Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be some kind of national reflection on the pandemic?

470 replies

23rdmarch2020 · 20/03/2023 18:46

It’s coming up to three years since the first lockdown. In many ways, it feels an absolute age ago. From personal experience, my life completely changed in the space of a week and so many things happened in my life that never would have because of the pandemic (some good, some bad). For some, it has been an absolute tragedy. In the space of a few weeks we went from being in our normal lives to it being a criminal offence to step outside our homes without a valid excuse. Obviously people are keen to move on but AIBU to think there should be more reflection on the pandemic than there has been?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
DemiColon · 23/03/2023 14:13

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 23/03/2023 13:29

We didn't, and I think it's a significant failing that we never had a government or really any leading politicians of any stripe who were willing to say to the public, these lockdowns that are being implemented in some other countries are utterly untested, we know they carry substantial risks in themselves and we have existing pandemic planning already which this very much is not.

That said, I think there were influences way beyond the UK here and am not sure any leadership could've done anything other than lock down by this time three years ago. I appreciate that not all Western countries did it but nearly all of them did, and we had a populist right wing government in Westminster with a leaderless opposition.

That was kind of what Boris said at the beginning.

And similarly, they started out in many countries with scientific advice about distancing and masking. THen after a few weeks, it was all crazy with no rhyme nor reason.

I can kind of see why some people went in for conspiracy theories, it was actually pretty bizarre.

DemiColon · 23/03/2023 14:09

MarshaBradyo · 23/03/2023 12:17

I’ve been around some behaviour change stuff and found it interesting. The success of the Covid campaign was incredible to me, the daily case number and death count was hugely effective.

I can’t think of another behaviour change programme that has been so impactful on people.

There are downsides to this though. We overlooked the damage and it went on too long to be the right approach.

And of course the case numbers had no context. Most people had no idea how many people normally die, how many people in care homes normally die, what the numbers for other causes of death include, or anything like that.

But the level of fear they created has impacted a lot of people long term in terms of their mental health, they've become completely unhinged around disease, cleaning, going into public. The level of anxiety it's produced isn't insignificant.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 23/03/2023 13:29

MarshaBradyo · 23/03/2023 13:03

Although we didn’t have much of a chance to make informed decisions

Belted at with fear tactics. If it had been ok here’s your personal risk, the damage of removing dc from school or closing sectors, the economic repercussions what do you want to happen

The public demand would have changed

We didn't, and I think it's a significant failing that we never had a government or really any leading politicians of any stripe who were willing to say to the public, these lockdowns that are being implemented in some other countries are utterly untested, we know they carry substantial risks in themselves and we have existing pandemic planning already which this very much is not.

That said, I think there were influences way beyond the UK here and am not sure any leadership could've done anything other than lock down by this time three years ago. I appreciate that not all Western countries did it but nearly all of them did, and we had a populist right wing government in Westminster with a leaderless opposition.

MarshaBradyo · 23/03/2023 13:03

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 23/03/2023 12:44

Politics.

Which to be fair is the reason for every single decision made during the pandemic, implementing restrictions and lifting them, the ones people liked and the ones they didn't. It was all political.

Although we didn’t have much of a chance to make informed decisions

Belted at with fear tactics. If it had been ok here’s your personal risk, the damage of removing dc from school or closing sectors, the economic repercussions what do you want to happen

The public demand would have changed

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 23/03/2023 12:44

Buzzinwithbez · 23/03/2023 11:30

I thought three weeks to take stock of where we were seemed sensible.
I did not expect to suddenly be cut off from family and friends. I expected things outdoors to continue and people to work from home where possible. I didn't expect partners who didn't live together being unable to spend any time together. What we got went above and beyond what I imagined and possibly what lots of people imagined.

It's been an eye opener on investigating people's assertions that we didn't have a plan, to see that we did in fact have a long standing plan for a virus that would be caught in a short space of time by 50 percent of the population and that had a fatality rate of up to 2.5 percent.
Why were we never told about the plan? Why were disaster planners screaming into a heavily censored void that we had a plan?
It was clear in the early days, the Diamond Princess being an excellent closed model what we were dealing with. Even in a population that was elderly and likely had more co-morbidities we didn't have anything like as worrying as what had been planned for. We also quickly knew more about demographics, age groups etc. So why did the plan go out the window?

Politics.

Which to be fair is the reason for every single decision made during the pandemic, implementing restrictions and lifting them, the ones people liked and the ones they didn't. It was all political.

Buzzinwithbez · 23/03/2023 12:27

New York times 21st March 23

"We now know that the extra cleaning was unlikely to have helped limit the spread of Covid-19, but it did increase people’s exposure to the chemicals used in those products — some of which may be hazardous to health. Experts worry that repeated inhalation or skin contact can be harmful over time. Calls to poison control centers about cleaning chemicals also increased during the pandemic, primarily for accidental or intentional ingestion."

Goes on to mention cancer, asthma and infertility.

MarshaBradyo · 23/03/2023 12:17

Buzzinwithbez · 23/03/2023 12:05

Yes -BMJ "The UK government’s attempt to frighten people into covid protective behaviours was at odds with its scientific advice"

https://www.bmj.com/content/380/bmj.p652

Except at least two of the authors seem to have forgotten they were on the advisory boards

I’ve been around some behaviour change stuff and found it interesting. The success of the Covid campaign was incredible to me, the daily case number and death count was hugely effective.

I can’t think of another behaviour change programme that has been so impactful on people.

There are downsides to this though. We overlooked the damage and it went on too long to be the right approach.

lazycats · 23/03/2023 12:14

Delatron · 23/03/2023 12:01

Yes people were basing their support of lockdowns on the fear-mongering and false modelling from the government.

People were terrified! Washing shopping, barely leaving the house. Where did that fear come from? The government.

Many worlplaces closed days before the government mandated lockdown. The fear was there already. Then the death count kept being terrible for months.

My memory of it all was a general resignation, not fear. Most people intially found it novel, then boring. Then annoying.

Buzzinwithbez · 23/03/2023 12:05

MarshaBradyo · 23/03/2023 11:47

This sounds better to me.

re lockdowns being popular in pp yes it’s no surprise as the campaigning was heavily skewed towards fear response. It was not indicating damage from restrictions.

It was highly effective but whether it was the right approach is the question.

Yes -BMJ "The UK government’s attempt to frighten people into covid protective behaviours was at odds with its scientific advice"

https://www.bmj.com/content/380/bmj.p652

Except at least two of the authors seem to have forgotten they were on the advisory boards

The UK government’s attempt to frighten people into covid protective behaviours was at odds with its scientific advice

The scientific literature shows that fear is generally an ineffective way of persuading people to engage in health protective behaviours Among the many revelations from recent leaked UK Government WhatsApp messages published by The Daily Telegraph is...

https://www.bmj.com/content/380/bmj.p652

Delatron · 23/03/2023 12:01

Yes people were basing their support of lockdowns on the fear-mongering and false modelling from the government.

People were terrified! Washing shopping, barely leaving the house. Where did that fear come from? The government.

MarshaBradyo · 23/03/2023 11:47

Delatron · 23/03/2023 11:08

Yea Sweden have completed their review and their main failings were not protecting the care homes and that has been admitted.

I think people over there were given the information and then made their own decisions based on personal risk. So vulnerable, elderly people probably wouldn’t have been out and about. Lots of people would have worked from home. But they kept children in school. They considered the mental health impact of lockdowns (especially on the young . They considered the economic impact.

This sounds better to me.

re lockdowns being popular in pp yes it’s no surprise as the campaigning was heavily skewed towards fear response. It was not indicating damage from restrictions.

It was highly effective but whether it was the right approach is the question.

lazycats · 23/03/2023 11:44

GreekDogRescue · 23/03/2023 10:04

Interesting how so many are now anti lockdown.

even arch bedwetter-in-chief Rachael Johnson who demanded that alcohol be banned as it encourages people not to socially distance, now claims to have been anti lockdown all the time.

just wish more of you had had the courage to speak up at the time but many were calling for even harsher lockdowns and calling those of us who protested ‘granny killers’ and ‘conspiracy theorists’.

I guess we are all anti lockdowners now.

I think the UK handled covid pretty badly but I do accept that every country was making it up as they went along. As far as lockdowns go I think there's a bit of a suvivorship bias going on right now that sweeps way too many counterfactuals (ie. how bad it would have been if there weren't restrictions) under the rug. But that doesn't mean some weren't still over the top.

There's no doubt if something like covid happens again that lockdowns won't be as severe or long-lasting. It'd be politically impossible and we simply couldn't afford it. But they were popular at the time, and stayed suprisingly popular until they stopped.

Buzzinwithbez · 23/03/2023 11:30

GreekDogRescue · 23/03/2023 10:04

Interesting how so many are now anti lockdown.

even arch bedwetter-in-chief Rachael Johnson who demanded that alcohol be banned as it encourages people not to socially distance, now claims to have been anti lockdown all the time.

just wish more of you had had the courage to speak up at the time but many were calling for even harsher lockdowns and calling those of us who protested ‘granny killers’ and ‘conspiracy theorists’.

I guess we are all anti lockdowners now.

I thought three weeks to take stock of where we were seemed sensible.
I did not expect to suddenly be cut off from family and friends. I expected things outdoors to continue and people to work from home where possible. I didn't expect partners who didn't live together being unable to spend any time together. What we got went above and beyond what I imagined and possibly what lots of people imagined.

It's been an eye opener on investigating people's assertions that we didn't have a plan, to see that we did in fact have a long standing plan for a virus that would be caught in a short space of time by 50 percent of the population and that had a fatality rate of up to 2.5 percent.
Why were we never told about the plan? Why were disaster planners screaming into a heavily censored void that we had a plan?
It was clear in the early days, the Diamond Princess being an excellent closed model what we were dealing with. Even in a population that was elderly and likely had more co-morbidities we didn't have anything like as worrying as what had been planned for. We also quickly knew more about demographics, age groups etc. So why did the plan go out the window?

Delatron · 23/03/2023 11:08

Yea Sweden have completed their review and their main failings were not protecting the care homes and that has been admitted.

I think people over there were given the information and then made their own decisions based on personal risk. So vulnerable, elderly people probably wouldn’t have been out and about. Lots of people would have worked from home. But they kept children in school. They considered the mental health impact of lockdowns (especially on the young . They considered the economic impact.

Crikeyalmighty · 23/03/2023 11:01

We went to Sweden a fair few times in 2021 and 2022 because we were living in Copenhagen. I thought from the start their approach made more sense, although they too got it wrong initially with care homes and elderly. Thing is with Sweden I find them a very pragmatic and thoughtful people (certainly the ones I've met) and they are shit hot on science . The idea though that everyone was out and about as normal isn't quite right - places were certainly not in full flow, but more personal choice was in the mix- along with support . If I dare say it though I think on the whole they are a healthier population and I saw far fewer feral idiots about - it does have some problems that have been reported but having been there it seems very contained within certain areas-

shrimp88 · 23/03/2023 10:23

GreekDogRescue · 23/03/2023 10:04

Interesting how so many are now anti lockdown.

even arch bedwetter-in-chief Rachael Johnson who demanded that alcohol be banned as it encourages people not to socially distance, now claims to have been anti lockdown all the time.

just wish more of you had had the courage to speak up at the time but many were calling for even harsher lockdowns and calling those of us who protested ‘granny killers’ and ‘conspiracy theorists’.

I guess we are all anti lockdowners now.

What makes you think people have changed their mind? There were many people on MN against lockdown at the time and they are probably the ones saying they are against it now. I personally wasn't anti lockdown and still am not although some of the rules were draconian/ridiculous (but I thought that at the time too so haven't changed my mind)

GreekDogRescue · 23/03/2023 10:04

Interesting how so many are now anti lockdown.

even arch bedwetter-in-chief Rachael Johnson who demanded that alcohol be banned as it encourages people not to socially distance, now claims to have been anti lockdown all the time.

just wish more of you had had the courage to speak up at the time but many were calling for even harsher lockdowns and calling those of us who protested ‘granny killers’ and ‘conspiracy theorists’.

I guess we are all anti lockdowners now.

Zebedee55 · 23/03/2023 09:41

No, my Dad had to die alone in a care home (on the day that Johnson held his garden party), and the guilt of not being able to be there, at the end, tore me up.🙁. I hated having to do a silly little funeral, all sitting apart.

I resented being told to shield (I didn't, I just followed the general rules), and I resented the oppressive atmosphere of neighbours policing people, the police going barmy at times with their new powers, and all the rest of it. And I missed seeing the family.

But, it's done, and after Partygate, I don't imagine anyone would allow themselves to be locked down again.🙄

Time to move on now.

DemiColon · 23/03/2023 09:29

And just to note: it seems to me like you guys in the UK are doing a little better than we are in Canada at looking back and analyzing things. You still will not see anything like this published in the mainstream media here.

DemiColon · 23/03/2023 09:27

I'm not in the UK, I'm in an Canada where the lockdowns and other measures were similar but stricter and went on for longer.

Although it's not well known by the public here, among those managing the response people who were less gung-ho and more cautions about other effects , and tried to warn or argue against them within the health community were sidelined and in many cases ultimately moved out of their positions. And when they tried to talk in the media, they were ignored.

And in fact the media is still ignoring these people, will not respond to them, even print letters to the editor. Not cranks, but people with good reputations as health leaders.

I also have been pointing out to people the interview that has come out with the lead researching on masking and other measures for the Cochrane reviews - the gold standard organization for meta-analysis of research. This is not just important for what they found, but because of what he describes as happening with the review that came out in 2020, which should have been important for policy makers. It's extremely shocking and tells us that "follow the science" was, from the very beginning, being deliberatly undermined by the health and science communities. Keep in mind that anyone who even suggested this at the time was vilified as a conspiracy theorist:

[[https://maryannedemasi.substack.com/p/exclusive-lead-author-of-new-cochrane?fbclid=IwAR3mW3LHS7k9WFfF9K5sBPahmmmbTfl8ZDOcqbNCmUCCSC3Qo8-42CY9ekk

EXCLUSIVE: Lead author of new Cochrane review speaks out

A no-holds-barred interview with Tom Jefferson

https://maryannedemasi.substack.com/p/exclusive-lead-author-of-new-cochrane?fbclid=IwAR3mW3LHS7k9WFfF9K5sBPahmmmbTfl8ZDOcqbNCmUCCSC3Qo8-42CY9ekk

Delatron · 23/03/2023 07:40

Good articles.

I’m very pleased there is a lot of discussion about the Swedish approach at the moment.

Interesting that even the German lockdown chief supporter Karl Lauterbauch said ‘closing schools was a a bad mistake’.

The paragraph where Tenegal discusses his reasons for keeping schools open made me sad for this country though (and others in lockdown). He clearly prioritised the mental health of the young and children
‘I think we are in a period of reevaluation and schools are such a good example and it’s so clear that the benefits were basically none and the damage you could do was so extensive’.

His determination was to keep the public calm and well informed rather than ‘frighten the pants off them’ which was Hancocks strategy.

Also an interesting discussion on how we based a lot of the lockdown decisions on completely false modelling. That needs to be evaluated. None of the decisions the government made were based on science and evidence. Go outside once a day! Why when know outdoors is the best place to be? Fresh air and exercise is so important for health.

And yes @Buzzinwithbez the shocking inequality of lockdown. What a blunt tool. Very good point that such an authoritarian regime targets the working class more whilst the middle classes lounge around in their gardens receiving their Ocado shopping.

There’s a lot to unpick and I know many want to move on but I hope the analysis and discussion continues. Because some very shocking things happened that should not be swept under the carpet.

ArcticSkewer · 23/03/2023 07:05

Good article today about Sweden.

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/23/anders-tegnell-swedens-pandemic-plan-lockdown-never-agenda/ www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/23/anders-tegnell-swedens-pandemic-plan-lockdown-never-agenda]]

Tbh I think we need more of a truth and reconciliation process than a day of reflection. I'd personally like to see about 80% of the UK public in stocks for a day and almost all the politicians. That anger won't leave until there's some kind of understanding on their part of what they have done. I accept that won't actually happen as it's part of the process of denial but a truth and reconciliation process would help.

I did realise this morning though that it was a very long and useful process for teaching my children very many important things in life. Those lessons will last a lifetime and prove very useful for them. That's one upside

ArcticSkewer · 23/03/2023 06:39

It's not bizarre that the left wanted even more restrictions. It's always been a feature of socialism to want to control the masses 'for their own good'

Buzzinwithbez · 22/03/2023 22:44

That should say unfolded, not unfiltered