Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The head refusing OFSTED

56 replies

Indigoshift · 20/03/2023 21:13

Not seen a thread on this. Apologies if there us one.

AIBU to think Flora is very brave but good on her for standing up and showing that OFSTED is not fit for purpose?

news.sky.com/story/headteacher-to-refuse-ofsted-inspection-following-ruth-perry-death-12838983 Headteacher to refuse Ofsted inspection after death of fellow principal Ruth Perry 

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
notimagain · 22/03/2023 12:11

@Pottedpalm

These examples are just not comparable. A train driver/pilot is in control of a machine which responds in a given way if controlled correctly ( barring emergencies for which there are set procedures),

Certainly in aviation it's not just about "driving", you are assessed on much more than that. In recent years a lot of emphasis has been placed on how you interact with colleagues and so Human Factors (Crew Resource Management) is a major part of every assessment. Of course (?) in addition instructors/examiners get checked out on how they teach/interact with their students.

That said I do really do fully accept the situation in schools is utterly different and the whole Ofsted situation sounds awful.

Boudicasbeard · 22/03/2023 11:56

@MsWhitworth

The reason why other heads and teacher think it is Ofsted’s fault is the way the inspection was handled.

The question really is: is a well run school, with happy children and staff and a record of success failing because some
children are badly behaved in corridors?

Because this is why this school failed. And this is the fourth school is this year, to my knowledge, that has failed for that reason.

Is this a reason to fail a school, end the career of the head teacher and create massive upheaval for the students?

Or is Ofsted being used as a tool to drive a new, badly thought out DfE policy into schools

Because we are now all pretty worried that corridor behaviour- which is very complicated to police and causes massive tensions with students and parents (the emails about use being too harsh are endless but if we don’t do it we fail inspection) and have put head teachers in an untenable position.

The conundrum is this- should we being doing things just because it is what Ofsted want to see or should we being doing what is best for the children. They are increasingly very different things!

MsWhitworth · 22/03/2023 11:47

Boudicasbeard · 22/03/2023 08:38

@MsWhitworth

Maybe you can’t understand because you’re not a teacher. It was her vocation. She’d been an outstanding head (as testified by her staff and pupils) for decades.

She’d given her life to her school- headship means long hours (70 plus a week), sacrificing family events during term time and always putting your school first. Heads don’t really have holidays like the teachers do. They are in school over holidays monitoring building works or looking after admin staff or updating policies or doing CAfCASs meeting or a while host of things that carry on during the holidays.

So when they down graded her school to RI she knew if meant that she’d never work again. She would lose her job as soon as the report came out. And she would never get another.

Because for heads and RI at Ofstead is like a scarlet letter. A badge of shame. You failed. You drove a school to inadequate. No parent body or governing body would ever let you run a school again. Your shame spread across a whole school community.

i can understand why she did it.

I’m not a teacher so I don’t I understand so thank you for explaining it more fully.

I am sympathetic to her and her death is a tragedy. And your post explains well what it must have been like for her. But I just don’t believe it’s the ‘fault’ of Ofsted - they inspect many across the country schools and they were just doing their job. They couldn’t possibly have known what would happen and even if they did, are we saying they need to alter their reports to take account of the mental health of the head and staff?

It’s clear from this thread that there are many issues with Ofsted and changes need to be made but it’s unfair to blame them for this.

thebellagio · 22/03/2023 11:33

My only experience of our school being inspected was when they arrived on the 18th March 2020.

Two days before the schools closed for lockdown.

In fact, I seem to recall the school closure announcement happening that very day. It was when it was glaringly obvious that the schools would shut that week - I remember emailing my clients on that Monday saying that I predicted a school closure announcement that week.

The fact that Ofsted thought that was the time to go in always struck me as fucking absurd.

I've always been baffled by how Ofsted seem to go in with confirmation bias. They seem to go in with their minds set, and they are looking for aspects to prove that mindset, rather than being independent and impartial. The fact that many outstanding schools hadn't been inspected for 10+ years shows that the system isn't fit for purpose.

Surely, every school should routinely be inspected every 2 years. That way, any issues are nipped in the bud before they escalate, and they can be given the support that they need to continue improving. It strikes me that Ofsted go in and say "you're shit, fix it" with no actionable support to help schools improve,

Boudicasbeard · 22/03/2023 11:21

I think the argument about who is more punitively assessed, with the most stringent oversight is pointless.

As far as I can tell, all the regulatory bodies that are in the pay (where they will admit it or not) of central government are political bodies and often not objective. They are essentially applying government policy rather than making supportive assessments for the good of the profession/ outcomes.

I’ve heard the same complaints about the CQC from family members in the NHS as from teachers- political, sometimes slow to act on real issues and endless, pointless, unhelpful box ticking.

There really does have to be another way.

Toddlerteaplease · 22/03/2023 10:10

donttellmehesalive · 20/03/2023 21:36

Do other professions have the level of observation and scrutiny that teaching has? Do people watch doctors talking to patients, or watch lawyers with clients? Maybe they do.

We have the CQC.

lifeissweet · 22/03/2023 09:45

No, the dft like to tell everyone they have nothing to do with the running of TOCs but that's for another day. We tend to have graduate entry people who've never worked an operational role in their lives impose arbitray driving policies that don't allow us to use our judgment then hammer us with requests for info about delays caused by driving to such policies or nitpick when we don't comply 100%. Or produce 9.5 hour turns that are within parameters by the skin of their teeth and that start at 3am and wonder why there are incidents. I think fuckwittery from on high is sadly universal.

Well this sounds horrendous. It seems this is the way of things now. Too much 'accountability' and not enough common sense or idea of reality. All about the numbers, isn't it?

christmaspudding43 · 22/03/2023 09:37

lifeissweet · 22/03/2023 09:09

I am out of classroom teaching now (thank fuck), but I went through 3 OFSTED's (managed to dodge one by giving birth the day of 'the call' - I hadn't gone on maternity leave by then. The Head nearly had an aneurism). The hoops to jump through were different every time.

One inspection seemed to be about the ethnicity and pupil premium progress data, so we had to spend days dissecting the class according to arbitrary ethnicity codes. It was a farce. I worked in an incredibly multi-cultural area, so would have to say daft things like '100% of Polish children are making above expected progress' (1 child).

Second time was all about mini plenaries and assessment for learning (the school had a stupid system of traffic lights on the tables so children could constantly assess whether they were meeting their learning objective). Again. Totally ridiculous and interrupted their work every 5 minutes to say 'remember your traffic lights!' - and I taught Year 1 who had no idea what they were for, really.

Last one was the 'deep dive' framework, which is still in place. Months of annoying each other about the subjects we were leading. Re-writing curricula and monitoring everyone else's planning for Music or Science. Again - totally distracting.

I assume that when pilots or train drivers are assessed, it isn't for some new idea that someone in the Department for Transport has dreamed up in an office somewhere without any idea of how a train or plane actually works? Because that's how it feels. We trained to teach. Lots of us have years of experience and know our teaching styles - let us do it how it works for us, please!

No, the dft like to tell everyone they have nothing to do with the running of TOCs but that's for another day. We tend to have graduate entry people who've never worked an operational role in their lives impose arbitray driving policies that don't allow us to use our judgment then hammer us with requests for info about delays caused by driving to such policies or nitpick when we don't comply 100%. Or produce 9.5 hour turns that are within parameters by the skin of their teeth and that start at 3am and wonder why there are incidents. I think fuckwittery from on high is sadly universal.

@rosesinmygarden of course, I have enormous sympathy for teachers. They are wildly undervalued and mistrusted, subject to ever more ludicrous ideas from idiots that don't know what they're talking about and are hauled over the coals for things they're not then allowed to do anything about. It's insanity.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 22/03/2023 09:25

donttellmehesalive · 20/03/2023 21:36

Do other professions have the level of observation and scrutiny that teaching has? Do people watch doctors talking to patients, or watch lawyers with clients? Maybe they do.

We do in nursing (I'm a Mental Health Nurse). The inspectors come into the ward and go through our care plans, risk assessments, basically all nursing documentation and they speak to our patients. They also watch the general goings on in the ward.

lifeissweet · 22/03/2023 09:09

I am out of classroom teaching now (thank fuck), but I went through 3 OFSTED's (managed to dodge one by giving birth the day of 'the call' - I hadn't gone on maternity leave by then. The Head nearly had an aneurism). The hoops to jump through were different every time.

One inspection seemed to be about the ethnicity and pupil premium progress data, so we had to spend days dissecting the class according to arbitrary ethnicity codes. It was a farce. I worked in an incredibly multi-cultural area, so would have to say daft things like '100% of Polish children are making above expected progress' (1 child).

Second time was all about mini plenaries and assessment for learning (the school had a stupid system of traffic lights on the tables so children could constantly assess whether they were meeting their learning objective). Again. Totally ridiculous and interrupted their work every 5 minutes to say 'remember your traffic lights!' - and I taught Year 1 who had no idea what they were for, really.

Last one was the 'deep dive' framework, which is still in place. Months of annoying each other about the subjects we were leading. Re-writing curricula and monitoring everyone else's planning for Music or Science. Again - totally distracting.

I assume that when pilots or train drivers are assessed, it isn't for some new idea that someone in the Department for Transport has dreamed up in an office somewhere without any idea of how a train or plane actually works? Because that's how it feels. We trained to teach. Lots of us have years of experience and know our teaching styles - let us do it how it works for us, please!

Ishefuckingkiddingme · 22/03/2023 08:54

ForestLilac · 22/03/2023 08:41

A child was locked outside naked as a punishment? What?

Yep. The Hesley Group residential special schools were given a Good Ofsted rating even after over 100 complaints to Ofsted about the way children were being treated. Incidents included being locked outside naked, intentionally denied their medication as punishment, children receiving injuries including a black eye from staff, children being swung by their ankles by staff, children being punched and kicked in the stomach by staff, staff hitting a child over the head with a ringbinder… And yet, with the school that Ruth Perry ran, they received an inadequate rating because Ofsted thought that a child flossing on the playground was a safeguarding risk. The very concept that Ofsted play any role at all in safeguarding children is a joke. They don’t.

If someone posted on here saying their DC had got in trouble at school for flossing on the playground because it’s a safeguarding risk, every response would say that the school are being ridiculous - and rightly so. A school cannot predict which ridiculous thing an Ofsted inspector will hone in on to justify downgrading a school and that’s why the inspections are so stressful. It’s not like other professions (like mine) where the regulatory body judge you based on your actual ability to do what you’re supposed to do. Ofsted are being told to downgrade school for political reasons and are finding any reason that they can to downgrade Outstanding schools and keep the bad school rated Good.

rosesinmygarden · 22/03/2023 08:53

christmaspudding43 · 22/03/2023 08:35

@rosesinmygarden @Pottedpalm I don't think anyone has said they're the same. The question was whether other occupations are subject to the same level of scrutiny (not the exact same scrutiny). One of my besties is a head teacher, another has left teaching already. You couldn't pay me enough to teach in this country. I fully support teachers striking.

If the poster who asked about scrutiny is considering a move to another industry and wants to know about the levels of observation and scrutiny then it's best they know the reality of those jobs before moving frying pan to fire. It doesn't help anyone to encourage them into something that is unsuitable.

@rosesinmygarden yes, there is variation in how managers interpret things, since you asked. One will tell you to do something one way and on another day one will pull you up for the exact same thing. Internal standard production is poor, it tends to be the national standards that are black and white but there are many assessments completed on things that are not standard nationally.

So train drivers must have some sympathy with the way ofsted works. It's just not fair when the goal posts are moved.

It's so hard for people outside of an industry to understand what it is like for those on the inside. Which explains why many people outside of teaching seem to think teachers are lying/exaggerating about ofsted.

ForestLilac · 22/03/2023 08:41

Ishefuckingkiddingme · 22/03/2023 07:19

Ofsted gave a good rating to a school that locked a child outside naked as a punishment. Not sure why you think they’d give a single shit about students being lost. Studies have shown there is no detectable difference in the standard of a school based on their Ofsted ranking.

A child was locked outside naked as a punishment? What?

Boudicasbeard · 22/03/2023 08:38

@MsWhitworth

Maybe you can’t understand because you’re not a teacher. It was her vocation. She’d been an outstanding head (as testified by her staff and pupils) for decades.

She’d given her life to her school- headship means long hours (70 plus a week), sacrificing family events during term time and always putting your school first. Heads don’t really have holidays like the teachers do. They are in school over holidays monitoring building works or looking after admin staff or updating policies or doing CAfCASs meeting or a while host of things that carry on during the holidays.

So when they down graded her school to RI she knew if meant that she’d never work again. She would lose her job as soon as the report came out. And she would never get another.

Because for heads and RI at Ofstead is like a scarlet letter. A badge of shame. You failed. You drove a school to inadequate. No parent body or governing body would ever let you run a school again. Your shame spread across a whole school community.

i can understand why she did it.

christmaspudding43 · 22/03/2023 08:35

@rosesinmygarden @Pottedpalm I don't think anyone has said they're the same. The question was whether other occupations are subject to the same level of scrutiny (not the exact same scrutiny). One of my besties is a head teacher, another has left teaching already. You couldn't pay me enough to teach in this country. I fully support teachers striking.

If the poster who asked about scrutiny is considering a move to another industry and wants to know about the levels of observation and scrutiny then it's best they know the reality of those jobs before moving frying pan to fire. It doesn't help anyone to encourage them into something that is unsuitable.

@rosesinmygarden yes, there is variation in how managers interpret things, since you asked. One will tell you to do something one way and on another day one will pull you up for the exact same thing. Internal standard production is poor, it tends to be the national standards that are black and white but there are many assessments completed on things that are not standard nationally.

MsWhitworth · 22/03/2023 08:25

While I agree that Ofsted has problems and the system needs an overhaul, I also think schools do need monitoring and that it’s unfair to blame them for this sad death. Suicide is complex.

Mateyduck · 22/03/2023 08:25

Suicide is not straightforward. It was probably a culmination of things, not just Ofsted that drove that poor woman to take her life.
I agree ofsted needs looking at , but it’s not the sole issue here .

rosesinmygarden · 22/03/2023 08:22

christmaspudding43 · 22/03/2023 07:55

Train drivers sit a formal exam at qualifying and then again after two years then every three years after that. In between times there is a programme of assessment including random downloads of the train's otmr (black box) to check standards, rides with a manager etc. There are additional assessments on top of these if a driver has made a mistake.

It's not impossible to persecute a driver if the manager so wishes but the union would be involved fairly early on.

I suspect the elements a train driver is assessed on are 99% within the drivers control? Other than freak weather, someone/something on the tracks. And even then, there will be set rules to follow in a given situation.

Or are the standards different depending on how the examiner interprets them in that day?

Does the examiner judge the driver by how the passengers on the train behaved?

It's not the same.

Bluevelvetsofa · 22/03/2023 08:20

@Boudicasbeard is absolutely right. The inspectors are taken to task if they don’t find something to criticise.

I worked in a school that was deemed Fresh Start and probably went through a dozen monitoring visits and Ofsted. It was never supportive.

Pottedpalm · 22/03/2023 08:12

These examples are just not comparable. A train driver/pilot is in control of a machine which responds in a given
way if controlled correctly ( barring emergencies for which there are set procedures),
A teacher could deliver a perfectly designed and pitched lesson but it will be received in a myriad of ways by the target audience. Some choose not to get involved at all, or to deliberately disrupt. Some become bored rapidly, or feel tired or unwell. Yet a negative judgement is given if all pupils do not achieve certain outcomes. It’s not comparable with getting a machine from one place to another.

Boudicasbeard · 22/03/2023 08:10

@notimagain

I’m glad you mentioned aviation because my husband works in that sector. We had a long old chat about it all last night and he came to the conclusion that the big difference between the CAA and various other aviation inspection bodies and Ofsted is that the aviation inspectors and working to a set a standards that are easily measurable- record keeping, safety etc.

Ofsted is a political weapon these days. They goal posts change from year to year (sometimes wildly) to suit whoever is Secretary of State for Education. This means we are sometime tearing up and rebuilding all our units from year to year. And the focus of inspection changes too- behaviour, SEND, LAC etc

They are not impartial observers. They are going in with an agenda and that agenda is never really to help staff or kids. It’s to tick some central government boxes about what they think schools should look like. Not the reality of what is best for children.

I say this as someone who has been through Ofsted three times. They start that first day knowing what they are going to give you before they’ve seen a lesson. Your job is to persuade them otherwise.

christmaspudding43 · 22/03/2023 07:55

donttellmehesalive · 20/03/2023 21:36

Do other professions have the level of observation and scrutiny that teaching has? Do people watch doctors talking to patients, or watch lawyers with clients? Maybe they do.

Train drivers sit a formal exam at qualifying and then again after two years then every three years after that. In between times there is a programme of assessment including random downloads of the train's otmr (black box) to check standards, rides with a manager etc. There are additional assessments on top of these if a driver has made a mistake.

It's not impossible to persecute a driver if the manager so wishes but the union would be involved fairly early on.

Enko · 22/03/2023 07:49

MrsKeats · 20/03/2023 21:59

raineth do you work in a school? I sincerely hope not as you have literally no idea what you are talking about.

As someone who has worked in a school I don't think @Raineth post was without idea.

I am uncomfortable with both ofsted and the way it's bulldozing I am also uncomfortable with the idea a school can say no we won't be under any account. We need accountability. I dont think ofsted does this well And I agree with the poster who said noone should be driven to commit suicide due to their work.

I would welcome a overhaul of ofsted but to me permitting a head teacher to say no to the current set up is not without its own concerns.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/03/2023 07:42

notimagain · 20/03/2023 21:54

Not sure if aviation counts as a genuine profession but there's plenty of observation and scrutiny - for flight crew (pilots) it usually a couple of days in the simulator every six months with the possibility of loss of licence if it goes wrong, plus an assessed flight on the aircraft at least every two years.

Similarly there's a lot of scrutiny, checking, and recurrent testing of Air Traffic Controllers and Cabin Crew and no doubt others in that industry.

If a pilot fucks up, the result can be over a thousand people dying horribly in air and on the ground.

You'd have to have a biology lesson involving releasing bubonic plague infected vermin into the school kitchen to have approximately the same scale of disaster in a school.

londonrach · 22/03/2023 07:33

The school in my town which is outstanding I never send my DD too for several good reasons. I had a friend who did and her D's struggled (due to the main reason I decided to not send DD to the outstanding school..the set up at playtime) and been bullied which luckily been sorted now. Example of the difference between the school s...outstanding school was given a word to dress up as on world book day, good school said choose a book you love and dress up as someone in that and all the teachers dressed up too. Not much difference but glad I didn't have word to dress dd in...some of the words were impossible and you didn't get to choose your word. I choose the good school with amazing head and felt a better fit for DD. Agree Ofsted needs an overall...a snapshot on one day or couple of day isn't a good way of looking at the school.