bit). Nevertheless, three years later and we now have a second child, are planning a life together, and are consistently working at strengthening 'us'. He’s a great father, a good man, and is evolving (as I am) into a good and thoughtful partner - we had both been the ‘eternal bachelor’ type before, so we have been learning how to live with someone else let alone how to parent!

I guess my issue is that as we work at our relationship we argue a lot, and badly. It often follows a pattern - he takes out his bad mood on me, I defend myself, and it escalates - or else I respond negatively to one of the traits that I dislike. In the past I laid the blame firmly at his feet (I wouldn’t need to argue if I weren’t defending myself!) but I think now that it’s more nuanced, and it’s how we respond to one another that is the issue. I revert to some terrible teenage tantrum style of shouting - it's awful and something I trained myself out of years ago. Indeed, I pride myself on being an effective communicator generally! He on the other hand is passive and sulky when we row. But both of us have done the silent treatment, we have sworn at each other, have said some awful things (in front of our toddler too) and in any other circumstances I would not have stayed around. It has been toxic at times.

However, I think we have hope. We always reflect on our arguments, and are beginning to recognise the triggers - recently we have tried a few techniques to pull us back if it escalates e.g. a code word or leaving the room or a change in tone of voice. He is open to seeing a couples counsellor (albeit a little grudgingly, I think he thinks we're generally fine and can handle this ourselves, whereas I think we need objective support). Our children mean the world to us and we know that we must model good behaviour. I have also been nothing but pregnant and sleep deprived since we met so I'm not even sure if this is the 'real' us if that makes sense.

I guess my AIBU is am I deluding myself? The post I referred to at the start had lots of people saying they never had shouty arguments with their partner. I would usually agree, it's never something I'd ever countenance were it not for our young children and the fact that I don't think we've given our relationship a chance. We haven't even been on a date yet, if you can believe that! (We met during lockdown, and since then I’ve been EBF or pregnant so childcare has been last of my priorities)

I just don't want to give up yet, not until the hormones and fatigue have subsided.

I'll be absolutely clear - if we continue arguing then I will absolutely leave, and we have discussed this. The children come first and I do not want to model this sort of relationship to them, I've had my own share of dysfunctional parental influences to do that to my own. But can a relationship survive this sort of topsy turvy start - children first, then love and respect and longevity - or would anyone suggest it'll end terribly despite the work we're willing to put in?

(I'm not asking what I should do, I have no intention of leaving just yet, just curious as to other experiences and opinions).

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 21/03/2023 14:32

@Daffydaff

I can see you want it to work but wanting it to work on its own isn’t enough. You are trying to make it all sound reasonable but it’s extremely apparent that it’s a volatile and unhealthy relationship and you very clearly are not well suited.

If you want to take a couple more years of this in the hope that it will magically turn around who am I to stop you?

But for your children’s sake it will be much cleaner and easier to do this sooner rather than burdening them with it as the become older and more aware of the fact you have an awful relationship.

Daffydaff · 21/03/2023 14:24

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/03/2023 14:13

Honestly? Yes you are deluding yourself.

You are putting a very constructive spin on two extremely incompatible people who want different things and are not able to compromise and put differences aside for the benefit of your children. And he’s not a “great dad”.

You appear to answer your own question when you say you will leave if you continue arguing all the time. That ship has sailed.

Not going to pass judgment: what’s happened has happened but you have the power to decide whether your kids should spent decades being subjected to this and they don’t.

Stop putting a happy gloss on this chaotic mess and do the right thing.

But we don't want very different things. We ultimately want the same thing, and I hope we can learn to get there together.

We certainly won't spend decades working at this, but it has been an insane few years with hormones and sleep deprivation and life changing decisions. I don't want to ruin a potentially good relationship before it's begun because everything is foggy.

I'm not arguing with you for the sake of it, but I genuinely want this to work, as does he, and we are doing everything we can to make it happen.

OP posts:
Daffydaff · 21/03/2023 14:18

SparklingLime · 21/03/2023 14:06

Your toddler is being impacted now. All the curiosity and navel gazing in the world won't impact that.

Yes, and I understand the navel gazing comment too, that's fair enough. The arguing in front of her was the worst thing I've ever done believe me. But this is why we are working on the triggers and behaviour that would immediately impact them - first we allow ourselves to calm down and not argue in front of the children and then we look at the topic of disagreement.

I'm not disagreeing with you, but I'm trying to create a solid family unit born out of a very unconventional beginning.

Right now our toddler is an absolute joy, and we make sure we show love at all other times (when we don't argue we are very happy!)

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 21/03/2023 14:13

Honestly? Yes you are deluding yourself.

You are putting a very constructive spin on two extremely incompatible people who want different things and are not able to compromise and put differences aside for the benefit of your children. And he’s not a “great dad”.

You appear to answer your own question when you say you will leave if you continue arguing all the time. That ship has sailed.

Not going to pass judgment: what’s happened has happened but you have the power to decide whether your kids should spent decades being subjected to this and they don’t.

Stop putting a happy gloss on this chaotic mess and do the right thing.

SparklingLime · 21/03/2023 14:06

Your toddler is being impacted now. All the curiosity and navel gazing in the world won't impact that.