Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I made my kids pay for the food they took

690 replies

piqueen · 21/03/2023 11:24

Did I go too far?
I took their Christmas money to replace the sweets and treats they took. We do a big shop once a month and I buy all the chocolates/ crisps and other cupboard bits for the month. These are for lunchboxes for the kids, dh and for picnics on the weekend (or pack lunches for days out) , also biscuits and breakfast bars. You know, the good stuff?
I did the shop on the 1st and by the 3rd I thought, the cupboard looked a bit empty on the 3rd (so 2 days) and by the 6th I definitely knew something was up.
The boxes of cereal bars were empty (but still stacked so first glance there is non missing), all the chocolate had gone, the biscuits had been opened and eaten.

me and dh did a big clear out of their room and moved the furniture around. We found all the evidence, evidence which included loads of fridge snacks too. Frubes, cheesestring, baby bell which the wax has got stuck in the carpet.
I was so pissed off i took the kids Xmas money and have been using it to replace the items for DHs lunch only. The kids are having no treats in their lunch and I'm only buying fruit.

The reason we do a big shop is because I don't drive so I get a taxi once a month to keep costs down. (it's cheaper to shop at aldi and pay £10 once a month than shop in sainsburies every week, so I bulk buy aldi and top up at the more expensive shop) The kids have obviously been doing this for some time as there was so much rubbish behind and under the wardrobe.

It's been 2 weeks since I took their money but I feel so guilty. They only get a little bit (it was £40 between them) and they are only 9 and 10 but, also they stole a month's worth of treats for everyone (dh works in a physical job so he gets easy bars he can stick I his pocket, sometimes he is doing a 12 hour shift, very labour intensive and no chance to nip to mcdonalds)

I'm going back and forth between
'actions have consequences' and
'kids will be kids'

I don't even know if the lesson has sunk in because they have been eating loads of fruit instead now which is better but obviously costs more than chocolate bars and the price if everything is going up I'm wondering if I'm being too harsh

Yabu - give the money back
Yanbu - they should pay for the food they took

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 21/03/2023 14:12

Yes, all these emotions associated with food, who is in control of it, 'shit parents' if you encourage your children to self regulate rather than control, control and control.

JudgeRudy · 21/03/2023 14:12

Itsbytheby · 21/03/2023 13:47

No right to food? Wow.

We don't know that they'd been offered a sandwich as far as I can see, how do you conclude that? I can't see that they necesarily have "oportunity to access" sufficient nutritious food. They aren't taking only sweets and treats, they are taking things that they are manageable for kids their age, cheese, yogurts, cereal. unless there is a weight or appetite concern they to me would signal hunger. This is also what my kids would take if no parent around to help them. I bet if OP had found they had been "stealing" ham or bread she would have been cross too.

@Itsbytheby Re-read. No AUTOMATIC right to food. You are correct, I can't see they have opportunity to access food....or that they don't. On the balance of probability I'd say if they had asked for a snack as they were genuinely hungry, they would have been offered something.
You state unless there is a weight or appetite concern I'd assume hunger. Is that why people are fat? No, it's generally psychological hunger or appetite....for more tasty things.
I've a reasonable understanding of nutrition so cereal and cheese would form part of a healthy balanced diet, even crisps and cereal bars....the point is they are all convenience and expensive foods. Noones advocating starving children, just stop helping yourself to expensive snacks because you're too lazy or too entitled to make/wait for a sandwich. I can assure you every time I've eaten a cake it wasn't because I was hungry!

Sugarplumfairy65 · 21/03/2023 14:10

Iwonder08 · 21/03/2023 11:40

What a horrible story.. It is food, they are children.. Ask yourself why your children feel the need to hide what they eat in their own home?

It isn't food, its junk that should be limited.

Floomobal · 21/03/2023 14:08

It’s also not “normal” behaviour to be taking food, hiding evidence, and then having your room turned upside down to find the wrappers etc, and then be charged for it. All whilst seeing that McDonald’s and whatever other junk food or snacks is fine for your dad to have, but not you.

You’ve clearly created a relationship with food and “supplies” that isn’t healthy, or normal, and isn’t working very well. So it’s for the adult to change, leading by example, not blanket punishments

929mummy · 21/03/2023 14:07

I do the same as this if you steal you have to replace!
It teaches consequence!
And responsibility for actions
Don't feel guilty if they steal when they are adults they will get worse consequences then having to pay it back IE being prison !
So think of it as your saving them from prison when older !
If you don't teach them now they will think it's ok to do and as get older may steal other things which would land them in prison good luck

Tohaveandtohold · 21/03/2023 14:07

I believe in actions and consequences but I think here, they’ve been punished twice. They have no ‘sweet snack’ for the month which I feel is good enough to show them that since they’ve eaten it all in one go, it’s not being replaced. They would have eaten it all this month anyway so they eat anything else you have at home till the day of the next shopping since they’ve finished that one. Taking their money is another punishment which I feel is not necessary.

Floomobal · 21/03/2023 14:04

Jonei · 21/03/2023 13:57

This is one of the most concerning threads I’ve read on MN

Kids needing to moderate eating junk food is one of the most disturbing threads you've ever read?

Lol.

Cheese is junk food now? Ok. I know mumsnet is weird about food, but that’s a step further again

uncomfortablydumb53 · 21/03/2023 14:03

I might cut out things like cheesestrings Frubes and baby bel and replace with chunks of cheese and ordinary yogurts but I definitely wouldn't take their money!
Perhaps they're going through growth spurts( common at their ages) and actually need more food
Increase portions at breakfast and evening meal

Brieandcamembert · 21/03/2023 14:01

I'm not sure the should be being fed all that junk anyway. That's a huge amount of processed junk foods in their diet. Maybe just not but it any more?

Jonei · 21/03/2023 13:58

namechange3394

Yes mine would have stuffed themselves with chocolate and junk until they were sick too. Not hungry. They just like it. It's only now they are older they have started to moderate themselves. Before, I had to do it for them.

Jonei · 21/03/2023 13:57

This is one of the most concerning threads I’ve read on MN

Kids needing to moderate eating junk food is one of the most disturbing threads you've ever read?

Lol.

namechange3394 · 21/03/2023 13:55

Floomobal · 21/03/2023 11:41

This is deeply disturbing. Your children are hungry and clearly don’t have access to enough food. They’re hiding wrappers because they’re scared of your reaction.

This is one of the most concerning threads I’ve read on MN

What a complete overreaction.

Have you never met anyone who'd eat snacky junk even when they weren't hungry just because it's there?

Both DSC and DC would eat chocolate until they were sick every day in an ideal world for them. But we wouldn't let them cos that would be fucking terrible parenting. If they are hungry they can have some fruit or toast or something specifically put aside for that purpose, not everybody else's lunch for the rest of the month.

DarkChocHolic · 21/03/2023 13:54

OP,
I battle with the snack demon quite a lot.
One thing I have found is I need a lot less snacks than I think I do.
Over the years, I have got used to buying a lot of snacks to the point I feel guilty when we sometimes run out.
Because of recent health issues, I am trying to buy less. I find its actually quite hard.
I buy online, add a lot of stuff and then have started to force myself to remove items from the basket.
I budget for a pack of cereal bar for each DC (pack of 5), one sweet treat (angel slices or Mr kipling type) and some after school bready type thing like hot cross buns.
I used to buy way more before.
Appreciate its easier for me as I shop weekly.
I would eat it all myself if I had a month's worth of snacks (forget the kids)

SchoolQuestionnaire · 21/03/2023 13:52

StarmanBobby · 21/03/2023 11:35

'Their lunches will have to be sandwiches, fruit, and veg like carrot sticks.'

This. As they get older and walk to school they'll be using their pocket money to buy crap, their friends will buy crap and share etc. So I would stick to non-junk in lunches while you can.
If they're hungry, they'll eat what they're given in their lunches.

And as for thse saying you must be starving them and food shouldn't be restricted. Get a grip! Only on MN would you find people saying your kids should be able to each as much junk as they like!

I agree that kids shouldn’t have free reign to eat what they want at all times, but it’s a bit harsh to say that they can’t but their ddad can because he has a physical job that’s “very labour intensive and no chance to nip to mcdonalds”. As if pocket snacks and drive thru’s are the only choices here.

It seems the kids are getting very mixed messages about what constitutes an appropriate diet which is unfair, particularly when you’re then expecting them to know that some foods are off limits. I also categorically do not believe in punishing children for eating under any circumstances. I’d stop buying the rubbish completely and keep it as a treat for a day out. I’m sure dh can manage to sort himself out.

LondonPretty · 21/03/2023 13:52

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

RosemaryAndTim · 21/03/2023 13:51

I wouldn't take their money. You're also punishing them twice if you've taken their money and you're not replacing the food.

I would rethink the food they're allowed freely at home. Have a range of foods that they can eat (unless it's right before dinner, say) such as fruits, veg, brown bread, cheese (the normal stuff not UPF like cheese strings etc- cheaper too). Treats- I'd work out what you are happy for them to have each week and give them that, clearly labelled (eg a box each)- when it's done it's gone. Put your husband's snacks somewhere else.

If they are still eating a lot (fruit) consider whether they really need something more substantial after school eg eggs and toast along with some fruit or veg.

Angebot · 21/03/2023 13:51

comingoutofmycageandillbedoingjustfine · 21/03/2023 11:32

I think YABU. You need to look at why they are feeling the need to steal food and hide evidence.

If you get a taxi to do a big food shop, you say you bulk buy, how much realistically can one person carry to a cab. Is the 'bulk' food shop really a bulk food shop?

Also - why don't you get an Icelandic delivery? Similar / cheaper than Aldi. And they deliver. Saves cab money.

I think punishing them is wrong. I'd look into why they are needing to steal and hide food. That wasn't a nice read and I think there are bigger problems than this.

Can you realistically afford to give them this much pocket money if you're this regimented on food?

Jesus have you been to Iceland recently?
So expensive and much more than Aldi .
I wouldn't have punished them but made future changes but im also a believer of never going back on the punishment either. So let it lie and maybes change the rules of snacking. I don't buy chocolate or biscuits in a big shop because mine will eat them in a few days too. I buy them sporadically.

ColonelDax · 21/03/2023 13:51

Itsbytheby · 21/03/2023 13:47

No right to food? Wow.

We don't know that they'd been offered a sandwich as far as I can see, how do you conclude that? I can't see that they necesarily have "oportunity to access" sufficient nutritious food. They aren't taking only sweets and treats, they are taking things that they are manageable for kids their age, cheese, yogurts, cereal. unless there is a weight or appetite concern they to me would signal hunger. This is also what my kids would take if no parent around to help them. I bet if OP had found they had been "stealing" ham or bread she would have been cross too.

I think you know full well the poster didn't mean 'no right to food', they meant 'no automatic right to choose any food they want based on whim'. 🙄

Arsewangry · 21/03/2023 13:50

Christ some of these responses. Keeping food in a locked box away from a growing adolescent child. Smh.

SixPenny · 21/03/2023 13:48

Kids are greedy and they will take chocolate, crisps, biscuits etc.
You don't see them stealing carrots and celery.

SybilWrites · 21/03/2023 13:48

My kids do this too - it's very annoying.

OP, I just think that taking money away from them isn't going to work! It's a crap punishment really.

For myself, I just limit the amount of snacks we have in the house, because they can't be trusted, and for the snacks we have, I take the "once it's gone, its gone approach" . I also buy some snacks for some children that no one else can touch - so my dd has a breakfast bar each day (she's 18 before anyone starts on at me) and they all know not to touch her breakfast bars. They all know not to eat my other dd's lunch stuff. But biscuits, nutella, crunchy nut cornflakes - they're fair game! (the weetabix does not get stolen and they have unlimited access to that, bread and fruit if they need a snack).

Itsbytheby · 21/03/2023 13:47

JudgeRudy · 21/03/2023 13:40

I don't think children do have an automatic right to food. They should be given the opportunity to access sufficient nutritious food but not a free for all. I agree a bowl of Cheerios isn't a treat for me, or a Babybel...its a lazy (and expensive) convenience food. I don't think a parent should need to change their shopping habits to accommodate untrustworthy children. The reason they didn't ask is because they knew they wouldn't get 5 packs of crisps. They'd have been offered maybe 1 and a sandwich.

No right to food? Wow.

We don't know that they'd been offered a sandwich as far as I can see, how do you conclude that? I can't see that they necesarily have "oportunity to access" sufficient nutritious food. They aren't taking only sweets and treats, they are taking things that they are manageable for kids their age, cheese, yogurts, cereal. unless there is a weight or appetite concern they to me would signal hunger. This is also what my kids would take if no parent around to help them. I bet if OP had found they had been "stealing" ham or bread she would have been cross too.

flutterbyebaby · 21/03/2023 13:46

moofolk · 21/03/2023 13:45

I think people are being harsh to say that kids are not getting fed enough / are going hungry and that's why they are raising the cupboard for snacks.

It's not like they are sneaking pasta and veg.

Kids have very poor control and love snacks, then often don't eat their meals. Surely every parent knows this.

Clear rules around what is fair game and what is off limits is better.

Also agree that taking their money and then having no snacks might be harsh but I get where you're coming from OP. They will remember this and think twice before gorging in future.

It's a bit useless for them to sneak food they'd have to cook ffs

Brefugee · 21/03/2023 13:46

And yabu to have a lot of junk food in the house in an accessible place and expect the kids to never take any. They’re kids, they’re still learning self-control

the complete and utter inability of some posters to understand how other people organise their lives, or to accept that we all do things in different ways, never ceases to amaze me.

I used to live 20 miles from the nearest shop, and 25 miles from the nearest supermarket. As a consequence we also did bulk shopping of everything. Once a month without fail. There was a market in a village 10 miles away and we'd go there on the middle weekend to stock up on the fresh stuff. And that was it. If you fancied a Mars bar for your lunchbox but someone had scarfed them all - then you went without.

That is how some people organise their shopping. Most of us give our kids a little treat in their lunchbox. If you want to do that, and you only shop once a month - OF COURSE THERE WILL BE A TIME THAT THERE IS A LOT OF IT AROUND.

I would have no problem in there being zero treats for the DCs for the next two months, just to drive the point home.

But the DH also misses out. If I'd done something like that I'd be getting the "well that's disappointing, i didn't realise I'd raised selfish children" speech and a reminder that we all have to share. And I'd have been devastated.

moofolk · 21/03/2023 13:45

I think people are being harsh to say that kids are not getting fed enough / are going hungry and that's why they are raising the cupboard for snacks.

It's not like they are sneaking pasta and veg.

Kids have very poor control and love snacks, then often don't eat their meals. Surely every parent knows this.

Clear rules around what is fair game and what is off limits is better.

Also agree that taking their money and then having no snacks might be harsh but I get where you're coming from OP. They will remember this and think twice before gorging in future.