Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I made my kids pay for the food they took

690 replies

piqueen · 21/03/2023 11:24

Did I go too far?
I took their Christmas money to replace the sweets and treats they took. We do a big shop once a month and I buy all the chocolates/ crisps and other cupboard bits for the month. These are for lunchboxes for the kids, dh and for picnics on the weekend (or pack lunches for days out) , also biscuits and breakfast bars. You know, the good stuff?
I did the shop on the 1st and by the 3rd I thought, the cupboard looked a bit empty on the 3rd (so 2 days) and by the 6th I definitely knew something was up.
The boxes of cereal bars were empty (but still stacked so first glance there is non missing), all the chocolate had gone, the biscuits had been opened and eaten.

me and dh did a big clear out of their room and moved the furniture around. We found all the evidence, evidence which included loads of fridge snacks too. Frubes, cheesestring, baby bell which the wax has got stuck in the carpet.
I was so pissed off i took the kids Xmas money and have been using it to replace the items for DHs lunch only. The kids are having no treats in their lunch and I'm only buying fruit.

The reason we do a big shop is because I don't drive so I get a taxi once a month to keep costs down. (it's cheaper to shop at aldi and pay £10 once a month than shop in sainsburies every week, so I bulk buy aldi and top up at the more expensive shop) The kids have obviously been doing this for some time as there was so much rubbish behind and under the wardrobe.

It's been 2 weeks since I took their money but I feel so guilty. They only get a little bit (it was £40 between them) and they are only 9 and 10 but, also they stole a month's worth of treats for everyone (dh works in a physical job so he gets easy bars he can stick I his pocket, sometimes he is doing a 12 hour shift, very labour intensive and no chance to nip to mcdonalds)

I'm going back and forth between
'actions have consequences' and
'kids will be kids'

I don't even know if the lesson has sunk in because they have been eating loads of fruit instead now which is better but obviously costs more than chocolate bars and the price if everything is going up I'm wondering if I'm being too harsh

Yabu - give the money back
Yanbu - they should pay for the food they took

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 22/03/2023 22:34

Pubesofsoberness · 22/03/2023 22:02

Not at that age they don't all

I still have to tell one of mine at 12 that no, you can't eat the whole punnet of grapes

And if ops dc were able to self regulate they wouldn't have eaten a month's worth of snacks in less than a week.

I did say it is a work in progress. My youngest is still impulsive but it is usually if she has had very little in the day due to not liking anything on offer at school or due to not eating enough at school as she has forgotten. My eldest is nearly 16 though and has eats a lot but will definitely stop himself and will leave stuff for another day. I don't really have much say over what he buys at the shops after school and I won't have any say when/if he goes to university in 2 years time so there is literally no point in micro managing a 16 year old's diet IMO.

croydon15 · 22/03/2023 22:25

Yabu they are only little kids eating snacks as people have said give them a certain amount for the week and when it is gone that's it, and explain to them why, and give them their Xmas money back,who would charge their children for food, they didn't steal they help themselves to some food.

Copperoliverbear · 22/03/2023 22:20

Sounds like they maybe hungry

FlutterbButterfly · 22/03/2023 22:16

Honestly don't understand this approach to 'treat' giving in the first place. I'd also not have more than a weeks worth in the house at one time. I started allowing my DC to help themselves to any snacks from around 4 years old. They learnt to self regulate and always ate their main meals. They are now 16 &17 year old, slim, fit and active. No food concerns- can't day the same about myself tho!

Greengagesnfennel · 22/03/2023 22:03

I think your decision to make them pay was a teency bit harsh but i understand why you did it and once you've made it you have to stick to it. Maybe a pocket money reward later if they start sticking to some new rules about how many snacks per day. That way you won't feel so bad as no long term taking of their money.

Also hide the snacks. It's not fair to expect children to have control that even some adults (me) don't have. If I saw a month's worth of snacks I think I'd eat a packet tinking it hardly will be noticed, whereas taking the last one, or one of 5 is less likely.

Maybe a locked location and just get a weeks worth out at a time.

Pubesofsoberness · 22/03/2023 22:02

Goldenbear · 22/03/2023 21:57

No and it is disingenuous for you to extract my information to make your point. My point was that by not restricting food they developed self regulatory habits. It is about trust though and I don't see myself as an autocrat as a mother many are not willing to relinquish that power.

Not at that age they don't all

I still have to tell one of mine at 12 that no, you can't eat the whole punnet of grapes

And if ops dc were able to self regulate they wouldn't have eaten a month's worth of snacks in less than a week.

SharonKaren · 22/03/2023 21:57

So you believe the reason most people are overweight is because they were denied unlimited sugary treats as children?

That's probably one part of the problem yes, it's psychological... But lots of other factors, sedentary lifestyle, fatty food at home, at school, attitudes of family, friends... But denying food is not helpful.

Goldenbear · 22/03/2023 21:57

Climbles · 22/03/2023 21:53

So you believe the reason most people are overweight is because they were denied unlimited sugary treats as children?

No and it is disingenuous for you to extract my information to make your point. My point was that by not restricting food they developed self regulatory habits. It is about trust though and I don't see myself as an autocrat as a mother many are not willing to relinquish that power.

SharonKaren · 22/03/2023 21:53

Of course they do lots of crazy things 🤣 but generally not related to food. About food, we work on it, we never really take it all completely away, monetise it so as to say, divide it into individual cupboards or smt. it's much better to teach them to think for themselves and give them tools of critical thinking to figure out if it's the right thing to eat 5 bags of crisps in one go. Hiding or harsh punishments don't solve the root cause of the problem. Also you need plenty of good food around. I'm not saying we're perfect, sorry if sounded a bit preachy there, but I really think it's not the kids that are a problem vast majority of the time...

Climbles · 22/03/2023 21:53

Goldenbear · 22/03/2023 21:30

Well they were certainly not like that at the OP"a children's age where the palette is still about the sweet stuff, I just think if you let them they'll grow out of it.

So you believe the reason most people are overweight is because they were denied unlimited sugary treats as children?

jannier · 22/03/2023 21:50

SomePeopleAreJustBloodyStupid · 21/03/2023 11:30

My daughter went through this recently with her 11 year old. The kid was getting in from school at 3.30, and whilst waiting for his mum to get home at 4.30, scoffed 3 bowls of cereal and 2 packets of crisps - just because the stuff was there. He had had, for his school lunch, a ham sandwich, packet of crisps, a yoghurt, apple, banana and a Twix. He certainly gets enough to eat (cooked dinner every night plus a dessert or fruit) My daughter now keeps the "snacks/good stuff" in a locked box

Was the sandwich etc his after school snack?

Goldenbear · 22/03/2023 21:50

BarryStyles · 22/03/2023 21:18

So presumably the vast numbers of overweight kids in this country are denied unlimited sweets, crisps and biscuits, and this is the cause of their obesity - yes, yes that makes perfect sense…

But why are they overeating, it is simplistic to blame it on biscuits and cakes. Are they sedentary, I mean the use of tablets over toys suggests it is a bit of a coincidence that over the last 10 years and more has seen this upward trajectory in weight gain alongside children using tech for long periods of time. My DC always played with toys which a) entertained them and b) meant they did not boredom eat, their elation was around toys not food. They also went to the park after school frequently and walked 3 miles to school and back in total and the eldest is always playing football and basketball at the park.

Pubesofsoberness · 22/03/2023 21:49

G5000 · 22/03/2023 21:43

It's not OK to take it all when you know it's for the whole family

No, but because it's inconsiderate, not because it's stealing. Wouldn't call the police, would I. Would explain why we are kind.

Well the op hasn't phoned the police has she? She admitted she probably over reacted a bit

If one of your children ate the others Easter eggs they may see it as a bit more then inconsiderate though

kennycat · 22/03/2023 21:43

I’m with you OP. My children (particularly my son) have spates of stealing food. They just do it to see if it’s possible not because they are hungry. They know they can have food if they ask. I get so annoyed when I find the evidence as I’ve budgeted for the food and know how long the food will last.
id not thought of making them pay but it’s a bloody good idea.
So far I’ve just taken the treat part of their lunches out. This clearly hasn’t got the message through to him though!!

G5000 · 22/03/2023 21:43

It's not OK to take it all when you know it's for the whole family

No, but because it's inconsiderate, not because it's stealing. Wouldn't call the police, would I. Would explain why we are kind.

Pubesofsoberness · 22/03/2023 21:39

G5000 · 22/03/2023 21:37

If they did it anywhere other than at home what would you call it ?

But that's the entire point? It's our home, it's family's food, it's OK to take things that are for family members if you are in fact a member of this family. Of course it's not the same if you walk into a supermarket and out without paying.

It's not OK to take it all when you know it's for the whole family

Goldenbear · 22/03/2023 21:39

Pubesofsoberness · 22/03/2023 21:34

Well tbf if one of my dcs ate all his lunch box snacks then moved on to eating all his brothers isn't that stealing from his brother ?

If a child took all the treat food out of your child's lunch box at school wouldn't that be stealing?

Don't think it's a bad thing to teach your child from a young age that it's not OK to take things that are for everyone

If they did it anywhere other than at home what would you call it ?

But they are at home and are 9 and 10. At home I don't want them to be hung up the idea of coveting food. You tell them to think about others. It works for us, otherwise I would continue to use that approach.

Pubesofsoberness · 22/03/2023 21:38

Your

Pubesofsoberness · 22/03/2023 21:38

SharonKaren · 22/03/2023 21:28

"If your children don't over eat or help themselves to the snacks in the cupboard then it's obviously different to if they do isn't it? If they don't then you don't have to work on it 🙄"

They don't, because we work on that healthy relationship with food and we work as a family unit. They understand that if they finish everything then mummy and daddy won't have any and that's not right. Children aren't born with this understanding we teach them. These traits are not inherent they're learned... Please see the text above.

So you're children have never done anything unexpected? Because it doesn't sound like the op expected her dc to eat all the snacks within a few days

And she has already said that she thinks she over reacted

G5000 · 22/03/2023 21:37

If they did it anywhere other than at home what would you call it ?

But that's the entire point? It's our home, it's family's food, it's OK to take things that are for family members if you are in fact a member of this family. Of course it's not the same if you walk into a supermarket and out without paying.

Madamum18 · 22/03/2023 21:36

firsttimelondonmummy · 22/03/2023 17:49

@Madamum18 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
finally someone taking some sense!!!

Thankyou. I hope it is helpful for the OP

Goldenbear · 22/03/2023 21:35

SharonKaren · 22/03/2023 21:28

"If your children don't over eat or help themselves to the snacks in the cupboard then it's obviously different to if they do isn't it? If they don't then you don't have to work on it 🙄"

They don't, because we work on that healthy relationship with food and we work as a family unit. They understand that if they finish everything then mummy and daddy won't have any and that's not right. Children aren't born with this understanding we teach them. These traits are not inherent they're learned... Please see the text above.

This is very much how we approach it. We are a family and we think about each other, even siblings, try to discourage rivalry that so many families seem to have so they have healthy relationships when adults. I'm not saying that always works but it is a work in progress

Pubesofsoberness · 22/03/2023 21:34

G5000 · 22/03/2023 21:20

Can't see where the op had said stealing

Several other people have said that though on this thread

Well tbf if one of my dcs ate all his lunch box snacks then moved on to eating all his brothers isn't that stealing from his brother ?

If a child took all the treat food out of your child's lunch box at school wouldn't that be stealing?

Don't think it's a bad thing to teach your child from a young age that it's not OK to take things that are for everyone

If they did it anywhere other than at home what would you call it ?

Goldenbear · 22/03/2023 21:30

Climbles · 22/03/2023 21:22

Congratulations, but you must realise your children are in the minority. This is why I said ‘most kids’. You probably haven’t needed to regulate your kids because they don’t have the same level of craving for unhealthy food that many kids do, You only have to look at the school play ground to know that the health issues facing kids are not because they are being denied snacks.

Well they were certainly not like that at the OP"a children's age where the palette is still about the sweet stuff, I just think if you let them they'll grow out of it.

SharonKaren · 22/03/2023 21:28

"If your children don't over eat or help themselves to the snacks in the cupboard then it's obviously different to if they do isn't it? If they don't then you don't have to work on it 🙄"

They don't, because we work on that healthy relationship with food and we work as a family unit. They understand that if they finish everything then mummy and daddy won't have any and that's not right. Children aren't born with this understanding we teach them. These traits are not inherent they're learned... Please see the text above.