Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The death taboo in England.

186 replies

Fifi1010 · 20/03/2023 19:23

I did a training session on dying well and wow so many people are so uncomfortable with dying even mentioning it . I have a will and life insurance. I have informed my family of my current wishes and I have written this down. If I change my mind I will update it. I don't think of death a lot but I see it as inevitable and a transition.

It saddens me when people haven't done the planning so decisions are made in crisis when emotions are high and people might not get the end they would want. What could be done to ease the taboo of death?

OP posts:
Itsbytheby · 21/03/2023 15:58

Whiteroomjoy · 21/03/2023 15:56

It’s also because so few people see a person dying, especially at home. Death is medicalised now so much. Before the NHS most people couldn’t afford to have a loved one die in hospital, and a lot less conditions were treatable - even antibiotics weren’t readily available until ww2

so, we don’t experience death in our homes

and then during 1914-18 a whole generation of young men died - people had to talk about it then

imagine being someone like Charlotte Brontë- nursing sister after sister through TB at home, then an Alcoholic brother - sure would give rise to gothic literature and dark imagination

I watched my mother die (in a hospice). I can't say its an experience I would recommend widely. The fact people aren't dying at home because they can't afford hospital is - to me - at good development not a bad one (although I think people (the dying and their families) should be better supported in their end of life choices).

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 21/03/2023 15:57

Also we are very bad at stopping treatment when it blatantly obvious it should be stopped to allow the dying process to happen

Whiteroomjoy · 21/03/2023 15:56

Xrays · 20/03/2023 20:13

I wonder if as people are living longer a lot of people haven’t personally experienced death, and perhaps that makes it more taboo. I notice I’m quite unusual in my circles losing all my relatives before 40. Most people still have their parents, some even have grandparents alive. A few generations back death was more commonplace; well I mean it’s always happened (!) but experienced more by more people.

It’s also because so few people see a person dying, especially at home. Death is medicalised now so much. Before the NHS most people couldn’t afford to have a loved one die in hospital, and a lot less conditions were treatable - even antibiotics weren’t readily available until ww2

so, we don’t experience death in our homes

and then during 1914-18 a whole generation of young men died - people had to talk about it then

imagine being someone like Charlotte Brontë- nursing sister after sister through TB at home, then an Alcoholic brother - sure would give rise to gothic literature and dark imagination

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 21/03/2023 15:56

@mids2019 yes you are right although much of the time people choose to have all of the invasive treatment despite being told it would be not much use. For me personally I wouldn’t want all of the treatments many in my care opt for because I have seen how it can turn out

unfortunately dying at home doesn’t always guarantee a peaceful pain free death either, many people wish to die at home without taking into account the other people still living at home and how they will cope then when it gets to crisis point etc they end up dying in hospital or with very distressed family, many choose to die at home in the rural areas that we cover which can take more than 30 mins to get to which means they may be in pain for a length of time before we can get to them to administer breakthrough etc.

I sincerely hope that in my time things will be much more plainly put, we are very good at keeping people alive but with very little quality of life and often in very bad health this needs to change

mids2019 · 21/03/2023 15:36

@AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii

Agree with this. However I feel that for cancer treatment any benign mention of not going through a full radical treatment can be met with accusations ageism or 'letting the patient down'. There must be cases where radical radiotherapy is completely inappropriate and extremely distressing for a very frail patient get it still happens. It is often the fact with the extremely elderly that although you may have some tumour cuts at great cost the patient will die of a co morbidity. (This actually skews mortality audits for cancer treatments).

a hospital must be horrible environment to die in really. The equipment is set up for life preservation not easing the passing of life. I support therefore the use of local hospices (or home) as the best place for some ones final days or hours.

mids2019 · 21/03/2023 15:24

One thing I would avoid is denial prior to death in spite of a relative's declining health. I have seen some sad Facebook posts wishing a loved one a swift recovery when they have died the next day. I wonder if in some cases people are in utter denial about death through grief and can't mentally take in medical statements on health?

I think this chimes with a nurse on a course who told me that so many bad deaths occurred due to relatives wishing or at least not preventing invasive procedures at the end of life? Is it possible that we have a culture of medics viewing death as failure so instinctively in some cases trying everything to avoid the inevitable often pressured by family?

we should not view ourselves as fighting disease in our mid eighties but possibly as passive actors in what are the inevitable symptoms of death in reality.

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:52

I was thinking more of people who say they want to save their kids money and grief by having a direct cremation @Itsbytheby. Having arranged both my parents’ funerals - and found it cathartic- I’ve told our kids that they have a template and they can do what they like within it.

Itsbytheby · 21/03/2023 14:37

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:32

No need for guilt, particularly for arranging a funeral. Funerals are for the living, not the dead. I’m really sorry and don’t want to upset you but I think decreeing no funeral is monumentally selfish. It’s not as if you’re going to be there.

I don't think it was selfish in my mum's case, I think she was worried people wouldn't come and didn't want to burden me with having to arrange anything for her. Not letting my dad be involved was selfish though, she would rather that I had to cope with it alone than have my dad support me by helping because of the issues they had when they divorces (no abuse or cheating or anything as far as I know, she just really disliked him and was angry when he moved on).

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 21/03/2023 14:33

My great grandmother was a village midwife and ‘wise woman’ in very rural Northumberland at the turn of the last century. So she had a lot of experience at both ends of life, she delivered babies and laid out the dead.

Obviously I didn’t know her , but she was a powerful figure in my upbringing, through my Gran and mother’s tales of her. She dealt with suicides and murdered bodies, as well as the natural deaths. At that time, death in childbirth was unfortunately quite common, too.

So even though I have not had such direct experience, I was brought up knowing about death, and I suppose accepting it. I find the current attitude of ‘if you ignore it it will go away ‘ baffling. There was a thread on here where a child’s Guinea pig had died when they were on holiday, and the parents were scouring pet shops to try and find one which looked similar enough to fool the child into thinking it was the same.

This is not kind, really. Of course the child would be devastated for a while. But it is losing a valuable opportunity to cope with loss and sorrow, so that when the larger sorrows happen, you have some preparation.

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:32

Itsbytheby · 21/03/2023 13:58

I don't know really. I think it's relevant for end of life care, but the after bit is for those are are greiving in my opinion.

My mum died when I was relatively young - 23 - and told me some of her wishes. I went against them because it was best for those around her (e.g. she asked me to not let my dad be involved in her death at all, at 23 I couldnt' cope with it alone so asked him to help me, she asked not to have a funeral but many people were asking and expressing wanting to say goodbye so I did one, etc). I felt guilty for many years for "going against her wishes", but it was the only way I could deal with it at the time.

No need for guilt, particularly for arranging a funeral. Funerals are for the living, not the dead. I’m really sorry and don’t want to upset you but I think decreeing no funeral is monumentally selfish. It’s not as if you’re going to be there.

Itsbytheby · 21/03/2023 13:58

I don't know really. I think it's relevant for end of life care, but the after bit is for those are are greiving in my opinion.

My mum died when I was relatively young - 23 - and told me some of her wishes. I went against them because it was best for those around her (e.g. she asked me to not let my dad be involved in her death at all, at 23 I couldnt' cope with it alone so asked him to help me, she asked not to have a funeral but many people were asking and expressing wanting to say goodbye so I did one, etc). I felt guilty for many years for "going against her wishes", but it was the only way I could deal with it at the time.

aswellascanbeexpected · 21/03/2023 13:53

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 21/03/2023 13:51

@Neededanewuserhandle - that was exactly what my mum said. She was a Humanist, but she recognised that my sister and I might want a church funeral - dsis is very active in her local church, and would definitely prefer a church funeral - and said we should do what gave us comfort.

Her letter has made things much easier for us, in the past few days.

Neededanewuserhandle · 21/03/2023 13:32

SixPenny · 21/03/2023 07:37

People need to grow up because death comes to us all, it's unavoidable.
How is anyone to know what the wishes of the deceased were for their funeral for example, if they never spoke of it.
If you try to discuss it you get ' oh don't be so macabre ' and shit like that.
Fine, I'll just dump you down the local household waste site then shall I.

You can dump me in the local waste site if you like. I am not such a bighead as to want to dictate what happens at my funeral - I won't be there, so people can run it however they want.

Dacadactyl · 21/03/2023 13:19

Neededanewuserhandle · 21/03/2023 11:33

I am fed up of being told off about my apparent attitude to death as an Englsih person.

No one is telling anyone off, lol.

Just that if you're from a family where (by virtue of immigration) you get to see another culture's attitude to it...you are in a position to compare and contrast.

cupofteaandabiccyplease · 21/03/2023 12:49

I don't want to live into old age and be a burden to dc and expense to the nhs.
The dc know I'm going to end my life if I felt I was becoming reliant on others or had a medical condition which will become worse.
We've always been open about dying and death so they have grown up with it. They accept and respect my wishes as does dh. It is freeing and I have control to a degree over my life's end.

Neededanewuserhandle · 21/03/2023 11:33

I am fed up of being told off about my apparent attitude to death as an Englsih person.

Fifi1010 · 21/03/2023 08:21

There's also the thing of advanced care planning. If I had an accident it's not just for illness. I love my DH and my DF but chances are they wouldn't want to let me go even if had a terrible quality of life. Which is something I personally wouldn't want. By avoiding the conversation or planning you are handing over all the power to your relatives and you have to hope they do the right thing by you.

OP posts:
KnittingNeedles · 21/03/2023 08:12

Oh I hear you @JacobsCrackersCheeseFogg about the “script”. We live in a small village, everyone knows dad has been unwell and is in hospital. So many people have stopped us in the shop or street and asked how he’s doing and said “if there’s anything we can do” and I think about 2 of them really meant it.

Dacadactyl · 21/03/2023 07:53

containsnuts · 21/03/2023 07:47

"Neighbours, friends, relatives, the whole community all go to the funeral and wake. It's not shied away from. Lots of open caskets, the body at home etc.

If you've been brought up in England with an English culture around death, I think its different to being brought up in England with an Irish culture around death."

I think those two things should be separated in discussions. I think it's good to talk about the persons wishes, what will happen to assets, and how the person would like to be remembered without the pressure to watch the actual death, view the body, or have the body at home which is maybe what puts some people off thinking about it.

Yes and that's fair enough, but what I mean about the Irish culture around death is that people are USED to doing these things from an early age. There is less of a taboo around it (eg there would be absolutely no discussion in my family as to whether a baby, or toddler, or 4 year old, or 10 year old would attend a funeral, or even see a dead body...trauma deaths and limited circumstances excepted)

I would argue that their attitude towards all of it comes from the fact that these sort of things are the done thing.

containsnuts · 21/03/2023 07:47

"Neighbours, friends, relatives, the whole community all go to the funeral and wake. It's not shied away from. Lots of open caskets, the body at home etc.

If you've been brought up in England with an English culture around death, I think its different to being brought up in England with an Irish culture around death."

I think those two things should be separated in discussions. I think it's good to talk about the persons wishes, what will happen to assets, and how the person would like to be remembered without the pressure to watch the actual death, view the body, or have the body at home which is maybe what puts some people off thinking about it.

Xrays · 21/03/2023 07:45

JacobsCrackersCheeseFogg · 21/03/2023 06:18

Our family is recently bereaved but unfortunately we are experiencing delays disposing of the body because the case is with the coroner and police.

My mother doesn't like the way my husband and I speak about death. She's not religious and has planned & paid for her funeral. She believes her body should be revered because it represents her in life.

We are of a different view. Once the person has died, that's it, they're gone. We don't believe the body needs to be treated with respect, it's just remnants of the person who has died. Our family member said he didn't care how we got rid of their body, they will be dead. We don't subscribe to all the usual rites. We just want to be able to get the death certificate, resolve their personal business, and move on.

We would prefer not to have a funeral because all the people who didn't bother staying in touch during their life suddenly come out of the woodwork and claiming how sad they are. Ghouls, all of them. Pretenders. They didn't make the effort when they were alive, why bother if they're dead? A free drink and sausage roll, probably. Our family member didn't have any money so they'll be disappointed in that regard.

My husband also complains about The Script: "Oh I'm so sorry for your loss. Let me know if there's anything we can do, ok?" Yes, please stop being so fake and foxtrot Oscar. They aren't being genuine, they just say it to be polite.

I want a direct cremation. The crematorium can throw my ashes in the bin because I won't care through being dead. My husband wants to be donated to medical science. We are both ardent atheists who are entirely practical about these matters.

I'm grieving so I hope people aren't too offended by my comments.

This is exactly how we feel as a family too. We had a direct cremation for my Mum and dh and I will have the same. It was amazing how many people were angry with us doing that and came out of the woodwork after 20 odd years of not seeing her or contacting her to say how upset they were that there was no funeral. 🙄 Utterly ridiculous. Even my Dad who had treated her terribly and had been divorced from her (and remarried for 25 years) suddenly wanted to turn up to her funeral. Errrr nope. If you couldn’t be bothered with someone in life you don’t get to turn up when they’re dead.

SixPenny · 21/03/2023 07:37

People need to grow up because death comes to us all, it's unavoidable.
How is anyone to know what the wishes of the deceased were for their funeral for example, if they never spoke of it.
If you try to discuss it you get ' oh don't be so macabre ' and shit like that.
Fine, I'll just dump you down the local household waste site then shall I.

Dacadactyl · 21/03/2023 07:31

SoShallINever · 21/03/2023 00:30

Really? In my experience of my huge Irish clan, they are quite obsessed with death in a proper miserable way. The talk always turns to who is sick and dying, who is bereaved. Lots of heaven and hell stuff. I find it suffocating.
I have no problem accepting death, I just don't want it in the next room at every conversation.

I mean they are open about it in a way that the English are not.

Neighbours, friends, relatives, the whole community all go to the funeral and wake. It's not shied away from. Lots of open caskets, the body at home etc.

If you've been brought up in England with an English culture around death, I think its different to being brought up in England with an Irish culture around death.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 21/03/2023 07:26

I work in healthcare in community nursing so death does not phase me what so ever, in fact i see many people being kept alive in some horrible states, no quality of life, or dying from cancer where we just can’t get on top of their pain or anxiety and to me that is far worse then death.

In elderly people we need to have far more frank conversations with people and their families as healthcare professionals, be more honest about pro and con of treatment, yes we can give you some treatment for that cancer but it will likely make you poorly and have little quality of life for the few extra months it might give you im talking about people in their 80s who want everything done, if it was me I’d rather not have the treatment and have a few months where I feel well enough to go out with friends or family etc