Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The death taboo in England.

186 replies

Fifi1010 · 20/03/2023 19:23

I did a training session on dying well and wow so many people are so uncomfortable with dying even mentioning it . I have a will and life insurance. I have informed my family of my current wishes and I have written this down. If I change my mind I will update it. I don't think of death a lot but I see it as inevitable and a transition.

It saddens me when people haven't done the planning so decisions are made in crisis when emotions are high and people might not get the end they would want. What could be done to ease the taboo of death?

OP posts:
mids2019 · 21/03/2023 07:24

Big topic.....being going since the dawn of ti me.

with the decline in religion and reduction of opportunities to discuss death we are in a position collective head burying to escape continual existential angst.

I think this has lead to a cult of youth and a determined if doomed attempt to eradicate all the features of aging. We do not talk about social care or hospices at an individual level as often and as early as we could.

this mentality has knock on effects on health care where increasingly aggressive and invasive treatment s are used in the elderly in artificially extending life often with little quality. The majority NHS spending is spent on the over 70s. For instance cancer proportionately impacts the elderly and yet the level of treatment is the same as for someone in their 30s and we have to question the holistic benefit of this.

People.I know are too proud to discuss degenerative ailments such as arthritis that disassociated with the elderly and we have a plethora of celebs who guard their appearance jealously aiming to eradicate the signs of old age of weakness.

LlynTegid · 21/03/2023 07:19

Focus on getting people to make a will.

Zuffe · 21/03/2023 06:49

My death will have no impact on me, only others.

Dying may do, but it’s transient.

WhenDovesFly · 21/03/2023 06:33

@Judellie
Still not sure what to do tho if someone died; do you ring the undertaker straight away or do you call the doctor or what are you meant to do?

If your loved one dies at home you should call the GP first. The undertaker cannot collect the deceased until the death has been certified. Sometimes, if the death happens out of GP hours, then a paramedic will do this.

Be aware though that if the death was not expected then the police will need to be informed and the death referred to the coroner. The attending police will arrange for the deceased to be taken into the care of a local undertaker who they have a contract with. You are not obliged to use that undertaker for the funeral, you can instruct whichever one you prefer to use.

JacobsCrackersCheeseFogg · 21/03/2023 06:18

Our family is recently bereaved but unfortunately we are experiencing delays disposing of the body because the case is with the coroner and police.

My mother doesn't like the way my husband and I speak about death. She's not religious and has planned & paid for her funeral. She believes her body should be revered because it represents her in life.

We are of a different view. Once the person has died, that's it, they're gone. We don't believe the body needs to be treated with respect, it's just remnants of the person who has died. Our family member said he didn't care how we got rid of their body, they will be dead. We don't subscribe to all the usual rites. We just want to be able to get the death certificate, resolve their personal business, and move on.

We would prefer not to have a funeral because all the people who didn't bother staying in touch during their life suddenly come out of the woodwork and claiming how sad they are. Ghouls, all of them. Pretenders. They didn't make the effort when they were alive, why bother if they're dead? A free drink and sausage roll, probably. Our family member didn't have any money so they'll be disappointed in that regard.

My husband also complains about The Script: "Oh I'm so sorry for your loss. Let me know if there's anything we can do, ok?" Yes, please stop being so fake and foxtrot Oscar. They aren't being genuine, they just say it to be polite.

I want a direct cremation. The crematorium can throw my ashes in the bin because I won't care through being dead. My husband wants to be donated to medical science. We are both ardent atheists who are entirely practical about these matters.

I'm grieving so I hope people aren't too offended by my comments.

sammylady37 · 21/03/2023 06:02

for some reason I cannot abide anyone using “pass/ed” on its own without the word “away”. It’s naff, like the sort of thing a crappy medium would say. “Pass over” is even worse. They’re not a rain cloud or an aircraft going overhead

I agree with this. I find even ‘passed away’ to be a bit avoidant and think it’s an attempt to avoid the reality of the situation. But bad and all as those phrases are, they pale in comparison to ‘gained angel wings’… I can somewhat understand that when it’s a parent talking about a young child who has died, but when I see that about an adult or elderly person, I raise an eyebrow. I agree with a pp that it’s all contributing to a society where death is feared and we don’t recognise it as part of life and the natural process.

FrozenGhost · 21/03/2023 02:00

I'm not sure.
It's denial rooted in fear with a helping of superstition ('tempting fate')

True, but in some ways wanting to talk about death and remove the taboo is the same thing. It's the same thing but the other way, to imagine that if you talk about and plan for death, it will make it easy, painfree or not sad for your loved ones. It won't though. You can't organise your way out of death any more than you can hide from it.

Same with funeral arrangements - who cares, you are dead. You don't have wishes any more and you'll never know.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 21/03/2023 01:24

tobee · 20/03/2023 20:09

I've been pondering a while about starting a thread on whether death is the last taboo in our society.

I feel like we're getting far more squeamish about death and the phrase "passed away" is used much more frequently than I can ever remember. I know someone who works in bbc news who said that the policy is to say "died" once and then "passed away" after that. Personally I think it's a ridiculous euphemism but I don't want to even slightly hurt people who've recently had a relative die recently.

I also know plenty of people who are superstitious about death and think that eg writing a will is somehow tempting fate. Death is often so random. I'm an atheist and to me it's not surprising that human beings have developed religious beliefs and structures.

I’ve always thought the “pass away” type of phrase trite and disliked using it. Until my dad died a couple of weeks ago and I found myself saying “passed away” to others I didn’t know well, not because I found the word “died” upsetting myself but because it sounded so jarring in some situations eg. Cheery casual work conversation by a visiting colleague who visits weekly asking “oh I didn’t see you last week, have you been ill? Wasn’t COVID was it? <Cheery laugh>”

it didn’t right to give a blunt “no, my dad died.” So I found myself saying “ah, no, I lost my dad” or “my dad passed away”, in order to protect THEM from feeling uncomfortable at the sudden switch from a cheery smile and question to the dark topic of death.

daft really.

for some reason I cannot abide anyone using “pass/ed” on its own without the word “away”. It’s naff, like the sort of thing a crappy medium would say. “Pass over” is even worse. They’re not a rain cloud or an aircraft going overhead.

warmeduppizza · 21/03/2023 00:54

As a priest who spends a lot of time around the dead and the bereaved, I am always happy to sit down with anyone (religious/non religious/anything in between) to listen, chat, answer awkward questions and give non biased, non pushy practical advice, and I know lots of my colleagues are. Just come and have a coffee, talk about death, go home feeling a little lighter and never see me again (unless you want to). That’s what we’re there for.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/03/2023 00:47

CharlotteMullen · 20/03/2023 19:25

I don’t know, OP, but it’s made worse by people behaving as though death is something like haemorrhoids— slightly embarrassing, only affects a minority and shouldn’t be talked about.

Of course it 'only affects a minority'.

It's never happened to me, nor any of my friends. I was in town today and it was rammed with people, all of them going about their lives apparently still perfectly alive and well.

SoShallINever · 21/03/2023 00:30

Dacadactyl · 20/03/2023 19:53

True. IME, the Irish are good with death.

Really? In my experience of my huge Irish clan, they are quite obsessed with death in a proper miserable way. The talk always turns to who is sick and dying, who is bereaved. Lots of heaven and hell stuff. I find it suffocating.
I have no problem accepting death, I just don't want it in the next room at every conversation.

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 00:16

mumda · 21/03/2023 00:03

I think we should be more honest about the insane cost of funerals. Thousands of pounds wasted on an event that no one wants to remember.

It’s not a waste if it gives comfort to those left behind. There’s great comfort in showing respect to and honouring those we love. A funeral should be a celebration of a life as well as a chance to say goodbye.

mumda · 21/03/2023 00:03

I think we should be more honest about the insane cost of funerals. Thousands of pounds wasted on an event that no one wants to remember.

FlowersareEverything · 20/03/2023 23:37

I have an Irish background (moved to a place on Scotland with a big Irish immigrant population) so grew up with death being a normal part of life. As a child I was used to seeing dead bodies in coffins in someone’s living room or bedroom and all the rituals that goes with it. My granny used to wash the dead and prepare the room for “the people round about” rather than the undertaker doing it. She had white sheets and a small white tablecloth that was wrapped in brown paper and string. One sheet was put on the bed under the coffin and the other was put over the window. You knew when there was a death in a house because of the sheet at the window. The tablecloth was out on a table beside the bed to put a crucifix and candles on, which my granny also had. People would knock our door and off she would go armed with the necessary. After the funeral the dead person’s relatives had the things laundered and brought them back in the brown paper.

I remember the first time I saw a dead body as a little girl, I was a bit apprehensive and my granny said ‘well she never harmed you when she was alive, so she’ll not harm you now she’s dead!” in her usual no nonsense voice. It never worried me after that.

My mother did veto her when she wanted me to “learn how to do the bodies” when I was about 14, thank goodness 😅

My personal hope is that one day I go to sleep and just don’t wake up, then my family just send my body for a direct cremation.

BMW6 · 20/03/2023 23:31

Bloody English don't even do death in the "correct" way 🙄

Xrays · 20/03/2023 22:48

TheNefariousOrange · 20/03/2023 21:22

The idea of not existing terrifies me. I genuinely have panic attacks sometimes. I haven't got any plans or anything organised because I don't have any wishes.

What helped me was to realise I didn’t exist before I was born either. And that didn’t bother me. Neither will it matter when I die.

ÉireannachÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ · 20/03/2023 22:16

I think death is taboo because we have medicalised end of life care. Not too long ago it was normal for people to be cared for by their family and to die in their own beds at home. We have lost the practical knowledge of death and the ability to speak of it so it has become taboo to many.

ÉireannachÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ · 20/03/2023 22:02

Dacadactyl · 20/03/2023 21:49

I also think that having a Faith helps when dealing with death.

I agree. Faith is a comfort for many during life and death.

I have seen many people die. My dear grandfather was a devout Catholic. I was with him (as were his 7 children and 20 other grandchildren) as he passed. His last hours were filled with faith and peace; I will remember it for how that faith and calm would be his final, faith-filled witness to his family.

Tropicaliyes · 20/03/2023 22:01

My grandma died in 2016 and I was the only one close to her in such a large family. She was diagnosed with Dementia around 70 but it was slow progressing and didn’t seem to have much of an effect at that time. I remember asking her (since she inevitably was going to go soon) what she would want when she passes away and if she wanted to be repatriated. She made it clear she didn’t want to be cremated, or sea burial (as she recently learned about it), nor did she want to be repatriated since apparently on our island a lot of the cemeteries are on hills and get flooded causing all sorts of issues (that can’t be the case for the whole country though but 🤷🏽‍♀️ it was her wishes.

about a year before she died she was found to have bowel cancer (or indicators of it) so further testing was done. By this time her dementia went from 0 - 100 and she was forgetting what happened the previous day or even earlier in the same day! When her results came in she did have bowel cancer which had now spread to her lungs and throughout her body… apparently she didn’t even know as she kept forgetting she had it.

she was dead a few months later due to my mother taking her out of hospital as “they could do no more for her there than we could at home”. She wasn’t eating or drinking and couldn’t take her diabetes medication as she had forgotten how to swallow so ultimately I’m sure the dehydration killed her over anything else. She was given a morphine driver in her leg which I guess stopped her feeling pain and she passed in her sleep.

I asked if anyone knew her funeral wishes and everyone looked at me mortified like it was such a terrible thing to ask! My grandma specifically told me she would haunt us if she was cremated.. when I mentioned this again they were besides themselves as it never occurred to them to even ask their mother what she wanted and we had enough time to plan things out!

I tried speaking about death (specifically my own) growing up as I became sick as a child and nearly died once and was told I was being morbid. So as a result nobody in our family spoke about it full stop then dealt with the stress when the time came for my grandmas passing!

I have already told my partner my wishes when I die, spoke about it early on too, we are both open about it and don’t see it being a issue and will speak to our kids about it too! (P.S. I was raised Catholic and it made no difference).

when my grandma died I had a dream where she came to my house and knocked on my door.. she barely spoke but she was really ANGRY, I couldn’t tell if she was angry at me or just how the whole thing went down but I got the message loud and clear that she was mega pissed! I was the black sheep of the family so I had no say and was not even able to take a family role at the funeral and treated like a associate considering I was my grandmas favourite!

but never will I experience that again and know it was all because they think speaking of death was morbid even though she was sitting next door in her death bed waiting for the day/night to come.. nobody spoke a thing about it (she lived next door to my mum).

lipstickwoman · 20/03/2023 21:59

@VariantHela fear. They have their heads in the sand. When you have had family tragedy it's terrifying. Doesn't make it less essential of course. But hard to face up to.

VariantHela · 20/03/2023 21:51

I dont know the answe but I really wish someone would have the conversation with my parents (me and my siblings have, countless times) and they "Don't want to talk about it"

We have suffered a few tragic deaths in our family so really cannot understand why they won't sort it out, they are going to leave us in such a mess

Dacadactyl · 20/03/2023 21:49

ÉireannachÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ · 20/03/2023 21:46

I don't fear death. When the time comes I am certain I will embrace it. If I'm really honest, dare I say it....there's a part of me that looks forward to it. That's not because I'm suicidal- no! But I get to meet my maker; where He will welcome me home.

I also think that having a Faith helps when dealing with death.

ÉireannachÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ · 20/03/2023 21:46

I don't fear death. When the time comes I am certain I will embrace it. If I'm really honest, dare I say it....there's a part of me that looks forward to it. That's not because I'm suicidal- no! But I get to meet my maker; where He will welcome me home.

Raineth · 20/03/2023 21:35

It’s extremely helpful when people write down their funeral wishes, my friend was so miserable agonising over what music he thought his mum would have wanted

Also… TELL PEOPLE where the will is!! My family member supposedly died ‘intestate’ despite having always said they made a will. A not very nice person ended uo with all the money.

AlbertCampion · 20/03/2023 21:33

I had cancer a couple of years ago and when discussing treatment options with the consultant he brought up this programme called Predict and literally showed me the different probabilities for dying with each treatment plan. Actually having an open conversation about the possibility of death was so refreshing - everyone else had been pussyfooting around me but he just met it head on.