Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paid back money but was wrong

245 replies

marchella · 21/03/2023 03:51

Hi
This is a very quick summary but basically my MIL gave some money to my DH as an advance on his "inheritance". I knew nothing about this until he paid off my credit card ( roughly 5000 pounds). I wasn't happy as I hate owing people money.
That was about 5 years ago.
Recently I was talking to her about a completely different thing regarding her sons behaviour and mentioned that I have financially supported him for years.
SHe said " that is not true" and mentioned the unwanted money that my DH used to pay off my credit card.
I am super sensitive about being called a liar and would not borrow money unless I was desperate.
So I got my DH to get her bank account details and repaid it that night via bank transfer. In the section that asks for an invoice or reference number I wrote " so Marchella doesn't feel beholden".
They are now not speaking to me.
I think I've fucked up , but I have a thing about being called a liar , or taking money.

OP posts:
ConcordeOoter · 21/03/2023 16:04

ulls out 5 grand from nowhere to pay that off.

That doesn't jive with the dutiful financial martyr story at all. Quite the opposite, really.

ConcordeOoter · 21/03/2023 16:03

SmileyClare · 21/03/2023 10:08

He kindly pays off your credit card

Am I missing something? Op has had to financially support this man for years, she’s so frustrated by his behaviour. He sounds like a feckless twat.

Yes he used some of his secret inheritance to pay off a credit card in his wife’s name.
If op wasn’t propping him up all the time she could have easily cleared it herself!

He probably asked his mum for money on the pretext that his reckless wife had run up debts.

Now at the end of her tether with his behaviour and having to support him, she confides in mil.
Mil says none of its true, she is the one who has supported you with her generous inheritance gift.
Id be so pissed off op.
Not so much with mil, as clearly she doesn’t know how much her son is taking the piss out if you.

You know what doesn't support the story of the poor beknighted person who has been run into unavoidable credit card debt by their horrid parasite husband, all when she is so viscerally unable to bear debt?

He paid the debt off and she was happy to let that fly, and now when feeling huffy she p

Tomkirkman · 21/03/2023 15:50

We don’t know the situation or what op means by her financing him.

It simply could mean she earns more. So she is paying more of the bills because she earns more.

It could mean she is paying all the bills. We don’t know. It was hugely vague.

I could say I finance dp because I earn 4 times as much. He does pays bills. But I pay a lot more.

SmileyClare · 21/03/2023 15:33

DizzyLizzyKizzy · 21/03/2023 14:56

Where does it say he asked for the advance on the inheritance?

You’re right it says he was “given an advance on his inheritance”

A moot point really. I mean he paid a few grand off a bill five years ago and has contributed little since? Why is everyone lauding his kindness, I don’t get it.

Kind of his Mum yes but I don’t think he’s getting a Pride of Britain award for paying a bill five years ago.

It sounds like op can’t complain about having to pay every household bill thereafter without being reminded of the bloody inheritance five years ago.

Whats your take on it? Maybe I’m wrong.

DizzyLizzyKizzy · 21/03/2023 14:56

SmileyClare · 21/03/2023 14:18

I must be reading a different OP. Why is everyone gushing about how kind this man is?

Based on opening paragraph
-DH asks his mum for an advance on his inheritance but doesn’t tell wife

-Uses some to pay a CC bill in wife’s name

-For reasons unknown doesn’t support himself or family financially for the next five years; relies on wife’s income

-Wife moans to her mil about dh’s behaviour and that she’s been supporting him for years now

-MIL calls her DIL a liar because five years ago she knows her son paid a bill out of the money she gave him

I’m not excusing being rude to MIL but
he’s hardly winning any prizes in my view.

Where does it say he asked for the advance on the inheritance?

SmileyClare · 21/03/2023 14:18

I must be reading a different OP. Why is everyone gushing about how kind this man is?

Based on opening paragraph
-DH asks his mum for an advance on his inheritance but doesn’t tell wife

-Uses some to pay a CC bill in wife’s name

-For reasons unknown doesn’t support himself or family financially for the next five years; relies on wife’s income

-Wife moans to her mil about dh’s behaviour and that she’s been supporting him for years now

-MIL calls her DIL a liar because five years ago she knows her son paid a bill out of the money she gave him

I’m not excusing being rude to MIL but
he’s hardly winning any prizes in my view.

Blondeshavemorefun · 21/03/2023 13:49

So dh kindly paid your £5k credit card and you Aren't happy

He paid it with his money he got given

How have you supported him all these years

And yes your payment reference name reply was petty

I can't write a reference that long

SmileyClare · 21/03/2023 12:41

Moveoverdarlin · 21/03/2023 12:27

So you don’t like owing or borrowing money but had 5k on a credit card? LOL!

To be fair, I don’t like asking friends or family for loans or expecting them to bail me out but would be fine with taking a loan or putting a big purchase on a credit card.

There is a difference.
Borrowing from family can come with guilt, feelings of obligation or resentment attached!

Moveoverdarlin · 21/03/2023 12:27

So you don’t like owing or borrowing money but had 5k on a credit card? LOL!

DeflatedAgain · 21/03/2023 12:23

The only way it could write that in the reference is if you sent payment as a 'CHAPS'. I'm sure you can add more information that way. I highly doubt you would send it using that method considering there's a charge of £20-£30 to do so whereas a 'BACS' is free and more convenient for £5000.🤷🏻‍♀️

ThomasinaLivesHere · 21/03/2023 12:23

I wish I could write longer references so if true I’d like to know the name of the bank. When making payments I can just fit in my average length name.

GoodChat · 21/03/2023 12:13

Chenford · 21/03/2023 12:03

Gosh, the OP hasn’t been back.

How strange.

She's probably at work...

SmileyClare · 21/03/2023 12:04

Yes @CurlyhairedAssassin I was offering up another spin on this.
I thought there were far too many posts calling the dh “kind” and telling op she’s the baddie!
Weird the op hasn’t been back though, on this basis I’m calling Bullshit 😂

Chenford · 21/03/2023 12:03

Gosh, the OP hasn’t been back.

How strange.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 21/03/2023 11:56

SmileyClare · 21/03/2023 10:08

He kindly pays off your credit card

Am I missing something? Op has had to financially support this man for years, she’s so frustrated by his behaviour. He sounds like a feckless twat.

Yes he used some of his secret inheritance to pay off a credit card in his wife’s name.
If op wasn’t propping him up all the time she could have easily cleared it herself!

He probably asked his mum for money on the pretext that his reckless wife had run up debts.

Now at the end of her tether with his behaviour and having to support him, she confides in mil.
Mil says none of its true, she is the one who has supported you with her generous inheritance gift.
Id be so pissed off op.
Not so much with mil, as clearly she doesn’t know how much her son is taking the piss out if you.

How can you possibly tell all that is the case from just one post from the OP, which has left out a LOT of background and context? We don't have a clue about their financial arrangements as OP has not provided any. We don't know what this "behaviour" is of the husband. We don't know why the credit card had 5k on it, why a credit card was needed in the first place, OR if it had been even higher than that to start or whether any regular payments were being made towards it prior to the husband putting the 5k towards it. We don't know exactly what the husband said to his mum about the credit card debt. We know virtually NOTHING about any details. You are just putting your own spin on it and making far too many assumptions

MisschiefMaker · 21/03/2023 11:55

If you've been financially supporting your DH why would you mind that he paid off your credit card bill?

cartagenagina · 21/03/2023 11:54

You sound very difficult.

You had no business sending that money to MIL. She didn’t give it to you, DH did.

horseyhorsey17 · 21/03/2023 11:52

I feel like there are a whole bunch of issues underlying this, of which this post only touches the surface. Why are you financially supporting your DH and not appearing to be that thrilled about that? Why is he giving you money without telling you?

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 21/03/2023 11:40

What did you say to DH at the time he paid off the card?

More to the point, HOW did he pay off the card?
I mean operationally, not financially. How did he access OP's account?

Not that we'll ever found out.
OP, who has a thing about being called a liar, has lied on her own thread, & is rightly having her arse handed to her.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 21/03/2023 11:37

Sierra26 · 21/03/2023 08:12

She didn’t call you a liar, she was referencing a fact (one you wish wasn’t true). Both things can be true - you support him day to day but he/she did pay off your debt.

you shouldn’t have put that passive aggressive comment in the transfer reference, that was a massive over reaction. What was that going to achieve other than escalate the situation. Not sure why you even paid it back to her when it was your husband who gave it to you.

Sounds like you’re all a bit in the wrong here, trying to get one up on each other.

This Above
You could have simply put From Marchella.
But you didn't explain. You could have sent a text explaining and saying it was generous of her(actually it was generous of your DH) but you would like to return it with thanks.

There would have been no problem. You left her wondering what's this about. Why is she accusing me of calling her a liar Presumably she didn't say "You are a liar."
She corrected your statement with a fact. That's not calling someone a liar.

What did you say to DH at the time he paid off the card?

Chowtime · 21/03/2023 11:35

Well you are a liar aren't you? Because you've lied about what you put as the reference - we all know you can't put a reference that big into a banking reference box.

Assuming the rest of it is true, then yes, you've fucked up. Big time.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 21/03/2023 11:27

Yes, you fucked up. There was absolutely no need to put what you wrote as the reference, you MUST have known that would stir up ill feeling. It was so passive aggressive and if you had done that to me it would have changed the way I felt about you from that point onwards.

I also don't believe for one minute that you hate taking money off people or owing. Otherwise you would have paid her back at the time, even over a period of time if you couldn't have afforded it in one go, not left it 5 years.

Your MIL is right. You HAVEN'T wholly supported him financially him for years if he paid off a credit card in your name, no matter where the money came from. However, and this is a massive caveat, you haven't gone into details about why there was so much money owing on the credit card and why it was in your name. For all we know, your husband is a waster and you took out the credit card to cover a joint bill, or because he gambled money away, in which case if I were you I would have set the record straight with MIL and let her know about all your financial difficulties caused by him. It would still be fair enough to acknowledge to her, though, that SHE gave money towards the credit card debt and be gracious about it. Did you not thank her at the time and discuss paying back? So without the context of the credit card debt or your husband's behaviour with money we have no idea what to write in our responses.

Lycanthropology · 21/03/2023 11:19

Blimey what a ridiculous way to behave. I’m not surprised they’re not talking to you. Your DH paid off your bill, not your MIL.

And “That’s not true” ≠ “You’re a liar”; it could mean she thinks you’re mistaken, or that she has a different take on things.

You really need to apologise.

dontgobaconmyheart · 21/03/2023 11:16

Very OTT and I'm not surprised it's all caused an issue.

MIL is rude for bringing it up and it should be none of her business, but she isn't wrong. You can't really claim to be financially supporting someone when it is them that paid off your credit card debt to the tune of 5k. I can't see how she's accused you of lying there. It may well be the case that like most couples you support each other and it's a joined finances household and therefore you also contribute a lot to that (more even) but the point still stands.

If you didn't want him to have paid it off you could have transferred it back at the time, there wasn't really ever a need to make a scene about it. Just a conversation about why you don't want it and return the money to him.

I'd suck this one up OP, explain you have personal issues around money and felt embarrassed at her comment so acted on the moment with the wording on the transfer. Don't let it be the hill you die on.

Mumuser124 · 21/03/2023 11:13

Sorry mother in law

Swipe left for the next trending thread