Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I made my kids pay for the food they took

690 replies

piqueen · 21/03/2023 11:24

Did I go too far?
I took their Christmas money to replace the sweets and treats they took. We do a big shop once a month and I buy all the chocolates/ crisps and other cupboard bits for the month. These are for lunchboxes for the kids, dh and for picnics on the weekend (or pack lunches for days out) , also biscuits and breakfast bars. You know, the good stuff?
I did the shop on the 1st and by the 3rd I thought, the cupboard looked a bit empty on the 3rd (so 2 days) and by the 6th I definitely knew something was up.
The boxes of cereal bars were empty (but still stacked so first glance there is non missing), all the chocolate had gone, the biscuits had been opened and eaten.

me and dh did a big clear out of their room and moved the furniture around. We found all the evidence, evidence which included loads of fridge snacks too. Frubes, cheesestring, baby bell which the wax has got stuck in the carpet.
I was so pissed off i took the kids Xmas money and have been using it to replace the items for DHs lunch only. The kids are having no treats in their lunch and I'm only buying fruit.

The reason we do a big shop is because I don't drive so I get a taxi once a month to keep costs down. (it's cheaper to shop at aldi and pay £10 once a month than shop in sainsburies every week, so I bulk buy aldi and top up at the more expensive shop) The kids have obviously been doing this for some time as there was so much rubbish behind and under the wardrobe.

It's been 2 weeks since I took their money but I feel so guilty. They only get a little bit (it was £40 between them) and they are only 9 and 10 but, also they stole a month's worth of treats for everyone (dh works in a physical job so he gets easy bars he can stick I his pocket, sometimes he is doing a 12 hour shift, very labour intensive and no chance to nip to mcdonalds)

I'm going back and forth between
'actions have consequences' and
'kids will be kids'

I don't even know if the lesson has sunk in because they have been eating loads of fruit instead now which is better but obviously costs more than chocolate bars and the price if everything is going up I'm wondering if I'm being too harsh

Yabu - give the money back
Yanbu - they should pay for the food they took

OP posts:
Genie321 · 21/03/2023 13:17

Hintofreality · 21/03/2023 11:29

What next? Charging them for flushing the toilet as they are using too much water?
Also, “stealing”, really? They are kids taking snacks from the food cupboard in their home. They are kids, kids get hungry and snack. It’s not their fault you are so anal about food.

Totally agree with this.

They are 9 and 10. Its your job to feed them. Why should they be paying? Its their home. they should feel comfortable about going into a cupboard and taking a snack. What sort of home are you operating?

AskAwayAgain · 21/03/2023 13:16

Give them a way to earn back the money.

Calmdown14 · 21/03/2023 13:16

Well this thread is mental!

@piqueen I think that their behaviour was totally unacceptable. They know it was too or they wouldn't have hidden the evidence. I'd probably have done similar regarding the money.

Learning some self restraint is an important life lesson as is knowing that there's a limit to how far money goes. I'd be livid if my kids ate all of one the better treats (imitation cornettos in this house) without asking. We are a family, one person doesn't get to hog it all.

The separate tubs are a good idea through I might go further and make them weekly (even though you buy it monthly).
If you need tubs I often buy the little individually wrapped brownies or muffins in farmfoods or Iceland. They come in a decent plastic tub but are also reasonably priced!

GreenWhiteViolet · 21/03/2023 13:15

I wouldn't have taken their money.

They ate all the treats, so the natural consequence of that is that they have no treats for the rest of the month. That's logical. As others have said, what you're doing is punishing twice.

I also agree with others that I wouldn't put yogurts and cheese in the same category as chocolate. Sneaking chocolate and crisps and hiding the wrappers might be typical impulsive child behaviour. Feeling that they have to do it with other foods is concerning.

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 21/03/2023 13:14

Whichwhatnow · 21/03/2023 13:12

Jesus.

As a former child snack thief, I can promise everyone here that I was not underfed, deprived or abused, I was not pushed into comfort eating by the sheer misery of my existence, I was not neglected and bored, and as an adult I do not have an unhealthy relationship with food (or my lovely, loving parents for that matter). I was just a greedy little sod.

This thread is mental.

You are not alone. Blush

WinterMusings · 21/03/2023 13:13

PenelopeTitsDrop3121 · 21/03/2023 11:25

If they're resorting to having to steal food,it doesn't sound like they're getting enough food :(

@PenelopeTitsDrop3121

theyre not stealing 'food' they're eating all the treats!! Big Dufference

Whichwhatnow · 21/03/2023 13:12

Jesus.

As a former child snack thief, I can promise everyone here that I was not underfed, deprived or abused, I was not pushed into comfort eating by the sheer misery of my existence, I was not neglected and bored, and as an adult I do not have an unhealthy relationship with food (or my lovely, loving parents for that matter). I was just a greedy little sod.

This thread is mental.

Brefugee · 21/03/2023 13:12

They are children and it's our job to make sure they are well fed.

there is ZERO indication in the OP that the DCs are anything other than well fed.

OP buys food once a month. Let's assume that each DC takes 2 snack things and the DH takes 3 snack things per day. Assuming it is Mon-Fri for each of them that's 40 snacks for each DC and 60 for the grown up.

It isn't beyond belief to think that if they get a sandwich and an apple for their lunchbox, plus a frube and a babybel for snacks they're fine. But if they eat ALL the snacks so the DH doesn't even get a breakfast bar to take with him? That's not a healthy family. It is nothing to do with what are "good" snacks or that this obviously Dickensian mother only gives her children thin gruel. It is about learning not to take everything at once and to ensure that everyone gets things.

So OP just needs to explain this. I guess the DCs knew this anyway otherwise they wouldn't have tried to hide the evidence. Nobody needs to forensically scratch their heand and do vast calculations to say "hmm doesn't add up". Bollocks to that. A once a month shop has been wrecked, and now everyone is paying the price of no nice snacks.

I do agree, OP, that you have double punished. So while you're having the "don't take all the snacks" discussion you could say that since they now understand, you are giving them their money back, but next time they will be coming with you and paying for the snacks themselves. (because there won't be a next time)

Goldenbear · 21/03/2023 13:12

BreviloquentBastard · 21/03/2023 12:59

This thread is fking hilarious, so many dramatic people! Swear some of them have never actually met a child, my daughter would eat her weight in Frubes and cheese and cereal bars if I let her, she's a black hole. Just because they're half inching a little bit of everything doesn't mean OP only feeds them one small bowl of gruel a day.

Calling it "stealing" might be a bit dramatic but I get what OP is saying - children shouldn't have free access to as many snacks and sweets as they want at all times, so helping themselves to a month's worth of snacks and scoffing the lot is sort of "stealing", in the sense they've taken something they know they shouldn't have (assuming they do know they're not supposed to help themselves to these foods)

I don't think I'd have taken their money, they'd be making do without any of the snacks for the rest of the month and I think that'll do, as well as a conversation about which foods are fine to help themselves to and which are not.

My DC definitely wouldn't eat their weight in cheese and yoghurt, I think that is exceptional and if they are doing that they genuinely must be hungry. If they do not have any self regulation then that is a different matter but suggests boredom. Do they play or do anything after school.

Scarlettpixie · 21/03/2023 13:11

I find the idea of children ‘stealing’ food in their own homes or having to ask before they eat something a bit bizarre tbh. I have never restricted what DS eats and he is a healthy weight (at 16). He gets through a lot of cereal as that is one of his preferred snacks and will often make himself something after I am in bed. When he was younger I never bothered if he wanted something close to mealtime as he would still eat his dinner. Whether he had the yoghurt before or after made little difference.

i do get that if you bulk buy you may have more snacks in the house just after a shop. Maybe explain to them how/why you shop this way and how long snacks have to last and that they are for all of you to share. It sounds like they knew they shouldn’t do it because they hid the wrappers but still may not really understand why.

could you shop online more frequently? With a delivery saver it is cheaper than your taxi.

i think a conversation would have been enough rather than making them pay and banning snacks. As others have said it is a double punishment.

PrincessScarlett · 21/03/2023 13:11

I'm quite interested that so many people allow their children unrestricted access to food. I'm definitely not anal about food and always let my children have something to eat for snacks or if they are extra hungry but my children (who are similar age to OPs) wouldn't ever help themselves to food without asking or mentioning it.

In answer to your post OP, I don't think I'd charge the children for taking all the treats but I definitely wouldn't replace them so they would have to go without until the next big shop.

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 21/03/2023 13:10

Don't replace it.

They can't eat what isn't there.

tealandteal · 21/03/2023 13:10

Over the summer I put snacks for the day in a bowl for my DS to eat as he pleased. The “good” snacks. If he ate them all then there is fruit/toast/cheese and crackers. The first few days he ate them all in 5 minutes but soon learned to spread them out. Now he has a Tupperware with the weeks snacks in for him. He is 5.

flutterbyebaby · 21/03/2023 13:08

Rather than hunger, could this be some form if comfort eating, are the unhappy?

gkhg · 21/03/2023 13:08

Feed them more, then they won't have to steal. Strange you need that explaining I would think

Goldenbear · 21/03/2023 13:07

Brefugee · 21/03/2023 12:59

this thread is batshit. I went to boarding school and most of us brought a tuck box at the beginning of term. Some just stuffed the lot in the first couple of days and some eeked it out so we had "good" snacks for the entire term. (I was one of the latter). It's just kids being kids. I'd love to live on snack bars, crisps and baby-bel too but i have learned to regulate myself.

Young DCs? not so much. This is what they have to learn from their parents.

If you eat all the snacks, especially those which were earmarked for other people's lunches as well as your own there are consequenses. I'm not sure I'd have taken all their money since they're not getting snacks, but i would be giving them the most boring lunchboxes ever in the history of lunchboxes. And one piece of fruit, and carrot sticks or celery in place of the "good" snacks.

Maybe your experiences at boarding school are influencing your view on this then which is not a typical set up for most, I e most don't have a tuck box of snacks or see food as reward and punishment. OP, I would not make a big deal of this, it is what it is.

Spangasspikeywig · 21/03/2023 13:06

Dreadful Oliver Twist twaddle.

Anonplease2023 · 21/03/2023 13:05

I think this is really unreasonable to be completely honest and makes me feel quiet uncomfortable.

They are children and it's our job to make sure they are well fed. At their ages being punished for eating isn't really an option as parents that we can impose - this could lead to negative feelings around food - binge eating etc

I would be inclined to question them regarding why they feel the need to hide the snacks and the evidence of eating them - this is the worrying part.

I understand times are tough right now, and if your budget doesn't allow for them to continously snack, could you not buy them and explain once they are gone thats it for the week. Or explain that you can have a chocolate snack and a crisp snack before dinner and then maybe a yoghurt and some fruit after dinner? Also maybe don't allow them to take food upstairs? Could they maybe eat their snacks at the table so you could monitor how much they are eating and maybe educate them on the right snack choices? I.e - instead of a chocolate bar could you have a banana, some dried fruit etc

Being at school and continously using their brains will make them hungrier, including play times, PE etc.

Hope you can come to a resolution OP

colddrytoast · 21/03/2023 13:04

I wouldn't start taking away their money! I'd just rely on the consequences of their actions ie no treat food until next month as they have decided to eat it all already. I'd also let them see their father really enjoying his replacement treat food in the meantime, and see what happens next month before I decided how/if to proceed.

Sortyourlifeout · 21/03/2023 13:03

piqueen · 21/03/2023 13:03

I'm OK thanks for asking. I'm just confused but then again I posted on aibu.
I should have went to parenting.

Got and put yourself in the corner 😉

piqueen · 21/03/2023 13:03

Sortyourlifeout · 21/03/2023 11:58

OP, I genuinely hope you are ok. You've gone quiet.

There are some horrible people on MN.

Your kids were being kids. You did what you felt was right.

I'm OK thanks for asking. I'm just confused but then again I posted on aibu.
I should have went to parenting.

OP posts:
ShallowHallo · 21/03/2023 13:03

If this is true, some of the foods your children are were cheese and yogurts. So, you are hunting around detective style and then punishing your own children for eating food ? This is horrible.

SleepingStandingUp · 21/03/2023 13:02

I'd also cut the amount of time they're spending alien unsupervised in general as they've proven they're not old enough to be left

Itsneverwhatitseems · 21/03/2023 13:02

If they are hiding the evidence they must feel that food is an issue, ( please MN don’t point out that we need it to survive, I don’t mean that type of issue ) this could develop into potential eating problems.

If they are taking so much food I would question why? They must be hungry, it doesn’t sound like an obsession with crisps, chocolate etc as they’re now eating all the fruit.

So it sounds like they are just hungry.
Can I suggest mid meal healthy snacks or/ and larger more calorie laden slow release main meals.

Making them pay for the food is inappropriate. That’s suggesting they have been naughty for eating when they are hungry.

SleepingStandingUp · 21/03/2023 13:01

You've said what their punishment was but you've mentioned nothing about the actual conversation you had with them.

Did they say why they'd taken the food? Do they understand why you've taken their money? Do they understand about money being limited and treats being to share? That matters more I think that the rights and wrong of punishment altho yes you're double punishing which I don't think is fair.

Second a test box each and a padlock on the cupboard. Get them involved in making their own lunches too so they notice that their school treats and home treats are the same supply?

Swipe left for the next trending thread