Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The death taboo in England.

186 replies

Fifi1010 · 20/03/2023 19:23

I did a training session on dying well and wow so many people are so uncomfortable with dying even mentioning it . I have a will and life insurance. I have informed my family of my current wishes and I have written this down. If I change my mind I will update it. I don't think of death a lot but I see it as inevitable and a transition.

It saddens me when people haven't done the planning so decisions are made in crisis when emotions are high and people might not get the end they would want. What could be done to ease the taboo of death?

OP posts:
EmmaEmerald · 20/03/2023 20:29

Vitriol you mean your mum is trying to talk about it but you stop her?

Strictly I like your dad!

tobee don't worry, I knew what you meant.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 20/03/2023 20:27

I'm a girl guide so am prepared. Although now I think about it I could write down more specific wishes.

I once asked my dad if he wanted burial or cremation and he replied rather dryly "surprise me."

As Cariad Lloyd puts it - it's a club. You only really get it once you're in the club.

Hbh17 · 20/03/2023 20:24

YANBU.
Death is normal.
Death will happen to all of us.
Death is not something to be afraid of.
We should all prepare for our own death, take the emotion out of it and discuss honestly and openly.

Vitriolinsanity · 20/03/2023 20:23

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius I recognise your name from many iterations and offer my sympathies for your recent loss.

I'd like to ask you and others a question that I hope isn't upsetting. When you say your person left instructions did you know they had done that, and if so what was your experience.

I ask as my mother talks about this and we breezily say there's no need to talk about it, she's not going anywhere etc. She's 87, so you know, it's not like she has too many forevers.

No one wants to consider life without the people they love the most. As a single parent I've put provisions in place. The fact remains death is a certainty (more so given the cig I'm currently smoking) yet we shy away from conversations that may actually be a comfort of mind that are staring reality in the face.

I tend to agree with posters talking of a downturn in religion. I don't expect an afterlife, but a reflection of life lived and knowledge of our wishes should be talked about more in life not in our eulogy I think.

illiterato · 20/03/2023 20:23

treneton · 20/03/2023 20:21

Hopefully you wouldn't know but it is very distressing for those that love you to see you like that. But who knows. I remember when my dear mum was dying I put headphones on her (she had had a stroke and couldn't move in the last few weeks) and played the Blue Danube which was a favourite piece of music. Tears rolled out of her eyes and she gestured to take them off. She died later that night and I think she knew it and didn't want to remember what had gone. She didn't want to leave the party so to speak. 30 years on I can't listen to that piece of music without welling up.

I dunno- I hear it’s like permanently waking up from a big night thinking “ oh fuck. What did I do/say?”. Basically permanent hangxiety.

tobee · 20/03/2023 20:22

tobee · 20/03/2023 20:18

That's a nice definition of passed away @EmmaEmerald

Just to elucidate I meant "nice" as in this definition

(especially of a difference) slight or subtle.
"there is a nice distinction between self-sacrifice and martyrdom"

Rowgtfc72 · 20/03/2023 20:22

When my daughter was 5 we had our dog pts. She asked lots of questions. Did it hurt? Could he still see? What would the vet do with him next. I explained he didn't hurt anymore, maybe he could see her from the sky but what we knew as our dog was no more. He was in a bag in a freezer with lots of other pets and would go in a bonfire with the other pets and what was left would blow across the fields and be free. ( sensible child not easy frightened and coped better with all the facts)
As it happened my dad died two years later. She remembered he was in a big fridge, would go in a bonfire.

She was very excited as the hearse pulled up shouting 'grandads here'. She proudly carried his ashes as we sent them up the firebox of a steam train and waved goodbye to him.
Obviously this isn't for everyone but for dd it helped her see death wasn't scary and just a process, if a sad one.

treneton · 20/03/2023 20:21

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2023 20:15

Hanging on forever in a body that's decaying around you is just too much to take.

I could deal with that. Hanging around forever with dementia is what really scares me.

Hopefully you wouldn't know but it is very distressing for those that love you to see you like that. But who knows. I remember when my dear mum was dying I put headphones on her (she had had a stroke and couldn't move in the last few weeks) and played the Blue Danube which was a favourite piece of music. Tears rolled out of her eyes and she gestured to take them off. She died later that night and I think she knew it and didn't want to remember what had gone. She didn't want to leave the party so to speak. 30 years on I can't listen to that piece of music without welling up.

ColdHandsHotHead · 20/03/2023 20:19

I've got a will and have put a note with it of the type of funeral I want, and the music I want. I did this after having arranged my mother's funeral. She didn't give instructions so we just picked what she would have liked.

tobee · 20/03/2023 20:18

That's a nice definition of passed away @EmmaEmerald

EmmaEmerald · 20/03/2023 20:17

Tobee "Personally I think it's a ridiculous euphemism but I don't want to even slightly hurt people who've recently had a relative die recently."

my dad "passed away" because it was sooooo sloooow and painful.

I had friends die in a terror attack, I used died for them because that's the right word.

also interesting..the OTT condolences come with reference to my father, but not to my friends, which was a much more awful thing. Watching parents bury their children...bloody hell.

anyway, that's actually a great example of why we don't talk about death! I wasn't intending to provide one but perhaps I have 🤷🏻‍♀️

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2023 20:17

vera99 · 20/03/2023 20:15

Necrophilia is obviously a grey area then ... 😁(attempt at graveyard humour alert).

😂

tobee · 20/03/2023 20:17

I suppose we can control so much nowadays and consider ourselves discerning consumers. Very difficult to cope with being so out of control with life's ultimate event.

rc22 · 20/03/2023 20:16

vera99 · 20/03/2023 20:15

Necrophilia is obviously a grey area then ... 😁(attempt at graveyard humour alert).

😁

Xrays · 20/03/2023 20:15

EmmaEmerald · 20/03/2023 20:13

Judge I can relate to the bit about OTT expressions of condolence. I do say "late" because it seems to avoid errors.

I used to tell my sister to put "That's All Folks!" from the cartoons on the final slide at my funeral. She said that was highly inappropriate and would upset people.

I was relieved my dad didn't leave funeral instructions, it meant I did as I chose mostly, my sister and mum didn't want to tackle it.

I do understand why people might not want to discuss it, myriad of reasons really. But I do think it's important to sort power of attorney, DNR if you want one etc.

I love that - that’s all folks!

My mum always said she wanted “I told you I was ill” on her grave stone 😆😳

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2023 20:15

Hanging on forever in a body that's decaying around you is just too much to take.

I could deal with that. Hanging around forever with dementia is what really scares me.

vera99 · 20/03/2023 20:15

rc22 · 20/03/2023 20:12

In Victorian England, discussing death was socially acceptable and sex was taboo. Now, it's more or less reversed.

Necrophilia is obviously a grey area then ... 😁(attempt at graveyard humour alert).

tobee · 20/03/2023 20:15

I don't know if I'm scared of death or the illnesses that lead to it. I'm scared of my parents death which I think about quite a lot as they are late 80s.

The only dead body I've seen was my newborn baby daughter (my middle child) who was stillborn. I was obviously extremely distressed about the whole experience but ultimately was able to think "how can I be scared of my own baby?"

treneton · 20/03/2023 20:13

We come from nothing we go to nothing so in the end what have we lost nothing. I hope I go like my parents from pretty good health in their mid 70s to dying within days as hard as that was 30 years ago to take it's probably the best way to die. Hanging on forever in a body that's decaying around you is just too much to take.

EmmaEmerald · 20/03/2023 20:13

Judge I can relate to the bit about OTT expressions of condolence. I do say "late" because it seems to avoid errors.

I used to tell my sister to put "That's All Folks!" from the cartoons on the final slide at my funeral. She said that was highly inappropriate and would upset people.

I was relieved my dad didn't leave funeral instructions, it meant I did as I chose mostly, my sister and mum didn't want to tackle it.

I do understand why people might not want to discuss it, myriad of reasons really. But I do think it's important to sort power of attorney, DNR if you want one etc.

Xrays · 20/03/2023 20:13

I wonder if as people are living longer a lot of people haven’t personally experienced death, and perhaps that makes it more taboo. I notice I’m quite unusual in my circles losing all my relatives before 40. Most people still have their parents, some even have grandparents alive. A few generations back death was more commonplace; well I mean it’s always happened (!) but experienced more by more people.

rc22 · 20/03/2023 20:12

In Victorian England, discussing death was socially acceptable and sex was taboo. Now, it's more or less reversed.

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2023 20:10

A thing that’s really changed is the reluctance to say die or death and replace it with the mealy mouthed pass or pass away.

One of my friends was really taken aback when I said I had no fear of dying and the preceding weeks or months frightened me far more.

tobee · 20/03/2023 20:09

I've been pondering a while about starting a thread on whether death is the last taboo in our society.

I feel like we're getting far more squeamish about death and the phrase "passed away" is used much more frequently than I can ever remember. I know someone who works in bbc news who said that the policy is to say "died" once and then "passed away" after that. Personally I think it's a ridiculous euphemism but I don't want to even slightly hurt people who've recently had a relative die recently.

I also know plenty of people who are superstitious about death and think that eg writing a will is somehow tempting fate. Death is often so random. I'm an atheist and to me it's not surprising that human beings have developed religious beliefs and structures.

Reluctantadult · 20/03/2023 20:08

I find the whole idea of death really fucking scary tbh. Since dh's dad died last year at home and I got there to help and had to deal with the paramedics and tell mil he'd gone and call dh and sil and take dh up to the bedroom to see his dad. Him lying there was just fucking awful. And that was a sudden death at home. He wouldn't really have known anything about it. So a pretty good way to go. Death is really really scary.

Swipe left for the next trending thread