Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The death taboo in England.

186 replies

Fifi1010 · 20/03/2023 19:23

I did a training session on dying well and wow so many people are so uncomfortable with dying even mentioning it . I have a will and life insurance. I have informed my family of my current wishes and I have written this down. If I change my mind I will update it. I don't think of death a lot but I see it as inevitable and a transition.

It saddens me when people haven't done the planning so decisions are made in crisis when emotions are high and people might not get the end they would want. What could be done to ease the taboo of death?

OP posts:
TheNefariousOrange · 20/03/2023 21:22

The idea of not existing terrifies me. I genuinely have panic attacks sometimes. I haven't got any plans or anything organised because I don't have any wishes.

Snugglemonkey · 20/03/2023 21:16

Dacadactyl · 20/03/2023 19:53

True. IME, the Irish are good with death.

Yes. I am Irish. I have lived in England and Scotland but neither place has the same kind of openness.

Notsureonusername · 20/03/2023 21:07

I made a will in my early 40’s after my divorce. I am now mid 50’s and have just completed my POA forms. There will be a lump sum for a funeral. My children know what I would like at my funeral & I have written a letter to them with these requests. I do know one thing for sure and that is I will die. Don’t know where, don’t know when. But I hope that I have helped my children deal with me with the minimum of fuss & complication

Judellie · 20/03/2023 21:03

The church we go to has forms where you can detail your funeral wishes. You don't have to go to that church; if you want you can just go in and get yourself a form, even if you never intend going to church again, or never have before. You can then use it as a guideline for your own wishes.
Not all churches do this as my friend from a different church was absolutely delighted with one of these forms (!).
I also wonder why we prolong lives so much, when people are so ill, old and uncomfortable, but as nobody ever mentions it, I thought I must be the only one who thought like that.
Still not sure what to do tho if someone died; do you ring the undertaker straight away or do you call the doctor or what are you meant to do?
And yes, the Irish seem to do it better - that episode of Derry Girls where Bridie dies and her body is in the house; the girls take it in their stride but English James is horrified by a dead body.

moveoverye · 20/03/2023 21:02

I feel strangely okay about my own death, even hoping that i won’t get too old and decrepit. Possibly this is because I’m in my 30s and still feels distant.
But I get very very upset thinking about my mum’s future death.

IncompleteSenten · 20/03/2023 21:00

I'm not sure.
It's denial rooted in fear with a helping of superstition ('tempting fate')

How do we stop people being scared of death? Of the unknown? Of possible pain associated with many causes of death?

I don't think anything short of scientists proving the existence of a beautiful afterlife would remove that primal fear of death.

Sunsetintheeast · 20/03/2023 21:00

My Dad died a year ago. I was with him and then me and my DSis dressed him in his favourite T-shirt gave him a flower to hold and we waited for the funeral director to come the next morning.

It was nice to leave him looking peaceful after a difficult few days dying of covid, but he was at home as he wanted.

I want to be put to sleep if I’m ever that sick. I’ve made it very clear to my DC and DH. I will take myself to Switzerland after a goodbye party.

EmmaEmerald · 20/03/2023 20:59

Join yes. One friend's mum died peacefully reading a book, having had her normal, busy active day. My friend kept on about how traumatising it was to have it happen so suddenly, but I just kept thinking, I wish dad had gone like that. They were the same age. Again, you can't say it, but I'm not a fool, I can't be shocked by a parent dying at nearly 80, but the three months of daily hideousness before the death was the real problem.

which leads on to...what does talking about death mean?

yes, I'm definitely seeing why people don't talk about it. In fact, I shall hide the thread now but will remember to tell sis to do a direct cremation and then please just crack on with life!

KickHimInTheCrotch · 20/03/2023 20:59

I really don't care what happens to me after I die. I'd like my kids to give me the send off that works best for them. Whatever gives them the most comfort, doesn't cost too much or take too much stress to organise. I can't imagine dictating songs or readings or the type of box I'm put in. So I won't be leaving g instructions. I have a will of course but thats just for the finances.

But I'm not scared of death. I'd like to outlive my parents because they've already buried one child and I'd like to see my children settled and happy to whatever they want from life. But other than that I don't want to hang around longer than is comfortable. My grandmother is 94 and I know she gets very little joy out of life, despite being fairly healthy and independent.

I talk about death often. I encourage others to talk about death. Death is a fact of life.

Dacadactyl · 20/03/2023 20:57

Sorry I've just re-read and I can see 19 was your first experience of death.

Diversion · 20/03/2023 20:57

I'm sorry to those who have had recent losses. Please talk to your family about your end of life and death wishes and encourage them to talk about theirs. Have Wills, POA, Advance Decisions in place. None of these will take away the hurt or make things better, but they will help dealing with the admin parts which are horrible at an extremely stressful time. Also make sure that you know where these documents are so you can have them to hand when things reach the end, especially a DNR or advance decision. I don't think that many of us know what to do after a death until we have experienced it. If the death is classed as unexpected, even if the person was very ill, the Police will be called and will examine the body and will not allow anyone in the room whilst they do this. This was one of the hardest parts for me as I did not want a male officer examining her, despite knowing that he was doing his job.

Dacadactyl · 20/03/2023 20:57

JoonT · 20/03/2023 20:48

I think we shut it out because it’s just so awful. Some people are lucky, and die dozing in front of the TV, or whatever, but for most of us it’s not a pretty sight. And in many cases it’s horrific. My first experience of death occurred when I was 19 and watched my beautiful, gentle grandmother die of a brain haemorrhage. It was horrifying and has completely poisoned my memories of her. My friend’s dad died of cancer when we were 24, and it was like something out of a horror movie. And it doesn’t end with death. It’s unbearable to imagine our loved one burning in an oven or buried in the cold, dark ground. We shut it out for a reason.

Was aged 19 your first experience of death though? I think the age you're first exposed to can make a difference.

I saw my uncle die of cancer at 12 and it was awful, for sure, but I'd already seen my great grandmother die and her body afterwards, when I was 10. I think it made it my uncle dying easier to cope with.

On top of this, my family are religious and we were always at funerals of people who'd died from Church or whatever.

Sidge · 20/03/2023 20:51

We don’t talk about death enough.

And we certainly don’t talk about death in relation to ageing enough. There seems to be an expectation that people should live excessively long lives, even when health is so poor. Quantity instead of quality.

JoonT · 20/03/2023 20:48

I think we shut it out because it’s just so awful. Some people are lucky, and die dozing in front of the TV, or whatever, but for most of us it’s not a pretty sight. And in many cases it’s horrific. My first experience of death occurred when I was 19 and watched my beautiful, gentle grandmother die of a brain haemorrhage. It was horrifying and has completely poisoned my memories of her. My friend’s dad died of cancer when we were 24, and it was like something out of a horror movie. And it doesn’t end with death. It’s unbearable to imagine our loved one burning in an oven or buried in the cold, dark ground. We shut it out for a reason.

Vitriolinsanity · 20/03/2023 20:43

I'm hoping it's brought you comfort @SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius

If we learn nothing, perhaps it's true that our mothers know best.

Xrays · 20/03/2023 20:41

illiterato · 20/03/2023 20:30

I actually think it’s really important to let your mother say what she wants to, however much you don’t want to hear it. I remember my grandad telling me he’d quite like to die. It was hard to hear but most of his friends and his wife were dead, his health was failing quite rapidly, and he said “ I’d rather it was now while I’m not in any pain”. It did help us make decisions further down the road to not try to prolong his life.

I agree too. I think it’s a very lonely place for someone at the end of their life if they’re sssshhed from talking about it or told breezily they’ve got ages left. It’s okay to want to talk about death. It really is. We need to be more open about it. My Mum knew when she had a few days left and she said she was “sad to be leaving the party” - and I really think that’s how we should all see life and death.

Vitriolinsanity · 20/03/2023 20:40

Woman, not email fgs.

Although she does love an email at her advanced age. I do rue buying that bloody iPad daily.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 20/03/2023 20:39

Thank you all for your kind wishes.

@Vitriolinsanity - mum wrote her letter and sent it to both of us in 2020 - some of it opus out of date, because of the special arrangements around funerals during Covid, but most of it still makes sense. If you didn’t want to see the letter ahead of time, perhaps your mum could write it and give it to you to be opened when needed.

Vitriolinsanity · 20/03/2023 20:38

Not stop her (you couldn't gag the email if you tried, god bless her!) but I don't feel I'm alone when I say we push the conversation down the road. We shouldn't, but we do. My point being that we all hope so hard to avoid talk of the inevitable for selfish gain.

museumum · 20/03/2023 20:37

I think our society is in an awkward place right now with Christianity and Christian traditions. My parents and everybody I know of their generation would assume a church funeral just goes without saying even for non church-goers.
Many much younger people are humanist / atheist and comfortable with that.

I am the in between generation. I don’t go to church and wouldn’t choose any mentions of god or heaven for myself. But if I were to die before my parents and they wanted a church funeral then I guess I’d rather they had whatever makes them feel better. I mean, I won’t care, I’ll be dead.

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2023 20:37

I actually think it’s really important to let your mother say what she wants to, however much you don’t want to hear it.

I agree. I knew what my mum wanted because we talked about it. There’s a note for our kids for both our funerals and we joke with them about us being dead, eg I’ve told them if there’s any religion involved in my funeral I’ll come back and haunt them.

Puppaddington · 20/03/2023 20:34

tobee · 20/03/2023 20:09

I've been pondering a while about starting a thread on whether death is the last taboo in our society.

I feel like we're getting far more squeamish about death and the phrase "passed away" is used much more frequently than I can ever remember. I know someone who works in bbc news who said that the policy is to say "died" once and then "passed away" after that. Personally I think it's a ridiculous euphemism but I don't want to even slightly hurt people who've recently had a relative die recently.

I also know plenty of people who are superstitious about death and think that eg writing a will is somehow tempting fate. Death is often so random. I'm an atheist and to me it's not surprising that human beings have developed religious beliefs and structures.

I’ve been bereaved recently and used the word ‘die’ when telling people or writing it down, personally I don’t like the pass away euphemism. I would have liked it if those I was talking to used the same expression, but most used passed etc. I know you cannot police others’ language but it would have been mindful of the way I was phrasing it.

Vitriolinsanity · 20/03/2023 20:34

@Hopskipnsigh I agree with you. Dead and died are, I believe not words to be shied away from. My own DS attended his GF's funeral, in fact contributed, as did my nieces when their mother died.

I look to Irish friends, where the death is acknowledged head on and the life lived celebrated, for guidance. Whilst religion plays a part the openness of the rituals is a comfort to the bereaved in way that my own slightly antiseptic experience has been.

illiterato · 20/03/2023 20:30

Vitriolinsanity · 20/03/2023 20:23

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius I recognise your name from many iterations and offer my sympathies for your recent loss.

I'd like to ask you and others a question that I hope isn't upsetting. When you say your person left instructions did you know they had done that, and if so what was your experience.

I ask as my mother talks about this and we breezily say there's no need to talk about it, she's not going anywhere etc. She's 87, so you know, it's not like she has too many forevers.

No one wants to consider life without the people they love the most. As a single parent I've put provisions in place. The fact remains death is a certainty (more so given the cig I'm currently smoking) yet we shy away from conversations that may actually be a comfort of mind that are staring reality in the face.

I tend to agree with posters talking of a downturn in religion. I don't expect an afterlife, but a reflection of life lived and knowledge of our wishes should be talked about more in life not in our eulogy I think.

I actually think it’s really important to let your mother say what she wants to, however much you don’t want to hear it. I remember my grandad telling me he’d quite like to die. It was hard to hear but most of his friends and his wife were dead, his health was failing quite rapidly, and he said “ I’d rather it was now while I’m not in any pain”. It did help us make decisions further down the road to not try to prolong his life.

treneton · 20/03/2023 20:30

I once asked my dad was it like being in the waiting room for death in his 70s and he was most annoyed. He said he felt like he was 17 and life was yet to begin. He died soon after.