Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The death taboo in England.

186 replies

Fifi1010 · 20/03/2023 19:23

I did a training session on dying well and wow so many people are so uncomfortable with dying even mentioning it . I have a will and life insurance. I have informed my family of my current wishes and I have written this down. If I change my mind I will update it. I don't think of death a lot but I see it as inevitable and a transition.

It saddens me when people haven't done the planning so decisions are made in crisis when emotions are high and people might not get the end they would want. What could be done to ease the taboo of death?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Itsbytheby · 24/03/2023 09:55

The thing is that death is such a normal part of life. Everyone dies. This means every knows someone who dies. It should be talked about, because it's hard enough as it is without the taboo and silence. I talk to my children openly about death for this reason.

EmmaEmerald · 24/03/2023 00:06

STDG - that's what I mean though. I can see why chatting with loved ones might be a good idea, but the whole idea of talking more about death is fraught with problems, as the language example shows.

I've just refrained from commenting on another thread about death. I began typing and realised what I was going to say might be offensive, so kept quiet.

Mollymalone123 · 22/03/2023 20:30

@MNDislimiting What a wonderful family you have by the sounds of it 💐 hugs to you

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 22/03/2023 19:23

EmmaEmerald · 21/03/2023 22:44

STDG "My worry is - unless I know ahead of time that a person hates the euphemisms or the direct words, there is always a risk of causing more hurt at an already difficult time. It’s a minefield."

Another excellent reason not to talk about death unless you have to.

I explained upthread my reason for saying dad "Passed away". It's amazing to me that anyone could find that offensive. I tend to take my lead from whoever has the loss but honestly, the minefield is very off putting.

That isn’t really what I was saying, though, @EmmaEmerald - I was addressing the specific side issue of using direct language versus euphemisms.

Death comes to us all, and it is always a difficult time, with emotions running high, and amidst all that, it can be very difficult to make all the decisions involved in planning a funeral and maybe clearing out a home. Speaking from experience, knowing what my mum wanted has made things that bit easier.

You said “Another excellent reason not to talk about death unless you have to” - but sadly we don’t always know that death is near - it can happen very suddenly. My dad died very suddenly - he was 72 but in pretty good health, all things considered, and whilst he had been under the weather with a nasty cold in the week or so before he died, he was never ill enough for mum to think she should make him see the GP. He literally collapsed one morning and died at home despite the neighbour’s best efforts at CPR.

So we had to cope with the trauma of his sudden death, and try to support mum who was devastated, and try to make all the arrangements.

When my lovely MIL was terminally ill with cancer, we knew the end was near, so we had the conversation with her about what she wanted for her funeral, and again, it did make things easier - I guess that was the sort of circumstance you were referring to as when you ’have’ to talk about death.

As I said earlier, my mum wrote us a letter with her thoughts on her funeral etc, and sent it to dsis and me - that is a way of avoiding the conversation, if it is too uncomfortable.

Blossomtoes · 22/03/2023 17:07

My dad’s was the same @WestwardHo1. I was so pleased when my cousin said to me “Uncle Jim would have really liked this”.

Dacadactyl · 22/03/2023 16:49

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius Thank you.

WestwardHo1 · 22/03/2023 14:03

mumda · 21/03/2023 00:03

I think we should be more honest about the insane cost of funerals. Thousands of pounds wasted on an event that no one wants to remember.

My dad's funeral was beautiful - it was a lovely way to end his life after a sad struggle with dementia. We had music, we had singing, we had chatting, reminisces, we had eulogies, we saw relatives and friends we hadn't seen for years. In fact, my only complaint was that he wasn't there to enjoy it - he'd have loved it. I am so glad we did it like that.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 22/03/2023 13:31

@Dacadactyl - my understanding of Medical Power of Attorney is that it has to be triggered when the person is no longer capable of making their own medical decisions - until that point, it is on file. So when the doctors say that the person can't make their own decisions, you get in touch with the Office of the Public Guardian, and they set the power of attorney going, so you can then make decisions for them.

So unless you had power of attorney already triggered, if your relative suddenly went down hill - eg. had a severe stroke - you would have to trigger the power of attorney before you could tell the medical profession not to resuscitate them.

However, an individual can state, ahead of time, that they do not want to be resuscitated - and it is my understanding that, once they have registered this, they keep the paperwork with them, and if they are taken ill, they take it with them and hand it to the hospital staff or paramedics.

Unfortunately the information doesn't always get passed on - my mum had a DNR order, but either it wasn't on her notes sufficiently prominently, and the hospital missed it, or it was at mum's home, and the carer who found her didn't know about it, so didn't give it to the paramedics, and my sister didn't realise she needed to let the hospital know, so when mum went into cardiac arrest, they did try to resuscitate her. They didn't succeed, and dsis and I are not going to make a fuss about it, because it was human error, and we understand how that can happen - but if they had managed to revive her, it would only have prolonged her suffering.

FarmGirl78 · 22/03/2023 08:31

My poor Mum has recently had to sort 3 lots of probate out over the past couple of years, and also had to take over finances of another existing relative who had to go into care with dementia at short notice. This spured my Dad on to get Power of Attorney sorted for both of them, and my Dad finally got round to writing his will.

Wanting to make sure that both me and my brother (as joint executors) understood the will, we held a "(proof)reading of the will" evening where we sat with my Parents, a bucket of KFC, and made sure we all understood the technicalities, reasons behind my Dad's decisions, possible issues if Mum died first, etc etc. A very humour filled, thought provoking evening. Dad changed a few things as a result of the conversation, some things he's still pondering and we all understand it. There were a few "well hang on, if Mum goes first that would mean...." conversations, which some families might find bizarre but my family is known for being remarkably open about these things.

For as long as I can remember, and I mean maybe 8 years old, we've always known to bury Dad in an banana box rather than an expensive coffin, and if we ever wake up one morning to find him dead in bed we are to somehow get him in the car and take him into town and throw his body under a bus as his life insurance would pay out more if he death was the result of an accident. If Dad goes first I'll need a week off work to console Mum, dry tears, offer support and comfort her. She will spend the rest of her life worrying unnecessarily about money and never spending anything of their hard earned money. Dad says she'll be sitting in a decrepid house with rain coming in and water running down the walls with thousands and thousands in the bank. If Mum goes first I'll need a day off work because I'll have to teach Dad how to use the washing machine. He's also said he'll want a new hoover, because he reckons it'll be easier to hoover up all the g-strings and nipple tassles that the strippers have left strewn round the living room. And I'll have to order him a new recycling bin from the council for all the pizza boxes.

There is humour still to be found in these circumstances. My poor boyfriend is horrified how we laugh about some things, but equally wishes his family could be the same because every time he tries to ask his parents if their wishes have been recorded, or things are sufficiently taken care of, they swiftly change the subject with disparaging tones of voices.

KnittingNeedles · 22/03/2023 08:01

Having just been through this, dads death was handled very compassionately by staff. When it became clear he was not going to survive, we had a very frank but kind discussion with a palliative care consultant who arranged medication to make him comfortable and withdrew other intervention like drips and injections, they even stopped monitoring blood pressure and temperature to allow him to rest quietly. By the end he was doped to the eyeballs and very comfortable. We had agreed to a DNR when he was initially admitted to hospital because of his age and other health issues.

PermanentTemporary · 22/03/2023 08:01

I work with very elderly people and at a hospice, and my dh and dad have died in the last few years. I feel surrounded by death sometimes.

My mother's family is perhaps unusual in that we talk about death a LOT, my father's family hardly at all. We all felt we knew exactly what was right for his funeral though. And funerals really can matter. My dh took his own life and the funeral was the most healing event possible. I was a control freak about it and it was exactly the way I wanted it. Dh would have thought nobody would want to be there and nobody would miss him - if he'd written his wishes it would be to be tipped into a black hole. I'm glad he didn't write them down. As it was we had a packed hall, lots and lots of happy loving memories, his whole personality and not just his illness.

Likewise I went to a friend's funeral last year, he died from one of the most awful progressive diseases you can imagine and he had time to plan his own funeral down to the last tee. It was one of the most painful events I have ever been to and I'm afraid it was about half an hour too long. I have deliberately not put too many specifics in my letter to my executors - basically a couple of suggestions re music and readings I like, and disposal ideas, but I give them free rein.

Mateyduck · 22/03/2023 07:41

IMO we are obsessed with keeping people alive at any cost, like quality of life doesn’t matter just keep them alive: I have see poor souls in pain, in bed unable to move and just out of it, having tablets poured down their throat because we have to keep them here. I think it’s sad and there is no dignity in forcing people to live when they no longer want to be here. It’s tragic.
My father in law is very weak, very frail and can’t do anything now - yet there is still talk about a bladder operation to shave down the Timor even though he will be in so much pain after and have the recovery of it all. He doesn’t want it, but no one will listen .

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 22/03/2023 07:36

@Dacadactyl that’s what I had said in my post, I work in nursing and know we are far too good at keeping people alive in poor health now, a victim of its own success.

yes proper conversations are often not had, families don’t know what to expect or that realistically they wouldn’t get much longer even with treatment and even if they do get a little bit more time they’ll likely be unwell the entire time. Going back to those dying at home families often don’t understand the dying process e.g. not eating anymore, losing interest in things they’d usually take interest in, bowels not moving etc and demand we do something about it, it is then left to us as community nurses to explain all of this which it shouldn’t be

Dacadactyl · 22/03/2023 06:55

Fifi1010 · 21/03/2023 23:22

I'm not actually talking about funerals really. I don't have any particular wishes for a funeral as I won't be here. I'm talking if I lost capacity to make decisions about my care and life sustaining treatment. If I had a life changing accident for instance. I know I probably wouldn't want to live if I had a poor quality of life and I was distressed. I would rather be let go, families often want to hold on even if life for the person is crap.

I think some things are worse than death. I have done advanced care planning as my work has made me more aware that people have accidents/ life changing illnesses every day.

I have told my husband that I'd rather not be kept alive by machines if I am "not here" mentally. However, I can tell he is uncomfortable thinking about it and wonder whether he'd actually be able to say "that's it, let her go now" to medical professionals.

I also think doctors and nurses are keen to "fix" things and maybe don't have the right words/training to advise families in these situations. Of course, some people just want their relative alive at all costs, but I am not sure family always understand what that will actually look like.

When my nan died, it was a very slow decline over 5 years. When she first had a stroke, she was mid-80s and had been very fit and healthy up to that point. But I do wonder why they didn't let her go at that point...how much longer was she realistically going to have?! Maybe she needed a DNAR in place at that point before they could legally not try, I'm not sure of the ins and outs of it tbh. But seeing her decline was unpleasant and she'd have been better off gone in that instant from the stroke than declining over time.

Does anyone know if that is allowed, or would she have needed a DNAR before they're not allowed to try? Would family have a say if they had medical power of attorney?

wheresmymojo · 22/03/2023 06:45

I've specified a few things...

One is the song to be played as the curtains close around my coffin for the cremation....

It's Nelly, Hot in Here

"It's getting hot in here, so take off all my clothes...I am getting so hot, I wanna take my clothes off..."

Genuinely this is what I want...And it does somewhat fit with my personality in life

MNDislimiting · 22/03/2023 00:42

I have a slightly different perspective on dying. I was diagnosed with Motor Neurone Disease nearly five years ago. I’ve had all this time, watching my body slowly declining, to think about what the end will look like.

At this point I have lost the use of my legs, my arms are just barely able to move, and I am starting to have trouble breathing. I am completely dependent on my husband and caregivers to feed me, bathe me, dress me, and put me on the toilet. I can do absolutely nothing for myself.

Fortunately, I live in Canada. Because of my diagnosis, I can have a medically assisted death so I’m not forced to live with no quality of life until I finally die of something. I get a choice!

There have been many conversations with family so they know how I feel. They all understand that this is my decision to make and are mostly supportive. Even the grandchildren are aware that grandma is poorly and will die. And I’m very thankful that we’ve all been able speak openly about the subject.

Fifi1010 · 21/03/2023 23:22

OneThrillingCombination · 21/03/2023 20:28

@Fifi1010 its interesting, I see it the other way round. Funerals, wakes, coffins etc aren’t important to the person who has died since they are dead. I feel like they are there for those left behind to say goodbye in the way that feels best to them at the time, therefore they should be able to decide on what they want.

I'm not actually talking about funerals really. I don't have any particular wishes for a funeral as I won't be here. I'm talking if I lost capacity to make decisions about my care and life sustaining treatment. If I had a life changing accident for instance. I know I probably wouldn't want to live if I had a poor quality of life and I was distressed. I would rather be let go, families often want to hold on even if life for the person is crap.

I think some things are worse than death. I have done advanced care planning as my work has made me more aware that people have accidents/ life changing illnesses every day.

OP posts:
EmmaEmerald · 21/03/2023 22:44

STDG "My worry is - unless I know ahead of time that a person hates the euphemisms or the direct words, there is always a risk of causing more hurt at an already difficult time. It’s a minefield."

Another excellent reason not to talk about death unless you have to.

I explained upthread my reason for saying dad "Passed away". It's amazing to me that anyone could find that offensive. I tend to take my lead from whoever has the loss but honestly, the minefield is very off putting.

aswellascanbeexpected · 21/03/2023 22:39

You are right @Dacadactyl that’s what I meant, for some people of faith the thought of ‘passing on’ may be a comfort.
For me, however, when my DH died suddenly last year I very clearly told everyone (and still do) that he is dead.
And as a person of no faith, I sort of believe in physics in that he’s here in the same way that everything from the Big Bang onwards is still here.
Having said that my understanding of physics is very sketchy!

KnittingNeedles · 21/03/2023 22:36

We are currently dealing with a death in the immediate family. When I am informing people I am not telling them that my dad has "passed" or "gone to heaven" or any of the other euphemisms. He has died and that is the long and short of it. Yes it's ugly and yes it's difficult but really, when you're the person who is bereaved and grieving, using nicey-nicey language does nothing to make things any better. So just don't.

Also I am so, so glad that my dad was organised and both he and my mum have taken time to think about what they wanted and organised it. They both have a funeral plan - named an undertaker, written down what they wanted for a service, even down to the music they want and the charity they wish to ask for donations for. This is taking such an enormous load off me and my siblings as we are not second guessing "what dad would've wanted" because it's all there in black and white.

Mollymalone123 · 21/03/2023 22:30

@Sunsetintheeast and @ÉireannachÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ
thank you both xx

ÉireannachÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ · 21/03/2023 22:02

😔is it not Molly? I am sending you a big hug if you want it.

I will keep you in my prayers. I hope you don't mind.
🙏May your pain cease,
Your strength increase,
And your fears be released!

Love to you @Mollymalone123

Itsbytheby · 21/03/2023 21:45

Dacadactyl · 21/03/2023 21:37

Yes but any religious person would be wise not to use phrases like "divine purpose" etc unless they knew with absolute certainty how their comments would be received. And even then, given the nature of grief, it would be wise to steer clear of this sort of talk in the aftermath because death can shake a person's faith.

In any event, thats not what the poster was saying. As i understand it, she meant that she now sees why people sometimes use the phrase "passing on" when they are religious, given that they believe the person is going elsewhere. But plenty of non religious people use the phrase "passed away" because it sounds less blunt than "died" or "dead".

Yes I know why people use it. I just don't that it's religious contet makes it any better. I meant general "you", not pp.

And while I'd agree they'd be wise not to people of faith to mention divine purpose, they say that sort of thing all the time "she's in a better place now", "she'll find peace with god", etc about dying. I know they are intending to offer comfort, but at least to me it has exactly the opposite impact and I was really cross they were using their religious agenda to somehow minimise the grief I was feeling. Oh yeah, I am real grateful I have lost my mum to a god I don't believe in, and a heaven I don't think exists, chin up! 🙄

Sunsetintheeast · 21/03/2023 21:37

I agree @Mollymalone123 I hope you don’t face our inevitable too soon.

Dacadactyl · 21/03/2023 21:37

Itsbytheby · 21/03/2023 21:18

See I found "people of faith" putting their religious spin on the death of my loved ones extremely offensive when both my grandparents and my mother died. This idea that they died "for a reason", "to go to a better place", like I ought somehow to be grateful for their deaths because they were with god now, or because there was some kind of devine purpose behind it, gave me the absolute rage. How dare you suggest that it's actually all fine and dandy and I shouldn't really be so upset that I've lost my mum because she is in your [to me] made up "heaven" now which apparently is just great for her. In my grief it was probably one of the worst thing people could say to me, as not a person of faith.

Yes but any religious person would be wise not to use phrases like "divine purpose" etc unless they knew with absolute certainty how their comments would be received. And even then, given the nature of grief, it would be wise to steer clear of this sort of talk in the aftermath because death can shake a person's faith.

In any event, thats not what the poster was saying. As i understand it, she meant that she now sees why people sometimes use the phrase "passing on" when they are religious, given that they believe the person is going elsewhere. But plenty of non religious people use the phrase "passed away" because it sounds less blunt than "died" or "dead".