Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what else I can do with a medical degree

141 replies

BelleMarionette · 21/03/2023 11:47

I'm a doctor, and don't think I can afford to be anymore, with the abysmal pay, conditions, and antisocial hours.

I have been working just to pay childcare for the majority of my career.

I'm looking for something better paid (this should be easy as pay is pretty dire) with flexibility to ideally work from home for some of the week. The difficulty with medicine is that we become so institutionalised that it's hard to see what else there is out there.

Any suggestions for careers that would value my experience? (Registrar, so completed foundation training and several years of speciality training)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SELondonLurker · 09/05/2023 11:59

@bimbobboo it really depends on Bank,
some have restrictions which say 1-2 years post university. But given you’ve just done your masters then that could still be applicable.

If I were you, I’d pick a few grad schemes you like the look of and just drop the HR team an email to explain your circumstances and see what they say.

bimbobboo · 09/05/2023 11:45

@SELondonLurker out of interest, how old is too old to apply for a grad scheme in the banks to become a banker? I'd like to apply but am 35 I have just completed a masters degree if that makes any difference... thanks.

bimbobboo · 09/05/2023 11:43

My friend retrained and became a dentist. Seems much happier and still does private GP stuff on the side.

SELondonLurker · 09/05/2023 11:41

Hi OP,

I’m an investment banker and we have an ex-doctor in the Bank who joined via our graduate scheme.

Hours very dependent on each Bank, department and role. During busy seasons it can be unsociable hours of course, say 7am-9pm, but we are compensated accordingly and childcare is definitely affordable. We are allowed to WFH 3 days a week, and again, dependent on team, 4 days a week contracts etc are available.

Most large Banks have teams which specialise in Consumer and Healthcare clients, perhaps this could be something to consider.

HootyMcBooby76 · 09/05/2023 11:39

Saschka · 21/03/2023 13:57

Pharma - clinical trials management. A consultant surgeon I know stepped sideways into that and doubled her salary/was able to spend time with her children again (very antisocial hours and no scope for private practice). Drug repping can pay well but is cut-throat.

Or I also know one person who moved into project managing at Dept of Health - I’m not totally sure how he did it, but there was a training scheme which he then stepped sideways from.

And somebody else who works in management consultancy - I think he just applied for the PWC graduate scheme along with everyone else. Works with health clients.

Came on to say this.

The money is very very good, but the hours would probably be worse! DH is the clinical director of a pharmaceutical research company and manages clinical trial projects. He earns far more than most doctors or consultants but works about 16 hour days, lots of travelling abroad to other sites, and it is high pressure.

There is money to be made in pharma if you can work your way up the ladder.
DH started out with a biology degree, then a PhD in respiratory toxicology.
The pay is good but we do sacrifice a lot in terms of family time, so I am not sure I agree about the hours being better!

GasPanic · 09/05/2023 11:33

I work in an area of technology that is associated with medical devices amongst other things.

There are lots of jobs for people with clinical experience at the interface between end user and device designers.

TBH I would just find a recruitment agency that specialises in these sorts of fields and send off your cv. You can be clear about things like minimum salary requirements. They will find potential employment opportunities for you in a way that AIBU on mumsnet won't.

Oxbridgetitans · 09/05/2023 11:14

pharmaceutical/consultancy. Excellent pay but can be demanding!

Orangetapemeasure · 25/03/2023 07:27

@Aphrathestorm you do realize that health visitors start as nurses, as do school nurses and they both need nursing degrees and occupational therapy needs it’s own degree too. A dr isn’t a nurse or OT with extra qualifications to fall back on. Retraining for a nursing job would be an utterly disastrous idea for the OP.

BelleMarionette · 22/03/2023 19:32

Saschka · 22/03/2023 17:05

Pay is often quite similar for junior doctors and band 5s. And junior doctors have less choice about where they are sent for work (you rotate every 12months, don’t get any say in which hospital you are sent to, and some are miles apart - Derby and Lincoln are in the same Deanery).

They also have no choice about working antisocial hours - usually if a band 5 nurse works nights, they are consistent shifts. It isn’t one week of nights, one week of 8-6, one week of 2pm-midnight, on constant rotation. Makes it very hard to use standard nursery hours unless you have a partner who can do a lot of the pick ups and drop offs.

If your DP is a doctor as well, on nights (8pm-9am), and you are on late shifts, finishing at 10pm an hour away from home, who is looking after your child between your DP leaving for work at 7pm, and you getting back at 11pm? Either heavy family help, or an expensive out of hours nanny, or somebody gives up work/changes to a more family-friendly area like GP.

Nurses are badly paid for what they do, but junior doctors do have specific problems accessing “normal” childcare that nurses don’t usually face. A&E nurses might do, but the average ward nurse doesn’t, I am friends with enough of them to know their shift patterns.

Thank you Saschka. I don't think the competitive race to the bottom is helpful to anyone. Everyone has different difficulties.

I just want better for my family and I, and it's clear that this will only happen by either leaving medicine or the UK. I don't CCT for several years unfortunately, and I can't see myself coping with several more years working for the NHS as it is. It's a pity, as I am UK trained and I would dearly like to contribute further to the NHS. So many of my colleagues have left long ago however (mainly to Australia)

OP posts:
Saschka · 22/03/2023 17:05

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Pay is often quite similar for junior doctors and band 5s. And junior doctors have less choice about where they are sent for work (you rotate every 12months, don’t get any say in which hospital you are sent to, and some are miles apart - Derby and Lincoln are in the same Deanery).

They also have no choice about working antisocial hours - usually if a band 5 nurse works nights, they are consistent shifts. It isn’t one week of nights, one week of 8-6, one week of 2pm-midnight, on constant rotation. Makes it very hard to use standard nursery hours unless you have a partner who can do a lot of the pick ups and drop offs.

If your DP is a doctor as well, on nights (8pm-9am), and you are on late shifts, finishing at 10pm an hour away from home, who is looking after your child between your DP leaving for work at 7pm, and you getting back at 11pm? Either heavy family help, or an expensive out of hours nanny, or somebody gives up work/changes to a more family-friendly area like GP.

Nurses are badly paid for what they do, but junior doctors do have specific problems accessing “normal” childcare that nurses don’t usually face. A&E nurses might do, but the average ward nurse doesn’t, I am friends with enough of them to know their shift patterns.

BelleMarionette · 22/03/2023 08:26

Thank you for all the suggestions, a lot of things to research further, and thank you especially for those with special insight.

@TheRealist the point is that band 5 nurses can't survive on their current pay. That is why they have been striking. We have food banks advertised in the toilets at work. It's really a fire situation all round.

@the

OP posts:
TheRealist · 22/03/2023 05:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ChairOfInvisibleStudies · 21/03/2023 22:10

@Cocobutt pharmaceutical consultancy. So for an agency, rather than in house at a pharma company.

Atnilpoe · 21/03/2023 22:02

Sit as a specialist member on Tribunal panels? Eg MPTS or one of the Tribunal chambers - they need medical specialist members in the HESC chamber and the social entitlement chamber. Flexible work and interesting if you get a number of appointments

coronafiona · 21/03/2023 21:49

Medical writing or work in pharma.

TheKeatingFive · 21/03/2023 21:15

Medical director at a healthcare advertising agency.

This feels like a very niche role. How many positions like this can there be? Plus advertising involves very long hours.

HeyMicky · 21/03/2023 21:12

Medical director at a healthcare advertising agency.

Ineedacoffee · 21/03/2023 21:07

There is an alternative careers for drs group on fb - you have to submit your gmc number to join but there are all sorts of ideas on there.
As above pgmuk on fb also a great source of knowledge and advice.
Depending on specialty and how long/how many exams to go it may be worth getting your cct as there are so many more options. Alternatively what about stepping off the training wheel and negotiating an SAS role with fixed hours (pretty sure there is a fb gp for this too! )
Good luck. Working in the nhs is truly crap at the moment and (I'm a GP) I can't contemplate exams and nights with small children. Honestly it's no wonder everyone is leaving xxx

defi · 21/03/2023 21:06

Pathology? I'm a biomed scientist and it's great work life balance. Mon to Friday and no direct contact with patients

mauvish · 21/03/2023 21:04

Do NOT move into GP if you want a better work life balance! (quite apart from which, as the OP wil be aware, it could potentially mean a step down in salary and several years more of retraining and various exams).

There's also the issue that it is very difficult to take time out from GP these days. If you are away from working as a GP for more than 18-24 months, you are now required to undergo some retraining, and to work essentially as a very low wage intern before being allowed to fly solo again. This can take a year or more. Hospital medicine has a lot more flexibility to encompass time away from the coal face.

Bubbleses · 21/03/2023 20:51

Patent lawyer (specialising in pharmaceutical patents for example ) - can be pretty lucrative (although you would need to train to be lawyer)?

CakeIsNotAvailable · 21/03/2023 20:43

As a PP said, I think you'd get a much better quality of response if you posted in a doctor-specific forum - PMGUK, or a Facebook group for your specialty if one exists. Even if you post there anonymously, it would help if you say which specialty you're in now and how close you are to CCT.

I'm a GP and very happy with my job - I've built up a portfolio career which pays reasonably well for the hours worked, with less stress than a typical GP job. There are lots of options for fully qualified GPs, including prison medicine, civilian GP work on a military base, a retainer post, medical education, private work, locum work with strict T&Cs...

If you are a GP trainee I'd implore you to keep your head down and get your CCT - there are so many options out there which don't include "traditional" NHS GP partnership or salaried work. If you're a GP trainee you're welcome to PM me.

A few people here have suggested medical copywriting. SIL does this (she is a PhD scientist by training, not a medical doctor). It's reasonably well-paid (FTE is less than I get as a GP, but not awful - £60-70k in her fairly senior role). However it is tremendously stressful and there are lots of deadlines. She works from home some of the time, but still needs to use childcare, and often works once her child is in bed, because the workload is so heavy.

StColumbofNavron · 21/03/2023 20:19

I haven’t read the responses, but I work with a large number of doctors in management consultancy.

Moraxella · 21/03/2023 20:18

all posters who have suggested GP - any other specialty would have to go back down the ladder and do 3/4years of hospital rotations in order to complete GP training. If you are 5years postgrad in another specialty (eg surgery for example), you go back to the basic pay scale of a new doctor and need to complete the training. It’s not “I fancy that specialty so I’ll swap”.

@BelleMarionette I completely sympathise; I’m relying on night nannies, babysitters and full time nursery and I can’t be bothered any more with a) the stress b) the cost; I can’t see it getting any easier with school either as there’s fierce competition for wraparound care here. I don’t see a future in medicine either

bighair32 · 21/03/2023 20:15

Have you looked into medical education?

Search jobs.ac.uk medicine